Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump (2025) - News and Discussion!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Shinuki no Reborn

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
15,808
Reaction score
40,888
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
Moderator Notice:

WEEKLY SHONEN JUMP THREAD RULES​

1. No fights or personal insults.
2. No bait or troll comments with the intention of annoying or starting heated discussions, if i notice it, i will warn the user or delete the comment.
3. No toxic attitude towards series, no one is obligated to enjoy any series and it's totally fine to criticize what you don't like, just avoid posting gratuitous hateful or toxic comments about X or Y series, if i notice this behavior, comment will be deleted.
4. Don't bring politics or off-topic stuff to the thread, this is about Weekly Shonen Jump magazine and mangas, so keep any conversation about topics that aren't relate about anime & manga outside the thread.
5. Don't post news about series from other magazine or publishers in the WSJ thread, post in the series own thread, but it's fine if you're mentioning other series or magazine to express a opinion or reflection about Shonen Jump.
6. Any tweet, specially japanese, about news, update or some interesting thing about the magazine or series has to come with a text of what that tweet means and also be on topic, if not it's going to be either deleted or i will edit the post.
7. No self advertising or advertising Youtubers videos in the comments.
8. Fanart posts just for the sake of posting is prohibited, this rule doesn't apply for official art by Jump artists posted on social media, they're fine to post
9. Don't discuss or hype chapter spoilers before Sunday release, only comment if is related to a series surviving status and do it only inside the spoiler tag.
~ Shinuki


I hope everybody read these rules and follow it without problem, the comment will soon be sticked at the top of the thread to be visible in every page, so if any doubt about what to avoid doing, just check it, also if i feel like any new rule has to be added in the future, i will do. Thanks!

Obs: Rules about fanart edited!
 
Last edited:

Hawke

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2024
Messages
714
Reaction score
1,934
Age
28
Country
Vandenreich
I haven’t seen the Sakamoto Days anime yet but the clips I’ve seen so far on twitter look good to me. Idk maybe I’m missing something but is the reason people mad that it doesn’t look like Sukuna vs Mahoraga or Tengen vs Gyutaro. I figured it’d be a slide show like a lot of the latest Blue Lock season but the clips I’ve seen have been solid. Maybe I’m getting only the positives of the adaptation from social media or something
I think to really understand why I'm griping about it and threw a Solo Levelling stray is probably best done by the third episode of the SakaDays anime

Compare with the manga (ch7-8) and it becomes pretty clear that the animating and directing choices for the fights are quite literally the opposite of the Sakadays action style in the manga— a lot of fluidity is sacrificed for these slow moments of visual emphasis that just don't work with the original tone of the manga. It's not unwatchable, but Solo Leveling's action is much closer to what the manga looks like with how fluid and non-stop it is, not to mention free of these egregious wind speed/impact lines.
 

Chamo

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2024
Messages
186
Reaction score
669
Age
25
Country
France
I'm not up to date on Akane (so it may have been stated in the manga) but the performance hall of the last chapter is actually based on a real one called L'Olympia.

It is probably the most famous performance hall in Paris. And for the release of the manga in 2023, Ki-oon (French publishing company), organized a big event there, with French rakugoka performing on scene.

 
Last edited:

ItsSamu

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2020
Messages
664
Reaction score
2,974
Gender
Male
Country
Scotland
I was going to post some of my favourites from the decades but from last year I've actually started reading every available WSJ title in chronological order. Currently on 1980 so have a good list for the 60/70s ready but I'll wait until I finish the two carryovers from that decade (Cobra + Kinnikuman). Might do a post for each decade whenever I do eventually catch up with each.

Anyway, Mission: Yozakura Family. Since Gondaira said it I'll stick with "lucky" as the key word to define the series. I do not buy for a second that this was treated poorly by the editorial department or some victim of the system. If anything it was the opposite. The system got softer and the standards by which MYF operated early on were juuuuuuuust enough to survive when all the veterans around it were taking up the possible cancellation spots. It was also an underperforming title in an era where the big series ending before it way outsold it and the series that came after would have a lower expectations for performance than what we had in the '10s (mind you, we've still had plenty of undeniable hits outperform MYF pretty much from the jump - so a hit is a hit is a hit, still). It didn't get that first anniversary cover but it got a massive amount of colour pages, a decent amount of spin-off materials, and beyond the initial stages where it could have been cancelled its TOC was always in a safe enough spot and often quite good. I would argue it got a very generous treatment by the editorial department for being the mild/moderate hit it was. Sales were never anything extraordinary but at least it never fell off, and in the end got a boost and bump in its final stretch.

Sales and performance don't make a series good though, so I'm glad fans of it can be happy with how it wrapped up story-wise. This was about as spot-on an ending you could want. The second last chapter in particular was the best of the series, which is no better place to have that than the very end. My own personal feelings are still that I think it's a juvenile take on a WSJ battle manga in that it appeals more to 14 year chuunibyous and evokes that same spirit within the series itself in a way that makes it the perfect counterpart to Reborn! (which I also didn't really care for, for the exact same reasons). I was never a fan of the comedy, the character archetypes and tropes used again and again, never fell in love with any of the main cast, and although I preferred the switch to the action on balance I often felt the power levels of the family being so much stronger than any of their opponents often robbed of a sense of tension - it mostly just felt like chances for them all to show off against a new set of villains each arc that never really had a chance. That feeling hit most in this final arc; one half of me was happy it was wrapping up swiftly by not extending these individual fights too long but on the other hand I think it was the chance to escalate the scale of tension and stakes and it failed to do that in all those fights.

The '19/'20 era of successful Jump titles (Mission: Yozakura Family, Mashle, Undead Unluck, Me & Roboco) still remains one of the weakest stretches of recent memory to me. Perhaps reading the decades prior will put that into better context the further I get through them. It was a time where we needed some big hits to replace the titans and highly successful series of the past decade wrapping up close to each other, and we didn't get that - if we got four Mashles then it would be a different story. So part of me has always been a little pissed off by the leeway MYF + UU (in its later half) got when it felt that (a) they didn't deliver on what the magazine needed and (b) I didn't personally find them compelling and wouldn't miss them if they did go. So yeah, I'm glad these series are ending now. Other than the relatively small diehard fanbases I don't think either of them will be remembered that much in the history of the magazine when looking back at the end of this decade. I personally still believe both went on for too long (though MYF was the lesser offender of the two), and I'm genuinely quite excited to see if we can get one or two more battle titles this year as a trade off that do resonate with me.

Top 3 for issue #8:
1. Akane-banashi
2. Sakamoto Days
3. Ichi the Witch
Almost in my Top 3:
4. Me & Roboco

Good good good:
5. One Piece
6. Mission: Yozakura Family
7. Kagurabachi
8. Blue Box

Pretty good, surprisingly:
9. Kill Blue
10. Hakutaku

Just fine:
11. Undead Unluck
12. Shinobi Undercover
13. Astro Royale
14. Hima-Ten!
15. Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi
16. The Elusive Samurai
17. Nue's Exorcist
18. Syd Craft: Love is a Mystery
19. WITCH WATCH

Zzzz:
20. Super Psychic Policeman Chojo

Shock, I loved the first post-timeskip Akane-banashi chapter. Sakamoto Days continuing to deepen the Sakamoto/Shin relationship with this flashback while the anime covers their early interactions in the manga is a perfect combo; that car scene was A+. Ichi the Witch almost took second spot for how fucking badass Desscaras is, love her. I almost wish one of the three didn't deliver because Me & Roboco deserved a top 3 spot with its best chapter in a long time - whenever it goes for these sincere, heartfelt chapters it pretty much nails it every time and this one stirred a little bit of emotion in me. So good.

Nothing terrible this week but a lot just middling at the moment. WITCH WATCH did have a weirdly self-indulgent gag that wasn't funny... but I got a good laugh out of Miharu falling asleep mid-crawl so I can't place it dead last. Super Psychic Policeman Chojo gets that for being just totally unfunny this time. And although I wasn't in love with the fast pace and switch of character focus in The Elusive Samurai it was noteworthy that we got a two year timeskip which means we've got (big spoilers for real world history that will define the series) 11 years left to cover, year 1353. I'm curious how Matsui is going to handle the passage of time now that he's done a few shorter but frequent jumps in the past few months.

Also I've got to say that even though it's ending, Hakutaku has also just done the worst thing an U19 flop can do... it's gotten good. This was my favourite chapter since the first one. The three-way conversations and build up to that final moment was really strong, actually. There would be potential here if it wasn't going to end in two more chapters.

As for GFC, I already gave my rankings but in terms of probability I'd guess either Signal All Red or Invisible Blood; Signal All Red is without a doubt the best one-shot there and it's not even close but I feel like Invisible Blood's polished art could give it that chance despite being pretty generic. Either way would be fine by me, wouldn't mind seeing both of them get a serialisation. Even if Invisible Blood is nothing super interesting I'm curious what Asahi Arisaka would be capable of in WSJ with a completely different story.
 
Last edited:

coldmess

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2022
Messages
528
Reaction score
531
Age
34
Country
United States
Oh, I just realized that the artist of the Apple oneshot is doing the art for the new Metaphor: ReFantazio manga in V Jump. The game is my 2024 GOTY so I'm excited to read the manga.

Also I've seem comments elsewhere that it's kind of unbelievable that no one has spotted Akane in Paris until now. I'm sure her performances would be all over the internet. Akane is my favorite Jump series right now but that is kind of ridiculous lol.
 

Cerclox

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2019
Messages
1,341
Reaction score
2,043
Age
27
Country
Costa Rica
Gondaira calling Yozakura Family "the luckiest series in the history of Jump" might be true, a LOT of series that have gotten axed and couldn't make it in the 2010's or even 2020's would've survived if they were in Yozakura Family position but hey sometimes u need some luck to be at the right time and at the right place so there's that.

It will be remembered for sure!
 

iker_03

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2023
Messages
1,711
Reaction score
11,206
Age
22
Country
Spain
Mangaka comments about Yozakura ending in Weekly Shonen Jump Issue 8 (2024)

  • Kouji Miura (Blue Box): Congrats on the conclusion of Yozakura! A job well done for five years, Gondaira Sensei!
  • Takamasa Moue (Akane-banashi): I felt close to you because we debuted around the same time! A job well done, Gondaira Sensei!
  • Hitsuji Gondaira (Mission: Yozakura Family): It was five years of being blessed with the right people, environment, and luck. I left all on the page. Thank You!
  • Yuto Suzuki (SAKAMOTO DAYS): Congratulations on five years, Gondaira Sensei! I always felt your kidness emanating from your work
  • Shuhei Miyazaki (Me & Roboco): The mission spanning five years has concluded! I really loved Shion!!
  • Santa Mitarashi (Shinobi Undercover): Congratulations to Mission: Yozakura Family! A beautiful conclusion to a long-running series
  • Taishi Tsutsui (Syd Craft: Love is a Mystery): I'm late, but happy New Year! And to Gondaira Sensei, congrats on a job well done
  • Tadatoshi Fujimaki (Kill Blue): I was certain the creator was a great person just from reading the work. Congratulations, Gondaira Sensei!
  • Yoshifumi Tozuka (Undead Unluck): Congratulations on the end of Yozakura, Gondaira Sensei! I learned so much from you. Thank You!
  • Ken Wakui (Astro Royale): Gondaira Sensei, congrats on the completion of your series!
  • Kota Kawae (Nue´s Exorcist): Congratulations on the end of Mission: Yozakura Family! I always looked up to you
  • Kenta Shinohara (WITCH WATCH): Congratulations on the end of a long-running series, Gondaira Sensei! Start a new series by the time the sakura petals begin to fall
  • Shun Numa (Super Psychic Policeman Chojo): Serious, but always with a flare of comedy. Your style was amazing. Congratulations.
 
Last edited:

Magister Xehanort

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 29, 2019
Messages
343
Reaction score
1,367
Age
32
Country
Brazil
Yozakura was also very lucky since in 2020 seven successful series ended:

Yakusoku no Neverland , Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san , Kimetsu no Yaiba , Haikyuu!! , Act-Age , Chainsaw Man and Boku-tachi wa Benkyou ga Dekinai.

Which helped the series have more time to become successful and gain fans with the end of several established series at the same time.
 

Franz

Registered User
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2015
Messages
12,606
Reaction score
11,329
Age
33
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
ended:

Yakusoku no Neverland , Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san , Kimetsu no Yaiba , Haikyuu!! , Act-Age , Chainsaw Man and Boku-tachi wa Benkyou ga Dekinai.
More like, moved.
 

TheRealTravisty

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2020
Messages
732
Reaction score
1,324
Age
39
Country
Canada
Mangaka comments about Yozakura ending in Weekly Shonen Jump Issue 8 (2024)

  • Kouji Miura (Blue Box): Congrants on the conclusion of Yozakura! A job well done for five years, Gondaira Sensei!
  • Takamasa Moue (Akane-banashi): I felt close to you because we debuted around the same time! A job well done, Gondaira Sensei!
  • Hitsuji Gondaira (Mission: Yozakura Family): It was five years of being blessed with the right people, environment, and luck. I left all on the page. Thank You!
  • Yuto Suzuki (SAKAMOTO DAYS): Congratulations on five years, Gondaira Sensei! I always felt your kidness emanating from your work
  • Shuhei Miyazaki (Me & Roboco): The mission spanning five years has concluded! I really loved Shion!!
  • Santa Mitarashi (Shinobi Undercover): Congratulations to Mission: Yozakura Family! A beautiful conclusion to a lung-running series
  • Taishi Tsutsui (Syd Craft: Love is a Mystery): I´m late, but happy New Year! And to Gondaira Sensei, congrats on a job well done
  • Tadatoshi Fujimaki (Kill Blue): I was certain the creator was a great person just from reading the work. Congratulations, Gondaira Sensei!
  • Yoshifumi Tozuka (Undead Unluck): Congratulations on the end of Yozakura, Gondaira Sensei! I learned so much from you. Thank You!
  • Ken Wakui (Astro Royale): Gondaira Sensei, congrats on the completion of your series!
  • Kota Kawae (Nue´s Exorcist): Congratulations on the end of Mission: Yozakura Family! i always looked up to you
  • Kenta Shinohara (WITCH WATCH): Congratulations on the end of a long-running series, Gondaira Sensei! Start a new series by the time the sakura petals begin to fall
  • Shun Numa (Super Psychic Policeman Chojo): Serious, but always with a flare of comedy. Your style was amazing. Congratulations.
Thank you for being faster than Viz!
 

NeeNeen

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2012
Messages
1,061
Reaction score
1,222
Country
United Nations
This week's chapters, in order. (I haven't read all the other comments yet, so sorry if I'm repeating things.)


Yozakura: Heh, nice fake-out there at the start. I picked up on the hint in the supermarket, but I'd almost forgotten about it by the time of the reveal. Very cute ending chapter.

Shinobi: That was a great chapter! Some strategy talk (with everyone acting reasonable instead of rushing to an early grave), some very cute moments and even a bit of character development for the side characters. I enjoy this much more than pure action.

KGB: They seriously couldn't find anyone to teach him? I can buy the other kid refusing, but Chihiro isn't that stupid. Did they just not have time? Regardless, good chapter.

Ichi: I admit, she's good. Still don't think she's going to catch him, but this is turning out to be quite the confrontation.

Sakamoto: ... I'm pretty sure it would've been safer to just let him fall into the water. Still really excited for this.

UU: I still think it would've been cute if the two of them just started over... but this is nice too. I wonder what the last chapter is going to be about.

OP: Lore dump! But interesting. Luffy's gonna Luffy (I'm already glad he isn't completely disregarding the advice of his crew), but the guy they're looking for seems to have found himself some rather nasty company.

Akane: Plot twist! But, uh, this makes the Japanese look pretty blind to the outside world if even a rakugo reporter did not know someone was making this kind of career in Paris. I guess nobody ever tried googling her name to find it on a French website? And it's not like she's performing in some obscure venue, either.

Syd Craft: Elio is as stupid as ever, but her bravery makes up for it a little bit. Still glad this series has other, more competent women in it though. I'm also glad the story acknowledges that a bomb exploding right next to the ship is as bad as if it had been on it.

Kyoshi: That was silly, but I'm releaved. Last time it seemed like the story was suddenly speeding up, which isn't a good sign. But this week we're back to slice of life and the series is getting a colour page for popularity next week, so it's not going anywhere soon.

Astro: That shot with the flames coming off of him is lit. Guess this tournament will be taking a good while after all.

WW: As predicted, we're back to random fluff. But at least it was charming.

TES: So were those the two examples mentioned at the start or are we only halfway this history lesson?

Kill Blue: I've been reading through the old forum pages, so I just came across a discussion about how people didn't like this series in the beginning because the old man's views were sexist... I guess he's come a long way since then, because right now, he's the only male in the picture who doesn't sound like a sexist pig. Can someone explain to these teenage boys that women aren't a commodity to be gambled over? (This isn't your fault, girl. The fact that he might see you as a mom figure actually makes his behaviour worse.)
Oh hey, and the "It's a 40-year-old guy dating a teenage girl" discussion looks like it'll be returning as well. Fun.:popcorn

Blue Box: As usual this series is good at creating atmosphere, but it would be more interesting if something, y'know.. happened? And then the one important thing that does happen almost gets skipped over. Or did that not happen and are we still daydreaming? It's honestly hard to tell.

Nue: These fights are kinda hard to follow. I'm also not terribly invested because there's no way he's going to lose/die anyway.

Roboco: This was uncharacteristically wholesome, but in a very by-the-numbers kind of way (I would've liked it better without the convenient deux ex machina ending). It also didn't make me laugh once.

Hakutaku: *yawn* Are we done getting rejected now? Can we move onto something else? Who am I kidding, this isn't going anywhere.

Himaten: Why do the Japanese refuse to draw roaches? Are insects considered more taboo than sex and gore? Call me next time, I'll pick it up and put it outside, you pathetic cowards.

Chojo: Is "Haha, this person is scared and lonely, isn't it funny?" the only joke we're gonna be doing now? Last chapter was at least somewhat trying to balance things out, now we're just moving backwards (their relationship here is worse than it was in the very first chapter). I hate it, thanks.


WHICH ONE-SHOT YOU THINK WILL WIN THE GOLDEN FUTURE CUP 2024?

As promised, we will start know the poll voting for the Golden Future Cup 2024! The results will be published next week in the issue #9, so the poll will be open until the night of Wednesday to Thursday! Since we have all the one-shots translated in english, i will post the links for anyone interested in reading and voting:

POLICEMAN YOKAI HUNTER BY YOSHIDAB6


Link: https://mangadex.org/chapter/3ba95614-4fe1-49cd-a91d-1f1f640d17b2/2


SIGNAL ALL RED BY IZUMI HAKASE


Link: https://mangadex.org/chapter/21781b8f-185b-4dc2-8234-67a27052e55e/2


OSAMU BY SENKI CHIKI


Link: https://mangadex.org/chapter/8fb995b4-11f0-4679-a175-20239123dc8d/2


INVISIBLE BLOOD BY ARISAKA AKIRA


Link: https://mangadex.org/chapter/04909f9e-493a-4a87-86b0-d5d6647710e0/2


GOD OF RESURRECTION BY OKAWA KAZUHIKO


Link: https://mangadex.org/chapter/522d696e-d2b2-474a-817c-cb7fcefa5753/2


Hope you guys participate and don't forget to send your votes! :super
Invisible Blood: This feels a bit like Phantom Seer 2.0 (which is good, because I liked Phantom Seer). The beginning with the mouse was a bit contrived, but I'm digging the characters and the art. I'd love to read a serialisation of this.
Signal All Red: Not the greatest one-shot (it's a bit too unfocused for that), but it does have potential to turn into a series. They'd have to be careful not to make it too much like Kaguya-sama though.
God of Resurrection: ... This one felt like a mix of Magu-chan and Zipman, but with even more convenient coincidences. Which isn't great. But at least it's memorable, I guess.
Policeman Yokai Hunter: Classical exorcist stuff. The art is decent, but the story doesn't have enough to make it stand out.
Osamu: I get what they were going for, but this is cliche even for a one-shot.
 

Broseph

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2023
Messages
968
Reaction score
1,562
Age
31
Country
United States
Just saw people were doing top 10 lists for WSJ decades. Ngl I might be able to make a list for the 2010s but I don’t think I even read 10 jump series for other decades lol. I could do a top 10 favorite manga per decade for those easily but I’ve only read a couple in the 2000s and 90s
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,099
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
So out of the people who failed previously and want to see come back (as well as not) I will focus on artists who were cancelled from 2019-2022 (2023 onwards is to soon).

Return:

-Natsuki Hokami
-Daijiro Nonoue
-Yuki Kawaguchi (barely)
-Daisuke Enoshima

Not want:

-Kentari Fukuda
-Jun Kirarazaka
-Kazu Kakazu
-Kazuza Inaoka (but I think they left)
-Minya Hiragi
-Tadaichi Nakama
-Shinpei Watanabi
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

18. Hima-Ten!: Kanna is trying her best, but no one is buying it for even a minute. Sooner or later they should introduce a new male character and direct her interest towards him, so that Iemori can focus on the two real female leads.
How about Iemori’s guy friend who is pushing for the romance. Makes him seem more present in the story than a tertiary character.
 

Dongus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2023
Messages
1,518
Reaction score
4,957
Age
29
Country
Malaysia
Also I've got to say that even though it's ending, Hakutaku has also just done the worst thing an U19 flop can do... it's gotten good. This was my favourite chapter since the first one. The three-way conversations and build up to that final moment was really strong, actually. There would be potential here if it wasn't going to end in two more chapters.
Hehehe, this is actually my favourite part of reading a U19 manga. The last minute interesting development plot point. Too many times, an author has a good card in their hands that they want to save, so they deal out all their other cards first without realizing how weak those cards are. Then as they approach an irreversible end as a result, they hastily deal that good card, but it's too late to win the game. I understand why you'd consider it the worst thing a flop can do. It'll be easier to say goodbye to something that's consistently bad from start to finish than it is for something that tugged at you, if even for a moment.

When I finish a manga that got axed, I tend to view them as fragmented puzzle pieces scattered on the floor. I like to sit down over my morning coffee and think about what I would do to assemble those pieces into something that would've functioned better. If possible, without adding any new elements into the mix. The thought experiments usually involve those good pieces of writings executed in the ending stages and thinking about how much sooner one would introduce those concepts. You know, things like a plot twist, a final boss, a revelation. Sometimes it's too early to be dropping bombshells, most of the time, if you've got nothing to drop, then you should be dropping the bombshell.

For Hakutaku, I would've thought that having two arcs to get... Uh... Itadori into the group is way too many arcs, and it feels superfluous since there wasn't any real indication (at least within the first three chapters) that the group actually needed a programmer. I don't think any of the characters introduced ultimately mattered, so why not just immediately rush into the indie game summit and get shot down within the first volume? Of course, I still think that the first chapter was ultimately a killer, and absolutely nothing introduced in it, besides the leads, have any bearing on whatever happens afterwards.

Lots of other mangas really make me think. Necromance would've been an entirely different manga (and perhaps better) if it's last chapter was its first. Psych House could've resonated toward a strong emotional core if it focused on drama like its closing chapters rather than being way too chill. But the most fun I have is when a manga is completely unsalvageable. Like i tell c, there is nothing anyone could've done to make that manga a mainstay. Or maybe Time Paradox Ghostwriter whose very concept was already a critical failure. The dead ends that fry my brain till I give up really shoot some adrenaline into my veins.

It's a nice wake me up in the morning.
 

iker_03

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2023
Messages
1,711
Reaction score
11,206
Age
22
Country
Spain
Weekly Shoseki Ranking Top 500
1. Jujutsu Kaisen #30
2. Jujutsu Kaisen #29
9. SAKAMOTO DAYS #20
27. Ichi the Witch #1
97. WITCH WATCH #20 (4,659 / 32,526)
176. Undead Unluck #24 (3,360 / 23,858)
307. Kill Blue #8 (2,168 / 19,109)
336. Me & Roboco #20 (2,038 / 13,896)
388. Hima-Ten! #2 (1,804 / 13,365)
393. Shinobi Undercover #1 (1,781 / 12,347)
 
Last edited:

icrawfish

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2024
Messages
795
Reaction score
1,252
Age
25
Country
United States
Hehehe, this is actually my favourite part of reading a U19 manga. The last minute interesting development plot point. Too many times, an author has a good card in their hands that they want to save, so they deal out all their other cards first without realizing how weak those cards are. Then as they approach an irreversible end as a result, they hastily deal that good card, but it's too late to win the game. I understand why you'd consider it the worst thing a flop can do. It'll be easier to say goodbye to something that's consistently bad from start to finish than it is for something that tugged at you, if even for a moment.

When I finish a manga that got axed, I tend to view them as fragmented puzzle pieces scattered on the floor. I like to sit down over my morning coffee and think about what I would do to assemble those pieces into something that would've functioned better. If possible, without adding any new elements into the mix. The thought experiments usually involve those good pieces of writings executed in the ending stages and thinking about how much sooner one would introduce those concepts. You know, things like a plot twist, a final boss, a revelation. Sometimes it's too early to be dropping bombshells, most of the time, if you've got nothing to drop, then you should be dropping the bombshell.

For Hakutaku, I would've thought that having two arcs to get... Uh... Itadori into the group is way too many arcs, and it feels superfluous since there wasn't any real indication (at least within the first three chapters) that the group actually needed a programmer. I don't think any of the characters introduced ultimately mattered, so why not just immediately rush into the indie game summit and get shot down within the first volume? Of course, I still think that the first chapter was ultimately a killer, and absolutely nothing introduced in it, besides the leads, have any bearing on whatever happens afterwards.

Lots of other mangas really make me think. Necromance would've been an entirely different manga (and perhaps better) if it's last chapter was its first. Psych House could've resonated toward a strong emotional core if it focused on drama like its closing chapters rather than being way too chill. But the most fun I have is when a manga is completely unsalvageable. Like i tell c, there is nothing anyone could've done to make that manga a mainstay. Or maybe Time Paradox Ghostwriter whose very concept was already a critical failure. The dead ends that fry my brain till I give up really shoot some adrenaline into my veins.

It's a nice wake me up in the morning.
I do appreciate the mindset of taking what can sometimes be an emotionally draining experience of watching manga that get you invested crumble and turning it into a psychological game. I do spend a little time thinking about some of the series I enjoyed and dwelling on what made them fail, one example being MamaYuyu and just how uninteresting that world map was. I enjoyed MamaYuyu and the characters were fun to see (if introduced at an aggressive pace, perhaps due to the axe), but when I saw the world map for the first time and it was just a cross with vaguely coastline-shaped edges, I was not super enthused (note: I am a little bit of a map nerd). Every time they went to a location I didn't feel the weight of "we're travelling somewhere new, it'll be a different experience" it just felt like "oh, I'm going to north place. You guys head over to west place." and nothing more. Now, do I think having a more realistic and involved world map would save the series? Probably not, unless you shifted the focus to make the world map really pivotal to the world-merging plot in some way, but you're writing a different manga at that point. There's a lot of fun things to pick apart in certain series following the path of "what got this approved by Jump?" to "what was the main hook of this story?" to "where did it lose sight/what didn't work with that main concept?" and other adjacent questions. I'd argue it's as much if not more interesting than analyzing the mega-hit successes and asking what made those series great and popular.

In short, being fully caught up weekly might be making me a little bit of a trash enthusiast? I'm easy to please though so almost all trash looks at least edible to me.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

As a non-sequitur: I'll admit in regard to this top 10 per decade lists that I've hardly read anything that started before 2018 outside of some One Piece, so I'm gonna have to go off of what anime I've watched. With that in mind... I'm still coming up short, since I haven't hardly watched enough to get 10 per decade. BUT! I can at least make a top 10 for the 2010's (if I include Undead Unluck since it was just outside the range of the decade), and I can make a top 10 of everything pre-2010's. It's not super impressive, and some of them I haven't even seen the whole show, but I'll do my best to be fair:

2010's (mostly anime):
1. The Disastrous Life of Saiki K.
2. Black Clover
3. Jujutsu Kaisen
4. Haikyu!
5. Assassination Classroom
6. Undead Unluck (manga) [cheating, I know, but I need 10]
7. My Hero Academia
8. Mission: Yozakura Family (manga)
9. Kimetsu no Yaiba
10. Dr. Stone

1980's, 1990's, and 2000's (almost all anime):
1. One Piece (includes manga)
2. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure
3. Gintama
4. Hunter x Hunter
5. Yu-Gi-Oh! (childhood pick)
6. Fist of the North Star
7. Bleach
8. Jojo's Part 6: Stone Ocean (it technically is listed as separate so I can count it?)
9. Yu Yu Hakusho
10. Naruto (only on the bottom because I grew up with it so I haven't seen all of it and forgot a lot)

Looking back at the list this is not my most impressive display... but I was at least able to scrape something together.
 

Dongus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2023
Messages
1,518
Reaction score
4,957
Age
29
Country
Malaysia
I do appreciate the mindset of taking what can sometimes be an emotionally draining experience of watching manga that get you invested crumble and turning it into a psychological game. I do spend a little time thinking about some of the series I enjoyed and dwelling on what made them fail, one example being MamaYuyu and just how uninteresting that world map was. I enjoyed MamaYuyu and the characters were fun to see (if introduced at an aggressive pace, perhaps due to the axe), but when I saw the world map for the first time and it was just a cross with vaguely coastline-shaped edges, I was not super enthused (note: I am a little bit of a map nerd). Every time they went to a location I didn't feel the weight of "we're travelling somewhere new, it'll be a different experience" it just felt like "oh, I'm going to north place. You guys head over to west place." and nothing more. Now, do I think having a more realistic and involved world map would save the series? Probably not, unless you shifted the focus to make the world map really pivotal to the world-merging plot in some way, but you're writing a different manga at that point. There's a lot of fun things to pick apart in certain series following the path of "what got this approved by Jump?" to "what was the main hook of this story?" to "where did it lose sight/what didn't work with that main concept?" and other adjacent questions. I'd argue it's as much if not more interesting than analyzing the mega-hit successes and asking what made those series great and popular.

In short, being fully caught up weekly might be making me a little bit of a trash enthusiast? I'm easy to please though so almost all trash looks at least edible to me.
I think the most boring guy is the guy who only watches things that are good. Why yes, these are great pieces of media, but there's no reason to be dismissive of all the dreck around it. I much prefer the guy who likes whatever the heck he likes, and resonates with things on a personal level, rather than a social one. It's easy to borrow an opinion on why something is bad, rather than forming one of your own. Individuality is a trait that gets lost in an age of social media... But that's a senile rant for some other day.

Really, there's no such thing as a trash enthusiast. My term for that? An explorer. Consume, eat, experience, but at the end of the day, form an opinion of your own. And who knows, you may find a tasty morsel lost within the sea of trash.

Mamayuyu, I've talked about it at length before, so I'd feel like a broken record saying any more. All I have for now is that I hope Hayashi grasps onto a vision and builds upon it with all he's got. While shaky foundations in conceptualization are not something that can be seen, it's something that can be felt critically as the story goes.


Weekly Shoseki Ranking Top 500
1. Jujutsu Kaisen #30
2. Jujutsu Kaisen #29
9. SAKAMOTO DAYS #20
27. Ichi the Witch #1
97. WITCH WATCH #20 (4,659 / 32,526)
176. Undead Unluck #24 (3,360 / 23,858)
307. Kill Blue #8 (2,168 / 19,109)
336. Me & Roboco #20 (2,038 / 13,896)
388. Hima-Ten! #2 (1,804 / 13,365)
393. Shinobi Undercover #1 (1,781 / 12,347)
Just, 12k huh... I was hoping Shinobi Undercover would've hit the 15k line. At least it would be considered safe for a while. There's still a lot of cushions at the moment. But for now, it looks like it'll be around Kiyoshi's level where it's got leeway to do what it wants, but if it doesn't pick up a healthy following within half a year, it'll be the one to go.
 

WyldViolet

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Oct 25, 2012
Messages
4,116
Reaction score
5,860
Age
33
Country
United States
1. Ichi the Witch
2. Nue's Exorcist
3. Sakamoto Days

4. Shinobi Undercover
5. Kill Blue
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top