1. No fights or personal insults.
2. No bait or troll comments with the intention of annoying or starting heated discussions, if i notice it, i will warn the user or delete the comment.
3. No toxic attitude towards series, no one is obligated to enjoy any series and it's totally fine to criticize what you don't like, just avoid posting gratuitous hateful or toxic comments about X or Y series, if i notice this behavior, comment will be deleted.
4. Don't bring politics or off-topic stuff to the thread, this is about Weekly Shonen Jump magazine and mangas, so keep any conversation about topics that aren't relate about anime & manga outside the thread.
5. Don't post news about series from other magazine or publishers in the WSJ thread, post in the series own thread, but it's fine if you're mentioning other series or magazine to express a opinion or reflection about Shonen Jump.
6. Any tweet, specially japanese, about news, update or some interesting thing about the magazine or series has to come with a text of what that tweet means and also be on topic, if not it's going to be either deleted or i will edit the post.
7. No self advertising or advertising Youtubers videos in the comments.
8. Fanart posts just for the sake of posting is prohibited, this rule doesn't apply for official art by Jump artists posted on social media, they're fine to post
9. Don't discuss or hype chapter spoilers before Sunday release, only comment if is related to a series surviving status and do it only inside the spoiler tag. ~ Shinuki
I hope everybody read these rules and follow it without problem, the comment will soon be sticked at the top of the thread to be visible in every page, so if any doubt about what to avoid doing, just check it, also if i feel like any new rule has to be added in the future, i will do. Thanks!
I actually think that the Fullbring arc is one of the best arcs in Bleach. This is coming from someone who started reading weekly right after the Arancar arc, so it's not a 'liked it because I wasn't reading weekly' thing. I enjoyed the slower pace and intrigue. It felt like it was thought out properly, which is not something I can say for a lot of Bleach.
I think I'll stick with similar to what I said before the 3rd cour of TYBW came out. Which is that while the anime has made changes for the better, the core writing in the last half of that arc remains the same, and is terrible.
Take that with a grain of salt though, as I'm kind of a source material snob. To me, if it's not in the original manga, it didn't happen/I don't care.
We finally glazing the Fullbring arc, eh? I'll put my dimes in and say that I actually do agree that the Fullbring arc is actually a very good arc. It dialed back the spectacle and power levels in exchange for a more mysterious atmosphere and better introspective on Ichigo. Tsukishima was a fantastic character that gave a haunting dread to the entire atmosphere. The problem is, well, bad placement, bad timing. You really cannot dial things back this far after Aizen, not with Ichigo.
If I could describe it in a way... Say you're playing an RPG, you beat the final boss, but oh no, he wasn't actually the final boss, you only beat Part 1! Aight, so you're gearing up for Part 2, it's gonna be cool, but... All your levels, gear and items have been taken away and you're starting from zero.
I think the general feeling of fatigue, especially after the marathon it took to beat Aizen, was the fact that progress was essentially reset and we're starting over from zero. Stunted progress, y'know. Do we really want to see Ichigo relearning the ropes? I think the arc could've worked better if Ichigo took a backseat and took up a more mentor role, so we could feel his experience shining through. All I'm saying is that Jojo Part 4 is the best Jojo arc despite being essentially what the Fullbring arc is to Bleach, a complete dialing down of scale and awe for a more mundane story. Who would Ichigo be mentoring? I don't know, Bichigo or something, make up a new character. Hey, Tatsuki has been in this manga from the start, has martial art skills, supernatural atunement, a feisty personality, and an actual relationship with the main cast, how is she still a side character? Just take the chance to use her for an arc, and let Ichigo coach her. I think their chemistry and bickering would've made for a good buddy cop dynamic...
My point is that the Fullbring arc is a good arc when we isolate it on its own, but if you were following it up from a major arc, it feels absolutely exhausting because of what appeared to be a reset status quo. If it shifted focus away from Ichigo and allowed him to take on a position that put his growth and experience in the forefront, I think it would've been much better received. Also, they had Ichigo waving around a swastika.
Correction it is a manjin, but it does come across that, so I understand. But it was also on the hilt of his blade in his fake bankai (before his true bankai). But I get it Dongus.
Same but for Naruto, I only followed Bleach out of the old big 3. I tried Naruto but kept stopping at when Sasuke left the village and OP is quite unreadable for me (not saying it's bad here btw)
I followed One Piece to an extent since I originally followed the 4Kids dub (I know no need to say much). And with Naruto, I only started back at the Chunin Exams, and that was my keen interest in the series.
Oh, we're talking about Bleach? My favourite WSJ series? *cracks knuckles*
As a fan from high school who loved it since I started reading weekly from chapter 324 and has been deep in the fandom pretty much ever since (Club Bleach, anyone?), the shift in the past few years has been fascinating. It's always been one of my all-time favourite manga and unlikely to change - it's one of those pieces of fiction where every plot detail and side character's name is burnt into my brain like a rolodex ready to produce factoids when even now I sometimes forget the name of the main character of a series weeks after I finished reading it.
Attempts at revisionism of Bleach's popularity and reputation during its run are just false and easy to disprove: a lot of people liked it, but a lot of people read/reviewed/reacted knowing they didn't and made a joke out of it week-to-week and enough people thought that was funny that it kept up for years and years. It was the little brother of the Big 3 who didn't get the attention and love its elder siblings got while they were growing up together, but only now that it's older and has a good job (adaptation) and for this moment in time is hotter stuff than its siblings who always got the attention it's resulted in a power shift. Bleach fans back then had no influence - the positivity that was there with casuals and die-hard fans existed amongst those who were earnest about enjoying it, but it was always overshadowed by criticisms or hate pretty much everywhere else. I blogged the TYBW manga weekly on RandomC.net until its completion (sadly those posts are gone now) and sometimes felt like I was one of the few positive voices for the series even during the final stretch.
As someone who found enjoyment in pretty much every part of Bleach, the constant bashing and lack of willingness to see positives (because that didn't fit the narrative at the time) was exhausting to push through every week for some 6, 7, 8 years when it was at its harshest. I'd like to think I've remained pretty level headed about it 17 years after but I can see why old fans who are now seeing the popularity resurgence of the '20s are fuelled by some sort of vengefulness to finally have Bleach be respected and attempt to re-write its history. It still "fell off" relative to its peak in terms of popularity and place within the magazine, and that TYBW TOC situation was a fascinating one that everyone (and and haters alike) had to just adjust to the new normal and accept that it was possible for a popular veteran series to live in the bottom five and not actually be in danger. Toriko took its place and then some years later Toriko was in a similar place in the TOC in its final stretch, as were others like Food Wars or Nisekoi. So Bleach wasn't the only modern series to suffer that fate, though it was the biggest.
For what it's worth I don't think Bleach ever "fell off" in terms of quality - not in the Arrancar arc, or Lost Agent, or Thousand Year Blood War. One thing about the new fans getting into the series and binging it in recent years is they're rid of the week-to-week experience that I feel influenced a lot of the criticism people had. There's no need to complain when a chapter takes a couple minutes to read when you've got 500 more still go after and it all flows together better as a result.
Now I'm seeing people actually find the merits in the series I always saw. Sure, the fights are cool as hell and the power system is one of the most iconic in manga which could be enough to love it, but when they're not told by people around them for years on end that Kubo is a shit writer who only knows how to draw good character designs, people now don't fall into that same way of thinking. Just because Bleach had a reputation among those who read it as it was publishing doesn't mean those opinions are inherently more correct. I've loved seeing the growing appreciating for Kubo's poetic and efficient approach to writing and seeing that the fights are so good because the powers the characters have intentionally push for their characterisation or arcs beyond just what dialogue is said or what happens in the plot - the fights are part of the storytelling. I feel that point in particular was lost on a lot of people as it was coming out. And hey, if anyone talks about the lack of backgrounds as if that's a legitimate problem or criticism then I genuinely don't consider their opinion on the series worthwhile.
I wouldn't say it's a series without faults: Kubo's attempts at comedy often fall flat; the repetitive nature of the Hueco Mundo section compared to Soul Society can be pretty blatant on face value; the Lost Agent arc's initial stretch was too much of a tonal whiplash and relied on keeping information from the audience when they were already being tested; and the TYBW wrapped up in a rushed way that satisfied almost no one at the time. I think there are legitimate counterpoints or reasons to all of those mind you (there are some really funny gags too; the repetition of the two arcs is intentional and continues the characterisation of those who carry through both of them; Kubo likely needed a creative reset in the series with the fullbringers after spending so long on the previous arc; and now we know he was ill and unable to wrap-up the series in the way he could have). But I think those takes are still valid.
And on the SuperEyepatchWolf video? I don't mourn the loss of the first one at all. It used misinformation that skewed in favour of his opinion he already had, which is no different from what that Reddit post is now complaining the fandom does in the opposite direction - both of them are annoying. I don't value his takes on the series because I've seen them being made for over a decade and just don't agree with them. What is weird to me is seeing content creators who I know read the series back then and took any chance to shit on it now watching the TYBW anime and doing a complete 180 and living for even the unchanged content. People can shift their opinions of course but in those cases it's hard not to take it as people's willingness to do and say whatever the general consensus is in order to get views and engagement. Hating on Bleach used to be cool, and now liking Bleach is cool.
tldr - Bleach revisionism of the series' popularity and objective metrics of its performance is dumb and annoying, but the modern shift in the overall perception for the series has been a net positive imo. It's allowed people to form opinions of the series without relying solely on or parroting the criticisms of those who were thick in the fog of their own discontent from reading weekly and past the point where they could see the merits the series legitimately has. But then again I'm a diehard Bleach fan so of course I'd say that!
I wanna add an addendum. Bleach was most popular during the 2005-2015 time range, and the internet was a drastically different place back then than it is today. But the most critical difference I would say was the advent of the critical reviewer. I won't name any names, but as I talk about it, you could probably think of a few names. You know. The reviewer who kinda just takes scenes from the movie and then riffs on it? A lot of the times, just showing clips and making a joke, or getting unnecessarily angry and stuff? Yeah, people don't do that anymore. And I think it's because people have wisened up that this form of review isn't really a review and doesn't engage with the media in a meaningful sense to understand what's being said and told. Right now, the term being thrown around is media literacy, and I think you'd get slapped with a lot of mockery if you were as petty and angry as the reviewers those days were.
The thing about the reviewers of that era, is that hating literally anything was cool. And while I'm sure that we have plenty of standup fellows who've created such videos, the effect it had on the audience they had would leak out and mirror the general behaviour of an internet user. And it just so happened that well... Bleach was written with the same methodology as a soap opera. Its strengths are in core emotional narratives and visualizing a character's inner world through their battles, that's what makes it differ from its contemporaries. But the result of that is that when things happen, they don't happen because it would be the most logical thing to happen, they happen because it would be the most emotionally engaging occurrence.
And for an internet user of that era, being extremely petulant and picking apart even the most minute of detail for a riff is irresistible. Bleach was a goddamn feast for people who loved engaging in their own hatred. Because it's deliberately written to be loose in how its world and mechanics function, even certain characterizations and details can be up for interpretation. As a result, it comes off really dumb when you're deliberately seeking flaws.
Bleach is a flawed piece of media, but it has its strengths in the places where it matters. A Jump editor once said that one of the core things to make a successful Jump publication was to have a main character you want to be friends with. Well, here's Bleach that has that feeling spread across dozens of characters. Literally anyone can be a main character in Bleach if you shine the spotlight on them for five minutes. And TYBW uses that to its absolute limits.
So transition from an internet that dives deep into every little nook and cranny to find something to complain about to be cool, to an internet of junkies who scream out their love for whatever, and you can see why Bleach's transition in opinion is so stark. I don't think anyone's perspective actually changed on Bleach. I think the overall behaviour of the internet has changed. And Bleach was published during a time where critical people looked for things to trash and picked apart as much as they could to be cool, Bleach being a piece of fiction so full of holes it might as well be swiss cheese (does that make it a Hollow?). Now it's airing during a time where people resonate with strong characterization, emotional hooks and scenes that look cool. Bleach might as well replace the Soul King with this because that's the thing holding the entire manga together.
Things really aren't any better today, in my opinion, but I would take an era of meatheads yapping about 'aura' over some fat guy in front of a camera screaming about how stupid it all is. It's nice that it's cool to love again.
Frankly, as someone who used to keep up with SEW (and as someone who is a big Bleach fan), there was definitely merit to taking down that video. SEW straight up doesn't understand how WSJ works and how manga sales work. I can't count the number of times he over-generalized, put too much emphasis on raw ToCs, omitted vital information, and etc. Iirc, he even said Bleach was cancelled (spoiler IT WASN'T, it is incredibly rare for WSJ to cancel actual hits, especially post 2010, what probably happened was Kubo set a deadline to end for a new batch to come in that soon became hard to wrap up the plot, and he was so burned out that he just ended it in spite of the Gintama option being available, it had a 200 chapter final arc lol. it wasn't cancelled.)
One thing to note about Bleach's decline is that most people really overblow it as some unprecedented fall-off. Aside from 3 exceptions, pretty much every shonen jump series to have a chapter count of 300+ had a noticable decline in some capacity. The exceptions, of course, are Naruto, One Piece, and HeroAca which are major outliers and not really normal. (And all had their anime run throught their runs) Reborn went from 580K when the anime ended to 300K when the series ended. Gintama went from 450-475K to sub 200K despite having an omnipresent anime airing during the 2010's. Toriko (which was primed as Bleach's replacement) went from 400K to 200K. And Bleach went from 800K at the tail end of the anime to 450K. Both Gintama and Toriko are widely agreed to have had consistent quality, so clearly it isn't correlated to that. Readership dropoff is fairly natural when a series doesn't have anything to keep interest afloat, hence why HeroAca and Naruto stayed consistent (and One Piece is such a phenom that I doubt anything could really tank it).
what probably happened was Kubo set a deadline to end for a new batch to come in that soon became hard to wrap up the plot, and he was so burned out that he just ended it
If Kubo was given a deadline to end so a new batch could come in, how is that not being cancelled? Him rushing/giving up at the end sounds more like a result of being axed than anything else. Like, that theory is basically what happened to Takei with Shaman King and you don't see anybody saying that it wasn't cancelled.
I mean, fans of the Youtubers will already see it, won't they? I don't really see a need to always spam the thread with the opinions of random Youtubers who aren't contributing users here.
One thing to note about Bleach's decline is that most people really overblow it as some unprecedented fall-off. Aside from 3 exceptions, pretty much every shonen jump series to have a chapter count of 300+ had a noticable decline in some capacity. The exceptions, of course, are Naruto, One Piece, and HeroAca which are major outliers and not really normal. (And all had their anime run throught their runs) Reborn went from 580K when the anime ended to 300K when the series ended. Gintama went from 450-475K to sub 200K despite having an omnipresent anime airing during the 2010's. Toriko (which was primed as Bleach's replacement) went from 400K to 200K. And Bleach went from 800K at the tail end of the anime to 450K. Both Gintama and Toriko are widely agreed to have had consistent quality, so clearly it isn't correlated to that. Readership dropoff is fairly natural when a series doesn't have anything to keep interest afloat, hence why HeroAca and Naruto stayed consistent (and One Piece is such a phenom that I doubt anything could really tank it).
But it was a unprecedent fall off, Bleach was alongside Naruto & One Piece the face of the magazine for 7 years, basically every week at the top of the ToC, one of the longest running anime (still airing) and amazing sales, it didn't had a "typical" drop in sales due to longevity or end of the anime, you can literally pinpoint the exactly moment where Bleach sales and specially rankings started to go south which is the Fullbring Arc.
If Kubo was given a deadline to end so a new batch could come in, how is that not being cancelled? Like, that theory is basically what happened to Takei with Shaman King and you don't see anybody saying that it wasn't cancelled.
Kubo himself confirmed years ago in his twitter that the end is how he planned but is rushed because his health was f@cked up, he was hospitalized a few times during the arc.
But it was a unprecedent fall off, Bleach was alongside Naruto & One Piece the face of the magazine for 7 years, basically every week at the top of the ToC, one of the longest running anime (still airing) and amazing sales, it didn't had a "typical" drop in sales due to longevity or end of the anime, you can literally pinpoint the exactly moment where Bleach sales and specially rankings started to go south which is the Fullbring Arc.
Kubo himself confirmed years ago in his twitter that the end is how he planned but is rushed because his health was f@cked up, he was hospitalized a few times during the arc.
I get that Kubo wants to blame it on his health. Hell, that totally could be a contributing factor. However, it always felt a bit to me like an attempt at saving face. Any other series that suffered such a massive drop in popularity/sales and spent the rest of its run at the back of the ToC, while also having a rushed final arc; we'd call it what it is. An axe.
I get that Kubo wants to blame it on his health. Hell, that totally could be a contributing factor. However, it always felt a bit to me like an attempt at saving face. Any other series that suffered such a massive drop in popularity/sales and spent the rest of its run at the back of the ToC, while also having a rushed final arc; we'd call it what it is. An axe.
Saying "Kubo wants to blame it on his health" is kinda wild cause you make it sound like he had a mild flu here and there when they guy was outright hospitalized a bunch of times while working on the manga. Well, even if I were to drag out whatever interviews were done about why Bleach ended, I don't think you'd interpret it as anything but an axe.
I will, however say that if something got axed, Jump would stop doing promotions of it in any way or kind. Why promote something you saw failing so badly you force it to end? Let alone let it have a gacha, or have a light novel that closes off a lot of loose ends that everyone keeps quoting and misquoting. Definitely wouldn't have an adaptation of its last arc animated ten years later and various games. You'll definitely have to give me an example of an axed manga that's being given the same golden treatment as Bleach.
There's been an update to our forum rules to broaden crediting/sourcing to all series news/announcement, etc. Please read HERE
To manage thread loading speeds and general user experience, we'd apppreciate if volume covers could be wrapped in spoiler threads, going forward. If you have any questions, reach out to a staff member. Thanks for your cooperation.
We use cookies
Essential cookies keep the site working. Analytics cookies help us improve.