Star Of Beethoven is pretty good. The writing on it feels great, but the art feels like it needed 2 more years of experience before doing serialization. That said, I've seen much worse art put on the mag, and this doesn't remotely veer into the territory of being 'bad'. I feel like Sakamoto Days during the first ten chapters shared a similarly amateurish look that's gone away now, and I wouldn't put it past this manga to find a look. Reverse Isekai Beethoven was not on my cards, kinda reminds me of, It's Ya Boy, Kongming! but that one was about clubbing and combining Zhuge Liang's strategems with clubbing. Star of Beethoven has Beethoven doing piano stuff, so it doesn't offer a strange combination of things that don't go hand in hand and somehow makes it go hand in hand. Nah, SoB (this is a very unfortunate acronym) is about doing classical music stuff with the goddamn messiah of classical music stuff.
I praised Beethoven last night, and I stay true to my words. Beethoven is written fantastically as a character. This geezer is spitting FIRE. Every line out of him is written in such a way that makes his character shine in a brilliant way that just makes him a treat to read. I'm not expert on the real Beethoven, but I don't have to be to understand that this Beethoven's a goddamn mad genius in his chosen field, and he wouldn't need the name to prove it. I believe it. But what I like the most is that Beethoven is so well researched in this chapter alone, citing his letters and scrutinizing details of what he said and did not say. There's a lot of love and homework being put into this historical figure, which I felt is deserved and presented him very well.
Beethoven can't carry this manga, so it was said. It's somewhat true to an extent. Beethoven isn't a ghost only Ichiro can see and hear, he's an actual person just launched into modern day Japan. That means he's just as much a person and character able to communicate with other characters, and he's taking a leading role as a mentor. In other words, unlike say, Tenmaku Cinema, the amount of things the author can do with Beethoven is much, much higher. He's also written in such a way that I'm willing to read an entire chapter of him yapping about rap music or something.
But it's also true that the rest of the characters need to pull their own weight. Man, that big tiddy girl with the beady eyes was nice... It's kind of an odd thing to admit, but I'm quite attracted to girls with beady eyes for some reason. It's not necessarily an attractive trait, but maybe because it has such a homely vibe to it, that I find it more interesting than a more standard pretty girl. It's also funny how she and her friend look like delinquents, when they go to an elite music school where you'd expect much classier women to be at, but here they are, looking like delinq-- Weird tangent!
Yaso's actually pretty good as a main character. He has a certain moodiness, without playing it into depression that makes him come off whiny. Instead, he's full of snark. He reacts to the situation of encountering... frickin' Beethoven about just as well as anyone would. And that grounding and realism goes a long way to allowing the reader to put themselves in his shoes. Anyone who runs into Beethoven at a convenience store would react the same way, and it makes Ichiro very believable. His loss of love for the piano is also a driving force to tie it all down, and it sets up a small mystery of what happened that made him give up? There's also questions about what his relationship is with that girl, cause she's friendly enough to wanna hear him play, belligerent enough to be somewhat uppity about him giving up. A lot of mixed signals. Small setups in his background and relationships go a long way when you start building it up this early. He bounces off Beethoven really well, and ain't no one better to tell you to not give up on piano than the man who made history in the music world while going deaf.
The art is where it's hard to put my money in it. It's very rough at times, and many times looks unfinished. However, as I said, it never veers into a territory where I could consider it bad. The thing is, the art serves its purposes. Yaso's many faces and expressions match his dialogue to a tee, and that's not even going into Beethoven's presentation that makes him feel larger than life. There's also the way when the piano was played, you can hear and feel the impact of the keys from how Beethoven's wickedness was drawn. Fun fact, Beethoven had to really hammer the keys when he played because well, he was deaf. So more trivia that matches the source. The piano play bore a certain heaviness that makes you hear something without actually hearing anything. The art can still develop, but where it is, it presents what it wants to present very well. And I think that's more important than masterful artwork.
I'll gamble on it. I hope it can stay on as long as PPPPPP at the very least, but it all depends on how they develop the modern day stories. I can read Beethoven talking about the most inane nonsense possible, but the plot has to go interesting places if they wanna hang on. I think the strength in homework and characterization leaves me optimistic about the prospects of the writing.
Embers, misunderstandings aren't my favourite plot point when it's for non-comedic purposes, and this chapter had two layers of misunderstandings, so I'm not particularly amused. That said, the footballing was football, and I can't get over the line, "Perhaps you've mistaken soccer for rugby?" which is a funny line to translate because Americans refer to football as soccer, most of everywhere elsecalls it football. And American rugby is usually referred to as football. So if going by American nomenclature, the line would've been translated as, "Perhaps you've mistaken soccer for football?" which is probably one very confusing line. That said, rugby is also considered its own sport cause it apparently has many differences from American Football, at least, according to some guy I talked to once before--
Weird tangent! Chapter 2 of Embers is about as decent as the first. But I still think Haitani is a lot blander than his background allows him to be. The thing is, his desire to win and his delinquent background were traits he had before he even started football, but it was never touched upon in the first chapter. And I wouldn't be peeved about it if it wasn't so prominent in his approach towards football. A short excerpt would've been fine, like his mom and dad are neglectful, idk. It just feels odd that such an important aspect to his personality isn't given much attention when it really should. And I think for a delinquent, he's way too chill and passive. As in, he doesn't start any problems on his own and is more reactive to the circumstances he's in than he is active in making a situation occur.
The midfielder dude looks like a goddamn yakuza, I don't know where he's getting at calling Haitani a punk. The footballing was balling, and it's really selling me on Haitani's potential as a defender, while still keeping his amateur footballing ability on the forefront without making him look like an unearned prodigy. The footballing is aight, I enjoy it. Art is fantastic when they kick balls, but still claustrophobic everywhere else, with too many things packed into a panel most of the time.
Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi is funny as usual. The action relies heavily on cool stuff happening rather than any form of power leveling or explanations, which is why it's better left as a comedy. I always enjoy Kiyoshi when it's being funny, but we're deep in the Black Parade atm. A lot of ending flags, yeah, but what matters is that it's fun stuff.
Speaking of ending flags, Kill Blue just screams ending to me. I know we talked a lot about axes and sales and future storylines but there's just too much finality in the events I dunno what to say. That said, what irony is there that a manga called Kill Blue ends with the Blue being unable to Kill? Hah! At the very least, there's a touching sense to it that the SoL has finally caught Ogami right in the neck and has him in the chokehold. The cliffhanger is either an ending, or a complete shift in status quo.
To those of you who talked about Astro Royale leaks being crazy, I want you to shut the fuck up and never do that again. All you've done is set my expectations high, till I read the chapter and was severely disappointed. I would've been alright if I had no expectations going in. The cliffhanger last chapter set up interesting revelations... which never came to pass. Instead, we had Tokyo Revengers Draken kicking ass. And it's cool that he's kicking ass, but that's not worthy of being considered a 'crazy chapter'. A crazy chapter to me is something that completely changes the status quo a lot, and makes you rethink events and characters in the manga, and go back to see if there was something hinting at it. This was not crazy. It was just aight. Never talk about leaks with minimal context when it's right beside a cliffhanger.
Nue's Exorcist likes to just jump into lighthearted romcom shenanigans 0.5 seconds after a heated battle. I've criticized this aspect before, but clearly it's fun for the fanbase. I don't wanna sound like a broken record, so hey! A shortstack! Nice. Move over Nue, your lap pillow powers have been taken over. Oh, and that shitty brat isn't dead, is he? I mean, he got a whole flashback and everything. Usually grounds for turning into a good guy, you know, sad backstory, not being so different from the MC, jealousy. He can be Vegeta. The mortality rate of dying from falling off a cliff into a bed of water is very minimal from all the manga I've read.
Eunuch of Empire had me at the babes and lost me at the no balls. I'm sorry, no amount of hot babes can get me to be schizophrenic enough to self insert into a guy whose peepee got chopped off. And that sucks because they were really hot babes.
Speaking of babes, Hima-ten has attempted to feed me with moms. Nice. I love older women, and I love me some milfs. Thanks for the treat, Hima-ten. I was getting tired of Kanna. Yum. Himari's mom has got it going on. She's all I want and I've waited for so long. Himari can't you see? You're just not the girl for me. I know it may be wrong but I'm in love with Himari's mom. But yeah, hot milfs. Himari's mom is a gangster, and sparks intimidation, but is pretty chill and has given her approval to her daughter's slave, uh, housecleaner. Kanai's mom is that typical mom next door type, who talks way too much and humiliates her daughter. And she's gonna do it again next week! Cause this Ten guy, he's for the streets. All the girls be taking him into their house to clean their stuff. This manga's telling young boys to CLEAN YOUR GODDAMN BEDROOM and get some bitches.
Speaking of which, Syd Craft is also feeding me with pics of Lulu. My neurons exploded when she just randomly showed up in a maid outfit. Damn. I can't believe 22i somehow fit Twister into this setting, but he does what he wants. Syd's parents are hilariously flippant about the shit they do to their son, and the situation was pretty funny and downright sexy without needing much skin. Syd's a real chap for avoiding to jump on those Lulus cause he thinks that she's dating Elio (hilariously stupid misunderstanding) and I think that makes him pretty great. Self control. Don't cuck your assistant, you know? Even if he is a dumbass. The chapter also serves as a shift in direction for Lulu who has dropped the whole 'finding his weakness' shtick and will now shift to seduction. Which means even more inappropriate shenanigans, ha! Which will fail because Syd doesn't wanna cuck Elio! Hah! What a trainwreck!
Speaking of fanservice, Witch Watch spent a lotta time this week talking about fanservice and how they can't publish that crap in Jump anymore and LIES LIES LIES LIES, what the heck just happened in Syd Craft, you liar! They even had a hot springs episode! Liar! That said, the chapter was funny to me as an artist cause the thing about drawing fanservice shit and naked women (You know I have some in my backpocket) is that you never have a horny feeling from doing it. The non-reaction of, "You drew something lewd?" "Hm? Yes." is exactly the kind of conversation I've had with some artist friends who just drew some smut. When you enter the zone, no amount of horny effects your mind, and you actually kinda feel like an enlightened soul when you complete an extremely horny piece of art. I'm dead serious about this. It's an artist thing. Yeah, decently funny chapter. If I'm not mistaken, Shinohara and Yabuki are brother-in-laws, so the trivia in this chapter is some seriously behind the scenes stuff you won't get anywhere else. I'm almost half sure that phone log was an actual chat they had...
Ichi The Witch had Desscaras talk about becoming a family with Ichi. Which hopefully doesn't go the same way as whatever's happening in The Elusive Samurai. But I digress. There's no way Desscaras is marrying the dumb dumb, she's clearly gonna adopt him. The chapter's way more somber than anything that came before, which is a nice change to show the more serious aspects of Desscaras and her history. I feel like it implies that the World Hater Magik warped her little brother which is why she's so set on taking it down. It also sets up her want to adopt Ichi, even if he is gratingly feral. It's great that the characters are treating the fact that they'll be siccing some kid out to die for some prophecy with a great deal of seriousness, and it really adds dimensions to their characters where they were more comedic before this. The World Hater dude really brought so many layers into the manga. What a fantastic antagonist.
That's all. Goodbye~
Oh wait, I should do stuff like this too.
1) Sakamoto Days 200
2) Star of Beethoven 1
3) Syd Craft 11