Lots of good chapters this time around. Only the last 2-3 were disappointing.
Votes #11
1) Ichi
2) Syd
3) Kiyoshi
4) WW
5) Sakamoto
6) Beethoven
7) KGB
8) Astro
Ichi: Is her hat liquid? I love the little worldbuilding details in this series. And I love how reasonable everyone (well, almost everyone) is, from the leader who doesn't play games over the friend who knows not to pry to the mentor who can tell what her student needs even if he doesn't realise it himself.
Syd Craft: Him losing it was a little forced, but the treasure hunt was fun. And that treasure is so them. I'm also glad they
aren't actually stupid enough to just let random people into their house (looking at you, Elio). They seem oblivious, but they're actually quite sharp, which is much more fitting and interesting.
Kiyoshi: HAHAHAHAHA! Quite rude indeed. I love it.
WW: Wow, not wasting any time, that one. You go, girl! I like how straightforward and stubborn they all are. (Simply making the borders lighter is not a great way to indicate a flashback though, it took me three reads to figure out what was going on.) I wonder, does the
timeskip apply to the whole series or do these two exist in their own space?
Sakamoto: That was pretty dumb, to confront him
before telling anyone. It's pretty clear they are
father and son, but I still can't get a good read on the guy.
Star of Beethoven feels like it needed one more revision. There are a few places where it's kinda hard to tell who is talking and/or in what language, and the parts about Beethoven and about Yaso not playing anymore read like two different stories stitched together not quite as seamlessly as they should've been.
That said, the foundations are solid. The concept is interesting and more original than I expected (though it will require more explaining than a ghost), the characters have character and the writer has clearly done his/her research (well, except for the Austrian Empire being an old name for Germany, but I'll blame that on the boy not knowing any better). The art is nice too, nothing groundbreaking but it works.
I do wonder where the story will be going from here though, since we already kind of solved both main issues. Either we'll be investigating who or what is reviving corpses and sending them to Japan (hoping for this), or it'll become just another non-sports sports manga with a quirky teacher (expecting this). Could be fun, but I hope they do something more with Beethoven than just have him spout music advice.
KGB: Doesn't the enemy know about
her school now? Is the seal supposed to make them forget? I'd like it if she could go back, but it would make this stretch of manga rather pointless, so I don't think it's happening.
Astro: Someone's got a stick up his butt. I wonder what their problem is.
Also, it looks like Eyelashes
already had the weird eye thing in the flashback. So it isn't an Astro then?
Chojo: I knew I'd seen the guy before. This manga sure likes its crossovers (though they're laying it on a little thick with this one). Gotta admit, some of it made me laugh (especially the "Now I'm curious how you managed to last ten volumes.") And Chojo is acting kind of like an adult for once, so that's nice.
Shinobi: She's annoying. Other than that, decent chapter.
OP: A wild weirdo appears. He uses yapping attack. It's not very effective.
I wonder how well his next attack will hold up against the new generation. After all that build-up, it could go either way.
Nue: Always nice to get a break from the fighting. Looks like we got ourselves a new friend, and some new foes.
Akane: Interesting. But none of the characters are leaving a good impression here.
BB: Was okay. Glad we can move on.
Himaten: This chapter made me realise how much Same Face Syndrome this manga has going on. That first one could've been the mom of
any of the girls and the resemblance would've been striking.
I did like the meeting with the other mom, I'm glad they were able to talk without any unnecessary drama.
Embers: That was a lame misunderstanding. I'm happy it got resolved in the end, but still. And I kinda saw this coming, but
stop copying Haikyuu. It's not going to make you popular, it's going to make people see you as the discount version. Especially when you're this obvious about it.
Kill Blue: Told you you shouldn't have wasted time dyeing your hair.
I get what they were going for, but it didn't work for me. I would've bought it if he was just
thinking those things and freezing up because of it. But
saying them out loud, while crying and sobbing, in front of a conscious, not-yet-incapacitated enemy? That's so incredibly stupid and out of character for Ogami it made me laugh instead.
Elusive:
2. Star of Beethoven - Isekai. Isekai. Isekai. Nice title, but may I suggest, Beethoven Born in Another World: History's Strongest Pianist Reincarnates and Goes to School With His Apprentice? Too short?
And then the school is like "So, euhhh..... why do you look 60?"
genuinely wondering how people think chojo is getting axed when the author managed enough pull to land a kochikame crossover and now admitted in his own manga he got enough requests to do a Samon kun crossover
He got Samon fan letters. That doesn't prove people like his new series.
10. Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi: We meet all the Demon Lords and their personality. Even that woobie from chapter one! In my opinion, this is the last call: if the series stays strong in ToC and (hopefully) in sales, it can continue after this war. If not, this can easily serve as a good final arc.
What woobie from chapter 1? Do you mean the demon lord who attacked the church in chapter 2 (the older brother of the 3rd)? Or are you confusing the friendly low-level demon from chapter 1 with a demon lord?
Anyway, there are supposed to be 3 great demon lords + 13 demon lords and I think we've only killed 2 so far, so that leaves quite a few of them still missing.
1. Asuta Roth?
2. ??
3. ??
1. Tonjinchi?
2. Mukurojima (present)
3. Kurose (present)
4. Gorgon Mede (present)
5. Bakku Yoraku (present)
6. Hydrako (present)
7. Jack Joe? (ally)
8. ??
9. ??
10. ??
11. Meto? (dead, ch1)
12. Sata (dead, ch2)
13. Mouroku (present)
15. Syd Craft: Love is a Mystery: I love the running gag of Ms. Lily’s masterpiece theater, and of Lily always appearing in Syd business for that matter. But apart from that, there’s still too much love and too few mystery for my liking. Firsts chapters were better.
I didn't mind this time because
the whole trip was part of an ongoing investigation (even though it didn't yield any clues in the end). It bothers me more when they are just slacking off. But yeah, more real mysteries would be nice.
17. Star of Beethoven: Not so long ago there was a new series on Jump+ where some philosophers reincarnated to modern day Japan and interacted with the main character. I quit it after one chapter (my self imposed rules allow me to do that for Jump+ series), then it bombed and was axed pretty quickly. This appears to be a better series, but still…just sayin’.
Yeah, but those were obnoxiously loquacious and grandiloquent (try saying that 10 times fast). Beethoven seems to have the exact opposite mindset ("the more words one uses, the cheaper they seem"), so he probably won't be rambling all over the place.
Bonus question:
Where are this guy's eyes at? Is he looking to the left, looking to the right, looking straight ahead or looking at his nose?
Because I can see all four and it's kinda creeping me out.