I'm not a strong player anymore really, one of those recent wins was me making the dumbest mistake ever and everyone else being too confused at how stupid it was. I probably have too much ADHD for what the game is nowadays.
Could be.
Could also be Apprentice, "following" and "learning someone else's role" could just be considered "stalking" and "impersonating" which I myself would see as pervy because that action would mean you follow and watch that person everywhere, not a second of privacy.
So we have:
Two restless spirits (one that started with NVD)
Erin who claims bodyguard
Gry who claims and looks like a Noble of some sort
_____________
Juvs the Healthy Townie
Kami the Psych / TSC
Two restless spirits sounds weird to me. One sure, but 3 passive townie roles in a game of 14 where at least 4 are already anti-town? Seems weaksauce for Town role list.
Disclaimer: I didn't claim Spy. I claimed I was not the prostitute after you decided I had to be one. I didn't wanted to confuse the real prostitute into thinking I am the escort and starting to doubt me.
So are you. You could have claimed first thinking nobody else has that role in a game of 14 just to get surprised by the 2nd reveal. Happened to me couple times and I have seen it happening many times to other Mafia players as well, claiming first and then getting struck down by a townie claiming same role second.
Same. 2 Lovers plus threesome plus noble vote is a good way of getting a strong vote base for 3 players to get into a winning position with 7 players left to at least have a 50/50 chance of lynching a townie if everything else goes fubar. Or just get lucky and manipulate a townie into voting for another sus townie and win that way easy then.
Weeeeeeeeeeell, one of you could be lying about being restless for all we know. And that person might very well have either an active role or is simply the lover trying to slide into the townie folk by claiming restless early on.
In any case, my two top voting players today would be either Gry or Faust. I might vote Gry to have a Gry vs Faust and see what the remaining people who haven't voted yet will do.
Well, losing a healthy townie and a restless spirit, if true, wouldn't be the worst first two days. Like we had games where we lynched doc first day and det second day and the other way around, that's like way worse. XD
Sure it ain't good but if you die restless spirit? Then clearly something ain't right with the 2nd one. Though if DD was Mafia why would he claim the same role as you instead of playing it cool and saying he would claim day 3, switching his role during night 2 while talking to mafia after more and more hints or even outright role claims like yours get revealed through day 2?
Makes no sense, right?
So DD being actual real restless is way more plausible than having lied being restless. Whereas for you, you could either be 1 of 2 restless spirits in game (weird choice but hey we had our share of "interesting" role lists in Panda games) or you are Mafia going in with a bold early claim you expected uncontested aaaaaaand got contested for. So yeah, my and probably most townie's thought process which is why people are voting for you.
And they are voting for Gry for being disengaged and the likelyhood of Town Noble lover being very high in a game like this.
In any case, my two top voting players today would be either Gry or Faust. I might vote Gry to have a Gry vs Faust and see what the remaining people who haven't voted yet will do.
I gonna vote for Gry after all.
With that we got 4 people who haven't voted yet: Gry, Hardy (our two Healthy Townie lynchers), Juviii and Raeko. With a 3-3 it gonna be interesting to see arguments and vote behavior. Votekill Grysun
I gonna vote for Gry after all.
With that we got 4 people who haven't voted yet: Gry, Hardy (our two Healthy Townie lynchers), Juviii and Raeko. With a 3-3 it gonna be interesting to see arguments and vote behavior. Votekill Grysun
Because of what I just wrote above. 4 people left to vote, 2 who voted for our healthy townie, one of the 2 being on the chopping board with you while claiming a stronger role than you own. Seeing how the 4 remaining people will vote and argue might tell us a lot. Like is someone suddenly super vocal about killing you over a noble because noble vote oh so important compared to restless spirit or does someone silently switch their vote to Gry last minute to save you. For day 3, this voting can tell us a lot about the people who voted who for what reason.
To be clear I think Faust is trying well too. I'm either right on him being red and he's doing great to seed discord or I'm wrong and it's a fight between two dumb dumbs in same stubbornness.
nope not at all I've been playing for almost 20 years haha
The games on MH tend to be a lot more complex with roles than I'm used to though. I like to focus more on how people are behaving in thread than focusing on night actions
also I hate coming into games late like this >< it feels so slow to catch up but if I jump into what's happening in the present moment then I'm missing so much context
nope not at all I've been playing for almost 20 years haha
The games on MH tend to be a lot more complex with roles than I'm used to though. I like to focus more on how people are behaving in thread than focusing on night actions
also I hate coming into games late like this >< it feels so slow to catch up but if I jump into what's happening in the present moment then I'm missing so much context
Ah, I thought it might have been your first MH Mafia game since you joined last year in July and you might have come over to the Mafia side of the forum recently. Yeah, new people are usually shocked by the amount of roles we got (I am responsible for quite a few of these additions *proud self shoulder pat*), what's interesting are the many different actions and how people can spot lies with claims regarding role actions if they make no sense or couldn't have happened the way it was described.
To be clear I think Faust is trying well too. I'm either right on him being red and he's doing great to seed discord or I'm wrong and it's a fight between two dumb dumbs in same stubbornness.