Games Mafia Game 144 - Pan the Diver - Night 3

[Copy Panda]

D4 VOTES

Voting 0/11

.

DAY DURATION

Beware of the poll closing time. ​

 

[GrySun]

Oh, nvm. Wife went to sleep the kid so I can stay.

Idk what is so incriminating about him lying about wanting to stay shallow when his role was townie there, like this isn’t what an actual detective would do before they reveal they are sitting on a det role (I’m pretty sure other people are lying about depth they wanna be at too). Anyways, I gave my two cents, I think Dd is having his infamous Dd play.
I have to go now, will not be here probably for last moments. If I do find time, I will come.

The lying isn't the incriminating thing, it's that at the time we did not know that he lied for some believable reason. It looked like a mafia slip any way you look at it. So not wanting him lynched at that point in time, before DD came and improved his case, is rather odd.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 1:06 PM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 1:05 PM ---

DD has like 2 posts of substance, we spending more time talking about him than to him.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 1:07 PM ---

I just put townie first cause I thought I wouldnt get killed by mafia night 1 oh well

So which role is truly first? Spy or Det?

 

[Lumii?!]

Oh, nvm. Wife went to sleep the kid so I can stay.



The lying isn't the incriminating thing, it's that at the time we did not know that he lied for some believable reason. It looked like a mafia slip any way you look at it. So not wanting him lynched at that point in time, before DD came and improved his case, is rather odd.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 1:06 PM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 1:05 PM ---

DD has like 2 posts of substance, we spending more time talking about him than to him.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 1:07 PM ---

So which role is truly first? Spy or Det?

thing is he might die anyway, either by the votes or by the mafia if he reveals his role

 

[GrySun]

We should have 4 mafias here in 16 players game, so if DD is a mafia and we let him go we have 3 people we could in theory still find, if there's any info to get to them.

 

[Copy Panda]

votes updated

players yet to vote: @89_Snehal @Mazino
players who haven't posted 5 times yet: @89_Snehal @Mazino

~45mins left

 

[Stylether]

I'm most definitely not caught up, but I just want to point out, in regards to DD, this wasn't someone who just casually lied during hinting. This was someone who, when seeing some motion of voting against them, decided to "come clean" in an attempt to gain good PR, only for said info to end up being a lie.

What's even the point of the gesture if it ends up being false, you get caught on that falsitude, and you then make a cookie cutter correction.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 1:22 PM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 1:18 PM ---

ok

Votelock Nash

...

Why?

 

[GrySun]

I'm most definitely not caught up, but I just want to point out, in regards to DD, this wasn't someone who just casually lied during hinting. This was someone who, when seeing some motion of voting against them, decided to "come clean" in an attempt to gain good PR, only for said info to end up being a lie.

What's even the point of the gesture if it ends up being false, you get caught on that falsitude, and you then make a cookie cutter correction.

The point from a town-pov is likely greed. Escaping lynch and not being a mafia target, have your fish and eat it too.

 

[Stylether]

I’ll votekill Shino

Is this in response to her vote of Natasha?

 

[Holt]

Is this in response to her vote of Natasha?

Yes and the response to my questioning was not satisfactory

 

[Stylether]

The point from a town-pov is likely greed. Escaping lynch and not being a mafia target, have your fish and eat it too.

I see, do you personally feel like DD is still suspect, or if you had sole lynching authority, would you pick someone else rn, and who?

 

[SirSamuel016]

I wouldn't be against a shino lynch tbh; assuming dego isn't bomb at 0-50m he might be a safe lynch too

 

[GrySun]

I see, do you personally feel like DD is still suspect, or if you had sole lynching authority, would you pick someone else rn, and who?

I was plenty wrong over the years to not feel much confident anymore. I have some other people that bothered me but whether moving to them is better than staying on DD I am not sure.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 1:40 PM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 1:39 PM ---

We've kinda wasted 40mins of our 1 hour extension without having come much closer to other conclusions. DD also just peaced out, maybe busy.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 1:41 PM ---

While the 5-1 vote difference looks daunting at first, all it takes is me and Style switching to anyone else with 1 vote to change the lynch. But I don't know..

 

[SirSamuel016]

votelock shino

Maybe it was her subtle but not so subtle pushing of me after I heavily hinted defuser but something stinks

 

[Natasha]

I wouldn't be against a shino lynch tbh; assuming dego isn't bomb at 0-50m he might be a safe lynch too

Dego I'm not super keen on.
Shino I don't mind.
(Im locked so all i can offer is royal advice)

 

[Copy Panda]

~15mins

 

[GrySun]

Sam
Natasha
arrow
Val
Dego
Style
Holt
Tatsu
Pompom
Erin
shino
Lumi
Snehal
Mazino
DD

Mazino would surely not be missing out the whole day phase if he was scum. Surely..?

Snehal barely has posts, a spooked newbie mafia? Or just a town unsure what to say?

Lumi not sure why he's so far down for me, I'd move him up above everyone there til Tatsu. Dego further down, around Lumi.

 

[Stylether]

Dego I'm not super keen on.
Shino I don't mind.
(Im locked so all i can offer is royal advice)

Oh lady of the lake, what is your wisdom.

Also, I seem to have dropped an axe in there, did you happen to find it? It was golden, or silver, I'm not picky.

 

[GrySun]

Oh lady of the lake, what is your wisdom.

Also, I seem to have dropped an axe in there, did you happen to find it? It was golden, or silver, I'm not picky.

You taking things a bit lightly. Are you thinking still of what to do?

 

[Natasha]

Never Gry/Sam

I don't find issue with Sty/Holt

Weakest lynch with cause for being afk is Mazi

Slightly stronger is Snail

Pom/Shino is interesting. I don't think both should be mafia but I'd expect 1. Probably Shino.

DD is my preference nonetheless of his late reasoning. I don't see that play being natural for him.

 

[SirSamuel016]

Snehal barely has posts, a spooked newbie mafia? Or just a town unsure what to say?

said fuck all about themselves fwiw

 

[GrySun]

In theory nobody is really trying to save DD, unless his mafias are afk/gave up on him, but that may not mean much.