I'm so proud of you,
@Brandish. Posting only the one true panel that matters. You made me run tears of joy.
I really enjoyed the first two-thirds of this arc. Many o chara's got their chance to shine. Erwin was pretty epic, but he had such a death flag on him that it took a bit off it. At least most people thought he should've been titanified...
Yup, Erwin had quite the spotlight there. In general, he was a great character and top notch leader. Too bad he couldn't make it to the basement. He was so damn close.

Dunno whether I would have went with Armin or Erwin, my head kinda says Erwin while my heart goes for Armin. A though decision which was nicely portrayed, the struggle was real. Well, I can get over with character's deaths whom I like as long as there is a proper replacement. Armin may be not Erwin, but he has other qualities, so I'm fine with it.
The other bits where we found out about the world I wasn't crazy for, these reveals often aren't for me. However it's more about what the story does with that info from here, so I'll be waiting. Some of the stuff, like the baby bit, feels
connected to Historia's bump

Got more resource/population vibes from the Eldian story.
Arc ending at the beach was something we/Eren could see coming ; ) Eren couldn't be happy, because the memories have made him more Jellal-like... felt sorry for the other two, mainly Armin. Couldn't imagine how it would feel to see the ocean for those guys.
Do you have any idea what you would have preferred in regards to the reveals, any ideas? I already told you that the opinions differ. I can see where you guys are coming from. The reveals weren't that great for me either, but I have seen so many bad reveals that it makes a kinda okayish reveal - like in SnK's case - look
better than it actually is.

Revelations generally have the habit to disappoint because it takes away the thrill which was build up over so many years, hence expectations are very high. Well, that's at least the way I see it.
Where exactly does the Shiganshina Arc end? I thought it ended when they entered the basement and found that photo. But you seem to know way more than that (Eldian, baby, Historia, beach scene). I have to be careful to not spoil you, haha. But you made an interesting point, in the end it's up to the author what he intends to do with the revelations.
You would think Armin reaching the beach would be some kind of a happy epilogue panel at the end of the series, but the real deal is just starting for them.
Oh, does Eren have two great titan powers in him? lol.
You doing great, man!