Renegade said:
I think it looks awsome poster-edged. It gives it a nice thick jagged effect, and isn't so boring.
You really think it looks better like this?:
http://img201.imageshack.us/img201/4487/319colouredcover2xl6.png
... Cuz I sure don't.
Everywhere else I post it, people love it.
http://forums.narutofan.com/showthread.php?t=128668
Strange why everyone hates it here.
personally, i like it better that way, not considering the greys and a bit of other stuff. with some shading and more contrast to it, that version is way better imo. unless there is any real point in messing up the lineart, indeed i like it better that way.
plus, no one said anything about hating anything. this is just constructive crit, and most the other ones who gave u fb here are artists as well (iDookie, not so sure... :P sorry
![smile-big :D :D](/forum/styles/default/xenforo/smilies/smile-big.png)
) and know fairly well what they're talking about.
edit: to give you some constructive crit, and a few pointers, consider the following:
* the stone wall behind naruto: along the lineart there are lots of grey pixels. unlock the layer you used for this and color along the lineart to remove them. as long as your layer is kept under the background copy, you wont color over it.
* remove the grey pixels in other areas/layers in the same manner
* if you dont wanna go into shading objects (naruto, hamburger, etc), at least you should make a shadow (from naruto) on the bench to give it a bit more depth.
* his left hand has a totally different skin color than the rest of his skin
the tips above apply to the version with no poster edges effect applied. take care of a few, or all of these things, and your art will definitely improve.
cheers