Fantasy August vs Irene

[Garmadooon]

Dragon Irene is physically stronger but if August has DS Magic he can win. It depends who lands the hit first.

 

[sharkai]

It's pretty easy. It can go either way. Either Irene breaks his bones with her claws or August oneshots her with Melt.

how strong is melt?

 

[Darklord#10]

If melt is indeed a DS spell it will one shot Eileen. Eileen is extremely weak to DS magic august is exceptionally fast and has meteor. I'm not really going to get into melt is DS magic or not, I'm skeptical about that

What @FireIce said is what I think will happen to. It's just depends on who's smarter and faster. No bias from me here I consider both Eileen and august to be not smart characters.

 

[FireIce]

how strong is melt?

Strong enough to damage Natsu and co. despite Natsu shielding them with his heat/fire resistance

 

[sharkai]

Strong enough to damage Natsu and co. despite Natsu shielding them with his heat/fire resistance

didnt natsu have minor damage? you think that will one shot dragon irene?

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

Eileen is extremely weak to DS magic

proof?

 

[Darklord#10]

proof

GMG laxus didn't one shot any dragon. Atlas flame no sold his attack.
Irene got bullied out of her dragon form by erza it literally got one shot and dragon Eileen at the time was still stronger than erza. It shows that dragon Eileen is one shot material for characters who meets two criteria 1) as strong as x792 erza 2) has dragon slaying magic. You can Cope with your usual POF Erza is stronger than everyone nonsense it doesn't matter.

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

you think that will one shot dragon irene?

Yes it will.

 

[Garmadooon]

proof?

Spoiler

 

[sharkai]

Irene got bullied out of her dragon form by erza it literally got one shot and dragon Eileen at the time was still stronger than erza. It shows that dragon Eileen is one shot material for characters who meets two criteria 1) as strong as x792 erza 2) has dragon slaying magic. You can Cope with your usual POF Erza is stronger than everyone nonsense it doesn't matter.

isnt it normal for fairy tail villains to fall after nakama speech?
does pof not exist in fairy tail?
how come enchanted erza couldnt damage human irene that much, but could one shot dragon irene?
how can we scale erza slash against dragon irene?
what feats does august melt have?

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

Spoiler

so if i add picture of natsu one shotting rot aconologia, that would be proof of august featless spell can one rot aconologia?
how are you scaling erza attack?

 

[Darklord#10]

does pof not exist in fairy tail?

Did POF help natsu against jellal or laxus or zero? POF doesn't allow you skip tiers

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

isnt it normal for fairy tail villains to fall after nakama speech?

Aldoron and natsu were still boxing after natsu gave nakama speech.

 

[sharkai]

Did POF help natsu against jellal or laxus or zero? POF doesn't allow you skip tiers

valid point.
can gmg gajeel destroy gmg jellal sema, which jellal seems to be using as last resort against gmg Jura?

 

[FireIce]

didnt natsu have minor damage? you think that will one shot dragon irene?

Yes. But it still damaged him despite his heat resistance.

I hardly see Irene tanking Melt if she can't withstand a hit from Erza's sword enchanted with dragon slayer magic.

 

[Darklord#10]

so if i add picture of natsu one shotting rot aconologia, that would be proof of august featless spell can one rot aconologia?

This is so stupid and idiotic. August and acnologia don't even scale to each other in the first place. August is one shot material for pre rot human acnologia. Hell only dragon gods igneel and some power up version of natsu and zeref. isn't one shot material for pre rot human acnologia. Why would you even compare them?

 

[sharkai]

Aldoron and natsu were still boxing after natsu gave nakama speech.

one example doesnt disprove a normal. most of erza opponents fall after her nakama speech

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

Yes. But it still damaged him despite his heat resistance.

I hardly see Irene tanking Melt if she can't withstand a hit from Erza's sword enchanted with dragon slayer magic.

that was because it wasnt fire.

so a featless spell is all that is required to one shot dragon irene.

how are you scaling erza enchanted sword

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023 ---

This is so stupid and idiotic. August and acnologia don't even scale to each other in the first place. August is one shot material for pre rot human acnologia. Hell only dragon gods igneel and some power up version of natsu isn't one shot material for pre rot human acnologia. Why would you even compare them?

because melt is a featless spell. and erza is one shottable material to dragon irene.
and once aconologia couldnt move (magical immunity), the ds move that hit him, one shotted him

both aconologia and dragon irene came across ds magic once which they werent immune to or blocking. this, in your mind, made it 100% that irene is super weak to ds magic

 

[Darklord#10]

valid point.
can gmg gajeel destroy gmg jellal sema, which jellal seems to be using as last resort against gmg Jura?

What you're saying doesn't even make sense. What exactly are you trying to prove. You can't be seriously trying to prove that erza can hit harder than august? Atleast that erza. Erza was very much still weaker than Eileen back then it's just that Eileen's dragon durability is literal shit. She's one of the first dragon that straight up got overpowered in her dragon form even merchphobia didn't get destroyed like she did. Infact you can even make an argument that Eileen in general wasn't much above erza but let's not get into that

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

because melt is a featless spell. and erza is one shottable material to dragon irene.
and once aconologia couldnt move (magical immunity), the ds move that hit him, one shotted him

Stop comparing acnologia with august. Besides the attack that downed acnologia was an attack that was combined with the seven dragon slayers and natsu was in dragon force against acnologia to

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023 ---

both aconologia and dragon across ds magic once which they werent imune to or blocking. this, in your mind, made it 100% that irene is super weak to ds magic

GMG dragons didn't get one shot
Half powered merchphobia didn't get one shot
Aldoron didn't get one shot. I don't know what you're trying to prove here. Irene is weak to DS magic. All august needs to do is hit as hard as Erza did and Eileen is fucked

 

[sharkai]

What you're saying doesn't even make sense. What exactly are you trying to prove. You can't be seriously trying to prove that erza can hit harder than august? Atleast that erza. Erza was very much still weaker than Eileen back then it's just that Eileen's dragon durability is literal shit. She's one of the first dragon that straight up got overpowered in her dragon form even merchphobia didn't get destroyed like she did. Infact you can even make an argument that Eileen in general wasn't much above erza but let's not get into that

what doesnt make sense. erza is one shot material for dragon irene. yet she destroyed deus sema, irene on screen strongest move.
projecting from this, we can easily predict, that gmg gajeel was capable of destroying gmg jellal sema. and yet, jellal used it against jura, why?

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

GMG dragons didn't get one shot
Half powered merchphobia didn't get one shot
Aldoron didn't get one shot. I don't know what you're trying to prove here. Irene is weak to DS magic. All august needs to do is hit as hard as Erza did and Eileen is fucked

why is irene, the only dragon weak to ds. maybe you arent scaling erza move correctly?

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023 ---

All august needs to do is hit as hard as Erza did and Eileen is fucked

can you provide august strongest move, please. and its feat

 

[Darklord#10]

why is irene, the only dragon weak to ds. maybe you arent scaling erza move correctly?

SHE GOT ONE SHOT

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

can you provide august strongest move, please. and its feat

All august need to do is be stronger than erza that's literally all it takes to wreck Eileen's dragon form and DS magic to

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023 ---

what doesnt make sense. erza is one shot material for dragon irene. yet she destroyed deus sema, irene on screen strongest move.

What is the correlation between this

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023 ---

projecting from this, we can easily predict, that gmg gajeel was capable of destroying gmg jellal sema. and yet, jellal used it against jura, why?

And this. What is the analogy between both of them

 

[Garmadooon]

@sharkai Erza isn't even top 3 in the guild in terms of power attacks. Her POF increases her durability and physical abilities but not her attack power. August >>>>>> POF Erza so if he can copy DS magic he can land a hit on Dragon Irene. Don't compare this situation with Natsu/Acnologia because Natsu had the help of all of Ishgar, Erza only had the help of Wendy.

 

[sharkai]

@sharkai Erza isn't even top 3 in the guild in terms of power attacks. Her POF increases her durability and physical abilities but not her attack power. August >>>>>> POF Erza so if he can copy DS magic he can land a hit on Dragon Irene. Don't compare this situation with Natsu/Acnologia because Natsu had the help of all of Ishgar, Erza only had the help of Wendy.

so we ignore erza destroying deus sema?

 

[Garmadooon]

so we ignore erza destroying deus sema?

Gildarts and Natsu can destroy Deus Sema if they are in POF. And August can destroy it, he has the best durability feats among the 12.

 

[Darklord#10]

why is irene, the only dragon weak to ds. maybe you arent scaling erza move correctly?

Hell igneel didn't even get one shot by acnologia. Half dead igneel was at a disadvantage against igneel. Not only was he not at full power, acnologia was stronger than him, acnologia was a dragon slayer and he is also immune to magic but igneel managed to keep himself in the fight against acnologia....... dragon Irene got bullied out of her dragon form by just one slash from a dying erza