Fantasy August vs Irene

[sharkai]

not really. just speaking the truth. besides most of the people think that Laxus stomps Erza. it doesn't mean they wank him. maybe my boy @Laxus chan-yo (not baiting, he knows me)

ffs, people say that Natsu one shots Erza. that's even worse lol

heck, I even like Erza almost as much as Laxus. not fond of her fights though.

besides, I doubt that Irene will show us anything new.

August is currently worth the hype which is why he wins here with mid diff, maybe high diff.

That is because he hasnt fought a main character yet. Wait till august comes across lucy. It will take him forever to put her down lol
Only relevant character he put down is jellal who was getting up. And jellal doesnt need to be stronger than erza

I dont know. You changed
I think someone hacked your account
Earlier you were.like with nakagami erza could probably defeat laxus in gmg. Now you think erza and mira arnt enough. You definitely arent the same person from before

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 14, 2017, Original Post Date: Jan 14, 2017 ---

It's not really about being an Erza fan or not. Personally erza has always been one of my favourite characters. But i'm just not going to pretend that Erza is Laxus's equal.

Its more like when you accept one hyoe over the other
Not this time skip. Erza has yet to finish her arc fight but before this time skip
Jellal nor laxus were ever portrayed to be above erza. Fan made it that by choosing selective hype.

 

[Demon Hunter]

I dont know. You changed

too much salt from FT made my change

Earlier you were.like with nakagami erza could probably defeat laxus in gmg. Now you think erza and mira arnt enough. You definitely arent the same person from before

Nakagami slices through Time and Space. she stomps.

besides, I voted for Erza and Mirajane against Laxus.

That is because he hasnt fought a main character yet. Wait till august comes across lucy. It will take him forever to put her down lol
Only relevant character he put down is jellal who was getting up. And jellal doesnt need to be stronger than erza

we are joking about that man.

August feats are still better than Irene's.

unless he gets owned by, I don't know, Meredy.

 

[Takuan]

Its more like when you accept one hyoe over the other
Not this time skip. Erza has yet to finish her arc fight but before this time skip
Jellal nor laxus were ever portrayed to be above erza. Fan made it that by choosing selective hype.

Spoiler: Off topic

Come on now. Laxus had to be nerfed to the ground and even then he maaged to take down a Spriggan. A Spriggan that's supposed to be on the same level as the one who destroyed Erza.
I know Erza will probaby defeat Irene soon, but again i think Laxus will also play another role soon. All we've seen from Laxus so far this arc is when he was dieing, and he still displayed better feats than Erza...

Both Jellal and Erza were portrayed to be above Erza.
Jellal by being a Wizard Saint for a while, actually he was a WS from the real begining and that was with only his thought projection. He also was fighting evenly with Jura during GMG, one who was called a beast.
Laxus, because he defeated Jura in GMG.
Also when Mystogan was introduced with his sleep magic, Erza, Mirajane and the rest of the guild were always put asleep. The only one having the MP needed to resist being put asleep were Makarov and... Laxus.
Laxus has been portrayed as better than Erza for a good while. You're kidding yourself if you genuinely believe Erza was / or is, stronger than him.

EDIT: just fell into the trap called out of topic. Damn.
Last time i'm arguing about erza or Laxus respective powers, out of a thread concerning them.

Regarding Irene vs August, for now August wins mid diff at most. I'm wondering who will take on August from FT, he seems invincible. I'm hoping for Gildartz Laxus Jellal or something like that.

 

[Seven777]

August still wins, imo only in dragon form or at least when using DS magic is Eileen his equal and even then im not certain she'd win.

EDIT: just fell into the trap called out of topic. Damn.

Dont feel too bad, i fell for it too

 

[Ilikeyou]

Irene in dragon form should win. Il pick august over her human form tho because her feats in that form were pretty bad. So for me dragon Eilleen midd diff august and august high or extreme diffs Eilleen. I do really think Eilleen could have destroyed erza without her dragon form but just went to that form because of her rage.

 

[Seven777]

So is August's "Melt" used with DS fire? Kinda implied he copied Natsu's magic.... If so he oneshots. I wonder if he copied God Serena and Laxus' magic. Also curious how fast Eileen is, cause she'd need to attack August with her claws or teeth if she wanted to hurt him.

 

[The President]

So is August's "Melt" used with DS fire? Kinda implied he copied Natsu's magic.... If so he oneshots. I wonder if he copied God Serena and Laxus' magic. Also curious how fast Eileen is, cause she'd need to attack August with her claws or teeth if she wanted to hurt him.

I think he has to actually see the magic to copy it so I don't think Melt was a dragon slaying spell (probably just some spell he learned before). However what he should know is Serenas magic (probably stopped Jacob just to see and copy it), and he would be able to use it with far more power (due to vastly superior MP), he should be capable of slaying Irene with that. Even without that all it takes is Irene unknowingly firing off a roar and its the end of her.

Dude probably has access to the magic of every spriggan 12 member (sans Wahl and Bradman). Pretty absurd once you think about it.

 

[Brandish μ]

It was implied that August used Fire DS in my view, since those panel demonstrated moments where he copied an opponent. However that spell in particular doesn't resemble a FD technique, so I'm on the fence about this. DSM comes from a dragon enchanting power, or a lacrima... perhaps August' ability is an exception here since he's acquiring the magic itself.

If August has DSM he'll defeat Irene.

If August doesn't have DSM, Irene will win.

Hopefully there is more to August to come, so will revisit next week.

 

[Takuan]

Considering that Dragon Irene was defeated by a mere sword imbued with DS, and the fact that AUgust has access to every magic he's seen which includes DS magic... Makes no doubt in my eyes that August wins.

 

[Stormsfury]

Irene ain't a holder type. August copies and neutralises her magic, then he stomps her.

If anyone votes Irene (especially after the latest chapter) they're just fanboys/fangirls

 

[Brandish μ]

Irene doesn't need to be a holder. She's a dragon. That gives her at least a 50-50 chance.

August is the one who needs to be a slayer. I think he's a good chance of being one, and if so he wins.

 

[Seven777]

Even if August cant copy DS magic(though imo that panel implied he copied Natsu's fire DS) August could just Age Seal her, or just repeatedly summon God Serena's Historia powered with his enormous MP, or the historia of any other Dragon Slayer Eileen has ever met during her time as queen of the dragons.
To avoid damage he could easily keep his distance with Meteor, or Racer's magic or Mest's magic.
Without PiS August is virtually unstoppable to anyone but Zeref cause he's immortal and Acnologia cause he's Acnologia.

 

[Demon Hunter]

my standing on this battle is this

August > base Irene
Dragon Irene > August

 

[Ilikeyou]

no even with the latest chapter Dragon Irene>august imo. August would maybe win if he has copied dragon slaying magic from god serena but even with dragon slaying magic(excluding pis)It still takes a lot of magic to overpower a dragon especially someone who has the same or higher mp than you. We only saw a glimpse of dragon Irene power and she brought a pretty big meteor(even tho the queen of asspulls destroyed it easily) She is probably capable of stuff on a next level destruction. While august is more versatile. Irene can also do a lot of shit with just being a high enchanter like turning people to mice,atmosphere enchants,berserk,environmental enchants,universe 1 and etc, so imagine all that but with a lot more power into it. I'm probably sure he can copy Irene magic in her human form but I doubt dragon form. August most likely never meet dragon so I dont think he will be able to copy her magic. If august brought back god serena that still wouldn't do much. Yes he is a dragon slayer but he is still a historia. Lol I bet Irene would just give him the stare erza give her historia and his gone.

 

[Takuan]

It still takes a lot of magic to overpower a dragon especially someone who has the same or higher mp than you

What are you saying... All it took was Wendy's magic power, and she was extremely exhausted. I'm pretty sure August's MP is higher than what Wendy had at this moment...

 

[Ilikeyou]

What are you saying... All it took was Wendy's magic power, and she was extremely exhausted. I'm pretty sure August's MP is higher than what Wendy had at this moment...

that is why I said excluding PIS and asspull which that was.

 

[The President]

that is why I said excluding PIS and asspull which that was.

If August has dragon slaying magic I don't see how there is any question that he would obliterate Irene. Even without it the fight would be hard fought, with the only thing going for Irene is her resistance to magic (which, with DS, August utterly bypasses). Although even then, as mentioned before, August can likely just summon a dozen of powerful DS mages (including Serena) from Irene's past.

 

[Star Frost]

What are you saying... All it took was Wendy's magic power, and she was extremely exhausted. I'm pretty sure August's MP is higher than what Wendy had at this moment...

Wait what do you mean by it took Wendy's magic power and she was exhausted?

 

[Takuan]

Wait what do you mean by it took Wendy's magic power and she was exhausted?

We were talking about the Magical Power needed for a spell or an attack to defeat Dragon Irene. All it took for that Erza sword to defeat Irene was the tiny bit of DS magic Wendy had left.

 

[Ilikeyou]

If August has dragon slaying magic I don't see how there is any question that he would obliterate Irene. Even without it the fight would be hard fought, with the only thing going for Irene is her resistance to magic (which, with DS, August utterly bypasses). Although even then, as mentioned before, August can likely just summon a dozen of powerful DS mages (including Serena) from Irene's past.

cause even if you have ds that doesn't automatically make you win against a dragon. GMG arc dragons were clear proof. Natsu and the rest iirc were not able to defeat the dragons even tho they were clear dragon slayers. Iirc.