Blackbeard vs. Magellan Round 2

[RichardMNixon]

So someone started a thread about Blackbeard's business in ID with discussion on what happens when he runs into Magellan again, I thought this fight might be appropriate.

Do you think another fight would turn out the same way, or was Blackbeard sucker punched? Would he win if he knew he was fighting for his life?

 

[Katz]

BB might be able to "absorb" magellan's hydra etc, but I dont see how'd he prevent from inhaling the poision, I still give the nod to Magellan

 

[RichardMNixon]

I really liked someone's suggestion way back when that if Blackbeard just touched Magellan, Magellan would likely lose his immunity to the poison he's covered in and be out of the game for good.

 

[msg]

It's Magellan win..BB will be like that monk character from inuyasha who sucks everything including miasma poison from his hand.I don't think he could absorb all that poison.

 

[Ooblahh]

I really liked someone's suggestion way back when that if Blackbeard just touched Magellan, Magellan would likely lose his immunity to the poison he's covered in and be out of the game for good.

If Blackbeard touched Magellan he would lose the ability to turn into poison/ he won't be covered in poison anymore.

 

[RichardMNixon]

If Blackbeard touched Magellan he would lose the ability to turn into poison/ he won't be covered in poison anymore.

He doesn't turn into poison, but he is covered with it. Why would poison he had already produced instantly disappear as soon as he lost the power?

Interesting that everyone has an opinion one way or the other, no one in the middle.

 

[Poneglyph420]

This fight really depends if BB has time to use his DF power or not..
If so He should win IMO.. but otherwise he's done..
One quick Hydra and he's toast...

 

[kkck]

I think that if BB does not underestimate magellan he can take this. Most of magellans poisons can be absorbed by the darkness. A combination of gravity and darkness would allow BB to get rid of the poison and attract magellan to cancel his ability. In that situation magellan could end up being burt by his own poison and take some reasonable damage from BB actual physical strength.

 

[beastboy]

Well...
I think it would end the exact same way...

If BB is slow... Maggelen hydra is fast... so I think Maggelen wins..
To touch him, Luffy needed Gear2...

To touch some one, BB always uses kuro uzo... wich would be suicide... cause the a hydra would be faster when caught in that.
And if he was hited by an hydra.. he wouldn't be able to touch maggelan...

I can't see BB winning cause of his lack of speed.
We can clearly see that he fights steady taking every hit and fighting back...
with poison, that will kill him..
after taking an hydra he will miss every attack.. and be open to more poisons!

Maggelan takes this one!

 

[Franckie]

Magellan's offensive powers are indeed great, possibly even greater than any of the 3 Admirals. Still, I don't see Magellan winning Round 2. BB won't be careless in this fight and will make sure to suck up the poison before he punches Magellan senseless, though not at the ease BB had with Ace.

 

[modoki]

honestly its unclear how much antidote shiryuu carries at the moment. But aside from that, they both sit in one spot like old men and fight. BB has the upper hand in this fight as far as nullifying DF powers goes.

In reality Shiryuu wants Magellan's head more than anyone.

 

[bittman]

Meh, I haven't voted yet for good reason.

On one hand: Blackbeard is an unknown quantity. He appears to struggle dealing with Luffy in ID, gets owned by Magellan in a heartbeat and even struggles Ace with their battle. But then he is said to have the strength to break necks, ability to cancel fruits on a touch, and to have wounded Shanks and killed a division commander. BB is still more hype than show.

And on the other hand: Magellan is quite possibly the strongest parmecia fruit user we've ever seen. Powerful enough to keep the world's strongest criminals in a state of fear, and send hardened veterens running for their lives. Minus a little blood emerging from his mouth, we have not seen Magellan take much physical damage despite canon fire, Luffy punches and other misc attacks, indicating that, even if you ignore his fruit, he has good tolerance and defensive capabilities. Drawing out a battle against a strong defence is natural, and Magellan is the type that you cannot afford to draw out a battle with.

Yet that said, BB is being set up by Oda as a great villain. The plot side of me says that BB will win the next confrontation between the two (or Shiryuu), but what we've seen still tells me that Magellan is beyond BB's league. Heck, Magellan is top tier and up there with where I'd rate admirals, Yonkou and mid/top tier Shichibukai.

 

[Pyrus]

http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/441/11/

BB can absorb anything but it still affects him, so its not like him absorbing Magellan's poisons will somehow detoxify them.

 

[LeKuaSimi]

no..What he meant is that he cannot transform into darkness to dodge attacks. Does not mean he cannot use his dark hole to suck up all the poison. If sucking anything with darkhole would hurt him, wouldn't he be pierced by the knifes/weapons/broken building material he sucked along with the village during the fight with Ace?

 

[OunknownO]

one question, would bb lose his df powers if he touched himself wile preforming his attack

 

[Fox666]

No, he would attrack the DF powers to himself, which is were they already reside...

 

[Oblivion]

If Magelan goes all out right from he start and creat his 'destroys-everything-toxic-giant' to create a wall inbetween himself and BB he won't be sucked in and the giant or a hydra would defeat BB.

All Magelan has to do is not being touch. With the giant and hydra he can do it. Constand hydra attacks would hinder BB from creating dark vortex to suck magelan into melee range.

Normally a range attack doesn't matter much to BB coz he'll just take it like he did with Luffy's punch and Ace's Lance, but Hydra is a onehit. He HAS to avoid it no matter what.

But for any reason Magelan is touched by BB, BB would have to not let go of him and beat the crap out of him right away.

Magelan took Iva's attack and Luffy's punch but it clearly didn't stop him much. So BB would have hit as hard as we have never seen before.

 

[frontaLobotomy]

I voted that Teach would barely win, emphasis must be placed on barely. While Magellan is clearly very strong, Blackbeard has the DF that is designed to take out other DF users. One bit of poison that isn't sucked in by his gravity powers and it's win for Magellan though.

 

[LeKuaSimi]

Or he can use black hole on magellan and liberate him when convenient.

 

[kkck]

Hhhmmm... Quite frankly I don't see what magellan could do once BB does this:
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/441/19/

Look at the absurd amount of darkness he released there. What could magellan do against that? Such an amount of darkness would more than easily every ounce of poison magellan can through and more. Even more, it can absorb magellan a billion times over. If BB is serious there is no reason for him to lose.