Critique my Cleaning

[mwsmws22]

Let me know what you think! Much appreciated!

Spoiler: Raw

Spoiler: Clean

 

[Mana Light]

It looks fine but you should test with some more raws of that manga to see if the way is actually good.

Spoiler: My cleans at 1600 px

Spoiler: at 1900 px (I choose this size. For your way, 1600 px is correct size because you use topaz)