Discussion Dark Guilds Power Rate [ANNOUNCEMENT!]

[Ebony Maw]

The Ishgar Mages have had their glory, it's time for the Dark Mages to shine!











The Dark Mages Rate

Now sadly this isn't being hosted by @BluePegasus, but he kindly let me and @Gryffindor manage this power rank in his stead. Now with that being said, we have 38 of the cruelest mages from 5 different but equally vicious dark guilds to rank!​

This is what you need to do:
- Rate every mage on a power scale from 1 to 10 (you may use half marks like 1,5 and 2,5, however you can't score characters as 10.5) and send them to @Gryffindor in PM. You may give one 11 to the dark mage that you think is the strongest out of all the others.
- Compare them with each other, and not with characters outside the rate.
- You can't change your scores after submitting.
- Make this work for everyone and don't send in troll votes.​

The contestants

Spoiler: Oracion Seis

Brain
MacBeth/Midnight
Erik/Cobra
Sawyer/Racer
Richard/Hoteye
Sorano/Angel
Zero

Spoiler: Grimoire Heart

Azuma
Ultear Milkovich
Meredy
Zoldeo
Zancrow
Rustyrose
Kain Hikaru
Bluenote Stinger
Precht Gaebolg/Hades

Spoiler: Raven Tail

Obra
Flare Corona
Ivan Dreyar

Spoiler: 9 Demon Gates

Kyoka
Seilah
Silver Fullbuster
Keyes
Ezel
Franmalth
Jackal
Tempesta
Torafuzar
Jiemma
Lamy
Mard Geer Tartaros

Spoiler: Avatar

Mary
Briar
D-6
Jerome
Abel
Arlock
Gouman

Rules

- The Oracion Seis are in their Tartaros incarnations
- Similarly, Ultear is in her GMG incarnation and Meredy is in her Tartaros incarnation
- No restrictions
- Precht/Hades has the "Devil's Heart"
- Didn't vote? Don't complain

VOTING CLOSES JULY 8TH, 7 PM GMT!!!

Once the voting period ends there will be three eliminations per day until #25, after that there will be two eliminations per day until #10, and at that point there will be one elimination per day.

If you wish to participate, copy and paste this list and put your scores behind their names

Spoiler: PM list

- MacBeth/Midnight
- Erik/Cobra
- Sorano Agria/Angel
- Richard/Hoteye
- Sawyer/Racer
- Brain
- Zero
- Ultear Milkovich
- Meredy
- Kain Hikaru
- Azuma
- Zoldeo
- Zancrow
- Rustyrose
- Bluenote Stinger
- Precht Gaebolg/Hades
- Flare Corona
- Obra
- Ivan Dreyar
- Jackal
- Tempesta
- Keyes
- Torafuzar
- Ezel
- Seilah
- Kyoka
- Silver Fullbuster
- Franmalth
- Jiemma
- Lamy
- Mard Geer Tartaros
- Mary
- Arlock
- Jerome
- Briar
- Gouman
- D-6
- Abel

 

[BluePegasus]

YESYESYESYES!

I swear if y'all gonna do Obra wrong..

 

[Takuan]

Holy shit, i didn't expect it to begin that fast! That's GREAT !!!
You better do as good of a job as BluePegasus did

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 2, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 2, 2017 ---

" - Similarly, Ultear and Meredy are in their Tartaros incarnations "

Does that mean Ultear is already old? Can't we consider young Ultear?

 

[Hermit]

Does that mean Ultear is already old? Can't we consider young Ultear?

Young her from the GMG

 

[CaptainTorch]

This is gonna be fun!! I had a list of tiers beforehand, which considered the character growth in both of the timeskips. So it came in handy! The Top 2 characters should be farther away from the others, but I didn't have enough points, so I guess it will suffice.
Glad that I came in time for this event! I was late the last time....

 

[Brandish μ]

PM'ing now. I didn't know where to put Ultear's ass on this. Very hard with Avatar as well, comparing them to previous villains.

- Didn't vote? Don't complain

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 3, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 3, 2017 ---

Neo-Minerva

 

[**Silver**]

Cobra is in the first place nothing else to say when the power levels is so twisted... so the war begins

 

[Ebony Maw]

Just updated the rules to clarify that Ultear is in her GMG incarnation. If there is anything else that needs updating or any questions feel free to ask them in this thread or PM me.

Sorry for the confusion and thanks to @Takuan and @Emperor Spriggan for bringing it up.

 

[Arjuna]

Pmed.

Infact this was difficult than Spriggan and Ishgar ranking.In the previous two we did on current powerlevel.

But here we are doing simply on previous feats.I feel this will be a great tournament.Waiting to see the results.

 

[Baszko]

Well clearly this will be hard too judge but i will look mostly how they do at they time because we don't know how powerfull charaters like Azuma would be if they would be alive. Still i am sure that Avatar will be first out only to be folowed by Raven tail but rest... This will be harder to predict.

 

[Ebony Maw]

I've just updated the rules to clarify that while you can give characters half marks (like 1.5 or 2.5), you can't give characters the score of 10.5.

Sorry if this causes any inconveniences.

 

[Baszko]

Pmed some were tough ones !! can't wait to see results !!! I speaking of avarage score : Avatar lowest for obvious reasons then Raven tail soled by Luxus
and here is Balam Alliance And this is tough i can easyli see all possible combination on place from 3 to 1

I've just updated the rules to clarify that while you can give characters half marks (like 1.5 or 2.5), you can't give characters the score of 10.5.

Sorry if this causes any inconveniences.

almost give 10,5 almost !
I so eager to se who wil win Hades? or Mard gear?

 

[Ebony Maw]

Glad to see so many people are taking part in this!

almost give 10,5 almost !
I so eager to se who wil win Hades? or Mard gear?

This is what's interesting me to, to be honest I personally think Mard deserves to win, but Hades is an absolute beast so he'd be more than deserving too.

 

[CaptainTorch]

I ranked the characters by their strength at the time. Which means I didn't assume that people like Azuma got stronger. And one thing is important - after the 2nd origin FT powered up a lot, so the new enemies(Tartaros) were also quite stronger. I find Jackal for example to be above Azuma. Hades and Mard Geer is a very interesting dillema though. I personally think Mark is a bit superior, but it's super close. At least we know what characters will get the 2nd and 1st place lol.

 

[Star Frost]

I'm so use to the current power levels for the Alvarez Arc that ranking these guys was so hard that I'm not so sure mine was even accurate.

 

[Doughboy]

Mard Geer gonna be #1. Hades 2 but dude is so overrated looking back on it.

 

[Hermit]

@Jko @Orgastthemage @Laxus chan-yo @Laxus pwns natsu @Linali
You guys wanna try this out?

 

[Takuan]

I don't even know if i will do this. This is EXTREMELY hard. I might just watch on the sidelines, which is a shame.

 

[Pheromone]

This was fun. Looking forward to seeing how Silver does.

 

[Baszko]

I see... i did my rating in soo difrent way... Ups? Any way I personly put Hades Abuve Mard for reasons like: Hades fight agnist like 6[counting Luxus] Powerful mages while Mard agnist 2 of them , I find Hades Magic and his versality more impresive than Mard curse and demon form. Also he got heavier plot device to get him down with having cat team destroying his heart[until then he was wining and would win] while Mard have disadvantage of Gray devil slayer magic featlike and battlelike both had it good through....[ i swear that it is in top fights in fairy tail]