- Joined
- Dec 19, 2007
- Messages
- 293
- Reaction score
- 245
- Gender
- Female
- Country
-
Do you have a link, or know where I could find that interview for Hoshino not caring for the last anime? I could use that in some of my writings regarding the last anime and how unfaithful (and bad) it was compared to the source material.First of all, here are minimum requirements for an original work to have more than 1 cour anime adaption:
-The original work has enough material
-The assigned studio either big or has enough budget if they are not Shaft/Kyoani (these two basically do whatever they want)
D.Gray-man Hallow fails to meet both requirements.
Second, filler won't do any justice. They are the worse things ever happened to the previous anime. Hoshino even never wanted the anime to continue due to all those change in the previous anime until she got convinced (source: Kosuge's interview). If the budget isn't that much to begin with (which has been clearly shown in the cast), it'd better be spent on taking care of the quality.
Third, Madoka is just 12 episodes at first and it's a masterpiece, meanwhile Fate UBW has serious pacing problems due to being 2 cours and you don't want the same thing happened to Sousei no Onmyouji happens to DGMH. 13 episodes is fine if the director is competent enough and D.Gray-man Hallow has that covered by Hoshino.
Final, more than half of those who is bitching about the 1 cour never think of buying BD/DVD even though THAT's one of the most crucial condition to get a series new adaption (though that's not really the case with DGM)
Though I also prefer two cours, this is understandable
In any case, Hoshino being involved may help the anime. I am disappointed it's only 1 cour. But I can see why now. Maybe they'll pick it back of years later when the manga is finally done. After all, plenty didn't think we'd even get this (Hallow)
I only have limited anime experience. Elfen Lied and Blood+ were both short anime. And both deviated from the manga hugely. The latter was still good in a different way. The former just butchered everything and sucked. But that creator mentioned that he chose to leave out some manga stuff because he didn't like it -which included a character.
Last edited:
I had to look and see who that was, because the name was anime-only. The character was unnamed in the manga.