Did Ace Survive...

[Impel Down]

He also loves his crew mates like his children.

 

[Anti-panda]

I think the real question this topic should be, should be "Did ace escape after his fight with black beard or did he get captured?"
Because lets face it Deaths are far and few in between in OP ... At least as far as named or central figures go. So the real situation is did ace get owned by blackbeard and get captured or did it end in pretty much a stalemate and Ace escape?
I think Ace got Captured ... and if BB hands him over to the World Govt then it may cause Whitebeard to take action against the govt. That would be cool.

 

[Impel Down]

If he lost and didn't die, then yes he got captured. Probably held in BB's black hole.

 

[The Boff]

its actually very simple.

Oda has a "ban of Death" in OP. info here:
http://mangahelpers.com/forums/showthread.php?p=127716#post127716

so simply put. Yes he survived. but he was probably captured.
and remember this:

my guess:
Ace being captured led to Blackbeard becoming a Shichibukai. and that leads to whitebeard going after Blackbeard and THAT will most probably be the great incident.
cause when one of the 4 emperors goes directly after a government "employed" man... we're talking about war.
and that could without a doubt be an opening for Dragon to attack as well.

just speculation but not impossible.

 

[Absolutio]

you made a good point here. it also fits with the theory of mine that ace will be held in the WG prison, near their HQ, so it might be an awesome "save ace" arc with WB+luffy(+shanks maybe).

 

[Impel Down]

So BB will become a shichibukai, putting them back into full power, and as he tries to reach Raftel, he battles with Luffy, which is the Great Incident.

 

[Anti-panda]

Whitebeard VS The World Govt.
That would be huge ... the colapse of the three great powers and a war between a yonkou and the world govt.

 

[Impel Down]

Well, if WB tangled with the entire WG, he'd probably lose.

 

[kadodo]

I don't think Oda will kill anybody in his manga. As a matter of fact we only know that the hat was down but we don't kow if he really lost the fight

 

[Impel Down]

Oda killed Brook, didn't he? And Brook is a major character.

 

[kadodo]

Oda killed Brook, didn't he? And Brook is a major character.

Here is what I think, if the person is a major character, he/she will not be killed. Broke was dead true but still get to see him because he had the life fruit or something like that

 

[Impel Down]

Lots of people in the flashbacks got killed.

 

[kadodo]

Lots of people in the flashbacks got killed.

True, true but tell me a charater that you liked very much and Oda decided to kill it

 

[Impel Down]

Kaku. It's pretty safe to assume that he's dead.

 

[Absolutio]

even crocodile, which luffy despises didnt die, although thousands of ppl died and suffered because of him. that was the first time that i really was disappointed from one piece ban of death.

 

[kadodo]

Kaku. It's pretty safe to assume that he's dead.

I don't remember who kaku is, was it during the crocodile arc?

 

[The Boff]

PEOPLE!!!

stay on topic or ill start deleting your posts and start sending warnings...
if you wanna discuss the ban of death then there is a thread for that:
http://mangahelpers.com/forums/showthread.php?p=127716#post127716

so here you talk about Ace's life and repercussions to that, ok?
ok.

 

[Impel Down]

Okay, okay. It's pretty obvious that Ace didn't die because of they way they had the end of the battle. It was like Luffy vs. Croc the first time, and Luffy didn't die.

(Also, Kaku was a CP9 member)

 

[Absolutio]

i just thought of it.. if ace is alive and imprisoned in impel down. what would garp do?

 

[Impel Down]

Nothing. He's a pirate, so he should be imprisioned is Garp's thinking.