Discussion Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread

Which side are you on?

  • Team Spriggan 12

    Votes: 48 51.6%
  • Team Diabolos/Dragon Eaters

    Votes: 45 48.4%

  • Total voters
    93

The President

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 18, 2016
Messages
785
Reaction score
2,437
Age
31
Country
Canada
But we don't have anything else to hang on to other than that. I'd like to give Serena the benefit of the doubt. I think that, were their speeds equalized, there would actually be a fight, an interchange of attacks. I think the outcome would be the same, GS would be killed, but some of his attacks would have hit in. Let's remember God Serena can probably eat Acno's element too. And probably he's got one counter against his element (as he had water, which would be rather effective against Natsu).
Give Serena the benefit if the doubt based on what? The fact that he defeated 4 characters whom your also giving the benefit of the doubt too? This is a very unstable argument you have here. Serenas DS attacks were weak, I see no reason to assume they would even so much as phase Acnologia. Even if he uses stronger DS moves the damage he will be dishing out to Acno will be minimal, and that's assuming Acno just stands there and takes it.

We don't know 4 of Serenas elements nor do we know Acnologias, I don't see a probability here. Maybe a very small possibility, if that.

First of all, claiming Jellal can one-shot a Spriggan is a little bit far-fetched. Not only was he bloodlusted (if that counts at all), but Neinhart clearly shows no Spriggan endurance at all. He seems the weakest of all of them. I'd like to see how that spell would've affected Wahl, God Serena, Jacob or Dimaria. It probably wouldn't have been a OHKO at all.
I agree, but Jellal only used a casual attack. Grand Chariot doesn't have a good track record, yet he improved so much that he one-shotted a Spriggan (even if its the weakest one) with it. He still has Abyass Break, Sema and Altairis and maybe some new techniques that he has developed.

A "landscape changing move" is not that impressive as far as that was an illusion. After all, the only thing he did was turn the day into night. How that could possibly beat any strong opponent (or Jura), I don't really know. I'd like to give the benefit of the doubt to Jura and think they're on the same league, even if I believe Jellal to be slightly superior.
It might have enhanced his heavenly body magic. Even if it was just an illusion though, that still takes Spriggan level MP to conjure something if that level.

I don't agree. First of all, Serena offpaneled them all and he didn't even have a scratch. I don't think they even got to touch him. When they fought "seriously", they got to "touch him", but he had no scratch either. He was literally toying with them. It was not until Hyberion intervened that he showed sign of concern: one drop of sweat. That is as much as they can push him, to one drop of sweat. I think it would be an overstatement to say that the 4 of them equal to Base God Serena, but I'd be willing to accept it. Saying they're superior, I think would be too much.I didn't think it was an implication that GS "had to" use God Slaying magic to beat them; I think he was done toying and he wanted to finish the job quickly.
Hyberion drains MP, obviously he wouldn't have had a scratch from his attack, but he was clearly worried even before Hyberion attacked him. If the implication was that Serena had to stop toying with them but could still defeat them with his base power then Jacob wouldn't have been worried enough to intervene and August wouldn't have anticipated Serena resorting to his DS magic.

It's not going to prevent Serena from getting ripped off, but it's going to help him dodge a few attacks and possibly land some others before he eventually dies.
He could land some hits but Acnologia would tank them. That's assuming Acnologia doesn't just competey offset Serenas attack with his own.

I think the fact that some were "trying to stand" and some were on the ground proves pretty much nothing. It is rather clear that Hyberion is above the three other Wizard Saints, whereas Warrod and Wolfheim are implied to be superior to Jura's. In my opinion, it would go like this: Serious God Serena >>> Base God Serena >>> Hyberion >> Wolfheim > Warrod > Jura. But who knows, right? Not enough feats. I'm willing to see them fight again.
How does it prove nothing? If one guy is standing and the other is knocked out on the floor that means that the guy who's standing either has greater durability or endurance (or both). There is literally no way around it.

In my opinion, Jura did not improve at all from the GMG. Had he improved, he'd be on par with Laxus, and we all know that is not the case. And as for Warrod, he is support type, but he's got the offensive as well. He can create trees out of nowhere at a reasonable speed. You are getting hit by something hard, tough and at a considerable speed. And if he makes sharp ends, he can pretty much pierce a body.
What? Maybe if Laxus made absolutely zero improvements that would be the case, but Laxus quite clearly improved tremendously, just as much as Natsu did (minus Igneels power). Are you operating under the assumption that no one aside from Natsu improved? Because if so I could see where you are coming from, but everyone clearly improved. Some more then others, specifically those who have had highlighted potential at a young age like the dragons slayers, Jellal, Erza and Gray. The improvements are so large its pretty clear we have had a power inflation on our hands. Characters like Jura and Makarov don't improve as much, if at all, because they are old and have already reached their maximum potential.
 

Char

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
689
Reaction score
1,963
Age
33
Country
Spain
I can agree with Hyberion. I would put Wolfheim slightly below overpowered Sitri Mirajane (Maybe Satan Soul: Halphas, although I don't think that is canon in the manga) but that is because I like to think that Wolfheim is many times weaker than Hyberion. Agree with Makarov. As for Jura, once again, I believe he is on par or slightly below Erza but the difference is almost negligible.
First of all, it's nice we agree so much! As for ranking/comparing the Wizard Saints, we seem not to agree that much. I share your point in the exponentiallity of their powers, though. If Jura is a 1, then Warrod is a 2, Wolfheim is a 4 and Hyberion is an 8. Around there. God Serena would be a 16 in base, and probably over 20 when angry/fullpowered/whatever.

As for development, I don't think Jura improved that much in the gap year, mainly because he was taking care of bureaucratic duties (and I think this applies to the other saints; they weren't training but managing, doing paperwork, meetings and whatnot). It's also important to notice that if GMG Laxus was superior to GMG Jura by not a large gap, in this case it seems that current Laxus is vastly superior to current Jura. Although, again, in order to confirm that, we should see how well would Jura perform against Wahl, or Laxus against God Serena; or what'd happen if Jura and Laxus fought again. And none of these scenarios is likely going to happen.

Give Serena the benefit if the doubt based on what? The fact that he defeated 4 characters whom your also giving the benefit of the doubt too? This is a very unstable argument you have here. Serenas DS attacks were weak, I see no reason to assume they would even so much as phase Acnologia. Even if he uses stronger DS moves the damage he will be dishing out to Acno will be minimal, and that's assuming Acno just stands there and takes it.
You seem to missunderstand me. I'd give God Serena the benefit of the doubt were he to fight Acnologia with equalized speed.
How are Serena's attacks weak to put down a Laxus tier (Hyberion), an at least Mirajane tier (Wolfheim) a possibly Makarov tier (Warrod) and a possibly Erza tier (Jura) all at once? You are underestimating God Serena very badly.

Minimal damage is enough. At least it would be damage, much more than the whole FT did to Acno back in Tenroujima, or Glidartz did to him during their encounter, proving God Serena is vastly superior to Glidartz. It would be a feat. Because no-one's ever harmed Acnologia, as far as we're concerned. And it's not about "standing there and taking it", since their speeds would be equalized there'd be possibility for both to land hits on the other.

I agree, but Jellal only used a casual attack. Grand Chariot doesn't have a good track record, yet he improved so much that he one-shotted a Spriggan (even if its the weakest one) with it. He still has Abyass Break, Sema and Altairis and maybe some new techniques that he has developed.
Given he was bloodlusted and he even changed the landscape, I thought it was his most powerful spell. But even if it wasn't and Jellal still had tricks up his sleeve, Neinhart is not a good match to compare Jellal to other magues. If Jellal fought Bradman, that'd be another story, since Bradman may very well be a low-to-mid tier Spriggan, or even mid-tier.

It might have enhanced his heavenly body magic. Even if it was just an illusion though, that still takes Spriggan level MP to conjure something if that level.
I agree, and it is very likely that Jellal is spriggan tier (mid spriggan tier). However we cannot compare him to Jura or Laxus based on feats, because Jellal didn't have a proper fight, and Jura fought a way too OP character.

Hyberion drains MP, obviously he wouldn't have had a scratch from his attack, but he was clearly worried even before Hyberion attacked him. If the implication was that Serena had to stop toying with them but could still defeat them with his base power then Jacob wouldn't have been worried enough to intervene and August wouldn't have anticipated Serena resorting to his DS magic.
It's been mentioned that Spriggans work on their own, they do not work as a team. The fact Jacob wanted to intervene may very well prove Base Serena was having trouble against Hyberion; but it could also demonstrate that Jacob has no idea of Serena's limitations. He might very well not know the extent of his power in base. I still think Serena is, in base, well above the 4; but we can't know for sure.


He could land some hits but Acnologia would tank them. That's assuming Acnologia doesn't just competey offset Serenas attack with his own.
If he's going to tank high-tier spriggan level attacks which happen to be magic-compatible against him, then there's no human way anyone in this manga can even scratch him: not Igneel Natsu, not Laxus, not Irene, not August, not Zeref.

God Serena's attacks are powerful, deadly, continuous, fast and diverse; and very effective against dragons. He's the most complete, versatile and powerful Dragon Slayer seen thus far. Maybe Igneel Natsu has more destructive capacity or offensive power, but overall, God Serena is a more complete wizard.

How does it prove nothing? If one guy is standing and the other is knocked out on the floor that means that the guy who's standing either has greater durability or endurance (or both). There is literally no way around it.
Or that he was partially hit, unlike the other which was completely hit. I don't think any of them were knocked out, actually they weren't because they all seem to perceive Acnologia's MP when he appear, so they were conscious. They were just on the ground because they didn't want to get up (they knew they could do nothing). Maybe Jura felt the urge to get up and he did, that does not imply Hyberion or Warrod weren't "capable". Warrod seemed to be about to die when he got up and landed a direct hit on Serena.


What? Maybe if Laxus made absolutely zero improvements that would be the case, but Laxus quite clearly improved tremendously, just as much as Natsu did (minus Igneels power). Are you operating under the assumption that no one aside from Natsu improved? Because if so I could see where you are coming from, but everyone clearly improved. Some more then others, specifically those who have had highlighted potential at a young age like the dragons slayers, Jellal, Erza and Gray. The improvements are so large its pretty clear we have had a power inflation on our hands. Characters like Jura and Makarov don't improve as much, if at all, because they are old and have already reached their maximum potential.
If they were on the same league back in the GMG, and they had trained for one year, they'd still be on the same league now. But they aren't. It makes sense, since Laxus had plenty of time to train whereas Jura was busy taking care of other business.
No, I agree that Natsu, Laxus and Lucy improved and became about a 100% stronger than they were. Same goes for Wendy, who managed to master a partial Dragon Force transformation. Mira showed an interesting feat (absorbing Sheilah), and if she absorbed Etherias Sheilah, then it'd be her strongest take over; but still, she is not 100% stronger than before the timeskip, in my opinion.
As for Laxus, Erza, Elfman, Mira, Gray... I think they all improved quite a bit, but not massively.
The 4 wizard saints + Makarov stayed the same, and if they had time to train or improve, I'd say it was marginally.
Jura is not that old, he's probably on his prime or a little past that. As for Glidartz, I wouldn't like for him to be very superior to current Laxus, because he was past his prime, and any improvement should be marginal.
 

Tinitus

Banned
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
May 25, 2016
Messages
69
Reaction score
37
Age
28
Country
Georgia
Most definetely not.



Well it shouldn't be that way. Mirajane is Erza's equal, and this is still implied to be this way. She hasn't still showed her training improvements, but I assume she's equal to DeS Gray and above Gajeel.
Gajeel is above Mirajane. Gajeel has better displays and showings.

Des Gray in a fight against Mirajane would own her since she's half demon, so they aren't equals.
 

Crimson Ice

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2016
Messages
2,259
Reaction score
3,715
Country
Vandenreich
Gajeel is being portrayed as the main one leading the force in the North and is physically on par with Bradman in base, he gets the benefit of the doubt over Mira.
 

Tinitus

Banned
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
May 25, 2016
Messages
69
Reaction score
37
Age
28
Country
Georgia
Gajeel is being portrayed as the main one leading the force in the North and is physically on par with Bradman in base, he gets the benefit of the doubt over Mira.
He also has better combat feats and stats than Mira.
 

The President

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 18, 2016
Messages
785
Reaction score
2,437
Age
31
Country
Canada
You seem to missunderstand me. I'd give God Serena the benefit of the doubt were he to fight Acnologia with equalized speed. How are Serena's attacks weak to put down a Laxus tier (Hyberion), an at least Mirajane tier (Wolfheim) a possibly Makarov tier (Warrod) and a possibly Erza tier (Jura) all at once? You are underestimating God Serena very badly.
Hyberion is not Laxus tiered because his feats aren't anywhere remotely close to Laxuses. It took Serena 4 of his DS techniques to take out already injured Ishgal Saints. That's hardly impressive when we have characters like Laxus, Natsu and Jellal who can one-shot Spriggans.

Minimal damage is enough. At least it would be damage, much more than the whole FT did to Acno back in Tenroujima, or Glidartz did to him during their encounter, proving God Serena is vastly superior to Glidartz. It would be a feat. Because no-one's ever harmed Acnologia, as far as we're concerned. And it's not about "standing there and taking it", since their speeds would be equalized there'd be possibility for both to land hits on the other
.

Sure, Serena is vastly superior to Tenrou Gildarts and the Fairy Tail guild back when they couldn't even defeat Precht together. All Spriggans are like that though.

Given he was bloodlusted and he even changed the landscape, I thought it was his most powerful spell. But even if it wasn't and Jellal still had tricks up his sleeve, Neinhart is not a good match to compare Jellal to other magues. If Jellal fought Bradman, that'd be another story, since Bradman may very well be a low-to-mid tier Spriggan, or even mid-tier.
Him being bloodlusted doesn't change the fact that its not his strongest spell. Bradman is arguably the storngest Spriggan we have seen thus far bar August and Irene, though he doesn't really fit into this current discussion.

I agree, and it is very likely that Jellal is spriggan tier (mid spriggan tier). However we cannot compare him to Jura or Laxus based on feats, because Jellal didn't have a proper fight, and Jura fought a way too OP character.
Yes we can. His feats are fairly similar to Laxuses and far and beyond Juras.

It's been mentioned that Spriggans work on their own, they do not work as a team. The fact Jacob wanted to intervene may very well prove Base Serena was having trouble against Hyberion; but it could also demonstrate that Jacob has no idea of Serena's limitations. He might very well not know the extent of his power in base. I still think Serena is, in base, well above the 4; but we can't know for sure.
Jacob had just witnessed base Serena fight and deemed he needed help, which tells us that base wouldn't have been enough for Serena. Hell, August agreed with him (though August knew about Serenas trump card).

If he's going to tank high-tier spriggan level attacks which happen to be magic-compatible against him, then there's no human way anyone in this manga can even scratch him: not Igneel Natsu, not Laxus, not Irene, not August, not Zeref.
They aren't high-tier Spriggan attacks. The ones he used on the Ishval Saints are honestly Jura level attacks with the sole difference being that he could use them in quick succession. That's not enough to harm a regular dragon, let alone Acnologia. I am willing to give Serena the benefit if the doubt and say he has stronger spells, but certainly not at the level that he could do much do Acnologia, and if he does then he can't use them in quick succession like he did his casual spells.

God Serena's attacks are powerful, deadly, continuous, fast and diverse; and very effective against dragons. He's the most complete, versatile and powerful Dragon Slayer seen thus far. Maybe Igneel Natsu has more destructive capacity or offensive power, but overall, God Serena is a more complete wizard.
He's the most versatile dragon slayer we have seen thus far but he's far from the most powerful. Laxus and Natsu have far greater feats as it is and I anticipate Gajeel surpassing Serena as well.

Or that he was partially hit, unlike the other which was completely hit. I don't think any of them were knocked out, actually they weren't because they all seem to perceive Acnologia's MP when he appear, so they were conscious. They were just on the ground because they didn't want to get up (they knew they could do nothing). Maybe Jura felt the urge to get up and he did, that does not imply Hyberion or Warrod weren't "capable". Warrod seemed to be about to die when he got up and landed a direct hit on Serena.
Baseless propositions. We have no reason to believe Jura was hit any less then his peers. What's worse though is your second proposition. They were on the ground because they didnt want to get up? Really? They weren't there because they wanted to pick a fight with them, they were there out of duty. Though despite how nonsensical this sounds to me personally, you have to understand that this only hurts your argument here. If they could still fight but chose otherwise, just how weak are Serenas attacks? I mean if he used 4 of them on the Ishval Saints who were already heavily battle worn and that couldn't take them out, then Serenas attacks are Wendy level.

If they were on the same league back in the GMG, and they had trained for one year, they'd still be on the same league now. But they aren't. It makes sense, since Laxus had plenty of time to train whereas Jura was busy taking care of other business.
Your ignoring a plethora of factors that go into training. Jura and Laxus wouldn't have the same progression because as you yourself have said Jura is at or near his prime, while Laxus wasn't. Then you have to factor in innate potential, which Laxus evidently has Jura beat in.

As for Laxus, Erza, Elfman, Mira, Gray... I think they all improved quite a bit, but not massively.
There ain't much to debate here my man, Laxuses dragon roar sized nuke alone is something he couldn't even come close to doing prior to the time-skip. His current feats completely eclipse his previous ones in everyway. Same goes for Erza. Elfman, Mira and Gray have yet to show the full reward of their labour, so I'll let that be.
 

Boomburst

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
945
Reaction score
1,872
Country
United States
Hyberion is not Laxus tiered because his feats aren't anywhere remotely close to Laxuses. It took Serena 4 of his DS techniques to take out already injured Ishgal Saints. That's hardly impressive when we have characters like Laxus, Natsu and Jellal who can one-shot Spriggans.

.

Sure, Serena is vastly superior to Tenrou Gildarts and the Fairy Tail guild back when they couldn't even defeat Precht together. All Spriggans are like that though.



Him being bloodlusted doesn't change the fact that its not his strongest spell. Bradman is arguably the storngest Spriggan we have seen thus far bar August and Irene, though he doesn't really fit into this current discussion.



Yes we can. His feats are fairly similar to Laxuses and far and beyond Juras.



Jacob had just witnessed base Serena fight and deemed he needed help, which tells us that base wouldn't have been enough for Serena. Hell, August agreed with him (though August knew about Serenas trump

Baseless propositions. We have no reason to believe Jura was hit any less then his peers. What's worse though is your second proposition. They were on the ground because they didnt want to get up? Really? They weren't there because they wanted to pick a fight with them, they were there out of duty. Though despite how nonsensical this sounds to me personally, you have to understand that this only hurts your argument here. If they could still fight but chose otherwise, just how weak are Serenas attacks? I mean if he used 4 of them on the Ishval Saints who were already heavily battle worn and that couldn't take them out, then Serenas attacks are Wendy level.



Your ignoring a plethora of factors that go into training. Jura and Laxus wouldn't have the same progression because as you yourself have said Jura is at or near his prime, while Laxus wasn't. Then you have to factor in innate potential, which Laxus evidently has Jura beat in.



There ain't much to debate here my man, Laxuses dragon roar sized nuke alone is something he couldn't even come close to doing prior to the time-skip. His current feats completely eclipse his previous ones in everyway. Same goes for Erza. Elfman, Mira and Gray have yet to show the full reward of their labour, so I'll let that be.
Dude just cause God Serena needed to use his full power to beat four of the strongest mages from Ishgar does not mean in anyway that he's weak as a Spriggan.

And why do you assume that DS magic is Serena's trump? Just because he didn't use it before doesn't mean it was his last resort. It probably just means he was just playing with them before they actually started to deal a little damage to him.
 

Jko

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Mar 28, 2016
Messages
7,448
Reaction score
18,767
Country
United States
Gajeel is being portrayed as the main one leading the force in the North and is physically on par with Bradman in base, he gets the benefit of the doubt over Mira.
Gajeel was getting wrecked by Bradman and needed Levy's help... in no way was he keeping up with Bradman :neutral.
 

Char

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
689
Reaction score
1,963
Age
33
Country
Spain
@Escanors Pride I respect your opinion, however I don't agree with most of the things you say. I can agree, for example, to the fact that Laxus is closer to his prime than Jura, who may have gone past it. I think "primes" don't play a "role" here though, because Glidartz has always been "past his prime" and still portrayed as the strongest mague in FT, and probably Ishgar (save for the four Gods of Ishgar, maybe); it hasn't been implied he was more powerful 20 years ago (although the contrary hasn't been implied either).

I can also agree that Laxus improved a lot, at least in DC, since he was able to pretty much create a nuke. I think he would've been able to create one before the timeskip, maybe not of these proportions though. What I do not agree is that Jura's potential is lower than Laxus'. I think they have a close potential, what differs is the amount of training and possibly their age (prime).

I also don't agree on Gajeel being (or being displayed) as superior to Mira; if Gajeel seems to be the one leading the force in the North is because Mira allows it. After all, Mira is an S-class mague and is her superior, so the "leading" doesn't really make sense: she could be leading and Gajeel would be stronger nonetheless (if you really think him stronger). I could also agree that DeS Gray would actually beat Mira, because he has the magic-compatibility advantage; but saying that Gajeel is on par with base Bradman is taking it a bit too far. Gajeel is a natural counter to Bradman's magic and he's still getting beaten badly. Unless he shows his improvements by combining his elements, or he awakens DF, he "cannot" win.

As for Mira, who eats poison, I can see her actually pulling off a win against Bradman, but Mashima seems to have forgotten Mira's ability. Cobra can also probably eat his poison.

About God Serena, the problem seems to be that you consider him "weak". For me, he's the strongest spriggan after August, Irene, Dimaria and probably Brandish. You consider him weak, but I don't know what you base on. Maybe the fact that he was ridiculuously one-shotted by Acnologia. Maybe it appears to you that he had to use his full power to defeat the four gods of Ishval. In my honest opinion, he was toying with them until he got tired. I can agree, if you will, that the four wizard saints may be equal to base Serena; but I can't agree with you on saying his attacks are weak "because they didn't knock them down" or that they prove to be Wendy level. I mean, this is ridiculous. Jura alone would sh*t on DF Wendy.

You seem to rely a lot on feats, for example, for putting Laxus above Hyberion when I think they're equals. I'd like to see more feats from Hyberion that would prove he's actually on Laxus' tier, but unfortunately I don't think that'll happen.

BTW, you also say Erza's improved a lot, but I don't see feats that prove so. I've only seen one new armor of hers, other than that, she hasn't showed anything too impressive.
 

Crimson Ice

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2016
Messages
2,259
Reaction score
3,715
Country
Vandenreich
Gajeel was getting wrecked by Bradman and needed Levy's help... in no way was he keeping up with Bradman :neutral.
It's really like you don't read my posts carefully at all. I'm not even going to tell you what's wrong with your reply, you figure it out......:epicfacepalm

As for the Gajeel thing Mira isn't allowing anything. You people act like being S-Class is worth a damn anymore. Also for magic barrier particles isn't regular poison.
 

Stormsfury

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2015
Messages
1,044
Reaction score
3,343
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Dude just cause God Serena needed to use his full power to beat four of the strongest mages from Ishgar does not mean in anyway that he's weak as a Spriggan.

And why do you assume that DS magic is Serena's trump? Just because he didn't use it before doesn't mean it was his last resort. It probably just means he was just playing with them before they actually started to deal a little damage to him.
Serena used full power?
It looked more like he only used part of his power and ended up destroying the gods of ishgar before he could actually get things into full swing, Serena never went all out.
 

Char

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
689
Reaction score
1,963
Age
33
Country
Spain
As for the Gajeel thing Mira isn't allowing anything. You people act like being S-Class is worth a damn anymore. Also for magic barrier particles isn't regular poison.
S-Class is a title given to magues who show certain skills that others don't. The most important one being strength and power, but also responsibility, will or intelligence. It's not that "S-Class is not worth a damn anymore". It certainly is outdated, and were S-class exams taken again, Natsu, Gray and Gajeel would definetely pass. But that doesn't necessarily mean they are above Mira. I believe Natsu and DeS Gray to be above Mira, but Gajeel, without DF, is at most Mira level.

As for the poison debate, it is indeed interesting since we don't know what'd happen if Mira or Cobra tried to eat that poison. Maybe they'd end up in much the way Laxus ended up when he breathed Tempester's, maybe nothing'd happen or maybe even they'd power up. So far it's safe to assume Gajeel is the only person immune to magic particles, a natural counter. Still, anyone with Levy's mask would seemingly be as immune.

Serena used full power?
It looked more like he only used part of his power and ended up destroying the gods of ishgar before he could actually get things into full swing, Serena never went all out.
Agreed.
 

BluePegasus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2015
Messages
1,818
Reaction score
5,128
Gender
Male
Country
Netherlands
I'm sorry but why is everbody talking about Mirajane like she is fodder?

Gajeel never showed me a single feat that outclasses Mirajane. Mirajane is faster than Gajeel and her spells are a lot more powerful than Gajeel's spells. Without Dragon Force, Mirajane will slay him.

S-Class is an important title, it's pretty obvious that S-Class mages have more impressive feats than the other mages.

Gray or Freed should be the next S-Class.

Anyway, my ranking of the mages in Fairy Tail:

1). Laxus (obvious)
2). FDKM Natsu
3). Gildarts
4). Mirajane
5). DeS Gray
6). Freed
7). Erza
8). Base Natsu/Base Gajeel/Base Gray
9). Evergreen/Bickslow
10). Juvia/Lucy
 

Stormsfury

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2015
Messages
1,044
Reaction score
3,343
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
I'm sorry but why is everbody talking about Mirajane like she is fodder?

Gajeel never showed me a single feat that outclasses Mirajane. Mirajane is faster than Gajeel and her spells are a lot more powerful than Gajeel's spells. Without Dragon Force, Mirajane will slay him.

S-Class is an important title, it's pretty obvious that S-Class mages have more impressive feats than the other mages.

Gray or Freed should be the next S-Class.

Anyway, my ranking of the mages in Fairy Tail:

1). Laxus (obvious)
2). FDKM Natsu
3). Gildarts
4). Mirajane
5). DeS Gray
6). Freed
7). Erza
8). Base Natsu/Base Gajeel/Base Gray
9). Evergreen/Bickslow
10). Juvia/Lucy
Where's Gajeel?
 

Asorx

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2015
Messages
563
Reaction score
1,193
Age
28
Gender
Male
Country
Poland
My ranking of the mages in ft:
1. Lucy with CSK
2. Laxus
3. FDKM Natsu
4. Gray
5. Erza/Mira
6. Mira/Erza
7. Gajeel
8. Lucy
9. Juvia (water body is op)
10. Freed
11. Wendy
The rest. I dont put Gildarts cuz we dont know how strong he is.
 

Char

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
689
Reaction score
1,963
Age
33
Country
Spain
I'm sorry but why is everbody talking about Mirajane like she is fodder?

Gajeel never showed me a single feat that outclasses Mirajane. Mirajane is faster than Gajeel and her spells are a lot more powerful than Gajeel's spells. Without Dragon Force, Mirajane will slay him.

S-Class is an important title, it's pretty obvious that S-Class mages have more impressive feats than the other mages.

Gray or Freed should be the next S-Class.

Anyway, my ranking of the mages in Fairy Tail:

1). Laxus (obvious)
2). FDKM Natsu
3). Gildarts
4). Mirajane
5). DeS Gray
6). Freed
7). Erza
8). Base Natsu/Base Gajeel/Base Gray
9). Evergreen/Bickslow
10). Juvia/Lucy
I agreed with you up to your ranking. Saying Mirajane is so above Erza is a bit far-fetched... I'd have Mirajane slightly below Erza. As for Freed, there's no way he's that high in the list. It should be like this:

1). Laxus (obvious)
2). FDKM Natsu
3). Gildarts (although we don't know if he's above FDKM Natsu or Laxus)
4). Erza
5). DeS Gray
6). Mirajane
7). Base Natsu
8) Base Gajeel/Base Gray
9) Freed
10). Evergreen/Bickslow
11). Juvia/Lucy

My ranking of the mages in ft:
1. Lucy with CSK
2. Laxus
3. FDKM Natsu
4. Gray
5. Erza/Mira
6. Mira/Erza
7. Gajeel
8. Lucy
9. Juvia (water body is op)
10. Freed
11. Wendy
The rest. I dont put Gildarts cuz we dont know how strong he is.
It's interesting you mention CSK Lucy. If I recall correctly. CSK was on par with Mard Geer, and that's not going to suffice against very high-ranked enemies. It's likely that CSK is Spriggan-tier, though. Still I'd rank him below Laxus. CSK's feats are impressive, but Laxus' too.

Gray shouldn't be superior to Erza/Mira, he should rather be on par or below. And I think it's rather clear that Juvia is stronger than Lucy. But yeah, some things are up to opinion.
 

Raven

Registored User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 8, 2016
Messages
3,107
Reaction score
12,870
Age
32
Gender
Female
Country
Joker
My list Without Hype ( Subject to Change )

1) Natsu.
2) Laxus.
3) Jellal.
4) Erza/Mira.
5) Gajeel/Gray.
6) Wendy.
7) Freed.
8) Lucy.
9) Juvia.
10) Elfman.


Update: ( Subject to change )

- Elfman added
- Mest removed.

Next (After their future respective fights) : ( Subject to change )

- Pantherlily , Jura , Makarov , Gildarts , Cana , Lissana , Levy , Mavis , Cobra , Angle , Yukino , Sting , Rogue , Minerva , Mest and Bacchus ( Subject to change )

Excluded: ( Subject to change )

Orga - Bickslow - Romeo - Evergreen - Loke.


Too lazy to proceed, later :) xaxaxa
 
Last edited:

Asorx

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2015
Messages
563
Reaction score
1,193
Age
28
Gender
Male
Country
Poland
I agreed with you up to your ranking. Saying Mirajane is so above Erza is a bit far-fetched... I'd have Mirajane slightly below Erza. As for Freed, there's no way he's that high in the list. It should be like this:

1). Laxus (obvious)
2). FDKM Natsu
3). Gildarts (although we don't know if he's above FDKM Natsu or Laxus)
4). Erza
5). DeS Gray
6). Mirajane
7). Base Natsu
8) Base Gajeel/Base Gray
9) Freed
10). Evergreen/Bickslow
11). Juvia/Lucy



It's interesting you mention CSK Lucy. If I recall correctly. CSK was on par with Mard Geer, and that's not going to suffice against very high-ranked enemies. It's likely that CSK is Spriggan-tier, though. Still I'd rank him below Laxus. CSK's feats are impressive, but Laxus' too.

Gray shouldn't be superior to Erza/Mira, he should rather be on par or below. And I think it's rather clear that Juvia is stronger than Lucy. But yeah, some things are up to opinion.
Mard Geer just dodge ataks if Lucy will fight 1 vs 1 with CSK noone can beat her.
 
Last edited:

Boomburst

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
945
Reaction score
1,872
Country
United States
Serena used full power?
It looked more like he only used part of his power and ended up destroying the gods of ishgar before he could actually get things into full swing, Serena never went all out.
Yea that was a bad choice of words on my part. I meant to say that it was his true power, not necessarily his full. My bad
 

Stormsfury

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2015
Messages
1,044
Reaction score
3,343
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Yea that was a bad choice of words on my part. I meant to say that it was his true power, not necessarily his full. My bad
It's cool, I'm glad it got cleared up.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
My ranking of the mages in ft:
1. Lucy with CSK
2. Laxus
3. FDKM Natsu
4. Gray
5. Erza/Mira
6. Mira/Erza
7. Gajeel
8. Lucy
9. Juvia (water body is op)
10. Freed
11. Wendy
The rest. I dont put Gildarts cuz we dont know how strong he is.
How is CSK landing an attack on someone as fast as Laxus, when he couldn't even land an attack on base Mard? How will CSK protect Lucy from someone as fast as Laxus, or someone with the explosive power of FDKM Natsu.
The fact that CSK only runs on Lucy's energy means that all people have to to when facing him is dodge until Lucy runs out of energy, pretty simple to beat really. CSK Lucy loses that fight all day everyday.
 
Top