Discussion - Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread | Page 923 | MangaHelpers

Discussion Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread

Which side are you on?

  • Team Spriggan 12

    Votes: 45 50.6%
  • Team Diabolos/Dragon Eaters

    Votes: 44 49.4%

  • Total voters
    89

Jhonatas Fernandes

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
512
Reaction score
423
Age
30
Country
Brazil
If Gray contradicts Makarov, I'm listening to Makarov. Why do people mention Ajeel's opinion like he wasn't claiming he could solo Ishgar the chapter before. Not a reliable witness at all
--- Double Post Merged, ---



Where is the Wahl is weak narrative coming from? This man made a bad copy out of boredom and it was also operating on Spriggan level. Enough to be sent on a completely seperate mission.
Mashima said he is the weakest of the group. But it's like I said: the fact that he is the weakest, doesn't mean he is the weakest by far. We have a lot of characters putting The Spriggan 12 in the same tier overall, with just Larcade, Irene, and August as exceptions, being the top 3 with significant differences in power when compared to the rest. (:
 

Ratrace

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2018
Messages
1,790
Reaction score
1,257
Age
35
Country
United States
If Gray contradicts Makarov, I'm listening to Makarov. Why do people mention Ajeel's opinion like he wasn't claiming he could solo Ishgar the chapter before. Not a reliable witness at all
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Which is why I said it could be him just being arrogant.
 

GodSlayer666

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2024
Messages
148
Reaction score
100
Age
23
Country
Brazil
You're saying that destroying Luso's dimensions isn't a big deal even after I proved that Tenrin's sword destruction can keep up with Laxus Red Lighting projectiles. Luso didn't give the trouble Laxus did to Erza because Laxus is stronger than Luso and because Luso is easily defeated when you get close to her. However, Erza needed to put effort into getting close to her. :(


Tenrin swords destruction was ONE OF the abilities she used against Laxus and he was able to rival it, Luso neither was able to rival it nor made Erza use something more than that. It's like i compared a villain destroyed by Goku's kamehameha with another who could produce a ki blast to stalemate the kamehameha. But you got the idea of Aldoron arc Laxus being stronger and even Youko having better feats, i guess it's enough for my point.

God Serena Historia was even with Gildarts in physical clash. If God Serena were severely weaker than Gildarts, he would be sent away by the clash instead of holding Gildart's physical strength. At the end of the fight, Gildarts had a blood mark around his mouth and it was revealed that both wizards kept spamming their magics (God Serena using her elements, and Gildarts breaking it) until Gildarts got the opening to use a finishing spelll. It's pretty clear that God Serena gave Gildarts a medium difficulty, which proves that God Serena is a "small fry" compared to her live self, but also proves that his Historia version could be a challenge to Fairy Tail wizards below Gildarts' level (which is basically anyone).
Well he was sent way in the end. Ye his historia was pretty impressive for a spriggan overall, but this just convince me that alive Serena is Gildarts level. Gildarts talked like if it was low diff though. And the point of him still being a challenge to fairy tail wizards still applies on him, other historia spriggans would be below it.

Wahl alive is strong enough to keep a fight with Laxus, who is also obviously stronger than Minerva, so Minerva showing the upper hand in physical combat against Wahl-Historia is a good feat because Gildarts wasn't able to do that with a Historia that, when alive, is his equal. On the other hand, Minerva was physically dominating a Historia that, when alive, was stronger than her (because it is in the Laxus' tier). Is that clear?
She got the upper hand at the start, but she was also shown to be overwhelmed later, and in the end she wasn't sure if his defeat was purely her merit of if it was due to Neinhart defeat, it's not like she had the upper hand in the entire fight. And Historia Wahl is below Laxus tier anyway.

I made a clear analysis of how Minerva's speed was well-portrayed and paired with Erza's when Jellal, Erza, and Minerva fought Luso and needed to run away because her hax alchemia turned them into dogs. Later, Erza alone fought Luso in a serious battle and the Titania was portrayed with difficulty getting close to attack her foe, and the Titania was also being hit by similar creatures that Minerva dealt before. So why are you trying to negate Minerva's speed feats?​
DF is very important to Rogue and Sting's strength since Sting entered DF after receiving Rogue's power in the battle with Larcade. We didn't see Rogue fighting seriously in the Viernes Arc, he was just acting casual, so if his "base form" is close to "base Gray form" that's not a problem. However, since his "base form" could keep up with and defeat Bloodman-Historia, I would say he is stronger than base Gray. However, base Gray defeated Hakune, which is a good feat. The problem is it happened in a world where Gray's magic power was enhanced.​

I'm not trying to negate the speed feats, i just don't think they add that much in practice in the end of the day, the feats against historia Wahl seems better than the ones against Luso minions for example. Gray used Devil Slayer magic against Hakune, he used a similar technique to Ice Make but was while using DS. Look at the devil slayer marks on him while he is making the soldiers

https://ww7.readfairytail.com/chapter/fairy-tail-100-years-quest-chapter-85/

Where is the Wahl is weak narrative coming from?

Mashima himself, i was also very surprised with it, not just Neinhart but Ajeel and Jacob definitely seemed weaker than him during Alvarez
 

Jhonatas Fernandes

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
512
Reaction score
423
Age
30
Country
Brazil
Tenrin swords destruction was ONE OF the abilities she used against Laxus and he was able to rival it, Luso neither was able to rival it nor made Erza use something more than that. It's like i compared a villain destroyed by Goku's kamehameha with another who could produce a ki blast to stalemate the kamehameha. But you got the idea of Aldoron arc Laxus being stronger and even Youko having better feats, i guess it's enough for my point.



Well he was sent way in the end. Ye his historia was pretty impressive for a spriggan overall, but this just convince me that alive Serena is Gildarts level. Gildarts talked like if it was low diff though. And the point of him still being a challenge to fairy tail wizards still applies on him, other historia spriggans would be below it.



She got the upper hand at the start, but she was also shown to be overwhelmed later, and in the end she wasn't sure if his defeat was purely her merit of if it was due to Neinhart defeat, it's not like she had the upper hand in the entire fight. And Historia Wahl is below Laxus tier anyway.




I'm not trying to negate the speed feats, i just don't think they add that much in practice in the end of the day, the feats against historia Wahl seems better than the ones against Luso minions for example. Gray used Devil Slayer magic against Hakune, he used a similar technique to Ice Make but was while using DS. Look at the devil slayer marks on him while he is making the soldiers

https://ww7.readfairytail.com/chapter/fairy-tail-100-years-quest-chapter-85/




Mashima himself, i was also very surprised with it, not just Neinhart but Ajeel and Jacob definitely seemed weaker than him during Alvarez
Luso wasn't able to rival it because 1) she is not as strong as Laxus overall, 2) once her speed of creation is surpassed and the enemy comes close to her, she can easily be defeated, 3) she lost her mind in the battle trying to prove that could overpower Erza's speed of destruction.

Gildarts needed to use a finishing spell against God Serena Historia. If this version of God Serena were so weak compared to Gildarts, he would never need to use his strongest spell to defeat him.

Minerva was dominated later by Wahl-Historia's magic, not by his physical status. Let me remind you that Wahl has the power to analyze his enemy and use the enemy's weakness against the enemy. I think Minerva's feat against Luso is pretty solid because: 1) Luso was able to defeat Jellal, Minerva and Erza with hax magic in the fight, 2) Later, when Erza fought Luso on her own, Luso could prevent Erza to get close to her directly, i.e, Luso could stop Erza's speed. The Titania needed to destroy her dimension and creatures first to get close to her, and Minerva had feats against these creatures from the group battle against Luso.

You're right about Gray! It isn't base Gray there, it is the DS Gray. So, basically, Gray really needs to use DS to defeat any relevant enemy.
(:
 

GodSlayer666

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2024
Messages
148
Reaction score
100
Age
23
Country
Brazil
Luso wasn't able to rival it because 1) she is not as strong as Laxus overall, 2) once her speed of creation is surpassed and the enemy comes close to her, she can easily be defeated, 3) she lost her mind in the battle trying to prove that could overpower Erza's speed of destruction.
I agree with points 1 and 2, the 3 while i can't deny, i can argue that her mental state wouldn't make much difference, Luso who has similar powers prefered to went directly on Alchemy Armor and even said ''no more, cheap tricks'' which should mean that using the World Alchemy hax wouldn't work on someone as strong as Erza. It seemed that great raw power and speed to destroy the world more faster than they could rebuild can counter their hax.

Gildarts needed to use a finishing spell against God Serena Historia. If this version of God Serena were so weak compared to Gildarts, he would never need to use his strongest spell to defeat him.
Empyrean was his second strongest spell, the strongest one he used against August. In pre-timeskip Empyrean may have been his trumph card but in Alvarez it was Absolute Heaven.

Minerva was dominated later by Wahl-Historia's magic, not by his physical status. Let me remind you that Wahl has the power to analyze his enemy and use the enemy's weakness against the enemy. I think Minerva's feat against Luso is pretty solid because: 1) Luso was able to defeat Jellal, Minerva and Erza with hax magic in the fight, 2) Later, when Erza fought Luso on her own, Luso could prevent Erza to get close to her directly, i.e, Luso could stop Erza's speed. The Titania needed to destroy her dimension and creatures first to get close to her, and Minerva had feats against these creatures from the group battle against Luso.
Minerva was just defeated among them, fighting Historia Wahl was still her best feat as you can argue that she could have won, while Luso dominated Minerva and there is no feat for Minerva to say she could win in a rematch, just fighting somone more powerful than Wahl don't upscale Minerva, if she have made Luso struggle it would have been a feat, but she was just overpowered by Luso. Beisdes Kyria defeated Erza in the first round and Laxus in their second round, Youko defeated the same team who defeated Irene, but all of this happened because the protagonists weren't bloodlusted, the same can be said about Luso due to obvious reasons.

You're right about Gray! It isn't base Gray there, it is the DS Gray. So, basically, Gray really needs to use DS to defeat any relevant enemy.
Yep, that's why people mock Gray nowdays, even because his last opponents were basically fodders. Unfortunately this basically downgrade a character when he is compared to base Gray, and this include the alchemy dolls, no wonder Lucy with Brandish body gag diffed them.
 

Jhonatas Fernandes

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
512
Reaction score
423
Age
30
Country
Brazil
I agree with points 1 and 2, the 3 while i can't deny, i can argue that her mental state wouldn't make much difference, Luso who has similar powers prefered to went directly on Alchemy Armor and even said ''no more, cheap tricks'' which should mean that using the World Alchemy hax wouldn't work on someone as strong as Erza. It seemed that great raw power and speed to destroy the world more faster than they could rebuild can counter their hax.



Empyrean was his second strongest spell, the strongest one he used against August. In pre-timeskip Empyrean may have been his trumph card but in Alvarez it was Absolute Heaven.



Minerva was just defeated among them, fighting Historia Wahl was still her best feat as you can argue that she could have won, while Luso dominated Minerva and there is no feat for Minerva to say she could win in a rematch, just fighting somone more powerful than Wahl don't upscale Minerva, if she have made Luso struggle it would have been a feat, but she was just overpowered by Luso. Beisdes Kyria defeated Erza in the first round and Laxus in their second round, Youko defeated the same team who defeated Irene, but all of this happened because the protagonists weren't bloodlusted, the same can be said about Luso due to obvious reasons.



Yep, that's why people mock Gray nowdays, even because his last opponents were basically fodders. Unfortunately this basically downgrade a character when he is compared to base Gray, and this include the alchemy dolls, no wonder Lucy with Brandish body gag diffed them.

Lusso (I discovered recently that she has two "s" in the official translation) has a power that turns "everything that she thinks" in reality on her dimension, so how is her mind status not relevant in the way she fights? There is a focus on Ennie asking her sister to cool down, but Lusso was already taken by the desire to surpass Erza's destruction speed with her own creation speed at the time. Lusso is very fragile once she is kept at a close distance, but if she is with her mind normally, she can alter her body to overcome a direct attack, as she already did in the past. There was clearly a plot facilitating Lusso's defeat by Erza (Lusso fought in a specific way, mentally stable, trying to surpass Erza's destruction without trying to use her hax against her foe). And some similar happened with Ennie, who preferred to fight a physical battle, without using dimensional manipulation + her skill as a physical fighter together). This manga is Fairy Tail, so the hero's enemy will not to use her/his magic to the fullest if it's what is necessary to make the hero win. (:

Whatever. Gildarts used her second strongest finishing spell still an act of using something powerful to defeat the God Serena, which means he didn't defeat the Historia without some effort.

Minerva losing to an enemy that Erza and Jelllal also lost in a battle team with Minerva because of the enemy hax isn't a demerit from Minerva, and the fact that the plot chose to take away Lusso's hax from the final battle with Erza proves how powerful it is. Minerva can create explosions in every place that she can look, so she could create explosions on every one of Lusso's creatures to come close to attack her, as Erza did with Tenrin armor. Actually, you can't prove that Minerva couldn't defeat Lusso if the latter only fought in the same way that she had fought against Erza (mentally stable and competing speed of creating X speed of destruction). I, however, can prove that Minerva has the speed and the magic to do it! (:

 
Last edited:

Ratrace

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2018
Messages
1,790
Reaction score
1,257
Age
35
Country
United States
Yep, that's why people mock Gray nowdays, even because his last opponents were basically fodders. Unfortunately this basically downgrade a character when he is compared to base Gray, and this include the alchemy dolls, no wonder Lucy with Brandish body gag diffed them.
Most fights don’t matter unless one of the characters have decent stats.
 

GL_Nova

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
3,021
Reaction score
3,127
Age
36
Country
United States
Mashima said he is the weakest of the group. But it's like I said: the fact that he is the weakest, doesn't mean he is the weakest by far. We have a lot of characters putting The Spriggan 12 in the same tier overall, with just Larcade, Irene, and August as exceptions, being the top 3 with significant differences in power when compared to the rest. (:
Where did Mashima say this?
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Which is why I said it could be him just being arrogant.
Could be implies there is a possibility his statement has truth to it...
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
6,457
Reaction score
2,172
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Where did Mashima say this?
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---



Could be implies there is a possibility his statement has truth to it...
In A quote from Hiro here

 

Star Frost

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 1, 2015
Messages
2,180
Reaction score
4,102
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Wall is the weakest? Even Jacob and Neinhart are stronger than him?:SOON
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
6,457
Reaction score
2,172
Country
Imperium of Mankind
It's probably because Jacob almost killed everyone in the guild with his dimensional magic and Neinhart really defeated Erza and held plenty of FT Wizards with his Historias. (:
Well Jacob was taking hits from Natsu as well, and Neinhart could knock out Jellal as well.
 

Ratrace

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2018
Messages
1,790
Reaction score
1,257
Age
35
Country
United States
Kind of want to know where the rest of the Spriggan are ranked because Hiro only tells us six of them. Unless I missed something
 

Jhonatas Fernandes

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
512
Reaction score
423
Age
30
Country
Brazil
I wish he did this with the FT members. Give us a confirmation from the the source himself.
I personally don't care about his opinion. I don't want to see what is his "idealization" of the character's power scaling, I will just deal with what was portrayed in the manga. It doesn't matter if Mashima says, for instance, that Mirajane and Erza are even at power level if it is not what the manga shows.
 

Rigel

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2016
Messages
1,193
Reaction score
2,625
Age
24
Country
Brazil
Mashima's opinion about the power level of the Guild members is relevant and at the same time problematic. I'm sure he wouldn't be honest in his stances, as he likes to maintain the characters' status quo , even if that's not what he's portraying in the manga.
 

Yunkers

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2016
Messages
614
Reaction score
685
Age
30
Country
Poland
I wish he did this with the FT members. Give us a confirmation from the the source himself.
Most people wouldn't care about Hiro's official statements. We get them from time to time and most people dispute them anyways.
Also, I'm pretty sure such thing doesn't exist. Mashima's views seems to be more "tiers-like". So it's more like a group of very strong characters, strong, mid etc. The situation with Wahl, when strenght on a certain character is mentioned, is really rare. And I think it happened only because the game staff needed it.
 

Jhonatas Fernandes

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
512
Reaction score
423
Age
30
Country
Brazil
Mashima's opinion about the power level of the Guild members is relevant and at the same time problematic. I'm sure he wouldn't be honest in his stances, as he likes to maintain the characters' status quo , even if that's not what he's portraying in the manga.
We're discussing the Power Level portrayed in the manga and not what Mashima thinks in his mind about it. Wahl being the weakest Spriggan is already something debatable: his magic can be weaker than Jacob's or Neinhart's, but Wahl is better at enduring attacks than them. But I agree with Mashima of Wahl position since Wahl seems to be the amateurish of Spriggan 12. He used a Lighting spell against Laxus, enhancing his opponent with it, and also mistook a shot directly on Laxus's body without reason. He is just not as "proper fighter" as the others. Jacob's weakness is humorous, but Wahl just makes mistakes while is fighting.
 
Top