Discussion Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread

Which side are you on?

  • Team Spriggan 12

    Votes: 48 51.6%
  • Team Diabolos/Dragon Eaters

    Votes: 45 48.4%

  • Total voters
    93

Loke

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2016
Messages
835
Reaction score
1,507
Age
30
Country
United States
Tell me who initiated a barrier when there was no one else there? If you can react then you can tagg as you're able to perceive their movement which is how most people with inferior speed are able to keep up. None of what you said equals dead Lucy speed as only one factor in a fight but it's not even close to the deciding when you're outmatched in everything else. Loke himself was able to stalemate base Torafuza and you think Wendy can take him with Lucy and another Spirit backing him up?
The Celestial Spirit King? Hello? Tell me why would she be so surprised after initiating a spell? I mean she did it right? If you can react you can tag huh? Too bad that's not only false but the one reaction feat you have for her isn't a reaction feat for Lucy at all. Hell during the the fight between herself, her spirits, and the 9DG she couldn't react to any of those explosions, much less counteract. That clock may be able to save her once then it's over. And yes I do. Loke was did in by Jackal explosions. Base Wendy endured that. Mind telling me how any of them are tagging her ?
 

Coné

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
218
Reaction score
141
Country
Portugal
Quite funny! by using their logic Wendy is > Gray , Gajeel.
Lucy > Wendy obviously no need to argue!:nono
Except Gray and Gajeel have decent portrayal to be around Base Natsu's level. All Lucy has is fanmade hype.

So you decide to state that again instead of debating against our points? :cookiestare
 

Coné

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
218
Reaction score
141
Country
Portugal
Stop underestimating lucy. I don't debate with epic fail Ftb members.
I'm not. I've provided evidence to prove my point. You haven't backed up your point with anything.

That's an Adhominem right there. Learn to debate and have some class, man.
 

Jko

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Mar 28, 2016
Messages
7,448
Reaction score
18,767
Country
United States
Why are you assuming that any of Lucy or her spirits' attacks would actually damage Wendy? DF Wendy physically matching Dimaria is actually enough a durability feat to prove that Lucy can't damage her. That would be like assuming Lucy has the same attack potency as a casual Dimaria, which can't be proved whatsoever.
I hope you're joking lol just look under.

Firstly, Dimaria is stronger than Jacob. Second, launching Jacob doesn't really mean you damaged and doesn't represent attack potency. In the third place, show me the scans.
Where did you get far stronger? In her base without God Soul she is not out muscling Jacob. Yes but Wendy's kick did not pack a lot of force if all it did was make Dimaria fall on her butt while Lucy actually sent Jacob flying in the air.

And how does that make tanking Age Scratch not an outstanding durability feat? Wendy still suffered the damage (rather pain) from the battle against Mystogan's father, against Chelia and against Ezel.
So she got the accumulated damage of three fight on her... that's nowhere near the main battle veterans of the show.

Explain, please. Just don't go stating stuff without providing proof.
Wendy has better strength feats in matching God mode Dimaria. Better durability/endurance feats in tanking Dimaria's attacks and matching her physically. Stamina is debatable, but not really a crucial factor. Intelligence is basicaly a non-factor in power-scaling. Diversity is irrelevant too and MP is debatable and meanwhile irrelevant since Wendy has more attack potency than Lucy. Reaction speed goes for DF Wendy too. She was reacting to Dimaria. Lucy has no speed feats that can counter this. I also liked how you made up a bunch of stats just for the sake of making Lucy more impressive.
Matching God mode Dimaria? Lmao she couldn't even flinch God mode Dimaria nor even perceive her attacks and think she was matching her? Attack potency of what? Lucy was able to one shot a 9D while Wendy needed multiple hits before her finisher. I didn't make up stats I 'm providing the stats that equate to their feats.
Wendy's kick

Lucy's kick
You can clearly see the difference between the force of their kicks.
It goes like this:

Lucy:
Intelligence, Diversity

Wendy:
Strength, Durability and Speed

Wendy basically has better stats on the most relevant stats for a versus thread.
If you think that go ahead but the only thing Wendy has on Lucy is speed everything else goes to Lucy.

Like the Demon Gates are still relevant when DF Wendy was clashing with Dimaria who's arguably stronger than Mard, who is vastly stronger than the DG.
Magical-created explosions. Not a notable reaction speed feat, especially when it requires casting time.
I just debunked that. Wendy has way more physical strength than Lucy.
First she was never clashing off with DImaria she got two hits that did nothing to Dimaria. Second comparing their pre-ts version feats to each other is irrelevant? If we know who was stronger pre-ts then we could conclude who's stronger now and before you say she could of been training more then Lucy that is highly unlikely as the only two who was stated to hardcore train were Laxus and Natsu.

A glass cannon tanking several attacks from a Spriggan 12.
Aplaudo bravemente essa tentativa de "trolling", mas foi muito fraca. Considera-te derrotado, panasca. (@Laxus told me to send this mesage in this language lol)
Took multiple hits and needed a finisher from FDKM Natsu but he's a glass cannon. Do I care about petty insults?

It was outright stated that he was more powerful. LOL
Who stated this?
Silver's flash freeze is unfortunately a no-limit fallacy, which means it can only be used against the strongest character it was shown against. That would be base Natsu, who was clearly weaker than Hades at the time. Same with Sayla. The strongest character it was used against was a weakned Erza, who, again, was weaker than Hades at the time.
No it's not NLF as Hades has no prior feats of getting out of instant flash freeze. What's NLF is people thinking his heart puts him above people who are way superior to pre-1st team Natsu and Laxus. Natsu couldn't even perceive SIlver's flash freeze let alone get out of it. Silver Flash froze mountain sized H-flames and an entire village of Giants. Same with Sayla who was already on deaths door and took over Minerva and Erza (who was nowhere near weakened as she was able to go her strongest armour) at the same time with no trouble whatsoever. Nothing Hades did gave him the ability to get out of hax and he surely can't just overpower it.
Anyways, powerscaling doesn't exactly work like versus battles. That's like saying that Marin can low-diff Erza, therefore they must be in the same ballpark, which is a false assumption. Hades has surperior feats, with Amaterasu 100. The guy low-diffed Titan Makarov, handled Team Natsu and was manhandling Laxus.
Marin can't low diff Erza he only surprised her with his hax. Makarov couldn't even perceive Erza yet he could easily see all of Hades' attacks. The guy low diffed an already tired Team Natsu and Laxus who traveled over many miles in his lightning body to get there. Any of the top three 9D could have replicated that feat any of them could've beat Makarov who couldn't even keep up with GMG Erza.

Oh you mean the kick that didn't do shit to Jacob?
Just like that punch that didn't do shit to Dimaria.
That's not how it works. You're essentially saying the more battles you have, the stronger you are. I guess Zeref is fodder going by your logic. :cookiehand
Not really. If you actually knew Age Scatch then you'd know that the attack does the accumulative damage of what you felt in your lifetime which mean Wendy accumulative damage is relatively low.
Ain't no Lucy downplaying, just you failing to show me some Lucy feats.
How?
How does Lucy have durability over Wendy when Wendy was tanking nukes from Dorma Anim? This is Pre-TS too.
Surviving Dorma Anim rockets is notable feat? Lucy tanked amateratsu 28, and tanked all of Jackal's explosions pre-ts which were much greater than tanking Dorma Anima rockets. Even tanking Kain's feats were more notable then Dorma Anim rockets.
How does Lucy have endurance over Wendy when Wendy endured an attack like Age Scratch, which makes you relive all your previous injuries?
The attack is not as effective as Wendy's barely been in battles. Look above.
How does Lucy have stamina over Wendy when she endured what I said above and managed to keep fighting till the end in everyone of her battles?
Fought two 9D, summoned three spirits at the same time, summoned the CSK right after that, and also fought another 9D before she got into the encounter with two others.
How on Earth does Lucy have more magic power then Wendy, especially in DF?
Look above.
How does Lucy have better reactions? Lucy is garbage in the speed department. All she does is stand around and let her spirits do everything for her.
Garbage wait what? Reacted to Jackal's explosion and reacted to Torafuza trying to blindside her.
I've pretty much disproved why all of this is BS. I don't know why people think Lucy is strong, when her feats are so sub-par. Surviving an onslaught doesn't mean anything when Jackal and Torafusa weren't trying in the least.
Torafuza was going for the kill he already stated this. You've pretty much disprove nothing.
 
Last edited:

Jko

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Mar 28, 2016
Messages
7,448
Reaction score
18,767
Country
United States
The Celestial Spirit King? Hello? Tell me why would she be so surprised after initiating a spell? I mean she did it right? If you can react you can tag huh? Too bad that's not only false but the one reaction feat you have for her isn't a reaction feat for Lucy at all. Hell during the the fight between herself, her spirits, and the 9DG she couldn't react to any of those explosions, much less counteract. That clock may be able to save her once then it's over. And yes I do. Loke was did in by Jackal explosions. Base Wendy endured that. Mind telling me how any of them are tagging her ?
The first time maybe the second time he left her to fight on her own
Yes she easily reacted to those explosions before they even blew up so no it isn't false. She got a power up in Tartaros so she was able to react to it. He got blindsided by Jackal the same way Natsu was. Also Lucy is the one who was able to react to the explosion and get herself and Wendy out of harms way.

The same way she tagged Jackal who was keeping with Natsu in speed.
 

Coné

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
218
Reaction score
141
Country
Portugal
I hope you're joking lol just look under.

Where did you get far stronger? In her base without God Soul she is not out muscling Jacob. Yes but Wendy's kick did not pack a lot of force if all it did was make Dimaria fall on her butt while Lucy actually sent Jacob flying in the air.
Because Dimaria actualy has better feats than Jacob. Matching Kagura, who's more or less in the same ballpark as Erza, is more impressive than catching Natsu off-guard. Though Wendy actually managed to damage Dimaria twice while Lucy failed to even get a scracth on Jacob.

So she got the accumulated damage of three fight on her... that's nowhere near the main battle veterans of the show.
That doesn't make Age Scratch any less of a durability feat. The accumulated damage of those battles is still a lot.

Matching God mode Dimaria? Lmao she couldn't even flinch God mode Dimaria nor even perceive her attacks and think she was matching her? Attack potency of what? Lucy was able to one shot a 9D while Wendy needed multiple hits before her finisher. I didn't make up stats I 'm providing the stats that equate to their feats.
You're right, that's not matching, but to actually fight Dimaria to that extent they'd need to be in the same ballpark.
Come on, Dimaria is vastly stronger than base Jackal. That guy was defeated by LFD Natsu in a stronger form.
You wanna go for stats? Then let's go for stats. Being in the same ball park as Dimaria puts DF Wendy at City+ level. One-shotting Jackal makes Lucy Town level. Satisfied? This is the very higher you can scale Lucy at. And that's using a power she doesn't have now.

If you think that go ahead but the only thing Wendy has on Lucy is speed everything else goes to Lucy.
I've provided my reasons. Ignoring them will do shit to my argument.
First she was never clashing off with DImaria she got two hits that did nothing to Dimaria. Second comparing their pre-ts version feats to each other is irrelevant? If we know who was stronger pre-ts then we could conclude who's stronger now and before you say she could of been training more then Lucy that is highly unlikely as the only two who was stated to hardcore train were Laxus and Natsu.
She did damage Dimaria though.
DF Wendy was already stronger than Lucy pre-skip. This only further proves my point and Lucy didn't get any portrayal of being equal to anyone.

Took multiple hits and needed a finisher from FDKM Natsu but he's a glass cannon. Do I care about petty insults?
This was clearly not directed at you and it was a sarcastic answer to Wendy being called a glass cannon.

Who stated this?
It's logical that being the leader of the organization he's the strongest and Hades stated that he didn't think anyone besides himself could have defeated Bluenote.

No it's not NLF as Hades has no prior feats of getting out of instant flash freeze. What's NLF is people thinking his heart puts above people who are way superior to pre-1st team Natsu. Natsu couldn't even perceive SIlver's flash freeze let alone get out of it. Silver Flash froze mountain sized H-flames and an entire village of Giants. Same with Sayla who was already on deaths door and took over Minerva and Erza (who was nowhere near weakened as she was able to go her strongest armour) at the same time with no trouble whatsoever. Nothing Hades did gave him the ability to get out of hax and he surely can't just overpower it.
What? That's not how a NLF works. I've explained it in my other post.
Hades was superior to base Tartaros Natsu and to Erza. Amaterasu 100 would one-shot both to be honest.
That wasn't flash freeze and we didn't get the scan of Silver freezing Atlas Flame, so there's no evidence that he did it in only one spell, really.
Hades > Erza. That's all there is to it. Macro was never properly explained, so we can't just attribute random resistance to it. Otherwise Sayla would be the strongest character in the verse.
Marin can't low diff Erza he only surprised her with his hax. Makarov couldn't even perceive Erza yet he could easily see all of Hades' attacks. The guy low diffed an already tired Team Natsu and Laxus who traveled over many miles in his lightning body to get there. Any of the top three 9D could have replicated that feat any of them could've beat Makarov who couldn't even keep up with GMG Erza.
Marin's hax counters Erza's magic, but it doesn't put him in the same tier as her. That's my point.
None of the Gates have feats comparable to Amaterasu 100 and none have speed feats comparable to matching Lightning Body Laxus. therefore Hades is stronger than the Gates. not difficult to understand.

I'm done debating here. This is going completely over your head and the only feat you're presenting from Lucy is kicking Jacob, even though it didn't damage him in the slightest.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Jko

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Mar 28, 2016
Messages
7,448
Reaction score
18,767
Country
United States
@Coné I never stated Jackal was anywhere near I was strictly speaking pre-ts for the Jackal. Second Wendy is not even in the same Country as Dimaria let alone the same ballpark. Thirdly just bcs he's the leader doesn't mean he's the strongest Bluenote was definitely at the same level as he'd give Hades a high diff fight. I'm done trying to debate with you as you seem to think Wendy is on the same level as Dimaria when she's not even close.
 

Mirage

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
472
Reaction score
541
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Just like that punch that didn't do shit to Dimaria.
Yeah and the difference between Dimaria and Jacob, is that Dimaria >> Jacob.

Not really. If you actually knew Age Scatch then you'd know that the attack does the accumulative damage.
If YOU actually know your shit, you would know this

>>> anything Lucy has ever endured.

Surviving Dorma Anim rockets is notable feat? Lucy tanked amateratsu 28, and tanked all of Jackal's explosions pre-ts which were much greater than tanking Dorma Anima rockets. Even tanking Kain's feats were more notable then Dorma Anim rockets.
The attack is not as effective as Wendy's barely been in battles. Look above. Fought two 9D, summoned three spirits at the same time, summoned the CSK right after that, and also fought another 9D before she got into the encounter with two others.
Are you kidding me? And I'm the one downplaying right?

Wendy didn't "survive" those mini-nukes, she full on tanked them. Lucy never actually tanked A28 from Franmalth, she endured it and was caught by some tentacles afterwards.

Not to mention that Franmalth's A28 is weaker than the real thing.

LGarbage wait what? Reacted to Jackal's explosion and reacted to Torafuza trying to blindside her.
Torafuza was going for the kill he already stated this. You've pretty much disprove nothing.
I've disproved everything. Reacting to dudes who aren't even trying isn't impressive. You're grasping at straws.
 

Tryndamere

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2016
Messages
90
Reaction score
75
Country
The Wall
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

You're a classical example of a dumbass. You mentioned Gray and Gajeel; I explained why that logic was wrong and now you say this shit.
You didn't explain anything, Maybe you wanted to say wendy < gray , Gajeel because they are Natsu's rivals but this is no explanation. Lucy got potentials more than wendy all of your words are ridiculous you don't know how to use portrays or feats.
 

Coné

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
218
Reaction score
141
Country
Portugal
@Coné I never stated Jackal was anywhere near I was strictly speaking pre-ts for the Jackal. Second Wendy is not even in the same Country as Dimaria let alone the same ballpark. Thirdly just bcs he's the leader doesn't mean he's the strongest Bluenote was definitely at the same level as he'd give Hades a high diff fight. I'm done trying to debate with you as you seem to think Wendy is on the same level as Dimaria when she's not even close.
Yeah, an you were using that to debate that Lucy was stronger than Current Wendy.

I mean ball park as they have similar power levels.

What feats does Bluenote have to actually show that he could tank Amaterasu 100? He was defeated by a weaker attack than that.

DF Wendy would be mid diffed by Dimaria. I'm not arguing about that. I'm arguing that she'd need to be relatively close to Dimaria to actually do what she did against her.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
You didn't explain anything, Maybe you wanted to say wendy < gray , Gajeel because they are Natsu's rivals but this is no explanation. Lucy got potentials more than wendy all of your words are ridiculous you don't know how to use portrays or feats.
And Wendy has better feats. LOL
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Jko

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Mar 28, 2016
Messages
7,448
Reaction score
18,767
Country
United States
Yeah and the difference between Dimaria and Jacob, is that Dimaria >> Jacob.
Base Dimaria is not stronger then Jacob in physicals.
If YOU actually know your shit, you would know this

>>> anything Lucy has ever endured.
That's literally what I just stated. She only truly started getting into fights after the GMG her accumulated damage is low.

Are you kidding me? And I'm the one downplaying right?
Well you are... you think tanking Dorma Anim little rockets is as high a durability feat when even Azuma's fodder attacks were stronger then that.
Wendy didn't "survive" those mini-nukes, she full on tanked them. Lucy never actually tanked A28 from Franmalth, she endured it and was caught by some tentacles afterwards.
She barely got up after getting hit which is barely surviving

and she almost got killed/severely injured when she was about to get hit by those rockets.
Lucy did tank that attack as she was still conscious and ready to fight. Lucy tanked amateratsu 28 way better then Wendy tanked those rockets.
Not to mention that Franmalth's A28 is weaker than the real thing.
Where did you get that? I mean you guys do think bigger means stronger so Lucy tanked an amateratsu higher then pre-ts Laxus did.
Hades to Laxus:

Franmalths to Lucy (Natsu and Happy too)
so in no ways was his inferior.
I've disproved everything. Reacting to dudes who aren't even trying isn't impressive. You're grasping at straws.
Torafuza was trying to kill her so if you'd think he wasn't trying to when he stated two-three times that he wanted kill her swiftly then that's on you but Jackal was sure as heck trying to kill her yet failed as she reacted and erected a barrier before his blast were able to hit her.

 
Last edited:

DemonKing888

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,202
Reaction score
1,152
Age
38
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Why do people understand estimate Lucy anyways. Lucy doesn't need to have the same stats as Wendy to win she just needs to have the same level of magic power as her. To use Gemini Stardress We can part Lucy at Marin's level or higher which allows her to copy him. I would say Lucy= Wendy magic power level wise, so Gemini copying her wouldn't be to hard. Even if Wendy could beat Lucy it would be a High difficulty fight. But if Lucy, pulled out the spirit king the match is over.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

XXEliteXXAceXX

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2015
Messages
2,099
Reaction score
3,100
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I really see no point in debating on Lucy vs. Wendy but their rankings should be relatively easy to determine.
  • Lucy > Wendy [Medium Difficulty]
  • Lucy = DF Wendy
To be honest, I know exactly where you're coming from, but it's easy to misconstrue the context here.

Weakness Magic is everything in this fight, my friend. Contrary to what may seem, Wahl doesn't have nullification magic per se. If the nullification magic you're pertaining to is Wahl nullifying the MBPs, that's not nullifying - that's a side effect of exploiting the weakness of that specific Rune Magic. Since Laxus set the rules to dispel that last rune barrier - the condition being to remove all MBPs - Wahl certainly did just that by fulfilling the condition Laxus set.

That outcome actually stemmed from Wahl's weakness magic. The Weakness Magic is a veritable counter to everything - Juvia's water body? Voila, Wahlbot has burning steam. Gray's ice? Voila, Wahlbot suddenly has fire. Elfman's sluggish powerpunches? Voila, Wahlbot suddenly has super speed. Those are no different from - Laxus has rune barriers? Voila, Wahl suddenly has MBP removing abilities to fulfill the condition in order to remove that barrier.

The Weakness Magic endows Wahl a diverse deus-ex-machina skill set to pinpoint an enemy's weakness and is different from battle to battle.

That's called exploiting every magic's weakness, and the Rune Magic was no exception. Wahl just exploited its major weakness - just fulfill the condition and it will disappear.
No, it should be fairly clear that Weakness Magic has no impact in this context. And yes, his Magic Barrier Particles Nullification Magic is separate.

If his magic is indeed nullification, he could've just rendered everyone's magic ineffective and could've just proceeded to lolstomp everyone. He could've turned Juvia's body to ice, he could've reduced Gray's ice to a puddle like Sugarboy from Edolas did, hell, he could've disabled Elfman's and Lisanna's TakeOvers to prove a point.

But he cannot, since his magic is Weakness, ergo - countering attacks with the thing that they're mostly vulnerable to, which will render them ineffective.

The only true nullification feat we've seen in FT so far is Erza and Brandish being in those anti-magic handcuffs (unless I'm forgetting something?). That's nullification. If there's any panel or feat of Wahl "nullifying" or dispersing something other than the MBPs, then I'll have to concede and admit that I misunderstood the context, but Mashima's panel placement in those scenes is pretty deliberate.
It was shown that Wahl only has Magic Barrier Particles Nullification Magic. The only other character that we've seen had true Nullification Magic was Lord Byro but he is not a canon character so that is besides the point. Other than that, the next one who comes closest is Ultear but she can only use it on materialistic things that are not "living" in a sense.

I'm sorry, but you're the one who's missing the point. I'm assuming that you're referring to this post?



Now now, we're going to silly semantics here. Wahl did not dispel the Rune Barrier per se. He just removed the MBPs (an ability granted by his Weakness Magic), which caused the Rune Barrier to disappear. Since he, you know - fulfilled the condition Laxus set. Once came after the other; they were not simultaneous.

The question you should be asking was why Wahl was all gungho and stupidly desperate enough to get out of that Rune Barrier.

Bottomline - Laxus outsmarted Wahl on all accounts and won on impressive terms. Laxus knew about Wahl's weakness magic and waited for the right time to use that ability for his own benefit.
Let me explain why none of this adds up. Ever since Laxus vs. Wahl, the Fairy Tail Wikia has made it known that the Jutsu Shiki or Freed's Rune Magic consists of magical barrier particles (MBP). They were forced to do so in order to try to make it seem logical. If we're going by the original MBP that were used in the Tartaros Arc, they are defined as Anti-Ethernano Particles. To make it easier to understand, it is Anti-Magic which eventually dispels magic by targeting and attacking Ethernano Particles. In a way, it is similar to Face where it exterminates magic but just in a different way. So tell me, how does Freed use magic? His magic is essentially made up of particles that oppose magic itself. In other words, he is constantly weakening his own magic as it is made up of particles that attack it. But that is not the case, right?

The real discrepancy lies in the name. MBP or particles that act as a barrier to magic (weakens it) is far different from particles that actually make up a barrier (shield). That is literally all there is to it. Same name. Different context. Illogical feat-wise.

True Effects of Magic Barrier Particles



Nothing like this happens when one is near or inside Freed's Jutsu Shiki though...
 
Last edited:

Laxus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2014
Messages
732
Reaction score
2,582
Gender
Male
Country
Dragonstone
I have seen people saying Lucy would solo a Spriggan, I have seen people saying Lucy would defeat August. So seeing people saying Lucy > DF Wendy doesnt surprise me a bit.

Durability - Wendy
Speed - Wendy (by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar)
Endurance - Wendy
Strength - Wendy
MP - Either way
Intelligence - Lucy

Overall, Wendy > Lucy.
 

Aizen

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2016
Messages
1,469
Reaction score
4,067
Age
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I have seen people saying Lucy would solo a Spriggan, I have seen people saying Lucy would defeat August. So seeing people saying Lucy > DF Wendy doesnt surprise me a bit.

Durability - Wendy
Speed - Wendy (by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar)
Endurance - Wendy
Strenght - Wendy
MP - Either way
Intelligence - Lucy

Overall, Wendy > Lucy.
Well I can tell you as someone who acknowledges that Lucy could defeat August I am not saying she will solo him, she would need Brandish and the CSK to have a chance but don't make it seem like it's completely absurd because if you think that Lucy won't be critical in one way or another in this battle I think you may be disappointed, She's a main character it could happen but it's also possible it won't. On the topic I think Wendy probably would beat Lucy from what we have seen but Lucy has not had a big fight yet that focuses on just her so who knows.
 

Laxus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2014
Messages
732
Reaction score
2,582
Gender
Male
Country
Dragonstone
Well I can tell you as someone who acknowledges that Lucy could defeat August I am not saying she will solo him, she would need Brandish and the CSK to have a chance but don't make it seem like it's completely absurd because if you think that Lucy won't be critical in one way or another in this battle I think you may be disappointed, She's a main character it could happen but it's also possible it won't. On the topic I think Wendy probably would beat Lucy from what we have seen but Lucy has not had a big fight yet that focuses on just her so who knows.
But people said Lucy would solo him. And that is what I meant. It is not absurb if Lucy wins with the help of Brandish, Natsu, Gildarts (examples).
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Aizen

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2016
Messages
1,469
Reaction score
4,067
Age
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Your bring maturity into this? Someone who completly ignores reasonable explaination and makes his own despite being against every logcial proves? Someone who blantly tried to troll with his comments without provinds a single back up in them?
The other guys expressed wrong. Doesnt surprised me you looked at the wrong way.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---


But people said Lucy would solo him. And that is what I meant. It is not absurb if Lucy wins with the help of Brandish, Natsu, Gildarts (examples).
Fair enough I should not have assumed you meant that, In that case I agree with you on that subject she would need help no doubt.
 

Solitrine

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2016
Messages
369
Reaction score
1,425
Age
28
Country
Australia
Even if Wendy could beat Lucy it would be a High difficulty fight. But if Lucy, pulled out the spirit king the match is over.
Lucy would never use the CSK in a fight under ordinary circumstances (due to needing to sacrifice a key that she has a strong bond with), let alone against a guildmate.
 

Stormsfury

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2015
Messages
1,044
Reaction score
3,343
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Speed: Wendy >>>>> Lucy
Offence: Wendy >>> Lucy
Defence: Wendy >>> Lucy
Intelligence: Lucy >> Wendy
MP: Lucy >>> Wendy
Durability: Wendy >>> Lucy
Stamina: Wendy > Lucy

Wendy lol stomps
 
Top