Discussion Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread

[The President]

I'm sorry but ignoring hype altogether is ridiculous, its still the word of god at the end of the day. You just have to know how to discern credible hype from non-credible hype. Prior to the time-skip Jura had far greater portrayel and better feats then Erza to boot. Jura had greater physical strength, speed, durability, defence and fire power. Sure Erza had armours that could make her more durable then Jura/Laxus like her Adamantine armour, but she has to trade out all her other stats to do it so its hardly worth it.

Its also ridiculous to say that AoE has absolutely no value as evidence. Its not the end-all-be-all, but if two characters thought to be equal throw an explosive attack and one of theirs is far bigger, its safe to assume that the bigger attack is also stronger. Judging an attack based on damage to a character is the most credible evidence though, followed by the damage to the surrounding environment. Hype on what it could have done had it not been stopped or whatnot is also useful.

P.S. I'd like to think that Erza was actually a bad match-up for Ajeel. She had the perfect counters to his abilities, Sand World was simply so overwhelming in scale that Erza couldn't do anything despite having a perfect counter on paper. Ajeel was also in the sky and on a relatively small and frail boat on top of that, he couldn't utilize his full arsenal to its full extent. While Erza could give him a Mid-Diff fight, I believe Ajeel to be a much much bigger threat as an opponent. Very underrated power.

 

[Takuan]

I didn't follow the full conversation and didn't talk at all, however i'd like to say that i agree with the post right above mine, from @Escanors Pride. Dude, i share your opinion 100%.
Just felt like throwing that out here :P

But sorry guys, dont mind me. Please continue =)

 

[Crimson Ice]

Why are you bringing up hype. It has been proven wrong before.
There is no way to validate a hype. A person can be arrogant or humble. They have made wrong hype before.
So give me some way to prove it.
Multiple blows before didn't seems to do much that is why I said it.
Jura took punches from laxus. Something we know natsu face can take. So erza being stronger than him can take um too. I will give couple of reasons below why is she stronger than natsu below.
I am sure you can find erza durability feat your self. But that huge nuke from Minerva she along with kagura tank.
Come to think of it. Was it only anime version where Minerva thought she thought she could handle both erza and kagura. But after the nuke she thought otherwise. Even Jura was impressed by that nuke. And Mavis was well.

Ogra dared Jura to block his charged cannon. Jura said fine. Ogra fired it. Instead of blocking it Jura side stepped it and one shoted ogra. Am I wrong? If so.
Please show me their conversation.

Sigh! Look dude. You are proving laxus is >> erza. Ok.
So obviously I don't believe that. So Jupiter would do alot to him in my opinion. You can prove me wrong.
Of course you will have to compare laxus durability with titan markarov durability. Because that cannon left a nasty hole bigger than laxus size in his arm.
So I imagine laxus would at least look like that.
Erza has very strong magic for defense, laxus doesn't.
To me laxus has better durability than erza
But no where near adamantine armor erza.
This is why I think pre ts laxus would nearly die from Jupiter cannon

Fairy law can be done by anyone who learns it. It is not sign of power. If you have problem believing this. Than look up cana. No laxus was nowhere near markarov.
Only thing he might have above marakrov would be movement speed. Cast speed goes to markarov too

And you keep on saying all statements are correct other than the ones you don't like.
All statements that hype laxus= correct
All statements downgrading erza = correct
All statements hyping erza = false

Why erza is stronger than natsu pre ts
Natsu was losing to blinded aria and he wasn't able to hurt him at all. A wrecked erza one shotted full powered aria with her medium level attack
Natsu is said to be equal to gray. Gray got one shoted along with elfman . While José couldn't finish off erza till markarov arrived
Racer was enough to take out natsu and three fodders and even landed hits on gray at the same time. While three OS members ganged up on erza to take her out.
Natsu is around gajeel level. Pantherlily fought on par with gajeel for awhile. The very next arc a weaker version of erza opponent oneshotted lily along with two other people
And
HYPE and portrayal

After this I say erza >> natsu.
Now you look at these an come up with erza = natsu
Than obviously laxus has done something outrageous that would make you put laxus > erza + Mira.
Please show me these things.

If one roar put down natsu and gajeel. Than who was kicking laxus ass couple of minutes later. How did lightening haven halbert hit gajeel who was already down.
Aria was a bad matchup for natsu.
I see
Though people say ajeel was not a bad matchup for erza even though erza second strongest attack wouldnt have even scratched ajeel face because he was immune to swords
But ok lets agree with your statement
How weak is aria.
Blinded aria was beating crap out of natsu
So was natsu = blinded aria
Or natsu = aria
Or natsu > aria.
Please give proof for this

And the what does erza need to do to one shot natsu. Remember she is also not wrecked.

Why wouldn't they be on the same team together?

I put the emotii there because you were comparing wrecked fairy tail attack team to full fresh laxus. Portrayal a put erza at zero level. So no
And mishma never showed this gap you speak of, when he had a chance. do you know why? he even didn't show it with jellal.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 6, 2016 ---

That is correct
If they had one more erza tier. Phantom would have been wrecked

IT IS NOT HYPE IT IS A STATMENT. Actually, give a good counter argument or don't even bother replying at all. As for the multiple blows they all had some sort of scuffs before, so no, it doesn't count. Natsu took some blows from a non- serious Laxus, the second Laxus got serious Natsu couldn't hang with him while Laxus was serious against Jura from the start. That blow wasn't impressive, the AoE of the blow (which I know that's the only reason you find the move impressive) was MCB+, not impressive and nothing Jura couldn't take.


Jura said fine but Orga is stupid for thinking Jura would agree and his guard was still up hence no use of the "?" or the "!". I can prove you wrong and I have, Jupiter wouldn't drop Laxus at all if you can only 'that's my opinion you' clearly have no good argument left.

Laxus should have comparable durability to Titan Makarov, that left a burn mark on Makarov's hand if Laxus took that he'd be left with some burns that's not as nearly as bad as what happened to Erza. While that Makarov isn't BoS Makarov. Erza has a strong magic for defense and Laxus doesn't? So, Laxus has much higher natrual durability and endruance than Erza so that's irrelevant.


Fairy Law is a sign of power, Bluenote clearly says it himself, if you have a powerful magic but the user is a scrub the magic itself is shit. Fairy Law gives Laxus the power to drop a WS tier opponent in one hit, something Erza didn't have. It's funny you bring up Cana, the very reason Bluenote wasn't beaten by Fairy Law was because it was Cana using it. So yeah Laxus was on Makarov's level BoS.

Did you even read my post? Natsu was struggling against Aria because ARIA USES WIND MAGIC WHICH IS A POOR MATCHUP FOR NATSU. You bring up Aria but Jose literally said Gajeel is stronger than Aria and Natsu beat Gajeel. As for him and Gray being equals DON'T BE SUCH A HYPOCRITE. DON'T PICK AND CHOOSE WHICH STATEMENTS YOU WANT TO USE, YOU WANT TO IGNORE BOTH MIRA'S AND ERZA'S STATMENT BUT CHOOSE TO USE THIS ONE EVEN THOUGH IT WAS NEVER STATED THAT NATSU AND GRAY WERE EQUAL. As for Jose he himself wasn't serious against Erza when they fought he was untouched while Era was panting her ass off exhausted and the second he got serious Erza was about to lose. Don't even know why you're bringing OS into this, 140 chapters into the series is no longer BoS. As for Gajeel and Lilly, Gajeel himself wasn't serious and the second he got serious he destroyed Lilly's sword off the bat.

Oh yeah, Laxus beat Jura which puts him over GMG Mira + pre SO Erza


Don't even try and say hype and portrayal when you've been ignoring it this whole time. If you could fully comprehend hype and portrayal we wouldn't be doing this right now. You can recover from being incapacitated, both Natsu and Gajeel couldn't move and Gajeel himself didn't even move in front of the Halbred in order to save Natsu he made himself a lightning rod.


Erza was a poor matchup for Ajeel (because she had access to wind and water) but the gap in power was too large for the matchup to matter, all you proved was the gap between Erza and Ajeel was larger than the one between Natsu and Aria.

Aria is weaker than Gajeel who lost to Natsu handily at full power.
An injured FT team altogether if still way above a fresh Erza. Portrayal puts Erza nowhere near Zero, especially since he done decent against DF Natsu who is wayy above Erza.

Mashima has made the gap clear as day but you still can't see it.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 6, 2016, Original Post Date: Jul 6, 2016 ---

Before I have to reply to dozens of people at the same time, I'll just post the back-up for my claims right here.

1). The reason why I think Mirajane > Laxus.

After last chapter I thought this would be more or less obvious because it's proven that Mirajane's magic power is far above any other Fairy Tail mage. Guess some of you are still not convinced by her. Well, no matter.

Firstly I'd like to point out that Mirajane's nuke isn't less powerful than Laxus' nuke only because "it is". The only argument I've seen to back this up is because Laxus' nuke was hyped to kill a Spriggan tier. Exactly, hyped as in never shown. As for the size, there is nothing that shows that Laxus' nuke was higher in AoE. I also like to point out that it's absolutely stupid to downplay Mirajane just because Juliet and Hynhe could tank Mirajane's blast. Why? Because they're swords, not humans.

Secondly, saying that Laxus' attack power is far above Mirajane is nothing more than assumptions. We haven't seen Mirajane going full out in her Alegria Soul at all, but we know that she has more to show. As for now, I think we can all agree that Mirajane has a far higher hand-to-handcombat in Alegria Soul than Laxus ever will posses.

Spoiler

Spoiler: Just look at the effect.

Thirdly, which is the most important reason why I rate Mirajane above Laxus, is Seilah Soul. Excluding the magic of the Spriggans, it's probably the most hax power that's ever shown. And no, stop coming up with that pathetic argument that it's NLF. The capabilities of Macro are stated, so it's nothing more than a canon fact.

2). The reason why I think DF Wendy > DF Natsu.

Simple, because DF Natsu's feats are pretty useless compared to DF Wendy's feats. Most of you find it impressive that he outclassed Mard Geer in speed. Like seriously? DF Wendy controls the space which means she can move freely through the area. Let's be real, SHE'LL BLITZ MARD GEER ALL THE WAY.

Speaking of DF Natsu strongest spell, it's less powerful than DF Wendy's nuke lol.

Spoiler

3). The reason why I think Freed > Erza.

And then we go to Freed, by far the most underrated character from Fairy Tail. He got even compared to Elfman and Juvia, LOL.

Anyway, Freed will just kill Erza with Dark Écriture. And no stop beginning about NLF. I'm just going with canon manga feats here.

Spoiler

And if this didn't convince you, fine. There are a lot other options for Freed to end Erza like Dark Écriture: Darkness, Dark Écriture: Absolute Shadow, Dark Écriture: Pain or Dark Écriture: Destruction. He could just pick one of the above and slay Erza. Her defensive is pretty pathetic after all. I mean, her most defensive armor was broken by a sealed sword. Dark Écriture: Destruction would be enough to deal with all of her armors.

This is for the people who say Erza will blitz Freed:

Spoiler

In the end, Freed's speed looks even more impressive. Not to forget that Freed can fly as well. He'll just spam some Dark Écriture: Pain from above.

At last, DARK ÉCRITURE: ABSOLUTE SHADOW IS NOT FEATLESS.

Spoiler

It actually has more feats than Nakagami Armor.



Why would I need to counter your claims? You don't have any back-up, all your argument are based on your opinions. If you want a decent reply than give me something I can actually reply to.

I've given evdience for my claims time and time again and you've NEVER ONCE PROVED ME WRONG. A no limits fallacy isn't an opinion based thing, something is either one or not. Stop making excuses because you can't even muster up a decent reply.

 

[Talenel]

I never posted my rankings. >.>

Top 10 in Fairy Tail:
1 - Natsu
2 - Gray
3 - Laxus
4 - Erza
5 - Gajeel
6 - Mirajane
7 - Gildartz
8 - Makarov
9 - Wendy
10 - Lucy

Now our villians:

1 - Acno
2 - Zeref
0 - Dimaria
3 - August
4 - Irene
5 - Invel
6 - God Serena
7 - Wahl
8 - Ajeel
9 - Bradman
10 - Dimaria

*Dimaria is ranked based off her time hax (which is absurdly broken) and without it it
*This list is based off my own expectations and not just feat and hype.

 

[Ebony Maw]

I never posted my rankings. >.>

Top 10 in Fairy Tail:
1 - Natsu
2 - Gray
3 - Laxus
4 - Erza
5 - Gajeel
6 - Mirajane
7 - Gildartz
8 - Makarov
9 - Wendy
10 - Lucy

Now our villians:

1 - Acno
2 - Zeref
0 - Dimaria
3 - August
4 - Irene
5 - Invel
6 - Ajeel
7 - Wahl
8 - Neinhart
9 - Ajeel
10 - Dimaria

Interesting rankings, if you don't mind me asking why is Neinhart above God Serena, Bradman and Jacob?

 

[Talenel]

Interesting rankings, if you don't mind me asking why is Neinhart above God Serena, Bradman and Jacob?

God Serena should be in my 6th spot...Ajeel is listed twice. >.>
As for Neinhart, casually knocking Jellal unconscious is pretty impressive. He has power....he's just a shitty fighter apparently. I should probably push him lower than Ajeel now that I think about it.

 

[Ebony Maw]

God Serena should be in my 6th spot...Ajeel is listed twice. >.>
As for Neinhart, casually knocking Jellal unconscious is pretty impressive. He has power....he's a shitty fighter apparently. I should probably push him lower than Ajeel now that I think about it.

Ah, that makes more sense lol. As for Neinhart I feel Bradman should be above him, his hax is insane and much more dependable, that said Neinhart is definitely strong but the other Spriggans out performed him IMO.

 

[Talenel]

Ah, that makes more sense lol. As for Neinhart I feel Bradman should be above him, his hax is insane and much more dependable, that said Neinhart is definitely strong but the other Spriggans out performed him IMO.

yeeeaaah, despite having knights as subordinates and wearing armor, Neinhart seems to have no physical ability at all. Looking back, his Historia was only as impressive and effective as it was because the heroes were already worn out or not going all out.
......I'm going to replace him with Bradman in my rankings.

 

[Char]

@Talenel, @SaberToothFan, @Crimson Ice, @Takuan, @Escanors Pride, @Jean Grey, @sharkai, @Kay3795, @NoHana, @Axiomus, @Daniel9dsi, @Cosmicstar, @Brandish, @Emperor Spriggan, @Shoutmon, @reesestl, @BluePegasus, @x777, @Asorx, @SirSamuel016, @Ice devil slayer, @THE ALMIGHTY CRYBABY, @Plutogrim, @Rain Cloud, @Ultimateasus, @Alvarez Princess, @EmberSpirit, @XXEliteXXAceXX, @PeanutButterJelly, @EmberSpirit, @Fox666
and anyone who’d like to join. You’re very welcome.

A few days ago, @Cosmicstar challenged us to provide a top5. This top5 should be carried out providing feats or justifying hype. Then we’d proceed for a top10, and so on.

I found it interesting since polls and the tournament in the Fairy Tail community in mangahelpers have certain limitations. After talking with @Brandish she suggested that I created a sorter, similar to the one in another thread, but shorter. So I did. It has 64 characters and took me 12 minutes to complete. It’s short and easy to do so please I urge you all to complete it. After this manual selection that took over 20 min lol, I expect participation!

Then we will post our rankings and we’ll proceed to compare them. When we’ve gathered a significant amount of them, results will be contrasted and a general ranking that encompasses the answers of the fandom will be provided. That is, of course, if people do participate.

Power ranking sorter:

http://charactersort.6te.net/custom/sorter.php?id=177

Rules:

-None of your picks can simply have hype behind them without any panels or feats to back it up. If you decide to go by hype, state where you think this hype comes from. Be consistant.

Ex: Meaning you can't say Wolfhiem is a city buster without any city busting feats to go along with that.

-If you use hype you must use all Hype or no hype.

Ex: If you defend that the GoI are above Jura because Ooba said so, then you also need to defend that all Spriggan12 belong to the same tier (except for August and Irene) because they’ve been hyped to be equals.

-Speculation is fine as long as there is some evidence to support or back you claim up. The evidence has to be relevant to you proposed speculation.


NO Bashing---Be Respectful

If you disagree with someone then you need to provide a counter argument with evidence. You can't just say you disagree. An argument must always be provided if you disagree with someone/something written.


If you decide to back up your ranking list or to criticize someone else’s, your post can't just be a wall of text consisting on baseless speculations.

You can choose to abide by NLF or not. Your choice.

Some characters do have "base" states and "powerup" states. Some like "Natsu", only have one powerup: Igneel-powered Natsu. Then there's just "Natsu". This "Natsu" stands for the strongest Natsu whose powerup depends on only himself: "BDKM Natsu". So, there's no "base Natsu" in this power sorter.


My ranking:

Spoiler

1. Acnologia

2. Igneel

3. Zeref Dragneel

4. Igneel-powered Natsu

4. Irene Belserion

6. August

7. Chronos Dimaria Yesta

8. Brandish

9. God Serena

10. Bradman

10. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)

12. Jacob Lessio

13. Laxus Dreyar

14. Jellal Fernandes

15. Ajeel Lamur

15. Wahl Icht

17. DF Gajeel

18. Natsu

19. DeS Gray Fullbuster

20. Erza Scarlet

20. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)

22. Neinhart

22. Full Power Precht Gaebolg

22. Mirajane Strauss

22. Gildarts Clive

26. Hyberion

26. Third origin Chelia Blendy

26. Kagura Mikazuchi

29. Base Gray Fullbuster

29. Mard Geer Tartaros

31. Wolfheim

31. Ikatsunagi

33. Warrod Sequen

34. Jura Neekis

34. Bluenote Stinger

36. Ur

37. Minerva Orlando

37. Marin Hollow

37. Freed Justine

37. Lyon Vastia

37. Shaila

42. Base Gajeel Redfox

42. DF Wendy Marvell

44. Makarov Dreyar

45. Future Rogue

46. Lucy Heartfillia

46. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney

48. Juvia Lockster

48. Kyôka

48. Silver Fullbuster

51. Cana Alberona

51. Evergreen

51. Mest Gryder

51. Azuma

51. Meredy

56. Bickslow

57. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun

57. Elfman Strauss

57. Ikaruga

60. Chelia Blendy

61. Levy Mcgarden

61. Base Wendy Marvell

61. Wahl Icht Proxy

64. Lisanna Strauss

 

[Talenel]

@Char
This seems fun, but I'm almost certain that everyone's top 5 will be basically the same.

A question though: it seem like Dragons are immune to non-dragon magic. Have we ever seen a Dragon take damage from non Dragon magic? if they're immune, I dont know that they should be on the list.
Also, since August and Irene are the strongest of the Spriggans, are we supposed to assume they have some way to stop Dimaria from freezing time or Brandish from shrinking their organs and leaving their bodies inoperable?

 

[The President]

Ex: If you defend that the GoI are above Jura because Ooba said so, then you also need to defend that all Spriggan12 belong to the same tier (except for August and Irene) because they’ve been hyped to be equals.

They are very different circumstances though.

This seems fun, but I'm almost certain that everyone's top 5 will be basically the same.

You would be surprised how many people disregard NLF.

A question though: it seem like Dragons are immune to non-dragon magic. Have we ever seen a Dragon take damage from non Dragon magic? if they're immune, I dont know that they should be on the list.

No but the strongest mage that attacked a regular dragon was Jura, so that doesn't say much. I'd like to think that dragons are resistant but not immune. Regardless, I believe this is measuring general/overall power.

Anyways, its rather difficult for me to make an actual full fledged rankings list because so many characters still need updated feats so I'm just gonna be discuss other lists. When we reach the final battle(s) I'll be able to bring myself to do this list.

 

[Char]

@Char
This seems fun, but I'm almost certain that everyone's top 5 will be basically the same.

A question though: it seem like Dragons are immune to non-dragon magic. Have we ever seen a Dragon take damage from non Dragon magic? if they're immune, I dont know that they should be on the list.

The point of this 'exercise' is not to get an accurate top5 but to see how we differ in opinions and then try to healthily debate/discuss our differences!
Dragons are not immune to non-dragon magic, although you have a point. Let's consider they were unaffected by the GMG mages because they were simply too weak, and that while non dragon slayers can hurt dragons (if they're very strong mages), dragon slayers are going to have a certain advantage factor.

They are very different circumstances though.

Well as long as you present consistant arguments, then you can take whatever variables you estimate accurate.

You would be surprised how many people disregard NLF.

Let them. The power rankings will be more varied that way.

No but the strongest mage that attacked a regular dragon was Jura, so that doesn't say much. I'd like to think that dragons are resistant but not immune. Regardless, I believe this is measuring general/overall power.

Yeah, Jura/Makarov were the strongest non-ds opponents those dragons had to face. I believe mages who're above that level are gonna comfortably put up a fight against dragons.

Anyways, its rather difficult for me to make an actual full fledged rankings list because so many characters still need updated feats so I'm just gonna be discuss other lists. When we reach the final battle(s) I'll be able to bring myself to do this list.

Most of the characters I used for the ranking have shown feats, although I do agree in some cases significant feats need to be shown before we can properly decide, at this point, I don't think certain characters are going to show much more so let's just speculate if we really have to.

 

[Demon Hunter]

damn, the list is too long. can we do top 20??? 64 is too much, especially when half of them didn't do anything..

 

[Talenel]

No but the strongest mage that attacked a regular dragon was Jura, so that doesn't say much. I'd like to think that dragons are resistant but not immune. Regardless, I believe this is measuring general/overall power.

IIRC, Wendy caused a dragon more pain than Jura.....thats what makes me doubt.

@Char
alright boss. Now my 2nd question: since August and Irene are the strongest of the Spriggans, are we supposed to assume they have some way to stop Dimaria from freezing time or Brandish from shrinking their organs and leaving their bodies inoperable?

I just realized that my boy Gray is featless.

 

[The President]

IIRC, Wendy caused a dragon more pain than Jura.....thats what makes me doubt.

Well yeah......she has dragon slaying magic. It removes the resistance factor and makes things even. Lets not forget that Zeref is planning to nuke Acnologia with a shit ton of magic (via FH) and I'm sure Zeref is accounting for his dragon form. They cannot be completely immune, just how much resistance you think they have is another story, I am on the camp that its enough to make the weaker mages non-factors but stronger mages should be able to do damage. Curses and physical attacks should also work normally.

 

[Talenel]

The difference between Wendy and Jura was enormous. How the heck does that scale? Do you need to be stronger than GMG Jura by as much as GMG Jura was to Wendy in order to do as much damage to a Dragon as did Wendy?

 

[Jko]

I just did it

Spoiler: Top 21

1. Acnologia
2. Zeref Dragneel
3. Igneel
4. Irene Belserion
5. August
6. Igneel-powered Natsu
7. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
8. Brandish
9. Wahl Icht
10. Laxus Dreyar
11. Natsu
12. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
13. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
13. Ikatsunagi
15. Mirajane Strauss
16. Third origin Chelia Blendy
17. DF Gajeel
18. Bradman
19. Ajeel Lamur
20. Gildarts Clive
21. Jacob Lessio

Everything past twenty was kind of out of wack. I am honestly surprised Natsu, Laxus, Wahl, and Brandish are above the parent Dragons . And I'm really surprised that Ikusa-Tsunagi is that high in the first place...I'd def put 15-21 above him. Pretty long survey though and I'm to lazy to do it again .

At least my bottom 4 seems about right

Spoiler: Bottom 4

61. Mest Gryder
62. Lisanna Strauss
63. Levy Mcgarden
64. Ikaruga

 

[The President]

The difference between Wendy and Jura was enormous. How the heck does that scale? Do you need to be stronger than GMG Jura by as much as GMG Jura was to Wendy in order to do as much damage to a Dragon as did Wendy?

Wendy hardly even did that much damage. Plus I consider Zirconis the weakest dragon (among the GMG dragons at least). This shouldn't be debatable though, like I said, Zerefs plan revolves around him getting FH and nuking everything with infinite magic. Dragons aren't downright immune to magic, this plan wouldn't be possible otherwise.

 

[Demon Hunter]

Spoiler: Top 23

1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Zeref
4. Irene Belserion
5. August
6. Natsu - Igneel's power
7. Chronos Dimaria Vesta
8. Brandish
9. Jacob Lession
10. God Serena
11. Laxus Dreyar
12. Wahl Ich
13. Jellal Fernandes
14. Natsu Dragneel
15. Ajeel Lamur
16. Erza
17. Gajeel
18. Brandman
19. DeS Gray
20. Base Gray
21. DF Wendy Marvel
22. Lucy Heartfilia
23. Base Wendy

 

[Char]

alright boss. Now my 2nd question: since August and Irene are the strongest of the Spriggans, are we supposed to assume they have some way to stop Dimaria from freezing time or Brandish from shrinking their organs and leaving their bodies inoperable?

I just realized that my boy Gray is featless.

As for August/Irene > Dimaria/Brandish, that's entirely up to you! Whether you class them above or below is fine, since either way makes sense.

ikr, Gray needs to shine.

The difference between Wendy and Jura was enormous. How the heck does that scale? Do you need to be stronger than GMG Jura by as much as GMG Jura was to Wendy in order to do as much damage to a Dragon as did Wendy?

The DS factor is probably more considerable than we'd like to think. GMG Wendy, who's many tiers below GMG Jura, managed to hurt a dragon more than him, that makes the Dragon Slaying factor multiplier quite high.

You probably need to be at least Warrod Tier / Mard Geer Tier to hurt a dragon.

I just did it

Spoiler: Top 21

1. Acnologia
2. Zeref Dragneel
3. Igneel
4. Irene Belserion
5. August
6. Igneel-powered Natsu
7. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
8. Brandish
9. Wahl Icht
10. Laxus Dreyar
11. Natsu
12. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
13. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
13. Ikatsunagi
15. Mirajane Strauss
16. Third origin Chelia Blendy
17. DF Gajeel
18. Bradman
19. Ajeel Lamur
20. Gildarts Clive
21. Jacob Lessio

Everything past twenty was kind of out of wack. I am honestly surprised Natsu, Laxus, Wahl, and Brandish are above the parent Dragons . And I'm really surprised that Ikusa-Tsunagi is that high in the first place...I'd def put 15-21 above him. Pretty long survey though and I'm to lazy to do it again .

At least my bottom 4 seems about right

Spoiler: Bottom 4

61. Mest Gryder
62. Lisanna Strauss
63. Levy Mcgarden
64. Ikaruga

The sorter is but a means to help you class them, but if you don't agree upon the results, you're very entitled to change them and I'll take into account the changes. After all, the purpose of this is to see who you consider superior to whom, not the sheer results of a sorter with which you do not agree :P

Thanks for taking your time and if you wish to change anything you can well edit your post, since I won't be gathering results for a while.

Also please, if you still have the list, since you've done the entire sorter, I'd appreciate if you could post the 64 characters. If you don't have the list any longer it's fine.

Spoiler: Top 22

1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Zeref
4. Irene Belserion
5. August
6. Natsu - Igneel's power
7. Chronos DImaria Vesta
8. Brandish
9. Jacob Lession
10. God Serena
11. Laxus Dreyar
12. Wahl Ich
13. Natsu Dragneel
14. Ajeel Lamur
15. Erza
16. Gajeel
17. Brandman
18. DeS Gray
19. Base Gray
20. DF Wendy Marvel
21. Lucy Heartfilia
22. Base Wendy

Thank you. I will not be gathering the users' results until a few people have posted theirs so remember you can always change (or enlarge) your list. Sorting the 64 takes about 12 minutes with the sorter, although 22 is fine!