Discussion Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread

Which side are you on?

  • Team Spriggan 12

    Votes: 48 51.6%
  • Team Diabolos/Dragon Eaters

    Votes: 45 48.4%

  • Total voters
    93

Jko

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Mar 28, 2016
Messages
7,448
Reaction score
18,767
Country
United States
Three different timelines were something you came up with. Nowhere was it was mentioned. All Zeref said was it was full of nothing but time magic. Anything else is your headcanon.



Brandish never said anything about that. All she said was Gajeel limiter was three minutes. That's the limit of Brandish as well since Brandish is the one casting the spell, not Gajeel. Nowhere was it mention this is because of Gajeel faulty body.



Gajeel was able to damage the golems, later on, don't know what you saying. It just means he didn't go that hard on the golems at the beginning,



He hasn't eaten DS magic. Can show me anywhere he has eaten DS magic? He failed against Igneel, Irene. He was dodging Natsu attacks. I have seen saying that you don't need to dodge if it can't damage you in a Laxus vs Erza discussion. He was dodging Stings attack as well. Everything magic he has eaten up until now is non-DS Magic. He ain't beating 5 DG together. Even half-dead they can beat him in physicals together.
No, I did not. It is literally stated the time lapse reacted with each use of the Eclipse Gate. The eclipse gate was use three times to alter the timeline. The paradox obviously grew since it was created from an alteration of the timeline so two more alterations would obviously make it worse.

Brandish says the limiter was Gajeel's body. "My magic can't make him bigger, besides that is his body's max size". The limitation of size and time limiter was bcs of Gajeel's bcs of Gajeel lol. She wasn't even phased by increasing his mass to that extent.
With a sword. He couldn't produce enough power with a strike in order to break it like Lucy did. So his statement of not being able to smash it is still valid. All he did against Aldo was punches and elbows.

So Natsu can't eat fire ds magic now despite doing so? Lol, Gajeel and Natsu have literally ate different elemental ds magic. No reason to believe Acno is any different. What are you even talking about now? Acno did not need to dodge anything from fodder like Sting when he straight up no sells Laxus and Gajeel's attacks without flinching lmao. He is moving mostly out of boredom. Sure if he fights like an idiot, but if he goes at them like he did the parent dragons then they are done. One of these guys got haxed out by Touka and she was going to do another one as well so these guys hax resistance is subpar. As soon as they start dropping magic attacks, he just gets fueled up and enhanced more and more by their attacks. Physical power isn't enough to beat him when he is trying.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Their were circumstances : when Gajeel and co were useless, the Golems seemed invulnerable as they were at full power. No one coud affect them. Even with combo attacks. With Doom's defeat, all Seeds were weakened and the Golems could be damage (Lucy with Taurus as exemple) and destroy even if they were still very durable.

Every Seeds's defeats weakened the Seeds still valid. And this is why Natsu could defeat Aldo brain.
Only God Seed Aldo got weakened and that is bcs their magic power connects to him. Nothing was stated about the other seeds getting weakened so they didn't.
 

Kurumi Tokisaki

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
May 14, 2019
Messages
3,172
Reaction score
4,238
Age
29
Country
Sri Lanka
No, I did not. It is literally stated the time lapse reacted with each use of the Eclipse Gate. The eclipse gate was use three times to alter the timeline. The paradox obviously grew since it was created from an alteration of the timeline so two more alterations would obviously make it worse.
It reacted to Eclipse doesn't mean it has 3 timelines in it. It only reacted to the eclipse gate because it was a by-product of it.

What are you even talking about now? Acno did not need to dodge anything from fodder like Sting when he straight up no sells Laxus and Gajeel's attacks without flinching lmao. He is moving mostly out of boredom.
There is nothing to suggest he is moving out of boredom. Might well as Laxus dodge Erza's first attack out of boredom.

One of these guys got haxed out by Touka and she was going to do another one as well so these guys hax resistance is subpar.
Mercophobia let White Wizard white him out purposely so he could save Elemina Town. Camille literally asked White Wizard to White him out.

With a sword. He couldn't produce enough power with a strike in order to break it like Lucy did.
He did destroy them later like the rest of the cast off-panel . Cana already mentions how they keep coming after they destroyed them.
 

GL_Nova

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
3,067
Reaction score
3,164
Age
37
Country
United States
Except no other person is doing that. Put any other characters besides immortals and they would have died. That feat is above enlarging the moon, or destroying a country. Yeah, and all he did was have to harmonize to stabilize. Still the thing is he didn't die from that lapse in time. Throw Natsu into the core of the sun and I am saying that feat would be better than any DG feat as well. Resistance only gets you so far, with or without it, the feat is their and thus making it more impressive lol. How is DGs gonna top him without magic? They won't. Lapse in time failed to kill him so fire magic (without PoF), moon magic, sword saint magic, and tree magic are doing jack squat lol.


Vape feat is multicontinental. Aldo's step and shockwave were country. The Gajeel calcs were also getting continental kinetic energy as well.

Bcs they can't do anything to him. Suzaku fought Acno he is getting body without putting a scratch on him. You are comparing fighting a DG to fighting Acno which is two different beasts altogether since Acno's DoM ability neggs magic.


Bcs there was nothing she could have done without magic. I am wondering what Suzaku could have done that Irene could not in that situation? Tanking a DG spell is not that hard, several have done it before hand and they are much weaker than Irene. The spell Selene used wasn't even impressive lol.

Bcs Brandish made him powerful enough to do so. Giga Brandish >= Giga Gajeel, only difference is Gajeel had DS magic lol. Laxus oneshot a S12 with an asspull and his weakness and Wall also stood there and let Laxus attack him. Wall shot off Etherion, Laxus would have been toasted point blank. Never said the DG are weaker, I said everything Suzaku has done, is about Giga Gajeel level which is only Brandish tier who is below the top 2 S12 lmao.

Except none of these guys put them down without plot interference or assistance in some capacity. They also failed to beat the top 2 S12, even PoF Erza with literally multiple advantages failed lol. The S12 are obviously still relevant as shown with the Giga Gajeel feat. S-Class FT members are not country level by feats which Brandish alone is based on feats and statements. Suzaku is sitting around high tier S12/Giga Gajeel tier. Both are below Irene/August tier.

Nothing he has done to Selene impressed me more than Giga Gajeel. That's the benchmarker and he has yet to surpass it. You are trying to compare nicking Selene to doing no damage to Acno which is a failed comparison since Suzaku can't scratch Acno either. That's why I said I am waiting until he does something better than Giga Gajeel did.
Ima read the rest when I have time, but drop your multi-continental calc or a link bro. Cause I haven’t seen anybody other than my friend Jason argue anything close to it. This is being made seperate from the response because it’s a genuine request. That id like to see.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Except no other person is doing that. Put any other characters besides immortals and they would have died. That feat is above enlarging the moon, or destroying a country. Yeah, and all he did was have to harmonize to stabilize. Still the thing is he didn't die from that lapse in time. Throw Natsu into the core of the sun and I am saying that feat would be better than any DG feat as well. Resistance only gets you so far, with or without it, the feat is their and thus making it more impressive lol. How is DGs gonna top him without magic? They won't. Lapse in time failed to kill him so fire magic (without PoF), moon magic, sword saint magic, and tree magic are doing jack squat lol.


Vape feat is multicontinental. Aldo's step and shockwave were country. The Gajeel calcs were also getting continental kinetic energy as well.

Bcs they can't do anything to him. Suzaku fought Acno he is getting body without putting a scratch on him. You are comparing fighting a DG to fighting Acno which is two different beasts altogether since Acno's DoM ability neggs magic.


Bcs there was nothing she could have done without magic. I am wondering what Suzaku could have done that Irene could not in that situation? Tanking a DG spell is not that hard, several have done it before hand and they are much weaker than Irene. The spell Selene used wasn't even impressive lol.

Bcs Brandish made him powerful enough to do so. Giga Brandish >= Giga Gajeel, only difference is Gajeel had DS magic lol. Laxus oneshot a S12 with an asspull and his weakness and Wall also stood there and let Laxus attack him. Wall shot off Etherion, Laxus would have been toasted point blank. Never said the DG are weaker, I said everything Suzaku has done, is about Giga Gajeel level which is only Brandish tier who is below the top 2 S12 lmao.

Except none of these guys put them down without plot interference or assistance in some capacity. They also failed to beat the top 2 S12, even PoF Erza with literally multiple advantages failed lol. The S12 are obviously still relevant as shown with the Giga Gajeel feat. S-Class FT members are not country level by feats which Brandish alone is based on feats and statements. Suzaku is sitting around high tier S12/Giga Gajeel tier. Both are below Irene/August tier.

Nothing he has done to Selene impressed me more than Giga Gajeel. That's the benchmarker and he has yet to surpass it. You are trying to compare nicking Selene to doing no damage to Acno which is a failed comparison since Suzaku can't scratch Acno either. That's why I said I am waiting until he does something better than Giga Gajeel did.
At this point, that’s the crux of the Acno argument though. Hax. An depending on what we find out about his DS magics particulars, he may still have a way to cut him. Anything can happen next week. An the story quite clearly makes the comparison from jump. The first thing we learn about the DG is they are at least as strong as Acno. Who else should I be comparing them too?

That’s a great point. Which since as I’ve mentioned, FT is already well on the way to leaving the Spriggan in their collective dust, makes perfect sense. Plus the nature of those attacks played a role.

What puts Brandish over Gajeel again? She’s one of the weakest Spriggan and has no really impressive combat showings. Outside of hax, what’s her threat here? An in what way did she affect his magic at all? Honestly outside of making him bigger, what indication is there that she did anything else?

You mean Laxus having his training payoff moment? I would definitely focus on that instead of the fact he tanked every blow while having organ failure and still was slapping Wahl’s immune self around majority of the fight. The fact you mention Wahl needed a full powered Etherion blast to kill a man already dying of Organ failure as some kind of impressive feat lol. “Help, that man’s having a heart attack, where’s my tank!!”

Yes, each used teamwork to counter the broken hax of the Spriggan they were facing (except Laxus), but none were shown to be massively outclassed combat wise. An once the hax were figured out, the response was quite swift. So while none of them have the prerequisite destructive feats, they have all gone blow for blow and one against mages who can. An the 2 they didn’t beat, they pushed to suicide. So at best you can argue Irene didn’t lose. August will to fight was broken enough that he really thought killing himself made more sense than just putting everyone down like he did in Bosco. All of which is really fascinating debating, and none of which changes that unlike August and the Spriggan who themselves got one shot by Natsu, and failed to put Erza down. Suzaku put both Erza and Natsu down and then stepped to a Acno lvl opponent and held his own for a chapter. Neither of them have feats that match this. Irene was in the exact same situation and couldn’t draw a drop of blood. An this was before anybody knew Acno could eat magic in a pinch. He just tanked her shit.


Actually, since Gajeel immediately got his ass kicked and did no major damage in return, I’m not sure how you’re logic holds up there bro. I’d argue that the sword Saint dragon has the best chance to cut Acno out of anyone, but that not being able to break Acno’s hax in no way invalidates his success. I get it though. At least Irene isn’t dead, and you have a chance for her shade to show she’s at least on Suzaku’s tier.
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Giant Gajeel is the combined efforts of Brandish and Gajeel. It's stronger than Brandish individually. Nowhere is it implied that Gajeel's max size is smaller than Brandish's. How strong Gajeel is should have nothing to do with how long he can stay big either.

August and Irene can still take damage from Wendy and Cana tiers. Brandish managed to stab August. August chose to dodge Cana's cards. Irene had been cut by Erza's slashes and Wendy's claws. Comparing this to Gajeel's sword just bounces off Acno's chest? I would say being able to cut Selene would be mightily impressive if she has Acnologia's level of durability. She might not though.

And honestly, oneshotting Erza and Natsu already gives him a decent chance at taking out August or Irene. Irene and August probably have more MP, but Suzaku's got the best speed feats from a non-Acno tier and his attack power is better. Durability wise, they might all be around the same level. We'll have to see how he facetanks an attack from Selene. If he lives through a serious attack from Selene, something in the spirit of Aldoron's thicket, he's basically DF Natsu level.
 

Ronin31

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 8, 2020
Messages
1,361
Reaction score
1,830
Gender
Male
Country
France
Only God Seed Aldo got weakened and that is bcs their magic power connects to him. Nothing was stated about the other seeds getting weakened so they didn't.
So Lucy is ace striker as she cut in half a golem with star mix dress and pierce another with Taurus form, while the others (Mira, Elfman, Raijinshouu, Gajeel...) couldn't, even with combine magic.

For me, previous and after Golem's durability showed up a clear weakening. No Aldo brain wasn't alone to be affect.
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Only Aldo seed got weakened, because Aldo seed shares MP with dragon Aldo.

Star dress mix has better striking than Iron Dragon club. Taurus dress might also have marginally stronger striking than iron dragon club, but Gajeel managed to cut a golem the next chapter with iron dragon sword for similar amounts of damage. However, this is all irrelevant because Gajeel simply isn't going all out here. Gajeel can trade shots, frustrate, and tire out LFD Natsu. Aquarius, who is stronger than Yokai-Lucy considers LFD to be lethal to Lucy.
 

Ronin31

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 8, 2020
Messages
1,361
Reaction score
1,830
Gender
Male
Country
France
Gajeel managed to cut a golem the next chapter with iron dragon sword for similar amounts of damage.
Yes, when golems were weakened, just when Lucy damaged one with Taurus dress.
They seemed unvulnerable (Gajeel's strike and co to nothing) and then after Doom's defeat, people damaged them just when Aldo explained that his magic was weakened. Coincidence ??
 

GL_Nova

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
3,067
Reaction score
3,164
Age
37
Country
United States
Why are we comparing a recovering Gajeel to Lucy? People are acting like he didn’t have a knock-down drag out with LFD Natsu prior to this.
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Yes, when golems were weakened, just when Lucy damaged one with Taurus dress.
They seemed unvulnerable (Gajeel's strike and co to nothing) and then after Doom's defeat, people damaged them just when Aldo explained that his magic was weakened. Coincidence ??
The golems weren't weakened. FT just started using better attacks.
 

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,060
Reaction score
1,111
Age
36
Country
United States
And honestly, oneshotting Erza and Natsu already gives him a decent chance at taking out August or Irene. Irene and August probably have more MP, but Suzaku's got the best speed feats from a non-Acno tier and his attack power is better.
Suzaku might not be faster than erza (irene as well). though mishma might push that in the start.

if you look at the feat. Suzaku starts to attack natsu. erza went from being behind natsu to moving infront of him, summoning a swords, and positioning herself in a perfect block stance, all while suzaku still was attacking natsu.
mishma might push for suzaku being faster than erza in initial part of erza va suzaku (if that happens) but that feat showed erza to be faster. and irene was faster than erza

we dont know the extent of irene attack power. she was pretty causal with aconolgia, and wasnt trying to hurt him, suzaku with selene. though irene did technically beat aconolgia. making him leave the battle for a very long time
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Suzaku might not be faster than erza (irene as well). though mishma might push that in the start.

if you look at the feat. Suzaku starts to attack natsu. erza went from being behind natsu to moving infront of him, summoning a swords, and positioning herself in a perfect block stance, all while suzaku still was attacking natsu.
mishma might push for suzaku being faster than erza in initial part of erza va suzaku (if that happens) but that feat showed erza to be faster. and irene was faster than erza

we dont know the extent of irene attack power. she was pretty causal with aconolgia, and wasnt trying to hurt him, suzaku with selene. though irene did technically beat aconolgia. making him leave the battle for a very long time
He's way faster than both. He told everyone he was about to attack before he made the first slash, so Erza knew what was coming before he drew his sword. By the time Erza blocked his first slash, his sword had already returned to his sheath. Erza flat couldn't respond to the 2nd slash. I mean, that's just strictly faster.

Wendy could react and block Irene's enchanments. She could also land shots on Irene. In general Suzaku dealt with Erza and Natsu much better than Irene did with Erza and Wendy.

Irene couldn't hurt Acno with magic even if she tries. He no sold roars from Igneel, who is flat out several tiers stronger than Irene.

Universe One requires preparation. Irene had to place enchanments on the land before the battle began. I don't consider bfr a testament to fighting ability either.
 

GL_Nova

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
3,067
Reaction score
3,164
Age
37
Country
United States
Sooo is it still a debate guys??
 

Hexbend

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2019
Messages
863
Reaction score
1,196
Age
24
Country
United States
No :yodawg
 

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,060
Reaction score
1,111
Age
36
Country
United States
He's way faster than both. He told everyone he was about to attack before he made the first slash, so Erza knew what was coming before he drew his sword. By the time Erza blocked his first slash, his sword had already returned to his sheath. Erza flat couldn't respond to the 2nd slash. I mean, that's just strictly faster.

Wendy could react and block Irene's enchanments. She could also land shots on Irene. In general Suzaku dealt with Erza and Natsu much better than Irene did with Erza and Wendy.

Irene couldn't hurt Acno with magic even if she tries. He no sold roars from Igneel, who is flat out several tiers stronger than Irene.

Universe One requires preparation. Irene had to place enchanments on the land before the battle began. I don't consider bfr a testament to fighting ability either.
Doesn't matter. Erza covered huge distance while suzaku movement was minimal. This distance was covered in same time. Aka erza is faster.
Though mishma might go for suzaku being faster.

I dont think suzaku made more than one strike. The move erza blocked was the move that broke erza sword and injured her.
Erza started all her movement after suzaku started unsheathing his sword.

I think Wendy only hit Irene when Irene was distracted or in wrong body.

Irene can hurt aconologia just fine. His magical immunity is far beyond selene
 

GL_Nova

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
3,067
Reaction score
3,164
Age
37
Country
United States
Doesn't matter. Erza covered huge distance while suzaku movement was minimal. This distance was covered in same time. Aka erza is faster.
Though mishma might go for suzaku being faster.

I dont think suzaku made more than one strike. The move erza blocked was the move that broke erza sword and injured her.
Erza started all her movement after suzaku started unsheathing his sword.

I think Wendy only hit Irene when Irene was distracted or in wrong body.

Irene can hurt aconologia just fine. His magical immunity is far beyond selene
Based on what?
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Doesn't matter. Erza covered huge distance while suzaku movement was minimal. This distance was covered in same time. Aka erza is faster.
Though mishma might go for suzaku being faster.

I dont think suzaku made more than one strike. The move erza blocked was the move that broke erza sword and injured her.
Erza started all her movement after suzaku started unsheathing his sword.

I think Wendy only hit Irene when Irene was distracted or in wrong body.

Irene can hurt aconologia just fine. His magical immunity is far beyond selene
Of course it matters. In fact that's all that matters. Suzaku made more cuts than Erza could defend.

Suzaku made 2 slashes. The one that Erza blocked is verticle and made contact at head level. This broke her sword. The second slash went horizontally across her midsection. The way Erza held the sword to defend against Suzaku wouldn't have actually blocked the slash to her belly. The sword broke before Erza's wounds opened up too.

Irene can't hurt Acnologia at all. The distraction argument simply doesn't work. Irene engaging Erza allowed Wendy to land a hit. Suzaku stomped Erza, and then Natsu....and then Wendy and Gray and Lucy decided to run away because they knew they stood no chance.
 

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,060
Reaction score
1,111
Age
36
Country
United States
Based on what?
Based on erza blasting rot aconologia across the town and irene literally having magic to separate dragons from ds magic.
Irene and August packed a huge punch.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Of course it matters. In fact that's all that matters. Suzaku made more cuts than Erza could defend.

Suzaku made 2 slashes. The one that Erza blocked is verticle and made contact at head level. This broke her sword. The second slash went horizontally across her midsection. The way Erza held the sword to defend against Suzaku wouldn't have actually blocked the slash to her belly. The sword broke before Erza's wounds opened up too.

Irene can't hurt Acnologia at all. The distraction argument simply doesn't work. Irene engaging Erza allowed Wendy to land a hit. Suzaku stomped Erza, and then Natsu....and then Wendy and Gray and Lucy decided to run away because they knew they stood no chance.
I dont thinks its two. Only one point of erza sword is shown, which breaks, that is why she is hit. Either how erza reacted to all. She even knew she was gonna get hit because her sword broke. Suzaku mentions this too

Yes she can. That is why aconologia was talking to her. That is why aconologia said fighting her would be interesting. That is why aconologia was so shocked he wanted to know who she was

Yes it does. She just saw her long lost daughter again. And is clearly talking to her. Pretty sure wendy could land hits on aconologia like this too, if he is talking to his lost love

Suzaku stomped erza like marin stomped erza. Its not that impressive. If ersa faces a suzaku again that won't happen again
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
I dont thinks its two. Only one point of erza sword is shown, which breaks, that is why she is hit. Either how erza reacted to all. She even knew she was gonna get hit because her sword broke. Suzaku mentions this too

Yes she can. That is why aconologia was talking to her. That is why aconologia said fighting her would be interesting. That is why aconologia was so shocked he wanted to know who she was

Yes it does. She just saw her long lost daughter again. And is clearly talking to her. Pretty sure wendy could land hits on aconologia like this too, if he is talking to his lost love

Suzaku stomped erza like marin stomped erza. Its not that impressive. If ersa faces a suzaku again that won't happen again
He made 2 cuts. This is the cut that he made on Erza. It went horizontally across her belly.
In red is where the slash would have been on Erza's body. In orange is all the angles of attack Suzaku could have done against Erza's sword judging from how it impacted Erza's sword.
Not to mention, Erza's sword broke at a different time than when her wounds opened up. If they were both the result of the same strike, the damage would have been simultaneous. Erza would not have time to express shock at the sword breaking before the wound started spraying blood. Suzaku was surprised that Erza could react to one of his attacks. Honestly, having to dwell this deep into it is a bit absurd. Suzaku stomped Erza in 2 pages. I don't see how anyone can look at that and say Erza was faster. He's also doing stuff that Erza has never done, like cutting things behind him in a seat position before anyone realized what's going on. It's so obvious that he's portrayed as faster than Erza.

No, she can't and they both know she can't. All Acnologia said was that Irene's magic power was impressive for someone that was taught by Zeref. Which says absolutely nothing about her chances of actually hurting him. Igneel, while dead, had enough power in his corpse to kill Zeref. Acnologia no-sold his roars. Also, Acnologia knows that he's immune to magic. In fact, we know that Irene can't damage Acnologia because we can actually track all of her feats. None of the attacks she used against Erza and Wendy in her human form could get past Wendy's barrier, much less Acno's broken immunity to magic. The claw swipe he used against Erza would be weaker than a punch from Igneel. Deus Sema is useless against Acno because it's not dragon slaying magic, and he can eat it. She enchanted her remaining power into Wendy right before she was about to commit suicide, and used all of it to beat Nebaru. This attack didn't even deal 1 point of damage to Aldoron's skin. So what exactly was Irene going to pull to hurt Acno?


No, Wendy couldn't. None of the dragon slayers landed a clean shot on him despite Acno talking the entire time. He blocked or dodged all of their attacks cleanly. Only Laxus even got close to landing a shot on Acno, and his attack was blocked and then Acno literally stepped on him.
 
Last edited:

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,060
Reaction score
1,111
Age
36
Country
United States
He made 2 cuts. This is the cut that he made on Erza. It went horizontally across her belly.
In red is where the slash would have been on Erza's body. In orange is all the angles of attack Suzaku could have done against Erza's sword judging from what we can see from Erza's sword.
Not to mention, Erza's sword broke at a different time than when her wounds opened up. If they were both the result of the same strike, the damage would have been simultaneous. Erza would not have time to express shock at the sword breaking before the wound started spraying blood. Suzaku was surprised that Erza could react to one of his attacks. Honestly, having to dwell this deep into it is a bit absurd. Suzaku stomped Erza in 2 pages. I don't see how anyone can look at that and say Erza was faster. He's also doing stuff that Erza has never done, like cutting things behind him in a seat position before anyone realized what's going on. It's so obvious that he's portrayed as faster than Erza.

No, she can't and they both know she can't. All Acnologia said was that Irene's magic power was impressive for someone that was taught by Zeref. Which says absolutely nothing about her chances of actually hurting him. Igneel, while dead, had enough power in his corpse to kill Zeref. Acnologia no-sold his roars. Also, Acnologia knows that he's immune to magic. In fact, we know that Irene can't damage Acnologia because we can actually track all of her feats. None of the attacks she used against Erza and Wendy in her human form could get past Wendy's barrier, much less Acno's broken immunity to magic. The claw swipe he used against Erza would be weaker than a punch from Igneel. Deus Sema is useless against Acno because it's not dragon slaying magic, and he can eat it. She enchanted her remaining power into Wendy right before she was about to commit suicide, and used all of it to beat Nebaru. This attack didn't even deal 1 point of damage to Aldoron's skin. So what exactly was Irene going to pull to hurt Acno?


No, Wendy couldn't. None of the dragon slayers landed a clean shot on him despite Acno talking the entire time. He blocked or dodged all of their attacks cleanly. Only Laxus even got close to landing a shot on Acno, and his attack was blocked and then Acno literally stepped on him.
Those pictures don't show two strikes. You are trying to see which might not be there. All I can see that suzaku attacked, in that time erza went from being behind natsu and un armed to.being infront of natsu and trying to block
Since she used random sword, suzaku move broke her sword and injured her.
That is pretty much it. It doesn't look like suzaku made.any more moves

Mishma might go for suzaku being faster, but technically this feat shows erza to be faster and yes mishma might not see it that way
Bit suzaku statement made it clear that erza speed is near or around his own

Injury thing could be simply explained erza reacting at high speed. Erza blocked her sword broke, erza expression and then erza injury.

No aconologia literally said this would be interesting. Irene ability to enchant things make it difficult for aconologia to eat it.

Wendy can't block sh!t. When irene was serious wendy was already out.
All irene magic is ds magic. Yes that deus sema would hurt aconologia. Its ds magic

Igneel being able to kill zeref is wrong. Even aconologia cannot kill zeref. The thing you are talking about is power of the dead, which might kill zeref. Zeref didn't know that. It is a possibility that natsu using dead igneel power could do it. The main point being dead igneel

Irene can pull same things as suzaku. By enchanting ground and air around him. Making it impossible for aconologia to eat anything.

Are you comparing aconologia chatting ds to aconologia meeting his long lost love lol
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Those pictures don't show two strikes. You are trying to see which might not be there. All I can see that suzaku attacked, in that time erza went from being behind natsu and un armed to.being infront of natsu and trying to block
Since she used random sword, suzaku move broke her sword and injured her.
That is pretty much it. It doesn't look like suzaku made.any more moves

Mishma might go for suzaku being faster, but technically this feat shows erza to be faster and yes mishma might not see it that way
Bit suzaku statement made it clear that erza speed is near or around his own

Injury thing could be simply explained erza reacting at high speed. Erza blocked her sword broke, erza expression and then erza injury.

No aconologia literally said this would be interesting. Irene ability to enchant things make it difficult for aconologia to eat it.

Wendy can't block sh!t. When irene was serious wendy was already out.
All irene magic is ds magic. Yes that deus sema would hurt aconologia. Its ds magic

Igneel being able to kill zeref is wrong. Even aconologia cannot kill zeref. The thing you are talking about is power of the dead, which might kill zeref. Zeref didn't know that. It is a possibility that natsu using dead igneel power could do it. The main point being dead igneel

Irene can pull same things as suzaku. By enchanting ground and air around him. Making it impossible for aconologia to eat anything.

Are you comparing aconologia chatting ds to aconologia meeting his long lost love lol
Yes, it does. Erza is blocking in a fashion that wouldn't have blocked the slash to her abs. Satisfy my curiosity. Draw the path you think Suzaku's slash took in the image of Erza blocking. Maybe you can square the circle, and explain how a vertical cut aimed at the head/shoulders managed to make a horizontal wound on Erza's belly. Not only that, but we see the sword break before Erza's wounds open up. If Suzaku broke the sword and wounded Erza with the same cut, the wound and sword breaking would have been simultaneous. It's not like Erza's body knows that it must pause for dramatic effect to start bleeding.
Erza's not faster than Suzaku in the panels lol. You can't get 2 shotted by someone and still claim to be faster. At best, she barely reacted to his first attack. Factor in everything else, and he dusts Erza. He oneshotted Natsu before he could react.

Acnologia saying that this would be interesting does not in any way imply that Irene can damage him. This has already been debunked. Acnologia also said magic doesn't work on him, which as as statement about Acnologia's durability actually matters. He didn't even say fighting her would be interesting. He was saying that Irene's magical power was pretty impressive for someone taught by Zeref, and that was interesting. In the conversation that follows, he doubt that Zeref could beat him even with Fairy Heart.

Lots of people have the power of the dead. Doesn't make them all capable of killing Zeref. Come to think of it, Irene is dead and Wendy had her remaining power. Wendy ain't killing Zeref with the attack that defeated Nebaru. The attack still has to be powerful enough to defeat and deal lethal damage to Zeref. The fact is Igneel's corpse had enough to make Natsu stronger than Zeref, and anyone else in the Alvarez Empire. Including Irene. This was after he exhausted most of his power fighting Acnologia for 20 minutes. Of which, Igneel had to resort to mostly physical attacks because his flames got no-sold..

Wendy can block Irene's explosions. Irene never actually took Wendy out with her own attacks either. What happened was that Irene enchanted her personality onto Wendy. Then Wendy enchanted her own personality onto Irene, and in an act of desperation Irene clawed at herself to damage Wendy. None of this scales to anything that would even tickle Acno. None of this would even remotely tickle Aldoron or Merc tbh. No magical fireball that Wendy could block with her enchantments (and yes, Wendy can absolutely block Irene's fireballs) is going to hurt Acno when his immunity to magic lets him no-sell Igneel's roars.

Deus Sema isn't DS magic. It's a higher form of Jellal's magic, which is heavenly body magic. Quite frankly, it wouldn't do anything even if were DS magic because Acno is immune to DS magic too. Even if he wasn't, Irene said so herself that the meteor isn't as tough as her own dragon scales, so the rock itself isn't going to break Acnologia's vastly superior dragon scales. The explosion isn't to be hotter than Igneel's roar or have more MP. I don't see why Acno can't just jump up and break the damn thing either, unless we're wanking Erza's strength above Acno's. So yeah, even if we take away Acnologia's broken immunity to magic, one that makes him a bigger threat in combat than FH Zeref, he's still not getting damaged by Irene.

Every single magical attack that was used in the Erza + Wendy vs Irene fight, and also every single magical attack that was used in the Wendy vs Nebaru fight wouldn't even come close to scratching Acnologia's dragon form. Even against his human form, Irene does less damage to Acno than Mercphobia (who is bigger and stronger than Irene) did against Natsu with Ignia's flames (whom Acno is still stronger than). Speaking of which, Ignia's flames burned away Mercphobia's MP reserves for the foreseeable future. Acnologia would no sell them too. So how exactly does Irene top this?

Enchanting stuff doesn't stop Acnologia from eating. Acnologia eats magic and enchantments are magic. Eating is irrelevant anyways. Dragon slayers don't have to eat to be resistant to their elements. Eating is only for recovering MP and powerups. He's immune to magic regardless. If worse comes to worse, Acnologia can always cancel an incoming magic attack like Natsu did to melt. Only Acnologia is leagues above Irene, not tiers below August. Acnologia takes less damage from Irene's attacks than Lucy took from melt under Natsu's protection. And this is before factoring in his raw durability.
 
Last edited:
Top