Gildarts (consistently treated as the strongest person in the guild)
Laxus (while it's kind of hard to judge his strength based on his power-up from the Kirin fight, he was still shown to be extremely strong without it)
Erza (fought Laxus to a double-KO, though she had a tougher time with the fight; Jellal would go somewhere around Laxus or Erza in terms of strength if he ever winds up joining the guild )
Natsu (under normal circumstances, so not counting outside power-ups or rage boosts; between Madmole and the illusionary guild members at Gold Owl, the series seems to indicate that Natsu's normally weaker than Laxus, and by extension Erza (who's roughly on par with Laxus) and Gildarts (who's stronger than Laxus))
Mirajane (she doesn't get many opportunities to show off, but she's still considered powerful, with the likes of Gray and Lucy feeling like they stand no chance against her - it's unclear how she compares to Natsu, especially if she uses her Allegria or Seilah forms, but I'll put her at fifth for now)
Wendy (she defeated one of the Dark Dragon Slayer Knights, even if he seemed to not be going all-out because of his crush on her; her talent impressed Irene, of all people, and her enchantments give her a ton of versatility)
Gajeel (he was able to fight base/Lightning Flame mode Natsu to a draw, and despite Natsu's desire to fight Laxus, Jellal, and Mirajane, he couldn't keep Gajeel down)
Gray (effortlessly beat all of the Thunder God Tribe at once; he hasn't had a ton of time to shine lately, with his fights almost feeling like afterthoughts, but he's still presumably about as powerful as Gajeel)
Lucy (while her Star Dress Mix didn't damage Elfman when they fought in the 100 Years Quest, she seems much more versatile and intelligent than him, which could give her an advantage, though not enough to put her over the people above her in the list)
Elfman (torn between him and Juvia - Juvia's got a lot of options to work with, but her magic seems weirdly easy to negate and she doesn't seem super durable once her Water Body magic is negated, whereas Elfman can take a ton of damage. A problem is that a lot of Elfman's fights (against Ajeel, Skullion/Madmole, etc.) happen off-screen, while Juvia's barely got to have any fights after the Grimoire Heart arc, so it's hard to judge)"
What do you think of this tier list? Not mines BTW. Natsu being madmolle tier is crazy

didn't natsu cook madmolle