Discussion Garp Discussion Thread

[Strawhat_4491]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

Luffy's grandfather was a pirat, he was probably third strongest in the world behind whitebeard. When luffy heard his name he probably had a flash back of something he did that was bad.Luffy's grandpa is mysterious.

 

[white silver]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

Maybe he was abused "master/student" style, or his grandfather could have taught him and ace how to fight!

 

[Pevee]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

I believe with all my heart that Gold D. Roger is Luffy's grandpa

 

[white silver]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

I believe with all my heart that Gold D. Roger is Luffy's grandpa

Or maybe his Granduncle! Luffy already knew both Gol D. Roger and his Granfather, thus they're just 2 different people! Granduncle again is more possible since he could be the younger brother of Luffy's Grandfather, get it!

 

[G-ology]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

I believe with all my heart that Gold D. Roger is Luffy's grandpa

Gol D. Roger died (at least) 20 years ago..
and Luffy 17 years old.

"It's simple mathematics"

 

[Lohnt]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

What does being his grandfather have to do with his birth being after Gol D Rogers death?

 

[G-ology]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

What does being his grandfather have to do with his birth being after Gol D Rogers death?

Oh damn.. is misread

Sorry.. but hey, im german

 

[Lohnt]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

No problem, I figured you thought he meant father ^^

 

[ftabah]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

Well, I really think that Oda will not make Gol something like Luffy's granfather. I think he want us to believe that and then surpise us.

 

[Rui]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

My guess had to do with Saul being Luffy's grandfather, but it's apparent now that it is false because of Wei's comment.
Now I really don't know what's gonna happen. What I do know is that Ace is Luffy's brother. Yes, marvel at my genius.

There're going to include more D's. We don't know anything about the family line as of yet.

 

[hyper_megaman]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

how can saul be luffy's grandfather..

u have 2 generation down to get to luffy, knowing biology the chances are there for luffy to turn out tiny

but to get enough of this chance u gotta at least get these 2 gens to be us humans.. his son/daughter who proceeds to find another mate to produce luffy and ace..
how would sauro and his 'son' do 'his stuff' with, e.g., the girl who lives down the street.. it's totally impossible for sauro and not very possible for his son. The only way it would work out was if he had a daughter, BUT the sauro impossibility thing is there in the first place. And why would a female giant be interested in a human male, and vice versa.. not to mention luffy and ace would have been killed on the way out, knowing their muscle strengths..

aaand.. for all u know their males might have boobs on their groins too, totally different from humans.. humans and giants are different species.. just look alike when in clothing, that much is all we know actually, if u look at it technically..

 

[sao]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

let's go metal gear solid with this :P

How about luffy's grandfather is like the big boss and all that possess the D in their name are clones of him :P

 

[Jammer]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

well the moment Kureha mentioned that Roger's real name is Gol D. Roger (K-F subs) I started beleiving that he is Luffy's grandfather! and when Luffy faces Aokiji he mentions that Luffy's grandfather gave him a hard time -> well at that time Aokiji is Kuzan and is still a vice-admiral - someone that takes action in a Buster call -> Gol D Roger was captured/executed 22 years ago, so probably during a Buster call prior to Ohara the pirate king gave a hard time to his captors, so it figures...
also luffy getting nervous when Aokiji mentioned his grandfather - maybe he doesn't want his nakama to know about the relationship because he wants to accomplish all by himself - without using his grandfather's fame/name etc.
Another mystery is that Dragon guy - he might be something like a guardian of the D.s - or their father, but I don't think he is human ... (the D letter may stand for Destiny). also he says something rather interesting like: "the world is waiting for our answer" (ch.100)- is it the answer of the Ds or of some shrouded in darkness organization well I think that many answers will pop out after Luffy goes to the Pirate summit (that his brother was talking about)

 

[chubs191]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

But here's a wild theory about the D. So Nico Robin talks about the Poneglyphs and the search for the true history by connecting all of them you will find the true history. She also thinks that, it's the One Piece that Gol D. Roger found and left on the last island on the grand line. What if the "D."s that all these characters have are a symbol of the link between the Ponegylphs? Kind of like a true living history between these people that connects them together?

Also remember Robin talking about the fact that there was a country that wasn't in exitence or something like that that the marines deleted from history I think that the D. in the peoples names is a symbol of not only Poneglyphs but of relation to that country in question.

 

[Noex]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

Well they dont ahve the same last name but they all have the D letter in their name so they must be related in someway (man its a big family tree ^^) anyway if they are all related then the Ds are one big ass family also a bunch of troublemakers i mean Gol D. Roger a.ka the Pirate King, Portugas D. Ace commander of the 2nd withbeard crew, Blackbeard, and the giant who was once a goverment dog but turned on them and help Nico Robin escape and then we have the Miguwara captain so even if they are just related the Ds has a big role in the current pirate era sence its probally the biggest pirate family hehe but who is luffys grandpa some say Gol D Roger and some say the giant but i think that we haven´t seen him yet but probally will very soon.

 

[hyper_megaman]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

fullstop button spoilt?
... lol

 

[rennokun]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

how can saul be luffy's grandfather..

u have 2 generation down to get to luffy, knowing biology the chances are there for luffy to turn out tiny

now that luffy can use gear 3 its possible that saul its the dad LOL j/k

 

[alazim]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

i really think that gold D. roger is luffy grandfather..after all when SH's at Skypea the former god say to robin that luffy remain him to gold d. roger..second prove when smoke say luffy remain gold roger when he been executed..both of them smile b4 been execute..

luffy also don't who his grandfather but maybe ace know..because his expresion when aokiji say about his grandfather luffy expresion more like shock..

the note that ace give to luffy maybe have an information about their bloodline..

if i not mistaken Dr.kureha also have mentioned that chopper has follow a great man..because the spirit of D..

blackbeard maybe their relative..or if he and gold roger a brother..

 

[mrhazuki]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

Saul and Roger died at about the same time. For Roger, about 20 years ago and Saul about 21 years ago. Robin is 29 now and was 8 when they met.

 

[mugen]

Re: Luffy's Grandpa?

@ Manu that's Luffy blowing air into his bnes. That not transforming into a GIANT. Also Saul being his Grandfather is too akward. THus i still hope that
Gol D. is his grandfather. Saul is not worthy of being Luffy's grandfather . He must've been adopted