Gold D Roger vs Blackbeard

[Poneglyph420]

I mean seriously.... BB is bad ass and has shown to be one of the "new" deadly forces in the "Scene"...
But he's a new force not a legend like Rayleigh or Roger...
I mean if Rayleigh could handle Kizaru at this point imagine him a decade or 2 ago... Then imagine he's just the Vice Captain, Roger would of been even more amazing!

This is a non question and even if "anyone" responds with inflammatory comments...sorry your wrong, but just admit it.
No one compares to Roger, except maybe Luffy 500 Chapeters from now..

 

[keydude]

@ Blackhair: Why are you even encouraging him(her)? He/she clearly wanted to start shit when he/she made fun of us, so be the better man.

@ Dung D Manh: You sure know how to get people's backs up. And how to start a borderline-flaming match. Not exactly the best attitude to have on a fan forum..


[nami] Since the posts have gone haywire with all the above posts, those posts have been deleted. Please continue your discussion as per norms. [/nami]

 

[hdiuy]

Voted for Gold Roger. We may not have seen what Gold Roger's fighting abilities are but to be able to fight with some who can create quakes powerful enough to form tsunami etc, he sure ain't weak.

 

[Lord Rayleigh]

Marco and Jozu are pretty strong, they are able to deal with admirals and can both injure logia users. On the contrary, Ace fought Smoker and we were able to see that none of them can injure each other and Ace himself said this fight couldn't end up by a victory and a defeat. Then, Marco and also Jozu are very likely to be stronger than Ace.
Besides, Marco and Jozu have been seen to be more experienced than Ace : they are able to control their feelings and stay calm in some difficult moments like WB does (at the end of the last chapter for example), whereas Ace has been shown as a man that is still young and that can reveal easily what he feels. I think you can guess what it means when you see how calm are the stronger pirates unlike the weaker. Ace has shown that he can be calm sometimes (when he began to fight BB) but as soon as the things turn bad, he cannot anymore (at the end of his fight with BB).
That's why I say that Marco is stronger than Ace, and also is Jozu.

 

[Darkever]

Is there really need to answer? XD

 

[Kaiser Will]

Whoever did this thread need to look chapter 576 again, in two pages, this one and that.
If you look carefully you will see that when WB attacked BB, he peed in his pants, knowing that he could've been killed.

Taking that as a fact, and stating that in the present time WB was almost dead, and if he was in his prime BB wouldn't stand a chance, because if Roger=WB then BB=loser against Roger, with 100% of certainty.