Discussion How would this crew fair in the NW

[Pirate Queen]

How well would this Crew fair in the NW?
Their Crew positions?

 

[jaymizzo]

Luffy - Captain
Law - Doctor
Lucci - Lookout
Sabo - Intel
Smoker - Navigator
Hancock - Goddess
Buggy - Shipwright

Not sure who among them is a good cook.
Sabo/Hancock 1st mate - They would follow Luffy to death. The rest are given commander ranks. I really like WBs and BMs crew structure (not the penalties in the latter).

Edit: Think this crew would still be below the likes of WB (if he were alive) and Shanks (given they are meant to be quite powerful individuals rather than a handful with some capable fighters). I could see them being a little bit below BM and Kaido in terms of firepower but Kaido himself is a hurdle. BM as well is the same. these two are just stupidly hax.

They would easily be the 4th/5th most powerful crew and could possibly control quite a large part of the NW unchallenged as the only real threat would be the Individual Yonko actually getting involved.

Luffy is already growing towards actually challenging the Yonko, Sabo has fought equally with one - or at the very least skirmished with one, Law and Hancock have ridiculous hax of their own. Would be a legendary crew to say the least. Add in Zoro and Jinbei for coverage and youre set.

 

[Pirate Queen]

Luffy - Captain
Law - Doctor
Lucci - Lookout
Sabo - Intel
Smoker - Navigator
Hancock - Goddess
Buggy - Shipwright

Not sure who among them is a good cook.
Sabo/Hancock 1st mate - They would follow Luffy to death. The rest are given commander ranks. I really like WBs and BMs crew structure (not the penalties in the latter).

Hancock learns to cook for Luffy

But down side is she would ONLY cook for Luffy lol

 

[jaymizzo]

Hancock learns to cook for Luffy

But down side is she would ONLY cook for Luffy lol

I guess these guys better learn to actually pirate or it will end up being a 2 person crew
But Its a very well structured crew. I doubt there would be much in fighting like the Rocks. Not sure about the atmosphere on the ship though.

 

[ThatOtherGuy]

Sabo > Zoro
Law > Sanji
Hancock > Jinbe. May be debateable, not sure.
Smoker >> Franky
Lucci >> Robin

Though I'm struggling to find a Strawhat who is objectively weaker than Buggy.

Anyway, I think this crew would fair better than the SHs as far as combat and intelligence are concerned.

 

[kkck]

Well, it doesn't have a musician or a cook so they'd be foderized within seconds of entering the new world by nameless third rate henchmen.

 

[TitaniumOxide]

Lmao it ll looks very good..until you see Buggy. He can be their entertainer but he's also a joke. I can see him pulling a Usopp at all times and then get his ass handed to him without Usopp results.

 

[afromarco005]

Luffy pirate captain
Boa Vice captain/fighter
Lucci carpenter
Buggy musician/performer
Sabo Tactitian/Historian
I want to see Smoker chan with an apron in the kitchen

 

[M3J]

Lose in WCI had they been there to take on Big Mom

 

[Pirate Queen]

Lose in WCI had they been there to take on Big Mom

Hancock solo's

 

[M3J]

Katakuri seems sexual only for food while Big Mom doesn't come across as someone interested in women, so Hancock would lose.

I wonder how Law would fare against Katakuri

 

[TitaniumOxide]

I just realized this fantasy crew is just too smart actually. And that is already me factoring in Luffy's bakaness. Everyone else there has a hella brain. Even Buggy! Hahahahaha they may only lack the man power required to do certain tasks. 7 might be a lucky number but damn having only 7 people in the crew and none are chefs... that sucks. And no music. I personally love great food. And I love music. And I know you guys do too and so do people in the OPverse. Therefore 2 more people is needed. If the rest can make up for Luffy's lack of brains then they can make up for the lack of brawn if these 2 other members are weak. Idc who it is lol. They need a chef and musician. I guess sexistly speaking Hancock can work in the kitchen and do some burlesque shows if she is up for that... damn 2 stones, one bird and no need to recruit more people. But honestly...she is too badass to be everyone's cook. But I bet you she can dance. And we already know how well she can handle a snake...

Seperately, Lucci can make his bird talk and do some entertainment there but who the hell wants to look at his fucking beard when we have Boa's black hole of a cleavage in our face? Ah shit forgot about Buggy. Well guess we only need a Chef then lol.

Katakuri seems sexual only for food while Big Mom doesn't come across as someone interested in women, so Hancock would lose.

I wonder how Law would fare against Katakuri

Lol some rand youtube reviewer can probably walk you thru a hypothetical battle to explain that. I honestly cannot see Law winning unless he can unleash multiple radio knives on Katakuri the same way he did to Doflamingo but again, multiple if not dozens of hits. Seeing how unlikely he can achieve this currently, I personally just see him using his room abilitities to escape as best he can.

If Oda illustrates this I'm sure it can still be an epic as fuck battle because Goda is able to make shit work because he is Goda.

 

[Pirate Queen]

Luffy - Captain
Law - Doctor
Lucci - Lookout
Sabo - Intel
Smoker - Navigator
Hancock - Goddess
Buggy - Shipwright

Not sure who among them is a good cook.
Sabo/Hancock 1st mate - They would follow Luffy to death. The rest are given commander ranks. I really like WBs and BMs crew structure (not the penalties in the latter).

Edit: Think this crew would still be below the likes of WB (if he were alive) and Shanks (given they are meant to be quite powerful individuals rather than a handful with some capable fighters). I could see them being a little bit below BM and Kaido in terms of firepower but Kaido himself is a hurdle. BM as well is the same. these two are just stupidly hax.

They would easily be the 4th/5th most powerful crew and could possibly control quite a large part of the NW unchallenged as the only real threat would be the Individual Yonko actually getting involved.

Luffy is already growing towards actually challenging the Yonko, Sabo has fought equally with one - or at the very least skirmished with one, Law and Hancock have ridiculous hax of their own. Would be a legendary crew to say the least. Add in Zoro and Jinbei for coverage and youre set.

Just realized, why make Buggy the Shipwright when Lucci is an ACTUAL shipwright

Lol

 

[Pirate Queen]

And just FYI, nothing definitively puts Hancock below a Yonko lol

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 8, 2019, Original Post Date: Nov 8, 2019 ---

I just realized this fantasy crew is just too smart actually. And that is already me factoring in Luffy's bakaness. Everyone else there has a hella brain. Even Buggy! Hahahahaha they may only lack the man power required to do certain tasks. 7 might be a lucky number but damn having only 7 people in the crew and none are chefs... that sucks. And no music. I personally love great food. And I love music. And I know you guys do too and so do people in the OPverse. Therefore 2 more people is needed. If the rest can make up for Luffy's lack of brains then they can make up for the lack of brawn if these 2 other members are weak. Idc who it is lol. They need a chef and musician. I guess sexistly speaking Hancock can work in the kitchen and do some burlesque shows if she is up for that... damn 2 stones, one bird and no need to recruit more people. But honestly...she is too badass to be everyone's cook. But I bet you she can dance. And we already know how well she can handle a snake...

Seperately, Lucci can make his bird talk and do some entertainment there but who the hell wants to look at his fucking beard when we have Boa's black hole of a cleavage in our face? Ah shit forgot about Buggy. Well guess we only need a Chef then lol.



Lol some rand youtube reviewer can probably walk you thru a hypothetical battle to explain that. I honestly cannot see Law winning unless he can unleash multiple radio knives on Katakuri the same way he did to Doflamingo but again, multiple if not dozens of hits. Seeing how unlikely he can achieve this currently, I personally just see him using his room abilitities to escape as best he can.

If Oda illustrates this I'm sure it can still be an epic as fuck battle because Goda is able to make shit work because he is Goda.

Hancock is a chef

 

[jaymizzo]

Just realized, why make Buggy the Shipwright when Lucci is an ACTUAL shipwright

Lol

Translation: Go home jaymizzo, you are drunk.