Fantasy Ishgar Mages Power Rate - [FINISHED]

[Brandish μ]

Idk what the fuss is about Ichiya not being down yet @Takuan. The way I see it Hiro used U1 to get him away from the Spriggans. And now that he reversed it, he's kept Ichiya away

All characters down so far I can't really comment on the order. They all deserve 1's or 2's really, but I was generous and put the weaker characters 1-4. Lucy/Wendy level is a 5, Natsu a 10; is how I tried to separate it.

 

[Axiomus]

That's the main problem though, how can you be certain that Sting and Rogue are now stronger than Rufus or Orga? There is nothing to back this up since Rufus and Orga have no feats at all and never appeared. For all we know they might still be around the same level.
I'm not saying that Rufus and Orga should be ranked equal to Sting and Rogue, because we can not do that. We don't know what they are currently worth. But that also works the other way around, we cant claim that they are worse now.

I am judging them by their most impressive performance in the entire series. As it stands WSD Sting (defeating Larcade) has the most impressive performance, followed by Minerva and Rogue (defeating a Spriggan Historia). I am fairly confident that Sting and Rogue surpassed Minerva by the Tartarus arc, and Minerva was the strongest in Sabertooth. Neither Rufus nor Orga has really shown the same growth. Their lack of feats really just tells me Hiro doesn't see them as that important to the story. Let's be honest, we're probably not going to see Rufus or Orga fight any Spriggan level characters at this point in the story. On the other hand, Sting and Rogue may yet still play a role against Acnologia.

 

[Kouichi]

Are you missing someone? For number 19.

I think he missed Lyon.

Either way. Where do you place Elfman if he is in there? Since they "beat" Ajeel though.

 

[Axiomus]

On my list, Meredy has gots to go.

Gildarts/Laxus/Natsu
Erza/Gray/Gajeel/Jellal/Sting
Sheria/Mirajane/Kagura
Hyperion/Wolfheim/Warrod/Jura/Rogue/Minerva
Freed/Lucy/Ichiya
Midnight/Cobra/Racer/Angel/Lyon/Rufus/Juvia
Bacchus/Yukino/Meredy
Milliana/Ren/Eve
Rocker/Toby
Hibiki

 

[Demon Hunter]

Jiemma is not the strongest demon lol.

its pretty damn obvious LMFAO.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

On my list, Meredy has gots to go.

Gildarts/Laxus/Natsu
Erza/Gray/Gajeel/Jellal/Sting
Sheria/Mirajane/Kagura
Hyperion/Wolfheim/Warrod/Jura/Rogue/Minerva
Freed/Lucy/Ichiya
Midnight/Cobra/Racer/Angel/Lyon/Rufus/Juvia
Bacchus/Yukino/Meredy
Milliana/Ren/Eve
Rocker/Toby
Hibiki

I think Meredy should go next too!!! Especially since Juvia was already voted out..... And their characters are similar tier.

But where is Wendy on your list?

 

[Axiomus]

Jiemma is not the strongest demon lol.

its pretty damn obvious LMFAO.

Mard Geer considered Jeimma above the 9 Demon Gates. At the very least, that would mean he's stronger than Minerva (not a 9 demon gate after transformation). Meaning Jiemma is stronger than anyone else in Sabertooth.

--- Double Post Merged, Feb 19, 2017, Original Post Date: Feb 19, 2017 ---

I think Meredy should go next too!!! Especially since Juvia was already voted out..... And their characters are similar tier.

But where is Wendy on your list?

I missed her. I would put Wendy in the same line as Lucy, though her recent performance against Irene may bump her to Rogue/Minerva's level.

 

[Demon Hunter]

Mard Geer considered Jeimma above the 9 Demon Gates. At the very least, that would mean he's stronger than Minerva (not a 9 demon gate after transformation). Meaning Jiemma is stronger than anyone else in Sabertooth.

that would mean Sting and Rogue > Erza > LFDM Natsu > Minerva.

don't really buy that.

just another lie said by Mard Geer.

nothing more.

 

[Axiomus]

that would mean Sting and Rogue > Erza > LFDM Natsu > Minerva.

don't really buy that.

just another lie said by Mard Geer.

nothing more.

Either way, Jiemma would be stronger than Minerva. And honestly, I do consider Jiemma to be a stronger fighter than the 9 Demon Gates when it comes to direct combat. It's just that Kyouka had the ability to steal Erzas's senses. It still didn't prevent Erza from beating her while she was blind and deaf though.

 

[**Silver**]

that would mean Sting and Rogue > Erza > LFDM Natsu > Minerva.

don't really buy that.

just another lie said by Mard Geer.

nothing more.

Either way, Jiemma would be stronger than Minerva.

this is my personal opinion but Silver is the strongest Demon Gate member. his Aoe Range is enormous Freezing Sun Village in seconds and was nerfed against Gray...

oh Forgot Silver one-shotted Natsu

 

[Axiomus]

this is my personal opinion but Silver is the strongest Demon Gate member. his Aoe Range is enormous Freezing Sun Village in seconds and was nerfed against Gray...

oh Forgot Silver one-shotted Natsu

I rank Silver on the same level as Kyouka, though he might be slightly stronger. He had impressive AoE when he froze Atlas Flame's ghost, but we have no idea just how much of his power he had to use to achieve it. His attacks against Gray is more indicative of his performance in actual combat, and also Gray's performance against Mard Geer once he received Silver's magical power (though this may be somewhat skewed due to slayer advantage). Silver probably had stronger attacks than Kyouka, but Kyouka also has more impressive durability. She was able to tank Erza spearing her through the cube and slashes from Armadura Fairy, whereas Silver had a hole blasted through him by a steel ball.

 

[Axiomus]

Why did the discussion went on about Jiemma and the demon gates when Jiemma is not even part of the Ishgar mages ranking ?

I guess it's relevant to Sting and Rogue's power level relative to Rufus'. I suppose we should get back on topic, and with that I'll reaffirm my position that Meredy should be the next that should be eliminated.

 

[The President]

Ma boi Bacchus is mad underrated. This dude was a problem for Erza Pre-1TS and only lost to Elfman who has shown that he is a spriggan level manz, not to mention, Bacchus was at quite the disadvantage. Ichiya in hulk mode is one of the strongest characters in FT so getting one-shotted by him isn't that bad.

 

[BluePegasus]

Because I'm busy (ok and lazy too) we'll get a guest reveal tonight by our one and only @PluePegasus. Yaaaaaaaas.

 

[PluePegasus]

@BluePegasus OH YOUUU I SWEAR
The Yannick God judges you

Anyways onto the elimination! Drum roll pls...










#25​

Freed Justine
Score: 5,375

Highest Score: 7,5 x 1 (@natsulucy)
Lowest Score: 2,5 x 1 (@Dranzer)
My score: 7/10

Ok why did you guys do this, Freed can kill anyone by writing "Death" on their chest.
N00bz

Overview
Magic: Dark Écriture, Jutsu Shiki
Affiliation: Fairy Tail​

 

[Zelefomavis]

Why..... why is Ichya not eliminated yet ? The guy is just a troll.... if he passes the top 20 I'll be so mad at ichiya s fans...
Freed >Ichiya...

 

[Hermit]

Shouldn't Ichiya or Bickslow be going next? I have him and Freed at the same level, mostly because Freed and Bickslow's performance against Rustyrose on Tenrou was almost similar, and Freed and Ichiya both combined forces to take out Wahl's proxy body in Kardia Cathedral at the beginning of the arc.
Freed in his Dark Ericture mode=Ichiya in his Power Parfum Mode.

 

[Takuan]

I don't even think i'm going to bother following the rest of the rankings if Ichiya doesnt come out VERY soon.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

Shouldn't Ichiya or Bickslow be going next? I have him and Freed at the same level, mostly because Freed and Bickslow's performance against Rustyrose on Tenrou was almost similar, and Freed and Ichiya both combined forces to take out Wahl's proxy body in Kardia Cathedral at the beginning of the arc.
Freed in his Dark Ericture mode=Ichiya in his Power Parfum Mode.

Is Bixslow in this running? I thought him, Elfman, Evergreen, and Cana were all sent up the sent up the creek without a paddle?

And don't you know..... Ichiya's rank has to be higher than Jellal and below Erza so his perfume can separate the two.

 

[Star Frost]

Shouldn't Ichiya or Bickslow be going next? I have him and Freed at the same level, mostly because Freed and Bickslow's performance against Rustyrose on Tenrou was almost similar, and Freed and Ichiya both combined forces to take out Wahl's proxy body in Kardia Cathedral at the beginning of the arc.
Freed in his Dark Ericture mode=Ichiya in his Power Parfum Mode.

I don't think Bickslow was even a candidate. What I'm wondering is how Freed was eliminated before Meredy? She was the weakest of the 7 Purgatory Kin. And Ichiya should be eliminated by now