nah i think zoro would win.
its cus zoro got shuusui=more power
luffy used gears all fight! zoro was base most fight so his douriki base must be 2200 to be fighting equally with kaku, that speaks volumes about asura
all zoro has to do is spam dat all the time like luffy. also since there arent any drawbacks he can do that the whole fight!
also zoro is a beast when it comes to endurance so i say luffy+df=zoro normal cus of the blunt resistance luffy has and the endurance zoro has
shigan v zoro is a swordfight basically. zoro has fought swordsmen his whole life, he wont lose to lucci there.
yh the speed thing would f*** him up i hav to agree but all zoro has to do is just spin in asura. like even lucci can hit a spinning tornado of blades without getting cut up in the process. he also cant use tekkai and move so definitely not lol
and the rankyaku aspect also has no relevance, ever heard of 108 pound cannon? also try zoro doing dat in asura, dahs like 324 pound cannon. luccis gaichou cannot compare
zoro also has power of destruction and can cut steel, what can tekkai do to him. and if he can cut steel with 1 sword then ichibugin would be enough to hurt lucci
the only major disadvantage i can see is that he doesnt fight opponents who punch. but really i doesnt matter as slashes do more damage in the long run and in fights than punches really. so add dat to his insane endurance and u got zoro matching in asura.
his base is no match but his current asura would win. i mean he can cut a pacifista. thats a true achievement.
also guys, its a manga luffy is stronger than zoro in ONLY POWER! hes the main character to be expected. zoro however is only a little bit behind. you cant blame him but i think its an achievement to be able to be onlt a little bit behind when the former uses fists while he uses blades. in speed luffy outclasses him that why he can keep up with lucci and not worry about the disadvantages shigan and rankakyu can do to him. zoro outclasses luffy to about the same extent together in skill, deadly attacks and endurance. (only straw hat to stand; oz, a bit of moria, ryuuma, kuma with ursus shock too, luffys pain and still stand up! luffy didnt take much from moria or oz and collapsed afterwards) zoro is also superior to luffy due to his combined smartness and trancescion. <-------sounds wierd but he did transcend himself in 1 match lol,once again with luffy only coming a bit behind. if you take all this into account as fighters they are the same but luffy will b better cus hes captain and main character, only they are both better at different aspects.
luffy

not actual figures just comparison out of 100)
power: 100
speed:100
intelligence:75
deadly attacks:65
endurance:75(only due to df)
skill:50
transcension:60= 525
zoro

not actual figures just comparison out of 100)
power: 84
speed:40
intelligence:83
deadly attacks:80
endurance:93
skill:75(not mihawk)
transcension:70 (got a long way to go)=525 exactly the same
as for the roukougan thing its just the same as when kuma pushed a bit of luffys pain into zoros insides, alot of damge but he still got up and took the whole thing and STILL stood. this shows that even that formidable technique wont beat our first mate.
cus of this now TB zoro will beat lucci in a close,epic battle with an on and off victor. the biggest disadvantage is fighting styles but apart from that im all zoro
