Fantasy Lucy vs Elfman

[Garmadooon]

Meh Elfman's performance against Madmolle isn't as impressive as people say. He hadn't even managed to damage it on screen and even his scratches aren't that strong. I don't see why people were comparing him to FDK Natsu when Base Natsu didn't even lose to Madmole (he was motion sick) and one shot him when he got serious.
Elfman might have a big defense but doesn't have the offense to knock out Lucy and she has much stronger spells than Lion Maiden. Based on her fight against Kyria, Lucy should take it extreme diff.

 

[kian]

Meh Elfman's performance against Madmolle isn't as impressive as people say. He hadn't even managed to damage it on screen and even his scratches aren't that strong. I don't see why people were comparing him to FDK Natsu when Base Natsu didn't even lose to Madmole (he was motion sick) and one shot him when he got serious.
Elfman might have a big defense but doesn't have the offense to knock out Lucy and she has much stronger spells than Lion Maiden. Based on her fight against Kyria, Lucy should take it extreme diff.

you do not need much offence to knock out lucy at all lol

 

[Aniokku]

Elfman isn't even Kyria level, Kyria would humiliate Elfman in every possible way

so Lucy one shot, I don't see how Elfman could hold Gottfried, I don't see how he can hold a long-term fight with the water clones either, Lucy is much more versatile and faster than Elfman and has good stamina. Lucy low diff

 

[Kouichi]

Changing my vote to Lucy.

 

[LuckSlayer]

This is not even for debate. Lucy will always win against Elfman, I mean, she's too versatile against him just being a defense powerhouse. Remember that Lucy defeated Mimi? Well, that's enough! UM and bye bye Elfman...

 

[Darklord#10]

Bump

 

[Mimi0207]

Lucy washes him with Gottfried.

She could explose Kyria while Elfman couldn’t do jackshit to Madmole.

 

[Darklord#10]

If we go by what we read in the manga Lucy wins imo, but if we go by mashima-sensei logic elf stomps Lucy excluding current power up

 

[Ronin31]

Lucy has surpassed Elfman's like in Elentir and continued to grow. Mimi was Elfmans' female like.

With current powers up, it's not even a fight, it's a curbstomp.