Theory Luffy is Roger Reincarnated

GodOfDestruction · Apr 8, 2016

Just read up on about everything Gold Roger. Him and Luffy have so much in common. First Luffy and Roger made allies nearly everywhere they went: Skypiega, Water 7, Lougetown(Yes i know Roger was born there), etc.

The straw hat.

Just like all other D, they smile at death.

People also tend to see Luffy and Roger alike.

Also every person around Luffy will be just like a person towards Roger.

Coby- Garp
Buggy- Golden Lion Shiki
Zoro- Rayleigh
Nami or Hancock(Whoever you ship)- Rogue
???- Whitebeard

Discuss in the comments.

I Am Atomic · Apr 9, 2016

GodOfDestruction said:
Just read up on about everything Gold Roger. Him and Luffy have so much in common. First Luffy and Roger made allies nearly everywhere they went: Skypiega, Water 7, Lougetown(Yes i know Roger was born there), etc.

The straw hat.

Just like all other D, they smile at death.

People also tend to see Luffy and Roger alike.

Also every person around Luffy will be just like a person towards Roger.

Coby- Garp
Buggy- Golden Lion Shiki
Zoro- Rayleigh
Nami or Hancock(Whoever you ship)- Rogue
???- Whitebeard

Discuss in the comments.

I do not agree! Roger's and Luffy's personality is completely different. Roger is a cruel pirate where he would kill anyone for example: Squardo's parents.

Shanks had the strawhat as well.

You said just like other D they smile at death. So it's not even a similarity between just those two but every other D as well except Blackbeard.

Luffy is an idiot but Roger is not!

Xguard · Apr 9, 2016

Then Ace should refer Luffy as Dad lol.

Fox666 · Apr 9, 2016

Barrier said:
Roger is a cruel pirate where he would kill anyone for example: Squardo's parents.

Huh? Roger and Squard respective crews once fought, and the later one was eliminated. But does that makes Roger evil? Zoro killed several people through the manga (i.e. the bounty hunters and Whiskey Peak), and Robin breaks spines all the time.

I Am Atomic · Apr 9, 2016

Fox666 said:
Huh? Roger and Squard respective crews once fought, and the later one was eliminated. But does that makes Roger evil? Zoro killed several people through the manga (i.e. the bounty hunters and Whiskey Peak), and Robin breaks spines all the time.

Roger was also a man who loved big, flashy things and reveled in his title of Pirate King despite his oncoming death. While not portrayed during any of his appearances, he can be a merciless enemy when he got angry. This was further evidenced when he killed all of Squardo's crewmembers personally for unknown reasons.

Roger was very quick to anger, and he would retaliate for something as simple as an insult to his crew, regardless of how small it might be. Garp stated that an angry Roger could be a violent, selfish, and short-tempered man, but his actions had been pure and straight, just like a child's, and that he was lucky to survive and become the Pirate King despite his extremely reckless nature.

Sorry. Maybe evil is not the right word.