Actually Leo received 1 penalty vote because he didn't vote in the previous day phase. I guess it can't be applied on night phases, though. If the X person receive a penalty vote for his inactivity on previous night, it'll reveal his role.
it can be applied to anyone with a night action who isn't mafia. (all mafia receive a penalty if no pm is sent)
Bodyguard dies if he protect someone... doctor is way more powerful
even so. still felt hard to keep afloat.
What about a person trying to lie about his role just to troll?
There was potential for 5.
The first would confirm the person has a night role, the second would give away the whole mafia, wtf. This whole idea about mandatory night actions is not working, just drop it.
But if you'd died in night 2, it would lead us to believe in Banana and when he claimed the whore role, probably i would get lynched and not him ):
I don't get it...I was ready to say stuff here as well ... bad stuff.
Wow, that's such a fair assessment.Not so much via PMs though, when he rants and crys like a girl and threatens to ragequit.
Never mind that by doing that you influenced the game from the host position, which is a big no-no. It doesn't really matter what the intention is, it's not like we had some obvious precedent that isn't stated in the rules. The Traitor is a green role, and it says nothing about how it can and should win, only that it's only Mafia if it gets recruited. It's ambiguous, prior to that.
Top 5 posters in the gameDon't worry, I give him the M2J award.
I felt like Hardy didn't overly post the last two days, but before that he could have combined some posts and perhaps not posted 24/7. I was pretty annoyed having gone to sleep Day 2, coming back to hundreds of posts, a huge portion being made by just Hardy and xi0.
Sleeper should be green, Traitor should be red. All you need is the clarification that he shows up as a Townie and can only communicate with the Mafia until, and only if he is recruited. It's too confusing as it is now. There's no point in putting a role as a green/townie role, if he can't win unless Mafia wins.Then why he green
...I don't know
That's the only way I can't see the Traitor being red (if he can actually be recruited by the town... something that I don't think is possible). I guess Evil will clarify this later.
And I only needed 1/5 of the total posts
It needs clarification either way, I'm not sure what the best choice is. But IMO, the Traitor should be Mafia in every way, except he appears innocent like the Boss, and can't communicate with them at night until recruited.
