Re: Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread v.5 - SIGN UP for Game 23!
Mafia never won when I hosted.
That's because Evil gives the Mafia more advantages than you do, digital, and I actually like the mafia having a greater chance of winning.
In game 17, there were four mafia and a seral killer for a total of 17 players.
In game 20, there were two three person mafia, three sleepers, and a death miller for a total of 23 players.
In game 21, your game, there were four mafia, a mentor, and a sleeper (he was hostkilled though) for a total of 22 players.
_______________
As you can see in the difference between games 17 and 21, with five less players in game 17, there were five anti-town forces in both games. The sleeper's not necessarily anti-town as he can be recruited by the masons.
Digital, you give the Town too many advantages. Apart from the Freeman, the Townies had no bad roles and even had a Vigilante. They weren't saddled with a Hider or any Naive roles.