One Piece Mega Convo Thread, the 1st Chapter

[Xarcer]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

if ruffy/luffy could beat him in his early stage then millhawk wouldnt even think about him, he's no threat and is nothing millhawk would bother about

 

[ANBU4U]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

if ruffy/luffy could beat him in his early stage then millhawk wouldnt even think about him, he's no threat and is nothing millhawk would bother about

Well obviously, but that doesnt mean he wouldnt note his presence.

And never refrence the 4kids dub. ever. lol

 

[bakashijinsan]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Has anyone noticed how in Chapter 434, Whitebeard mentions that's it's been 22 years since the time of Gol D. Roger (since he's been killed)? Since we also know that Roger was killed 22 years before the very beginning of the story, does that mean that all of Luffy's adventures have taken less than a year? Less than six months maybe (otherwise Whitebeard probably would've rounded up or something)? Any thoughts?

Oh, and I'm pretty sure someone's asked this before, but I'd just like to see what everyone thinks.

There was a theory that was presented by readers in APforums on how long has it been since Luffy and the gang journeyed to Grand Line. What I've read was the Moon Theory. There was another one which I haven't read yet. You can go to Arlong Park Forums to see.

From what it says, the entire journey from Ussop's village up to this point is just roughly 40 days
It's an interseting theory with some convincing evidence.

 

[ANBU4U]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

There was a theory that was presented by readers in APforums on how long has it been since Luffy and the gang journeyed to Grand Line. What I've read was the Moon Theory. There was another one which I haven't read yet. You can go to Arlong Park Forums to see.

From what it says, the entire journey from Ussop's village up to this point is just roughly 40 days
It's an interseting theory with some convincing evidence.

40 days?!?! I knew it was less than a year...but 40 days seems ridiculous for the amount of stuff thats taken place...wow.

What a month right?

 

[Kikuna992]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

They say 40 days but how can Kobi and Helmeppo become mature in such a short time? Sure they may have had a growth spurt but does it only take 40 days to learn soru. I think Lucci said rokushiki can only be acheived after years of training. 40 days can't be right???

 

[ANBU4U]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

They say 40 days but how can Kobi and Helmeppo become mature in such a short time? Sure they may have had a growth spurt but does it only take 40 days to learn soru. I think Lucci said rokushiki can only be acheived after years of training. 40 days can't be right???

That is shady, but soru is arguably the easiest technique to pick up....the most telling part is as you said, their growth. NO ONE grows like those two did in 40 days! Especially not Coby...I mean come on! Even Oda wouldnt do that.

 

[ahfei]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

The only thing we can do now is to count day by day from the manga, considering day and night. Any math geek here?

 

[zelllogan]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

a french site have done that. It's approximatively 70 days in total

http://www.volonte-d.com/details/temps.php

 

[Kikuna992]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Omg it all works out. 70 days? That still sounds short but the French sight was convincing. I'm going to have to conclude that time in the one piece world is not time as we know it in our world. Very few mangas have had strict time enforced. The writer of another manga Kochikame said, in one of his chapters, that in the manga world, time morphs at the will of the writer and should not be taken seriously.

I was just wondering I think I remember Buggy looking for the lost treasure of Captain John on an Island with a Skull shaped rock formation... Could this Captain John be the same person as the zombie Captain John, the one who is constantly drinking??? Give me your thoughts on it...

 

[ANBU4U]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Omg it all works out. 70 days? That still sounds short but the French sight was convincing. I'm going to have to conclude that time in the one piece world is not time as we know it in our world. Very few mangas have had strict time enforced. The writer of another manga Kochikame said, in one of his chapters, that in the manga world, time morphs at the will of the writer and should not be taken seriously.

I was just wondering I think I remember Buggy looking for the lost treasure of Captain John on an Island with a Skull shaped rock formation... Could this Captain John be the same person as the zombie Captain John, the one who is constantly drinking??? Give me your thoughts on it...

That was brought up some time ago. Given Oda's knack for forshadowing it seems likely.

 

[Absolutio]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

you cant really count it just by the manga, coz there are fillers that take time too. and 70 days sounds way too short! it's because all the time on the ship, when they're just traveling from one island to another, is not being shown (coz nothing happens.. )

 

[HikaruYami]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

You CANNOT count fillers in the time of an anime. Fillers do not exist. I promise, anyone who thinks a single second passes in a filler is an idiot. Only the manga holds any power in the timeline of a series like this, where the anime chooses to follow so closely the storyline of the manga.

And I still say that drinking-all-the-time zombie is related to Doctorine somehow... it's too obvious... but I guess it's possible he hid a treasure on that island.

Oh, and for any other people who suggest that you have to factor in sea travel, I'm 95% positive that Oda has already said that it takes no more than a day of travel to get from one island to another. (maybe not even a day for some? I can't remember) Sheesh, find out these things before posting previously disproven theories >> 70 days sounds right, and their "plus or minus 2" makes it sound more realistic, because there's still a chance that they miscalculated a TINY bit. Don't forget, just because One Piece has been going on for almost 10 years doesn't mean it needs anywhere near that much time in-storyline. If just take the number of chapters and average how many chapters it takes for a day to pass (especially in major action arcs, like Skypeia and Enies' Lobby), you shouldn't come out with any more than 100 anyway, and that's because it's a very rough estimation (that's about how much I thought it was, but I choose now to believe that French site absolutely)

Moderator Notice:
Next time, express your opinion more kindly.~ Luckas

 

[HASJ]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

70 days?! It can't be, I think it's been at least 2years... Common... Would the WG let Lufy and his crew go from 30millions to 600millions berrys in only 70days? I think they would go like crazy to take them down...
Plus there's the Cobby and Meppo growth...

I know that the Ennies Lobby take 1 day to get concluded, even though it was almost 2years here (IRL)... But not so sure that the Alabasta saga would get concluded in less than 50 days...

 

[Schabrak]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

It can't be less than 2 years.-_- I think thay said something like this in the last episodes with Luffy's grandpa.
And remember: they do not sail with an engine, so they could have sailed for many weeks till they come to another isle.

 

[Krisel]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Making a chronology of Luffy's journey isnt necessary for us cuz evry One Piece mystery or unexplained thing is made by Oda to make it more interesting and giving us space for imagination.Oda is very clever,so if he hasnt explained smth then ppl can debate and imagine [brain workout ] what really happend.
The world of One Piece is fantasy,it isnt reality.Enel has landed on Moon and has no problem in breathing O2,the Spacey's went on Moon using ballon's,none die's even they are beaten up pretty badly etc.Why the Strawhat's can't have sailed for 70 days?Evrything its possible there.Even cuz for 70 days Luffy's crew had a bounty over 600 mil(including Luffy),they are the future Pirate King's crew damnit!

 

[JC123]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Er, Coby grew up a LOT in 70 days if that's the case...

And people do die just not main characters.

 

[Kamikage]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

My brother have seen a interview about one piece on youtube, and they asked about the timeline there, and I think my brother told me they said that it's been seven months from series start to were they are now. It's still less than I thought it would be, but lots more than 70 days.

 

[theshizzle]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

This has been said probably a million times but i just started to get into OP, but why is Luffy like Mr. Fantastic but much cooler than MF??

 

[Kamikage]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Because MF thinks alot and Luffy goes on instinct... MF likes science, Luffy likes meat. MF rather talk than fight, and Luffy rather fight than talk... the list goes on

 

[Splat]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Luffy isn't at all like MF. MF has the ability to stretch, Luffy is a rubber man, the difference is that if you stretch rubber, it pings back to it's original size, hence why his punches are so powerful, because he has his own strength, plus the extra speed gained from his rubber retracting. Also, MF can stretch himself out and stay that way, because he isn't rubber and there is no tension trying to ping him back to his original state, which is why Luffy can't remain stretched out. Although thinking about this, it may be possible that by becoming really strong, Luffy could use his strength to stop his rubber retracting, and therefore be able to stretch like MF, but this would be a pretty useless skill, since he would just be really lanky, and less strong, since he's using all his strength to remain stretched.