Opinions About Luffy's Mother

[kyubisharingan]

Luffy's mom is a sexy b*tch, thats y Monkey D Dragon married her...or made love with her

 

[The Boff]

Maybe it true. Luffy's mother maybe that bar tender from chapter 1.

that was my first guess too actually because it felt logical, but now after the revelations from Garp i dont think thats the case anymore. Im guessing that Luffy and Ace were village children. technically they lived with their grandpa but as i see it he was away all the time doing marine stuff. so they were raised by all the people in the village. one more reason to why i think this is Luffys response to the revelation of Dragon being his father: "I had a dad?" it means Luffy never met Dragon. so its not totally unlikely that he never met his mom either.

but what then of Luffys mother? again this is just a guess but, Dragon should have a reason for being the revolutionary man that he is. WHAT IF his wife were somehow murdered by the government? we know that they are friggin bastards, look at ohara. so she could have been killed in some way and Dragon became REALLY pissed because of it. just a theory, i have no real proof but thats what my gut instincts tell me

 

[jairdan6]

or maybe his wife completely controls him and he just happens to be really strong, but he's a whipped man and it's his wife that wants to overthrow the world government.

 

[weixiaobao]

that was my first guess too actually because it felt logical, but now after the revelations from Garp i dont think thats the case anymore. Im guessing that Luffy and Ace were village children. technically they lived with their grandpa but as i see it he was away all the time doing marine stuff. so they were raised by all the people in the village. one more reason to why i think this is Luffys response to the revelation of Dragon being his father: "I had a dad?" it means Luffy never met Dragon. so its not totally unlikely that he never met his mom either.

but what then of Luffys mother? again this is just a guess but, Dragon should have a reason for being the revolutionary man that he is. WHAT IF his wife were somehow murdered by the government? we know that they are friggin bastards, look at ohara. so she could have been killed in some way and Dragon became REALLY pissed because of it. just a theory, i have no real proof but thats what my gut instincts tell me

This sound very educated. but I don't think Dragon is that simple of a man, revolt the gov just for the sake of his wife. But that another possibility, Luffy's mother already died "(

 

[jeffhmwong]

Awww....thats so sad...if she'd died.....

I rather her to be another pirate captain (like avilda) and when the meet they can have a 4 way battle

Ace Vs Dragon Vs Luffys Mom Vs Luffy.

 

[bax]

I like your idea Boff. But like movingstone said, Dragon needs more reasons to revolt against the government than what you're saying. Then again, there's no right and wrong here, so you maybe correct on that.

 

[sushi]

she's dead

 

[Liqiud]

Eheh, My theory is that Luffy's mother was the daughter of Gol D. Roger. She married Dragon had Luffy and was most likely kidnapped by the WG to force Gol togive himself up. Garp probably disagreed with this but had to follow orders. Roger and him most likely met up and made a deal: Roger would turn himself in and be executed while Garp would attempt save his daughter from the WG, who would of coarse kill her after she had outlived her usefulness. Garp didn't make it in time to save her. Dragon found out from his father and set out to destroy the WG, having a vendetta, a cause, and a reason to topple the WG.

 

[Mugiwara_no_Jack]

Nice theory...

 

[Liqiud]

Er, thanks...

 

[The Boff]

This sound very educated. but I don't think Dragon is that simple of a man, revolt the gov just for the sake of his wife. But that another possibility, Luffy's mother already died "(

I like your idea Boff. But like movingstone said, Dragon needs more reasons to revolt against the government than what you're saying. Then again, there's no right and wrong here, so you maybe correct on that.

yeah i totally understand what youre saying, but think about it. what does OP lack? romance. we have been given pretty much everything except that. so wouldnt it be kinda nice with a really good but ofcourse tragic love story. and given Luffys character, a man who doesnt know how to give up. If he got that from his father then its actually not that far fetched. Luffy declared war on the government because they took a friend from him. Imagine if they took his love away. but yeah its all still a theory.

 

[sushi]

you guys sure got lots of ideas

 

[weixiaobao]

you guys sure got lots of ideas

Sure, sure

yeah i totally understand what youre saying, but think about it. what does OP lack? romance. we have been given pretty much everything except that. so wouldnt it be kinda nice with a really good but ofcourse tragic love story. and given Luffys character, a man who doesnt know how to give up. If he got that from his father then its actually not that far fetched. Luffy declared war on the government because they took a friend from him. Imagine if they took his love away. but yeah its all still a theory.

One Piece = Romance as in tragic love story = ahhhhhhhhhh = up # of fan girl

Your theory is like the same story in (spoiler) Dais Adventure (Dragon Quest)

Anyway it could be truth since I can't think of a reason why Dragon would revolt against the World gov beside if he know the blank history or his wife was killed by World gov

 

[Liqiud]

Eh ...My theory got ignored

 

[weixiaobao]

Eh ...My theory got ignored

Your is pretty much the same as other plus little twist and anyway don't take it too personaly (newbie are ussually ignore= sad but proved to be truth 75% of all times by the great mind of movingstone (accually i made that up))

Anyway because we have a conversation before your post.

Ok, comment on your theory. if luffy mother is daughter of GR (sound like Romeo and Juliet) and will be unlikely since GR look too young to have a kid and he die 22 years ago or so when luffy only -5 years old so i can't see how goldR's daughter (if have one) be luffy mother.

 

[Liqiud]

Hmmm, there seems to be a loophole...

 

[weixiaobao]

Hmmm, there seems to be a loophole...

??? you meant me or you?

 

[sushi]

hahahahha
guys ...is it true that newbie is ignored???

wait why can't he has a daughter???garp got a son and he was in GR era tooo...

 

[weixiaobao]

hahahahha
guys ...is it true that newbie is ignored???

wait why can't he has a daughter???garp got a son and he was in GR era tooo...

I said i made that stuff up

(accually i made that up))

Garp look so freaking old. he should be older than Gold Roger, one generation older. Same era doesn't meant same age (take the giants for example)
Garp about 22 + 22 +17 = old

while Gold Roger about 22+ 22= 44

 

[sushi]

that's not true right since GR also look kinda old to me look at aokiji he was young before

uh yea whose garp's wife nyway[br]Posted on: November 19, 2006, 11:30:11 PM_________________________________________________adding they can get married early wut like maybe around 16??? possible right?? plus giant is diferrent since their life span is way longer than human look at shanks he is with roger but now his still look as fresh as he was back then right