Rate this please (need a feedback)

[Obxist]

Hello everyone in MH,.. i need your comment for this

RAW MQ/HQ

Spoiler

Done without text

Spoiler

Done with the text

Spoiler

 

[ddadain]

oh nice nice... which denoising program did you use?

Some of the lines became blurry... you might want to sharpen it more a bit... :O

 

[Obxist]

thanks,.. i am using neat image,.. LOL yonie's tutorial really helps a lot ... the lines is blurry on purpose,.. its no good to sharpen it again ,..

 

[Vato Loco!]

Quite a bit of detail loss, (in eyebrows and wolf eye/nose). the grays are altered a lot (too much for my tastes anyways.) There's also random dust blurs around lines; such as on the guy's nose, where hair lines start to join, or in narrower spaces such as on the coat zipper. And the blacks/whites aren't fully filled/clean.

All that said it's still a pretty decent denoise.

 

[Zwivix]

Well I'm not sure how to evaulate, since im not a Manga Editor. But on the eyebrow after the cleaning it still has a few lines of white. And after you added the text there is someting on the first "T" of Torture.

Thats all i could see to make it perfect to me so ill give it a 9.5/10!

Great job.

 

[Obxist]

thanks for the rate ,.. and yep i've yet mastered the denoise LOL

 

[GGpX]

The redraws are good.

I could care less about anything else on the page.

 

[Obxist]

The redraws are good.

I could care less about anything else on the page.

thanks,.. and yes i am only good at redrawings, but i am bad at leveling and denoising etc lol