Discussion Series All Time Relationship Rate [VOTING OPEN!]

[Unforgettable]

If Juvia hadn't been around Gray and Natsu would have been more competitive. Gemini did point out Gray thought she was hott but I don't see a lasting relationship with them. They do make great friends.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 29, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 29, 2017 ---

I think this is left:

Jellal Fernandes and Erza Scarlet
Gajeel Redfox and Levy McGarden
Alzack Connell and Bisca Connell
Elfman Strauss and Evergreen
Brandish & Dimaria Yesta
Sting Eucliffe and Rogue

fixed

 

[Reebi]

Gray and Ultear are like the step siblings with awkward sexual tension who compete for their parents attention but in the end it won’t go anywhere because they are like brother and sister.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

@Emperor Spriggan great post!

Yes. Ultear x Gray is sexy and Reina x Musica is otp material, but always felt Ultear was a bit more of brotp as the Ur connection was hyped up more which made them feel more like siblings.

Although that sun village arc moment was something worthy of Jaime x Cersei

 

[Reebi]

@Emperor Spriggan great post!

Yes. Ultear x Gray is sexy and Reina x Musica is otp material, but always felt Ultear was a bit more of brotp as the Ur connection was hyped up more which made them feel more like siblings.

Although that sun village arc moment was something worthy of Jaime x Cersei

I get too much of a brother sister vibe from them

 

[Stormsfury]

So I had to delete half this post to keep it from crashing...














It's just because this couple has the most moments of the series...








































But if anyone wants the extra eye candy, be sure to message me....
I can provide the full post to you...











































@Lenny said:

The ship











@Jko said:

Best And most developed relationship in the show. They helped each other grow.












@DiMaria Yesta said:

the only thing I don’t like is Natsu constantly being insensitive toward Lucy’s feelings, groping her boobs, and getting Lucy watery-eyed.







































@Emperor Spriggan said:

This ship was REALLY good in the Grand Magic Games, even with the Future Lucy stuff, but the last arc seriously disgraced it. What the hell was that nudity bullshit with warming up Natsu?





































@BluePegasus said:

Apparently Natsu doesn't experience emotions related to love so there's not much to here.

























@Raven said:

Roses are red, Violets are blue ,The sun shine bright but not as bright as Nalu





















@Takuan said:

One of the best ships in the series. Minus point for the friendzone at the end, and for NaLu fans.

# 14

Natsu Dragneel and Lucy Heartfilia


6.233



Highest Score: 11 x 6(@Star Frost, @Reebi, @Jko, @Raven, @Axiomus, @Crescent_jinxgrace)


10 x 4(@Seven777, @Lenny, @Takuan, @Asorx)



Lowest Score: 1 x 8 (@Nemispelled, @EmptySoul, @Elusia, @MonkeyD-Dragon, @Yui-kitten, @PluePegasus, @Raijin 雷神, @BluePegasus)





Trolls be gone.

It’s a sad day when people give so many 1’s to the main bond of the series that started in chp 1 and went consistently through until chp 545.












Some tales are as old as time

​

Once upon a time in a land far, far away...

...lies the kingdom of Fiore...


​

... where a girl fell under an evil love spell.​

Until a special boy broke the charm....

The evil wizard wasn’t happy with the girl roaming free thus tricked her into his boat but the boy, a dragon slayer, rescued the girl before inviting her to come to a place of endless adventure and wonder...

Spoiler: Their endless adventures 1-3

Spoiler: Their endless adventures 4-6

A place called "Fairy Tail."

Little did she know that more than just adventure awaited her...

But finding a place she belonged...

Her father, a powerful man, wanted her to marry a duke. A girl like her didn't belong in a place like that, but the boy told her to stay...

“You’re Lucy of Fairy Tail.” He said.

She knew that the boy would always catch her when she falls...

...carry her through the troubled times...

Spoiler

... and comfort her during her sadness.

She secretly thought he was really cool.

And thought he was cute while he slept...

And whatever reaction this is when he woke....

He cleans up pretty good... Doesn't he, Lucy?

"I always believe in you." She told him.

Some days she wondered what type of relationship they really had.

Apparently she wasn't the only one.

They are best partners.

But could they be something more?

She loved how he would make her laugh...

Even though sometimes he made her cry...

But he would always find fun ways to apologize...

He knew her better than anyone.

“Lucy is Lucy.” He would say.

And she understood he was Natsu....

Nothing more to describe...

He thought of her in unexpected times...

Some guys give girls flowers but he got her a tree...

And giving her even the clothes on his back.

She always knew she would choose him...

...above others.

Cuz it's just more fun when they're together...

But would he choose her in return?

She wouldn't leave him.

Even if he did grope her boobs a lot.

Spoiler: “nsfw”

She would make him cultured.

Take the beast out of the boy.

Keep him safe.

Cherish him...

Make him smile

Give him warmth

Comfort him during troubled times

Stay by HIS side...

Spoiler: “More NSFW

They met interesting characters during their time together.... alternate forms of themselves.

Spoiler: Edolas

Big shout out to Edolas Nalu!!!!!!

Sometimes things tried to separate the two.

A tribe of Angry Tumblr CaveWomen

But nothing could...

Not Jealousy

Not love rivals...

Not Time...

Nor Space...

Nor Death

Nor War

Nor Heaven....

Nor gates of hell...

...could separate them.

This family that they had grown to be...

...had at some point become "home."

“We will be together forever...”

Cuz isn’t that what happy endings are suppose to be...

See the story still works without a single other character mentioned!!


A true
“Fairy Tale”

​

I cant believe I missed the salt on this post, why did no one alert me?

 

[Biri Biri]

Nothing to see here. Just want to share Gildarts and Irene is one of my guilty pleasure.

Now, jog along son.

Spoiler

 

[Tirl]

I found some interesting ship. Please, enjoy

Spoiler

 

[Crescent Jinx]

​

When a man loves a woman....

​

Can't keep his mind on nothing else.....​

​

...He'd trade the world for the good thing he's found​

#6
Elfman Strauss and Evergreen
6.750

Highest Score: 10 x 2(@Asorx, @Raijin 雷神)

Lowest Score: 1 x 2(@MonkeyD-Dragon, @Axiomus)

@Lenny said:
Manly man and girly girl always wins for me, even though Ever can be pretty badass as well-Just hoping their offspring is gonna be better than what Mirajane imagined.

@Yui-kitten said:
5-Cause no one else will vote for them probably

@Jko said:
Underrated ship tbh. They really hit it off, and the dynamic between them was awesome.

@Emperor Spriggan said:
Again, who are these chumps?

@Takuan said:
I'm not much of an Ever or Elfman fan, but this ship is solid. I like their development during Tenrou.

In the FF arc, Evergreen petrifies Miss Fairy Tail girls in a scheme set up by Laxus. Elfman becomes determined to save Mirajane. The two encounter each other, while he is initially disadvantaged because of Evergreen's Stone Eyes, he transforms using his Beast Soul Take Over, and blindfolds himself to avoid eye contact. However, Evergreen still manages to defeat and petrifies him.

When Freed later choses Bixslow to be his partner for the S class trials, Evergreen is unhappy enough to begin eyeing Elfman to be her partner. As the first trial starts, everyone is still on the boat, and Freed sets up a rune barrier that prevents anyone from leaving the boat for five minutes. Evergreen counters this by rewriting the rune barrier, allowing her team to pass. The two choose route A where they have to face Elfman's sister.... the She-Devil. The two manage to defeat Mira by telling her Elfman put a bun in Evergreen's oven.

In another part of the island, Mirajane explained to Erza, Juvia, and Lisanna how Elfman and Evergreen were able to beat her. She believes that they lied to beat her, but then imagines them having a very ugly child, which causes her to cry.

When the second trial begins, Elfman and Evergreen run into one of the wild animals on the island. While Elfman and Evergreen are running he tells her where to go, which upsets her. As they continue running Elfman talks about how men shouldn't run away, but Evergreen just wants him to stop talking. Right when the animal is about to trample them, Elfman grabs Evergreen and pushes him and her of harms way. They roll down a tunnel and back out into the wild with Elfman's body on top of Evergreen's. She pushes him off and reminds him that they just pretended to be engaged and to not start thinking that she actually liked him.

Numerous Grimoire Heart members then emerge from bubbles in the sky and prepare to fight the two. Elfman shouts that a man does not excuse intruders, and Evergreen notes all of them as pests. Nonetheless, the two easily dispatch all of them in their immediate vicinity. Rustyrose then arrives, and because of his weird personality and hand motions, Elfman questions if he is a man, to which Evergreen tells him that this person is an "idiot." As the battle begins, they're nearly defeated.

Afterwards, Rustyrose reveals the true reason for coming to the island, to acquire Zeref and lead civilization into the Great World of Magic, where non-Magic users are unable to survive. The two Mages protest their ideals and continue to battle. However, despite their teamwork, Rustyrose's Arc of Embodiment overpowers and defeats them with an explosion.

Evergreen finally admit to being glad to be his partner. After Rusty Rose is defeated, Elfman manages to walk, despite his serious injuries, and carries Evergreen back to the guild's campsite. Elfman tells the group that their opponents are too strong and that he is pathetic for not being able to protect his sisters and his partner.

Their interactions include a mixture of tsundere and aloofness from Evergreen and humor from Elfman, as Evergreen is always shown hitting or scolding Elfman, mostly because of his 'Manly' comments or outbursts.

Most of the Fairy Tail Mages seem to tease their relationship, mostly Freed and Bickslow.

Also, Elfman calls Evergreen by her nickname, Ever, which is only used by Freed and Bickslow, her team members, as well as Laxus.

During the Grand Magic Games, when Elfman was injured, Evergreen was seen sleeping near his bed. At first, he was flustered, but as he calmed down, he seemed pleased and said that she was a 'Woman', which was considered a large step in their relationship (since for Elfman, the world seems to consist of his sisters, and the rest are just men, including all the other females).

Also they were shown having a date in the waterpark omake while wanting to keep it secret from Mira and Lisanna.

During the battle against the dragons Elfman worried about Evergreen fighting a dragon telling her: "You better be safe."

In Tartaros, Elfman promised a bedridden Evergreen he would seek revenge for her. Unlike Gajeel, Jellal, and Gray who spent parts of the time jump with their females, Elfman leaves everyone to go train, much like Natsu. Later when fighting when the thunder legion gets attacked at the Cardial Cathedral during the opening attacks of Alvarez, Elfman is shown worrying about Evergreen.

 

[Tirl]

When a man loves a woman....

Please, do make all the rest posts, you are awesome writer poster
Or at least Gavy. Im begging you

 

[Reebi]

Cute couple. Very Beauty and the Beast like. Not my favourite but they bicker like a married couple.

 

[Takuan]

Damn, so close to top 5. But i'm glad this ship made it this far. A pretty cute couple.

 

[Reebi]

My thoughts:

1.Brandish and Dimaria
2. Jerza
3. Bisca and Alzack
4. Gale
5. Sting and Rogue

 

[Cat Sidhe26]

My thoughts:

1.Brandish and Dimaria
2. Jerza
3. Bisca and Alzack
4. Gale
5. Sting and Rogue

Well here are my thoughts:
1. Gale
2. Bisca and Alzack
3. Sting and Rogue
4. Brandish and Dimaria
5. Jerza

 

[Crescent Jinx]

Please, do make all the rest posts, you are awesome writer poster Or at least Gavy. Im begging you

I can't promise that they will all be mine.......




















So what is more important?
Size?
Speed?
Time?
Emotion?

#5
@Brandish µ and @DiMaria Yesta
6.817

Highest Score: 10 x 6(@Miralicious akuma, @Star Frost, @EmptySoul, @DiMaria Yesta, @Asorx, @Raijin 雷神)

Lowest Score: 1 x 5(@Nemispelled, @Elusia, @MonkeyD-Dragon, @Yui-kitten, @Axiomus)

@Tirl said:
Love? SM? Slave? Lesbians always are good.



@Jko said:
Without the killing each they were cute. They are a good BROTP but not OTP.



@Emperor Spriggan said:
It's a weaker Kyoka-Seilah, but Dimaria really seems to love and cherish Randy. This is coming from someone who doesn't exactly interact with the other 12 so much.



@Takuan said:
I'd have placed them way higher, had Dimaria not tried to murder Brandish. Disappointing as fuck. I can't take this friendship seriously anymore.

I am already going to say that I don't really understand the hype of this ship.
For a lesbian couple, Seilah and Kyoka actually have more of a functional and caring relationship especially from Seilah's POV. They are also a true Master and Slave pair. And they actually had sex. As for the friendship bond with hints of romantic love, Wendy and Chelia do it better. And as for sex appeal.... pretty much any of Mashima's girl x girl pairings are sexy. Let's be real with out basic instincts.

If Mashima made one of the two characters male, this relationship would be instantly be called toxic by overzealous Tumblr members.

The first time we see Brandish is on Caracole Island with her subordinate Marin, who also happens to be one of her pets (she later references her pets in Naked Battle when she wants to make Lucy into one). When Dimaria and Brandish interact for the first time, Dimaria comes to get Brandish as Marin is painting her nails. We can see the women are close by the nicknames they give each other, but Dimaria orders Brandish to make Marin is right size and that she better bring him along to the meeting.

When Dimaria leaves, Brandish immediately throws shade on her much like a young Mirajane would to a young Erza.

And later the tsundere/yandere Dimaria tells Brandish that they never will be friends when Brandish admits that she doesn't like Dimaria.

When Brandish is captured in battle, Dimaria first laughs while making fun of her love interest.

And in battle, Dimaria specifically goes after Kagura because her haircut looks like Brandish's.

While Jacob actively is fearful of Dimaria's reactions if he hurts Brandish.

But then Dimaria gets captured...

...changing her perception of Brandish's capture, making her regret making fun of her.

Dimaria just didn't realize at that moment that Brandish heart was already given to her captor. And apparently Fairy tail is a lot nicer to their captives then Lamina Scale.

Later she finds out that Brandish is cheating on her...

...and instead of first going after the love rivals.

She kills Brandish and blames Lucy for it.

I'm pretty sure if Gray ever cheated on Juvia... she would kill the love rivals first and torture Gray later.

Then at the end, Dimaria becomes Brandish's new pet (cuz Marin ran away and payback's a bitch).

​

 

[Reebi]

This is out before Sting and Rogue?? Wow

Is an alright ship but with some therapy then can have a strong relationship

 

[Cat Sidhe26]

This is out before Sting and Rogue?? Wow

Is an alright ship but with some therapy then can have a strong relationship

This ship is confusing to the point it confuses me that I don’t know what kind of relationship Brandish/Dimaria have.

 

[Reebi]

This ship is confusing to the point it confuses me that I don’t know what kind of relationship Brandish/Dimaria have.

It's either all in Dimaria's head or they just have wild lesbian sex. Maybe it's an actual relationship but I think it's left to the readers to decide.

 

[Cat Sidhe26]

It's either all in Dimaria's head or they just have wild lesbian sex. Maybe it's an actual relationship but I think it's left to the readers to decide.

It won’t surprise me if this relationship is all in Dimaria’s head seeing that Brandish doesn’t like Dimaria but probably sees Dimaria as a friend. Well if this relationship is left to the readers to decide then this relationship will make for some good fan fiction/fan art ideas.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 3, 2017, Original Post Date: Dec 3, 2017 ---

This is out before Sting and Rogue?? Wow

Is an alright ship but with some therapy then can have a strong relationship

To be honest I never saw this ship before Sting and Rogue.

 

[Hermit]

"I'm sorry to disappoint you, but I'm running on empty here too. I'm here on a special delivery from the mistress. Now, eat me!"











































"Guess I've got no choice!"




































"Fight on.....White Shadow Dragon."




#4

Sting Eucliffe & Rogue Cheney
Score-7.050
Highest Score: 11 x 2(@Linali, @MLG Bradman)​

10 x 4(@Reebi, @PluePegasus, @Raijin 雷神, @Gryffindor)

Lowest Score: 1 x 6(@Valhalla777, @Nemispelled, @MonkeyD-Dragon, @Yui-kitten, @Axiomus, @BluePegasus) ​

My score-8

They have a wonderful bond. Imagining the battle between Future Rogue and Future Sting, forced to fight his best friend who has been possessed by the shadows and eventually being killed by him. has always killed me a little inside.

NOOOO.

Best BroTP ever

Basically a better Gratsu, and the most developed relationship of the Saber Core Four. What else is there to say?

This is a better done Natsu-Gray dynamic, they even explain Rogue turning on Sting in the future is due to the shadow's effects and not just a mindless 180. Plus they have the BEST Unison Raids in the series, hands down

A solid brotp, extremely high complicity and synergy.

I'm biased as hell, but whatever

I'm not much of a Sabertooth fan in general (Despite Minerva and Rogue being among my favorite characters in the story), but honestly, Sting and Rogue is easily one of the best broTP's in the show. What I find impressive about them, in comparison to all the other Dragon Slayers who tend to operate on an individual basis, is that they practically stick together through thick and thin. Even 400 years ago when the 5 Dragon Slayer kids were together under Anna, Sting and Rogue used to stay around each other, while Gajeel and Natsu always duked it out. That changed a little when they went through Eclipse, with Rogue joining Phantom Lord for a while, but shortly after he defected and joined Sabertooth where along with Sting, they became the corner stone of the guild:

The two Dragon Slayers are a major part of why Sabertooth became such a powerhouse in the seven year gap between Tenrou Island and the Grand Magic Games. Ironically enough, their Dragon Slaying Magic(s) are mirror opposites of each other, since Sting is the White Dragon while Rogue is the Shadow Dragon. Light and darkness:

This is part of the reason Rogue is not afraid of turning evil in the future, despite learning that his future counterpart was the reason behind the dragon apocalypse after the Grand Magic Games. He is always together with Sting, so he is aware that Sting will stop his descent into darkness whenever it happens:

Aside from their contrasting magic, they also have glaring differences in personality, since where Rogue tends to be quieter and reserved, Sting is more bashful and outgoing. This is cause for some strife between the two from time to time,but nothing they both can't handle :

In battle, their teamwork and coordination is unmatched by any other team in the series, hands down. This isn't just limited to Unison Raids (Like with GruVia), but even basic strategies like entering superior modes is all coordinated im perfect harmony between the two:

In layman's :

But of course, they do have their own share of combined attacks and Unison Raids:

As key members of Sabertooth, their love for the guild members is present in both of them (Though it did take a while for Sting to become compassionate like Rogue). This is shown in them venturing to Tartaros to save Minerva who had been kidnapped and made a member of the guild:

Fighting the Underworld King, Mard Geer together:

And later on disposing of their former Guild Master, Jiemma, since they felt he had fallen too far into depravity (@Valhalla777 ) to be redeemed again. Not to mention being part of the reason Minerva's childhood was a living hell:

They didn't have as many spectacular moments in the Alvarez Empire Arc, though their combined efforts did lead to the defeat of the third strongest Spriggan, Larcade Dragneel (Along with Minerva and Kagura).

All in all, a solid friendship and camarederie between these two Dragon Slayers. The fact that it made it this far is pretty solid proof of that

^These are their faces at not making first place

​

 

[Tirl]

First 7 scores Congratulations
Now I want GaLe to get 8 or higher