Here are my number. I use stamina as 'ability to withstand physical damage', since the stamina 2 can shrug off a triple digit tiebreaker in terms of endurance. All arounders tend to have higher totals but this doesn't mean they're necessarily stronger.
Byodouin
Power - 6.5
Stamina - 6
Tech - 4
Mental - 7
Speed - 4
Total 27.5
Shuuji
Power - 2
Stamina - 2
Tech - 7
Mental - 6
Speed - 7
Total 24
Duke
Power - 7
Stamina - 7
Tech - 2
Mental - 4
Speed - 2
Total 22
Ryoga
Power - 3
Stamina - 4
Tech - 6
Mental - 6
Speed - 5
Total 24
Oni
Power - 6
Stamina - 6.5
Tech - 4
Mental - 4
Speed - 3
Total 23.5
Tokugawa
Power - 4
Stamina - 5.5
Tech - 6
Mental - 3
Speed - 5
Total - 23.5
10-ball Ryoma
Power - 1
Stamina - 4
Tech - 5.5
Mental - 6
Speed - 5
Total 21.5
Kintaro (after training)
Power - 5.5
Stamina - 5.5
Tech - 1
Mental - 3
Speed - 5
Total 20
Sanada (Black Aura)
Power - 5
Stamina - 5
Tech - 3
Mental - 5
Speed - 3
Total 21
Note: this assume he can't use Rai in Black Aura, or his speed would be at least a 5.
Yukimura (with Dream)
Power - 2
Stamina - 4
Tech - 6.5
Mental - 4
Speed - 4
Total 20.5