Last edited by a moderator:
The scenes with the dragon are great enough to make the movie a good movie. Without it, it was an average ok movie. There were some bad choices: The love story involving Tauriel might be the worse choice. But still, Peter Jackson is the best at filming epic landscapes and that didn't change with the hobbit. Plus, Martin Freeman is for me the best actor of the whole franchise. He is perfect in his role. The love couple "Sam-Frodo" was getting on my nerves. Just how much of a good guy is Sam in the first three movies ...I found Desolation of Smaug extremely silly. Big hand for the action choreographers for being able to be so out there with their imagination, but otherwise it was just meh. At least it wasn't as bad a 3DCGI rollercoaster as the first one was. Better than the first one, but imho that wasn't much. I could watch this one easily, without checking the clock all the time. Still, it left me with a shrug of shoulders. Okay, that was Hobbit 2. I didn't feel anything, I don't want to see it again. And I'm a Tolkien fanboy. I was not fanboycrazed nor fanboypissedangry. It was just meh.
Why so much Legolas? Why a completly random romantic sideplot? Why Gandalfs sidequest is so boring? Why does he even try cross bridges anymore?
Also, why Legolas is so dumb? He can headshot countless of minion orcs while doing ballet on heads of barrelriding dwarfs, while going down wild rapids. And the later he rides of after sub-boss orc, holding a sword high on his hand, while carrying a bow on his back. Shoot the bastard. If you need him a live, shoot the mount god dammit.
Only acting performance I enjoyed, was Lee Pace as Thranduil.
Though I've seen the first one, I have to mostly agree about Bilbo. The only one who could match him as a character is Gandalf.Loved Bilbo and Smaug too. And Legolas. Owning.
And I concluded that truly, Bilbo is the most fascinating, most colorful character ever on the entire LoTR franchise. movies and books combined.
The fact that you did not include the original Star Wars trilogy or Godfather I and II means you should be banned from life and everything.Films I'd like to see in theatres (IMAX or not):
1. Back to the Future
2. Ghostbusters
3. Ferris Bueller's Day Off
4. Alien
5. Blade Runner
6. Seven Samurai
7. The Good, The Bad & The Ugly
8. Coffy
9. A Clockwork Orange
10. Dr. Strangelove
11. Fist of the Northstar (1985)
12. Akira
13. The Shining
14. Metropolis (1927)
15. Do The Right Thing