"I've also played all including all 3 endings in 3. i also must agree with you on 2 being the best for all the reasons you listed plus another, the multitude of species and character diversity. more than any other title in the series, each individual character stood out alot more. this was partly due to its much higher level of incorperation of other races and clans (vampire, werewolf, kobald, winger, griffon, elf, etc). other titles made reference to these races (3 did the best job) or tried to substitute (the Nay-kobald from 4 haunt my dreams). plus, Bob was just fantastic"- sahugani
i knew i was forgetting something... aw come on! the nay-kobold were kitties! KITTIES!!! the essence of cuteness!!
"It doesn't surprise me, most people who have played the whole series tend to pick the second game as their favorite. One of things that enjoyed about Suikoden II is the cooking contest. I really loved it, hahaha! I wish Suikoden 5 brought it back^^
Yeah, the lycanthrope Bob was so awesome, too bad he didn't have any significant role on the plot."- the filipino channel (just kidding TFC)
i don't want to spoil anything for you....