Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Tamil]

I need that poll asap. Just post it here plzzzz

 

[ChocoBar9]

Yeah that is weird. Was Kimetsu's poll just longer or did it really receive that many entries?

 

[DyanSon]

Popularity poll sure is weird. You get Nisekoi( 1/4 of it is from Y-san) and KnY both moderate success getting 30k vote while Ass class and Bnha both big success get only below 10k. But I'm sure is happy to KnY.

 

[Tamil]

Yeah that is weird. Was Kimetsu's poll just longer or did it really receive that many entries?

Popularity poll sure is weird. You get Nisekoi( 1/4 of it is from Y-san) and KnY both moderate success getting 30k vote while Ass class and Bnha both big success get only below 10k. But I'm sure is happy to KnY.

The extended period helped since we were supposed to get this in August. It's well worth the wait and a sign of Kimetsu's growing popularity.

 

[shoyoboyo]

Well, granted, Kimetsu did have like 5 months to gather votes. But even then, I was really worried that they waited so long because there weren't enough votes. Even if we did get the results in August though, we definitely would have had over 10k, so even then I would have been happy.
I know that popularity poll total votes don't mean much (AssClass for example), but I'm just happy that Kimetsu has a better number than Black Clover.

 

[Tanzo]

Jump Manga 1st Popularity Poll # of Votes:

Spoiler

Naruto 　72733
Mr. Fullswing　57231
Bleach　　　　39618
Hunter x Hunter　 37648
One Piece　　36000
Soul Catcher(S) 　35000
Shaman King　31949
Rising Impact　29658
Prince of Tennis　 29466
D.Gray-man　　　27033
Haikyuu　　　26370
Kimetsu no Yaiba 26105 (New System) ←New!
World Trigger　　25981
To LOVE-Ru　　25076
Buso Renkin　　20910
Reborn　　18655
Nisekoi 　17759
Beelzebub 　16555
Kuroko no Basket 14973
NuraMago　 14702
Toriko 14000~
Muhyo & Roji　　13801
HeroAca　11125（New System）
Psyren　　11055
Yuragi　　10659（New System）
Pretty Face　10034
Mieru Hito　　10031
Black Clover 9825 (New System)
Hokenshitsu no Shinigami　　 9668
Souma　　　8225
Sket Dance 　　8176
Magico　　5950
Sesuji　　5225（New System）
Samon　　　5024（New System）
Medaka Box　 4807
Kurogane　3907
AssClass　　　2598（New System）
Enigma　unknown

 

[Tamil]

Jump Manga 1st Popularity Poll # of Votes:

Spoiler

Naruto 　72733
Mr. Fullswing　57231
Bleach　　　　39618
Hunter x Hunter　 37648
One Piece　　36000
Soul Catcher(S) 　35000
Shaman King　31949
Rising Impact　29658
Prince of Tennis　 29466
D.Gray-man　　　27033
Haikyuu　　　26370
Kimetsu no Yaiba 26105 (New System) ←New!
World Trigger　　25981
To LOVE-Ru　　25076
Buso Renkin　　20910
Reborn　　18655
Nisekoi 　17759
Beelzebub 　16555
Kuroko no Basket 14973
NuraMago　 14702
Muhyo & Roji　　13801
HeroAca　11125（New System）
Psyren　　11055
Yuragi　　10659（New System）
Pretty Face　10034
Mieru Hito　　10031
Black Clover 9825 (New System)
Hokenshitsu no Shinigami　　 9668
Souma　　　8225
Sket Dance 　　8176
Magico　　5950
Sesuji　　5225（New System）
Samon　　　5024（New System）
Medaka Box　 4807
Kurogane　3907
AssClass　　　2598（New System）
Enigma　unknown

You posted this before, was this Takeshi's first popularity poll?

Spoiler

20K votes with Takeshi if it's the first.


Toriko had 14k

Spoiler

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

WNL in second is very good.
Robot needs to recover and get good positions.

As I imagined, Tomatoypoo replaced Isobe Isobee Monogatari.
I hope Fulldrive and Golem Hearts do not disappoint me.

 

[Caiops]

Zenitsu have to be in first.

Best character in Yaiba.

 

[Tanzo]

You posted this before, was this Takeshi's first popularity poll?

Spoiler

20K votes with Takeshi if it's the first.


Toriko had 14k

Spoiler

I'll add Toriko.
From this link it looks like that was Takeshi's 2nd poll, couldn't find the first one.

 

[Tamil]

Kimetsu has a pretty big cast now that I think about it. I'm curious how the other pillars are going to rank, excluding popular ones like Shinobu, Rengoku & even Uzui.

Yushiro/Tamayo are characters that may rank pretty high too I'm predicting.

 

[shoyoboyo]

inb4 half of the votes are sent by the Y-san of Kimetsu for Rengoku. I wouldn't even be mad.

 

[Nemesis]

WNL in second place is surprising but great. I imagine that they want to push the series because of the new volume

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

Gintama will reveal the final popularity poll results next issue.
Kimetsu had 26,105 votes in the popularity poll. Holy shit.
Spring Weapon poll results will apparently be released in January.

> Hijikata Toushirou will win.
> 26k? Wow, I hope Tanjiro, Inosuke and Rengoku are the top 3.
> If Spring's vote has more than 5,000 votes, I'll be surprised.

 

[Scruffy8642]

This new EiC trying to start a war. Stuff is all over the place.

 

[ShenGao]

This ToC looks so weird. Is Souma's current arc so terrible that it deserves the bottom while it's 3rd anime season is airing? And how did Kimetsu garner over 26.000 votes? Was it an online voting system where anyone could vote anonymously and vote multiple times or does Kimetsu have it's own Y-san fanatic?

 

[TyVip]

This ToC looks so weird. Is Souma's current arc so terrible that it deserves the bottom while it's 3rd anime season is airing?

sadly yes

 

[Nakurawari]

26K votes in the Kimetsu poll, wow. I'm sure the really long voting period contributed, but that's still damn impressive. Rengoku better be top 3.

Looks like Tomatoy is the new Isobe. I've read the first 2 chapters, and it's okay. From what I've been able to read of Isobe, I prefer Isobe.

 

[TotalEconomist]

This ToC looks so weird. Is Souma's current arc so terrible that it deserves the bottom while it's 3rd anime season is airing? And how did Kimetsu garner over 26.000 votes? Was it an online voting system where anyone could vote anonymously and vote multiple times or does Kimetsu have it's own Y-san fanatic?

The TOC for Soma has been all over the place, it was like first or something a couple weeks ago. At this point, it gets treated like Gintama with it's placement.

 

[Tanzo]

Soma's editor changed again by the way.

Spoiler: author comments

Editor info from 4chan (from a translator of the SnS manga scans)

New recruit in the editorial office. Kanji is 南村, first appeared in this year's July 10 Vol 32.
http://ujiriyo.com/osusume-manga-jump-32
>I'm the new guy, Namura. Currently hooked on ARMS. Ninjara strong (Namura)
http://ikura.open2ch.net/test/read.cgi/wcomic/1432606305/
>Vol 38 (8/18): When I was an exchange student in the Philippines a long time ago, my nickname was Baby
>Vol 43 (9/29): Climbed Mount Fuji. Saw the sunrise from the top and lots of horse poop.
QED this is most likely his first rodeo at WSJ.