Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[xAsum0x]

Wasn't Sahara Samurai popular? It got a CP too

 

[Mammo]

no, every single miniseries made by a guy who used to have a series in WSJ get a cp, and they get by turn since they can only put certain amount of cp in a single issue

 

[Tanzo]

I thought that by being out of the top 3 in the last six months, BnHA would be in a lower position.

>People still somehow thinking Yuragi will get axed after all this time

WNL stayed in the bottom 5 for a significant amount of time early on, yet I didn't see as many people say it would get axed.
Also I dunno if ToC averages can be trusted much considering how the new EoC is mixing things up a lot nowadays.

 

[iceemperor]

Manga sales from August 21st to November 19th
0821-1119
2040375 2040375 Ｏ ８７ 1711 (OP)
*663711 *663711 ハ ２８ 1710 (Haikyuu)
*597059 *597059 僕 １５ 1709 (Heroaca)
*447972 *447972 僕 １６ 1711 (Heroaca)
*362653 *362653 食 ２６ 1709 (Soma)
*310076 *310076 約 　５ 1709 (Neverland)
*304239 2496033 Ｏ ８６ 1708 (OP)
*290761 *290761 食 ２７ 1711 (Soma)
*245884 *245884 ド 　４ 1711 ( DB Super)
*237386 *237386 約 　６ 1711 (Neverland)
*228241 *228241 銀 ７０ 1710 (Gintama)
*222467 *222467 Ｂ 　４ 1711 (Boruto)
*210530 *210530 ブ １３ 1710 (BC)
*197153 *197153 終 　４ 1710 (Harem)

 

[cody]

Manga sales from August 21st to November 19th
0821-1119
2040375 2040375 Ｏ ８７ 1711 (OP)
*663711 *663711 ハ ２８ 1710 (Haikyuu)
*597059 *597059 僕 １５ 1709 (Heroaca)
*447972 *447972 僕 １６ 1711 (Heroaca)
*362653 *362653 食 ２６ 1709 (Soma)
*310076 *310076 約 　５ 1709 (Neverland)
*304239 2496033 Ｏ ８６ 1708 (OP)
*290761 *290761 食 ２７ 1711 (Soma)
*245884 *245884 ド 　４ 1711 ( DB Super)
*237386 *237386 約 　６ 1711 (Neverland)
*228241 *228241 銀 ７０ 1710 (Gintama)
*222467 *222467 Ｂ 　４ 1711 (Boruto)
*210530 *210530 ブ １３ 1710 (BC)
*197153 *197153 終 　４ 1710 (Harem)

I like how Neverland is casually overtaking Soma, Gintama, Boruto and BC. (sorry if I'm completely wrong, I might be completely misinterpreting these numbers)

 

[savethecat]

Does anyone have a link to Moue's One shot raws?

 

[Doughboy]

I'm not much of a sales guy, that stuff seems way out of my attention span spectrum, but Dr. Stone next volume sales I'll be watching. Ranking 6th for the year shouldn't surprise me but it still does kinda. The more I read this series the more I think the art is carrying it. This arc has had more ups than downs but the recent developments are tilting me:

Spoiler

Senku vs. Kohaku gets scrapped for plot reasons, and yeah I'm hip it would of been a throwaway fight but would of enjoyed even a fluke fight between them
Magma beats Kinrou in an annoying and dickheadish way, which fits his character but it was still weaksauce
Ginrou's comic relief really isn't all that funny, which is surprising cause the comedy got better

 

[ChocoBar9]

I'm not much of a sales guy, that stuff seems way out of my attention span spectrum, but Dr. Stone next volume sales I'll be watching. Ranking 6th for the year shouldn't surprise me but it still does kinda. The more I read this series the more I think the art is carrying it. This arc has had more ups than downs but the recent developments are tilting me:

Spoiler

Senku vs. Kohaku gets scrapped for plot reasons, and yeah I'm hip it would of been a throwaway fight but would of enjoyed even a fluke fight between them
Magma beats Kinrou in an annoying and dickheadish way, which fits his character but it was still weaksauce
Ginrou's comic relief really isn't all that funny, which is surprising cause the comedy got better

Trust me you are not the only one who believe this. From what I've seen from the first two volumes thus far the series does not have legs and is casting by editorial good will. With MHA, Neverland and Souma we saw clear interest in the series that made them top sellers early on but Stone seems to be following the BC tradition of two weeks before dropping out entirely.

 

[Halloween]

In Golem Hearts, I'm really liking Noah's new look. I hope it's a series that ends up surviving. It definitely seems like a step up quality wise from the recent failed action series in Jump. Plus, it's actually charming.

 

[SharkBait]

Manga sales from August 21st to November 19th
0821-1119
2040375 2040375 Ｏ ８７ 1711 (OP)
*663711 *663711 ハ ２８ 1710 (Haikyuu)
*597059 *597059 僕 １５ 1709 (Heroaca)
*447972 *447972 僕 １６ 1711 (Heroaca)
*362653 *362653 食 ２６ 1709 (Soma)
*310076 *310076 約 　５ 1709 (Neverland)
*304239 2496033 Ｏ ８６ 1708 (OP)
*290761 *290761 食 ２７ 1711 (Soma)
*245884 *245884 ド 　４ 1711 ( DB Super)
*237386 *237386 約 　６ 1711 (Neverland)
*228241 *228241 銀 ７０ 1710 (Gintama)
*222467 *222467 Ｂ 　４ 1711 (Boruto)
*210530 *210530 ブ １３ 1710 (BC)
*197153 *197153 終 　４ 1710 (Harem)

was there really only one BC volume in this period?

 

[iceemperor]

was there really only one BC volume in this period?

There was one released, Volume 12, in August but it dropped off the charts after the third week and thus didn't make the cutoff line for this chart.

│*69741 (3)│128256│149552│------│------┃*,149,552 (*17)┃2017/08｜ブラッククローバー 12

 

[Aipom626]

first couple of pages of Numa Shun new oneshot have leaked

https://tieba.baidu.com/p/5446828110

looks like he's doing an action manga

Interesting. I can see he still manages to use that troll face in a more serious series lol. Looks kind of like a combo between Isobee and Samon. I'm interested to see what the full oneshot is, hopefully it'll be put up soon

 

[OfficialHxH]

From what i could tell the author of Saiki is ill?

 

[Tanzo]

Raw chapters for all miniseries/oneshots from Jump GIGA 2018 #1
Takamasa Moue's "K.K In the City of Fog" Miniseries CP

 

[iceemperor]

From what i could tell the author of Saiki is ill?

It says that he's ill for this upcoming 52nd issue and thus Saiki will be on break and it will resume on 2018's first issue set to go on sale on Dec 4.

 

[101nemesis]

Just like for One Piece, the artstyle of Kimetsu no Yaiba is the perfect litmus test.

Agreed.
It's such a great series. And I really enjoy the art as well.

 

[razerxs]

Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san has 1.5 million copies in print.

 

[SharkBait]

1.5mln is all thats needed for an anime adaptation? Surprised the barrier of entry is lowering so much now.

 

[Caiops]

Manga sales from August 21st to November 19th
0821-1119
2040375 2040375 Ｏ ８７ 1711 (OP)
*663711 *663711 ハ ２８ 1710 (Haikyuu)
*597059 *597059 僕 １５ 1709 (Heroaca)
*447972 *447972 僕 １６ 1711 (Heroaca)
*362653 *362653 食 ２６ 1709 (Soma)
*310076 *310076 約 　５ 1709 (Neverland)
*304239 2496033 Ｏ ８６ 1708 (OP)
*290761 *290761 食 ２７ 1711 (Soma)
*245884 *245884 ド 　４ 1711 ( DB Super)
*237386 *237386 約 　６ 1711 (Neverland)
*228241 *228241 銀 ７０ 1710 (Gintama)
*222467 *222467 Ｂ 　４ 1711 (Boruto)
*210530 *210530 ブ １３ 1710 (BC)
*197153 *197153 終 　４ 1710 (Harem)

Almost no boost to Black Clover

But i expect a second boost when the Peter Jackson movie its out, and a third boost when it wins the Oscars.

 

[Mammo]

another preview for Nisioisin's new oneshot from the artist instagram

https://www.instagram.com/iwasakiyuji0701/

posted the link to the entire page because there are a lot of cool art in it