Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[savethecat]

Is the hate for Ochako a meme? I still see ppl around forums saying she's the worst Shonen Heroine ever. While she isn't great, i honestly don't see what about her is particularly bad

 

[SharkBait]

Is the hate for Ochako a meme? I still see ppl around forums saying she's the worst Shonen Heroine ever. While she isn't great, i honestly don't see what about her is particularly bad

Why would the truth be a meme, she's even more awful that Sakura Haruno in her pre Naruto pt 1 filler days. When has Ochako done anything as of late that wasnt the same repetitive antics for her midoriya? After her Bakugo fight she has just gone downhill. Meanwhile Sakura Haruno went up as soon as she realized she could be an important asset for team 7. If Ochako can realize that she can be an asset for Midoriya then her character can begin to be salvaged.

 

[Mammo]

Is the hate for Ochako a meme? I still see ppl around forums saying she's the worst Shonen Heroine ever. While she isn't great, i honestly don't see what about her is particularly bad

yes, it's a super forced meme because of that one popularity poll about what Jump Heroine make you sick


This Week's Jump Comic Sales:

01. One Piece #84 (1,500,448)
02. Boku no Hero Academia #12 (183,544)
04. Platinum End #5 (73,583)
10. Yakusoku no Neverland #2 (40,683)
23. Hinomaru Zumou #13 (20,372)
27. One Piece #83 (17,865 / 2,629,367)
29. Sesuji wo Pin! to〜Shikakou Kyougi Dance-bu e Youkoso〜 #9 (17,786)
31. Masuda Kousuke Gekijou Gag Manga Biyori GB #2 (17,376)
33. Captain Tsubasa Rising Sun #5 (17,006)
44. Ao no Exorcist #18 (12,803 / 479,668)

 

[SharkBait]

Is that a 100% increase over v1 for promised neverland? I hope its not outperforming BLack Clover.

 

[xAsum0x]

She just needs more moments to shine. She's been taking the back seat to other females like Momo and Jirou. Especially Momo

 

[Kefka Palazzo]

04. Platinum End #5 (73,583)

Wow... Names can be amazing, right, guys?

Is the hate for Ochako a meme? I still see ppl around forums saying she's the worst Shonen Heroine ever. While she isn't great, i honestly don't see what about her is particularly bad

I kinda liked her in the beginning, but nowadays she's one of my least favorites from BnH.

 

[Bigivelfhq]

what kinda of kids go to college when they're 15? A Genius?
what kinda of dumbass is still at highschool by the time they're 20? A Dumb Person?

 

[Nakura]

I don't hate her or anything, but she's definitely not as interesting as she was in the Sports Festival arc. I'm sure something cool will happen again with her, but I do give her a weird look when she's on screen these days.

 

[justsomeguy]

Jump should put One Piece in the middle of the magazine and give its spot at the top to new, prominent series. One Piece has two consecutive years in the top 2 (since 2015 #8 when it ranked 4th). I mean, people would read it even if it's at the bottom.

I don't hate her or anything, but she's definitely not as interesting as she was in the Sports Festival arc. I'm sure something cool will happen again with her, but I do give her a weird look when she's on screen these days.

This. Iida has been forgotten too. Hori should stop introducing new characters and start focusing in the current ones.

 

[TyVip]

24,380　Yakusoku no Neverland Vol.1 (Nov 28 - Dec 4), Volume released on Dec 2 so 3 days sale

Yakusoku no Neverland #2 (40,683) Volume 2 is also 3 days sale(Jan 30 - Feb 5), volume released on Feb 3rd

~fixed, thanks

 

[savethecat]

I don't hate her or anything, but she's definitely not as interesting as she was in the Sports Festival arc. I'm sure something cool will happen again with her, but I do give her a weird look when she's on screen these days.

Don't get me wrong, I don't think she's a great character. I just don't think she's particularly bad either. Just a character with little screen time

 

[Halloween]

I hope its not outperforming BLack Clover.

It has a real shot of it if it wins that manga taisho award, apparently.

 

[TyVip]

Jump should put One Piece in the middle of the magazine and give its spot at the top to new, prominent series. One Piece has two consecutive years in the top 2 (since 2015 #8 when it ranked 4th). I mean, people would read it even if it's at the bottom.


This. Iida has been forgotten too. Hori should stop introducing new characters and start focusing in the current ones.

One Piece never out of top 4 from its debut in 1997. It's a FLAGSHIP title.

http://pharaodopazoplus.blogspot.co.uk/p/weekly-shonen-jump-rankings-2000.html feel free to fact check me.

 

[Kefka Palazzo]

what kinda of kids go to college when they're 15?
what kinda of dumbass is still at highschool by the time they're 20?

I had one classmate in 9th grade that was 17 years old. :^)

 

[Kave]

24,380　Yakusoku no Neverland Vol.1 (Nov 28 - Dec 4), Volume released on Dec 2 so 3 days sale

Volume 2 is also 2 days sale if I counted correctly? (Jan 30 - Feb 5), volume released on Feb 3rd

Feb 3
Feb 4
Feb 5

 

[Mammo]

A Genius?
A Dumb Person?

he said his uncle work for a highschool
which means the dumb people in their early 20s that are still in highschool like Black Clover
which is not surprising at all

I had one classmate in 9th grade that was 17 years old. :^)

 

[ChocoBar9]

Is the hate for Ochako a meme? I still see ppl around forums saying she's the worst Shonen Heroine ever. While she isn't great, i honestly don't see what about her is particularly bad

Pretty much. Doesn't really help that most of the hate is unjustifiable and people are still taking that stupid poll from last year seriously.

This. Iida has been forgotten too. Hori should stop introducing new characters and start focusing in the current ones.

Iida had a moment with Aoyama in the last arc showing how much the Stain incident changed his outlook. Really he hasn't given anyone more attention the others but he really needs to do more with the cast he's got hence why people are getting impatient.

 

[DyanSon]

Is the hate for Ochako a meme? I still see ppl around forums saying she's the worst Shonen Heroine ever. While she isn't great, i honestly don't see what about her is particularly bad

She's the Traitor

 

[N0R7H]

what kinda of kids go to college when they're 15?
what kinda of dumbass is still at highschool by the time they're 20?

You know, there are also young teachers in highschool, not only students...

 

[Mammo]

You know, there are also young teachers in highschool, not only students...

he said his uncle got his data from talking to his students tho

Teacher can have conversations with there students that doesn't pertain to school you know.