Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[G_I_A]

My ranking:

1 - Dr. Stone
2 - Hungry Marie
3 - Poro
4 - U19
5 - Bokutachi wa benkyou ga dekinai!

It would be nice a contest with "badges" for people to get the positions/cancelations right or something.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

I've been trying to hold back, but I think We Can't Study is the worst serialization since Sporting Salt.

 

[WyldViolet]

1. Hungry Marie
2. DR. STONE
3. U19
4. Poro
I'll start We Never Learn if it doesn't get cancelled.

 

[Nakura]

1. Dr. Stone
2. Poro
3. Hungry Marie
4. U19
5. We Never Learn

 

[Swavey]

I've been trying to hold back, but I think We Can't Study is the worst serialization since Sporting Salt.

You are being harsh it isn't terrible.

 

[Koi Kage]

Personally my list (as of now could change once the golf manga's chapter 1 run's in the magazine)is

1. Poro
2. U19
3. We can't study
4. Dr. Stone
5. Hungry Marie

We can't study is an oddity to me I'm not the biggest fan of romance manga's in general, but I can't seem to bring myself to actually want it to get axed. I'm in no way implying that I like it it's just safe to me in terms of staying in Shounen Jump

 

[Kadir0]

1. Hungry Marie
2. Doctor Stone
3. Poro
4. U19
5. We can't learn

 

[savethecat]

For me

Dr.Stone
Poro
Hungry Marie
We Never Learn
U19

 

[Swavey]

Hey, we have the same ranking of the new series. You read my mind. Only that I rank DR Stone in 3 and U19 on 4

My opinion about Dr Stone is:

GOOD

• Boichi´s art is as good in this Jump series as it is normally on his other works. Specially the color pages, which look more like HQ wallpapers. And is good in B/W too, with the rough look, with thick lines.

MIXED

• The panelling is a little bit complicated. The contrasts sometimes make a panel not understandable.

BAD

• For as much as you say "this manga will be a smash hit, it has two good veterans", that´s bullshit once you have an entire chapter bugged down by a stupid love confession plot that seemed to be more important for the writer than the worldbuilding itself.
  
  
• And who the heck can believe that a teen turned into stone could count how many years have passed? Or how could a couple of humans be alive after so many years? Some plausibility had to be thrown out of the window. If this was a silly work, it would be good. But it´s playing it straight, so no.

It´s better than the garbage of Hungry Marie, and the art is pleasing in color, but this 1st chapter wasted its interesting premise on something that wasn´t the establishment of this new world the characters are living in. I think the next chapter will be better, but this is not that good of an impression for the first chapter.

I am not a fan of how you prematurely over critique things this is a shonen manga it will always have some flaws in its logic you won't gain anything by attempting to expose it by blowing things out of proportions.

 

[Nemesis]

For now is

1 - We can't Study
2 - Hungry Marie
3 - U19
4 - Dr Stone
5 - Poro

 

[xAsum0x]

Dr Stone
Hungry Marie
U19
Poro
We Can't Study

 

[Halloween]

Even when Dr. Stone was first announced, I knew it was going to be great. After reading it, that opinion is unchanged.

 

[Doughboy]

Dr. Stone
We Never Learn
Hungry Marie
Poro
U19

Not even gonna entertain the thought of reading a golf manga, if I wanna watch golf I'll watch prime Tiger Woods highlights on YouTube. Poro is lowkey overrated too but has good art.

 

[xAsum0x]

Nice to see varying opinions at least

 

[Doughboy]

Nice to see varying opinions at least

It's why all this is a wash lol if I went with all the opinions on this thread I would think Black Clover is the most cancerous manga ever created. Although from first glance to me it looks kinda weak but a type of series I would like I'll wait for the anime before trying the manga. Always best to go off your own opinion even if hearing others is cool.

 

[xAsum0x]

It's why all this is a wash lol if I went with all the opinions on this thread I would think Black Clover is the most cancerous manga ever created. Although from first glance to me it looks kinda weak but a type of series I would like I'll wait for the anime before trying the manga. Always best to go off your own opinion even if hearing others is cool.

I like black clover despite contrary belief. I just think it has one of the worst mcs and power creep I've read in shonen. If I thought it was horrid I wouldnt be reading it still

 

[TyVip]

I have nostalgic memory with golf manga so the last one has my interest. I used to owned/read Dan Doh!! during my childhood.

No ranking from me until I've read all 6.

 

[HIGAN0]

For me......
U19
Poro
We Never Learn
Dr.Stone
Hungry Marie

 

[Doughboy]

I like black clover despite contrary belief. I just think it has one of the worst mcs and power creep I've read in shonen. If I thought it was horrid I wouldnt be reading it still

True, that's a good way to look at it. But when people trash it idk why but I start dying . Just cause the jokes are pretty funny.

 

[xAsum0x]

It's hard not to make fun of this stuff when the MC believes never giving up is his magic and screams it whenever he needs a boost of energy