Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Leoat12]

Everything that lasts long enough in Jump invariably receives an anime, why the rush? I still have to read the manga, so let it for a while. XD

 

[Mammo]

I like how Satsuriku no Tenshi is on the list

because you know, when you think of Satsuriku no Tenshi you think of the manga adaptation and not the popular video game

 

[savethecat]

Everything that lasts long enough in Jump invariably receives an anime, why the rush? I still have to read the manga, so let it for a while. XD

*cough cough* Hinamaru Zumou

 

[G_I_A]

Everything that lasts long enough in Jump invariably receives an anime, why the rush? I still have to read the manga, so let it for a while. XD

Hinomaru Zumou is crying because of this comment.

 

[Leoat12]

*cough cough* Hinamaru Zumou

Putting sumo manga that sells nothing aside.

 

[Scruffy8642]

Everything that lasts long enough in Jump invariably receives an anime, why the rush? I still have to read the manga, so let it for a while. XD

I think you mean "everything that sells"...

 

[G_I_A]

I think you mean "everything that sells"...

For some people here sales means "nothing"... The TOC is their bread and butter.

Holy crap, my beloved Uratarou is on the list?! Way to go.

But since Fire Force is also there... I would take it with a grain of salt...

 

[Leoat12]

Sales really means nothing when it comes to survive in the magazine, but it does matter when an anime studio is looking for something to animate. They have to see if that series is merchandisable (this word even exists? XD) and Hinomaru Zumou clearly is not...

I think you mean "everything that sells"...

Read my post again, I said everything that lasts long enough.

 

[Scruffy8642]

But since Fire Force is also there... I would take it with a grain of salt...

Ive heard hate for Fire Force elsewhere, and maybe its because im not too far in it, but Ive actually really liked it so far. Started it like a week ago and was admiring how good of a job it did those first few chapters compared to the mess that has been this serialisation round (and the many series before it). Even the veterens this time didnt have that solid a start. Dunno if it went bad later or if you think it was always bad, but that was my response to it at least. Ill leave it there because this isnt the place to discuss it.

Read my post again, I said everything that lasts long enough.

It only took Jojo 25 years to get a proper one... Jaguar is crying with its 10 years. As is Rokudenashi Blues with its 9, and Rising Impact with its 3.5. And many more... Granted all those series had good sales too, so it has nothing to do with that either.

 

[G_I_A]

Ive heard hate for Fire Force elsewhere, and maybe its because im not too far in it, but Ive actually really liked it so far. Started it like a week ago and was admiring how good of a job it did those first few chapters compared to the mess that has been this serialisation round (and the many series before it). Even the veterens this time didnt have that solid a start. Dunno if it went bad later or if you think it was always bad, but that was my response to it at least. Ill leave it there because this isnt the place to discuss it.

Well I translate it since chapter 1... I think it's a "ok" series but the problem is... When we start comparing with Soul Eater there's no way that its on the same page. I think the "hate" is because of that.

 

[Mammo]

Rising Impact, Flowers of Keiji, Mr. Fullswing, Muhyo & Roji's, Rookies, Wild Half, Black Angels, Jinnai Ryuujuujutsu Butouden Majima-kun Suttobasu, Astro Kyuudan, Doberman Deka, Outer Zone ...

all of these lasted years in Jump without an anime

if you don't count ovas and movies as anime then the list will be even larger

as I'm writing this I see a lot of them are sport manga, weird how they ignored one of the most popular genres

 

[Tamil]

Everything that lasts long enough in Jump invariably receives an anime, why the rush? I still have to read the manga, so let it for a while. XD

Seikimatsu Leader Den Takeshi!! never received one and it went on for like 25 volumes. It sold well and won a Shogakukan award.

IMO HZ deserves an anime before KnY so I agree there's no need for a rush.

 

[Mammo]

Is there any point to adapting Hinomaru? I mean even if they announce it now by the time the anime starts airing the manga will be finished

 

[Tamil]

If it gets a live action then maybe lol

 

[Nakura]

What are your guys' favourite anime adaptation of a WSJ series? I think mine is Gintama.

 

[Mammo]

can't decide between the 2 HxH's adaptations

Nippon Animation need to animate more things

 

[G_I_A]

The second hiatus x hiatus adapation is pretty much the best. Madhouse is too overpowered.

 

[WyldViolet]

What are your guys' favourite anime adaptation of a WSJ series? I think mine is Gintama.

Ninku

 

[savethecat]

Yu Yu Hakusho

 

[Newkerzy]

What are your guys' favourite anime adaptation of a WSJ series? I think mine is Gintama.

If BONES produces Season 3 of MHA and throw all of their money on it, I have no doubt it will be the best WSJ adaptation ever.