Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[WyldViolet]

Everybody thinking that Shudan will be canceled and it is getting CP and extra pages? What the hell is going on? Now we have a true pushing without anything to argue about.

Haha, not that I mind the pushing. Shuudan is legit my favorite thing in Jump rn.
I'm not the fondest of our current battle lineup, but Haikyuu, Hinomaru Sumo, Robox x Lazerbeam, and Shuudan are a god tier sports lineup imo.

 

[Leoat12]

Now what they are going to cancel? Spring Weapon no. 1? Or maybe the important announcement for Isobe is that they are going to move it to Jump+ or something since they cannot get rid of it for some reason.

 

[WyldViolet]

Now what they are going to cancel? Spring Weapon no. 1? Or maybe the important announcement for Isobe is that they are going to move it to Jump+ or something since they cannot get rid of it for some reason.

C'mon dude, you know they aren't going to cancel SW#1 yet. It's gonna be Cross Account if any more get axed.
Also, you should know that Isobe is the new Jaguar.
Both are totally fine and clearly have editorial favor.

 

[ElJin]

Is there any talk of the Black Clover anime on 2chan and Japanese Twitter?
What do they think of it

Black Clover was on Japanese Twitter's Trending Topics today. I just can't prove because we can't post images directly from the phone here, but I have a printscreen.

 

[savethecat]

Black Clover was on Japanese Twitter's Trending Topics today. I just can't prove because we can't post images directly from the phone here, but I have a printscreen.

Just curious of what the overall consensus was. I don't need to actually see the post.

 

[Doughboy]

I would imagine they enjoyed it but had issues with either Asta, his voice actor, his incentous screaming, or all the above. It was gorgeous visually but it was mind-boggling why he tried so hard to ruin the episode for us anime-onlys. Manga readers saw this coming. Do people consider the side characters better than mains or not that much discrepancy? That visual had about two that caught my eye.

 

[Koi Kage]

Just curious of what the overall consensus was. I don't need to actually see the post.

There's no proof of this either but Black Clover may have also crashed Crunchrolls servers with the number of people who wanted to watch it, again no solid proof but it started having issues around when it was released on Crunchyroll so take it with a grain of salt.

 

[Nakura]

Shoseki Rankings 3/10
109. Black Clover #12
155. Black Clover #2
156. Black Clover #1
183. Black Clover #7
209. Black Clover #3
218. Black Clover #9
222. Black Clover #10
230. Black Clover #8
231. Black Clover #6
238. Black Clover #11
283. Black Clover #4
308. Black Clover #5

For the sake of comparison:
3/4/16
72. My Hero Academia #2
74. My Hero Academia #1
82. My Hero Academia #7
88. My Hero Academia #3
110. My Hero Academia #5
112. My Hero Academia #6
113. My Hero Academia #4

These are just the debut days of course, so you can't really gauge yet.

 

[TyVip]

SPring Weapon won’t get cancelled this round- i said this every round and look at it now .Almost one year anniversary.

 

[SharkBait]

Shoseki Rankings 3/10
109. Black Clover #12
155. Black Clover #2
156. Black Clover #1
183. Black Clover #7
209. Black Clover #3
218. Black Clover #9
222. Black Clover #10
230. Black Clover #8
231. Black Clover #6
238. Black Clover #11
283. Black Clover #4
308. Black Clover #5

For the sake of comparison:
3/4/16
72. My Hero Academia #2
74. My Hero Academia #1
82. My Hero Academia #7
88. My Hero Academia #3
110. My Hero Academia #5
112. My Hero Academia #6
113. My Hero Academia #4

These are just the debut days of course, so you can't really gauge yet.

BLack Clover will get to Naruto level like many of us predicted it would when the anime came out, dattebayo, believe it.

 

[ElJin]

Shoseki Rankings 3/10
109. Black Clover #12
155. Black Clover #2
156. Black Clover #1
183. Black Clover #7
209. Black Clover #3
218. Black Clover #9
222. Black Clover #10
230. Black Clover #8
231. Black Clover #6
238. Black Clover #11
283. Black Clover #4
308. Black Clover #5

For the sake of comparison:
3/4/16
72. My Hero Academia #2
74. My Hero Academia #1
82. My Hero Academia #7
88. My Hero Academia #3
110. My Hero Academia #5
112. My Hero Academia #6
113. My Hero Academia #4

These are just the debut days of course, so you can't really gauge yet.

It's really nice to see all volumes back to Oricon. I guess the real improvement in sales will happen when the fights with Kuro no Bougyuu starts (like the Magna/Asta/Noelle arc).

 

[Caiops]

Boku no Hero true boost came after 3 episodes of the anime, for now it looks like Black Clover boost is World Trigger level.

 

[tirakai]

Similarly to that I feel like we'll need to wait to see the Black Bulls before seeing what the real boost is (unless Asta's voice has already driven everyone away by then).

 

[Tanzo]

World's End Harem - 8 million downloads

Spoiler

 

[shoyoboyo]

Calling it now, Black Clover will become a million per volume seller because everyone would rather read the manga than listen to Asta screaming for 12 hours.

 

[De La Croissant]

Haikyuu and Boku no Hero have returned to the top 5 at the same time (they're even on the cover). And at the same time, RxL and TPN came out of the top 5. The conspiracy continues...

 

[ChocoBar9]

Calling it now, Black Clover will become a million per volume seller because everyone would rather read the manga than listen to Asta screaming for 12 hours.

His dialogue is just as cringey in the manga

Honestly the compilation has made be warm up to it once you realize that its really just another "tic" like most shounen MCs have. I'm sure people thought Naruto sounded annoying in Part I especially when he ended everything with "datteboyo" (Believe it) or Luffy's "shishishishi" but while those characters were voced by veterans this new guy is REALLY trying to work what's being directed of him and it shows.

 

[iceemperor]

*31852 *522623 僕

Monthly sales from sept 4 to October 1st
0904-1001
520968 *522623 僕 (Heroaca)
321388 *322576 食 (soma)
258976 *260050 約 (neverland)
116083 *116460 ゆ (yuragi)
*90954 2417757 Ｏ (OP)
*74353 **74635 Ｄ (stone)

Heroaca might show up for a 6th week just barely with around 20k.

 

[Caiops]

How well is the new volumes doing today?

 

[shoyoboyo]

Haikyuu in first is a rare sight to see, especially above One Piece. We'll need to see future ranks of MHA to make a proper judgement here, but so far this is a good sign.

His dialogue is just as cringey in the manga

Nah, it's more bearable in the manga because the last syllable isn't stretched out for 5 seconds every time.