Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Nemesis]

I remember that. Oda has more power than an anime of 22 episodes.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 2, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 2, 2017 ---

About BnHA, I was reading Blue Flag, from the creator of Cross Manage, and I saw this page:

Very comfy romance. Better than Nisekoi and WNL, btw.

Spoiler

I'm just playing with you guys. But it's really a nice read.

I also read this and it's really good but also different in that it's more of a romance/drama than Nisekoi/WNL that are a romcom.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 3, 2017 ---

I would like to see MHA do a crossover comic with Marvel, where the Marvel heroes are the American heroes in MHA's universe, and MHA characters are the Japanese heroes in the Marvel universe.

Obviously would be just for fun, and non canon. but the crazy thing is, this could probably actually make sense in the canon story of both franchises.


Edit: well it wouldn't make sense in Marvel universe because they don't live in a world where everyone has superpowers. So forget that. But it would still be a extremely fun crossover.

Would also be a great idea for a MHA animated film(if BONES ever does one). I know there's a lot of licenses involved, but I feel like Shuiesha and Disney could really make a crossover film happen if someone on either side brought the idea to the table.

Avengers had a crossover with Shingeki no Kyojin years ago so I don't doubt that some day this could happen

 

[Aipom626]

Shudan's chance of survival continues to be dangerously low as Volume 1 was ranked at #46 on honto's daily ranking, it was not in Tsutaya's top 20 for 11/2 and it was in the low 30s on Bunkyodo's real-time ranking in the evening Japan time and ranged from 30 to 40 during the day. Tsutaya, honto, etc are some of the biggest suppliers of Jump comics and their individual daily and weekly rankings have been really close with Shoseki and Oricon rankings. If these are the first day results, there is little chance that it will suddenly shoot up unless there is some sudden TV/radio promotion. The chance that it might show up in the top 50 on the weekly chart is also rather low at this point.

It'll be interesting to see if this or Cross Account sells more. Both seem like they'll be in great jeopardy once more stuff begins getting serialized. In regards to Spring Weapon, do people think it will last for more or less chapters than Samon?

 

[Tanzo]

延期
1/4　→　2月
彼方のアストラ　5

2/2
僕のヒーローアカデミア 17 400
食戟のソーマ 28 400
フルドライブ 1 400
ハイキュー！！ 30 400
ゴーレムハーツ 1 400
トマトイプーのリコピン 1 400
Ｄｒ.ＳＴＯＮＥ 4 400
ぼくたちは勉強ができない 5 400
シューダン！ 3 400
魔女の怪画集 1 438
左ききのエレン 2 400
サマータイムレンダ 1 400
彼方のアストラ 5 438
貧民超人カネナシくん 3 550
路地裏バンチ 2 400
カラダ探し 17 400
エルドライブ【elDLIVE】 9 619
心臓に杭を打ちつけて 2 400
スライムライフ 2 514
終末のハーレム 5 580
れっつ！ハイキュー!? 5 350
さぐりちゃん探検隊　1 438
ヴィジランテ-僕のヒーローアカデミアILLEGALS- 3 438

February 2nd Volume Releases:
Haikyuu!! #30
Shokugeki no Soma #28
My Hero Academia #17
We Never Learn #5
Dr. Stone #4
Shudan! #3
Full Drive #1
Golem Hearts #1
Tomatoypoo no Lycopene #1

Jump+:
Karada Sagashi #17
eIDLIVE #9
Astra Lost in Space #5
World's End Harem #5
Let's! Haikyuu?! #5
Hinmin Choujin Kanenashi-kun #3
Vigilante -MHA Illegals- #3
Hidarikiki no Eren #2
Rojiura Bunch #2
Slime Life #2
Drive a Stake Into the Heart #2
Summertime Render #1
Saguri-chan Tankentai #1

 

[Mammo]

Shudan's chance of survival continues to be dangerously low as Volume 1 was ranked at #46 on honto's daily ranking, it was not in Tsutaya's top 20 for 11/2 and it was in the low 30s on Bunkyodo's real-time ranking in the evening Japan time and ranged from 30 to 40 during the day. Tsutaya, honto, etc are some of the biggest suppliers of Jump comics and their individual daily and weekly rankings have been really close with Shoseki and Oricon rankings. If these are the first day results, there is little chance that it will suddenly shoot up unless there is some sudden TV/radio promotion. The chance that it might show up in the top 50 on the weekly chart is also rather low at this point.

its chances of survival was already super low due to its horrible rankings so I'm no too sad
what's interesting about the ranking is Aisareru yori ￮-saretai which have been in Jump Plus top 5 list since it started publishing is no where to be found on any ranking list
on the other hand another Plus title, Yamcha Reincarnation is doing super well, might be the most successful Plus title since Harem of the End

February 2nd Volume Releases:
Haikyuu!! #30
Shokugeki no Soma #28
My Hero Academia #17
We Never Learn #5
Dr. Stone #4
Shudan! #3
Full Drive #1
Golem Hearts #1
Tomatoypoo no Lycopene #1

Jump+:
Karada Sagashi #17
eIDLIVE #9
Astra Lost in Space #5
World's End Harem #5
Let's! Haikyuu?! #5
Hinmin Choujin Kanenashi-kun #3
Vigilante -MHA Illegals- #3
Hidarikiki no Eren #2
Rojiura Bunch #2
Slime Life #2
Drive a Stake Into the Heart #2
Summertime Render #1
Saguri-chan Tankentai #1

Saguri-chan and Render are releasing the same day as BnHA, I see what you are trying to do there Shuiesha

 

[Tamil]

 

[Halloween]

I see Toriko, and now I'm interested. What does this say?!

 

[Leoat12]

We already talked about it here as far as I remember, JUMP REMIX is cheap edition made for convenience stores. It is good for warm you during the winter, but not to read the manga properly. hahah

 

[iceemperor]

its chances of survival was already super low due to its horrible rankings so I'm no too sad
what's interesting about the ranking is Aisareru yori ￮-saretai which have been in Jump Plus top 5 list since it started publishing is no where to be found on any ranking list
on the other hand another Plus title, Yamcha Reincarnation is doing super well, might be the most successful Plus title since Harem of the End



Saguri-chan and Render are releasing the same day as BnHA, I see what you are trying to do there Shuiesha

Yamcha Reincarnation's art and artist are being praised as being close to peak Toriyama back during serialization due to how close the art style is. Its a really unexpected hit.

It is interesting that Horikoshi's master and assistant(?) are having volume releases on the same day as Heroaca. It would be nice to see Horikoshi draw a sketch commemorating their volume releases though you have to wonder how Tanaka feels seeing his former assistant selling more than he probably ever has (and maybe will) in a span of 3 years and continue to sell tens of times more. Its a rather interesting aspect of Jump. Make it big and you can sell millions.

 

[SharkBait]

We already talked about it here as far as I remember, JUMP REMIX is cheap edition made for convenience stores. It is good for warm you during the winter, but not to read the manga properly. hahah

I think its a good way to support the author of series one may be on the fence of.

 

[iceemperor]

※｢シューダン！1」の初版は約4万部（推測値）
※「DRAGON BALL外伝 転生したらヤムチャだった件」の初版は約10万部（推測値）

Shudan Vol 1's first print in approximately 40k whereas Yamcha reincarnation vol 1's first print is approximately 100k. Keep in mind these are estimates by the person that puts out Shoseki but they have been rather accurate in the past.

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

※｢シューダン！1」の初版は約4万部（推測値）
※「DRAGON BALL外伝 転生したらヤムチャだった件」の初版は約10万部（推測値）

Shudan Vol 1's first print in approximately 40k whereas Yamcha reincarnation vol 1's first print is approximately 100k. Keep in mind these are estimates by the person that puts out Shoseki but they have been rather accurate in the past.

The new One Piece is coming ...

This can only be a joke.
If this Yamcha manga appears in the Oricon selling over 50k, I will rethink my existence.
LoL

 

[Leoat12]

It is Dragon Ball... For some reason I don't know yet, everything that they throw on the fans, still sell well.
Gonna sell 100k and get a reprint.

 

[iceemperor]

The new One Piece is coming ...

This can only be a joke.
If this Yamcha manga appears in the Oricon selling over 50k, I will rethink my existence.
LoL

Its above Platinum End, Yuragi and Twin Star Exorcists for the first day and seems like it might stay that way for the second day and most likely the weekly sales as well. I can definitely see it doing at least 50k first week and ranking for at least 3 weeks at this rate.

 

[Mammo]

what's interesting about the ranking is Aisareru yori ￮-saretai which have been in Jump Plus top 5 list since it started publishing is no where to be found on any ranking list

I thought this will be like Aharen-san or Shuukyoku Engage, something that debut around the 40th place before dropping out of the top 50

but nope!

233 9784088812663 愛されるより〇されたい　１ 集英社 ユーキあきら 2017.11.2


one the other hand, Mone-san did debut around the 40th place

 

[Doughboy]

Chp 2: https://jaiminisbox.com/reader/read/golem-hearts/en/0/2/page/1

Spoiler

On God if Jump doesn't let this one survive I'm fucking done.... it was simply great. It was chilling when you saw the death of the master while charming cause Noah's archetype works for him wanting to be helpful and the best. All getting left off with a great cliffhanger with the heroine.

 

[Mammo]

Chp 2: https://jaiminisbox.com/reader/read/golem-hearts/en/0/2/page/1

On God if Jump doesn't let this one survive I'm fucking done.... it was simply great.

Spoiler

It was chilling when you saw the death of the master while charming cause Noah's archetype works for him wanting to be helpful and the best. All getting left off with a great cliffhanger with the heroine.

^use the spoiler tag buddy

Spoiler

I still think it's generic and predictable so it really haven't grabbed me yet, the pacing for this chapter was all over the place too
anyway, I don't think the master is dead yet, the new girl is probably a healer

 

[TM2]

Certainly better paced than the last chapter.

Spoiler

Though while I thought it had more impact than chapter 1. I don't think that Lamech had enough development to kill off yet. Which made the scene feel emotionally manipulative. Just a bit though. Then again I probably need to take into account that this is still shonen jump magazine and Golem Heart's ultimate fate is still in the air so the author might be trying to speed things along to get to material that will appeal to the most readers.

 

[ShenGao]

I thought it was worse than the first chapter.

Spoiler

What's the point of a level 5 golem arts spell being high class if people with zero skill can use it? And Lamech's "did Noah inherit his skill from him" comment already paves the way for Noah to be some special snowflake whose creator is some golem arts god or something like that, although it contradicts the very first page of the very first chapter which showed that Lamech is Noah's creator.

 

[shoyoboyo]

Spoiler: Golem hearts

I doubt that he would contradict Lamech creating him in the first chapter. This isn't Kubo lol. It's probably more like Lamech had used a human as some sort of "base" for Noah to be created.

I do think things are going too fast though. When Lamech died I thought "wait what really?" It was pretty out of nowhere. Actually, I don't think Lamech is dead yet. Not with that girl just arriving.

 

[Doughboy]

Lol my bad, was being a hypebeast . See what you mean though but nothing outright bad has happened so far and that’s an accomplishment for me. What I wanted to see occurred so I’m content, once they get off the island and start traveling it’ll pick up for others. If not rip