Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[cody]

the staff wasn't revealed yet?
I tought it was.

It was proven to be fake. We know absolutely nothing about the staff at the moment...

 

[nonowa]

Neverland is probably getting the big reveal on Chapter 100.

 

[Xzone]

It was proven to be fake. We know absolutely nothing about the staff at the moment...

Yeah , I kew the clover's one was fake but I thought that it was revealed.
My bad.

Ah, were they jokes?

Usually the jokes make you laugh .....

I laughed at this joke(other user too) but you take it seriously and you become salty because people say to you "calm down, it was a joke".

For some reason I can't see Naruto as Horikoshi's favorite character. For me it was an editorial need.

Spoiler

Editor-in-chief: Who's going to stand next to Asta on the cover?
Editor: Hiei.
Editor-in-chief: C'mon man, why not Yusuke? Is Tabata a fujo?
Editor: I-I don't know.
Editor-in-chief: Whatever, who did Furudate choose?
Editor: Cascade.
Editor-in-chief: Who?
Editor: It's the horse from Mi-
Editor-in-chief: A horse? A fucking horse?! Remind me to cancel Haikyuu!! tomorrow.
Editor: Haikyuu!! sells 800k.
Editor-in-chief: Oh, hehe, forget what I said. Posuka-chan now.
Editor: Talulu from Magical Talulu-kun.
Editor-in-chief: You got to be kidding me!
Editor: Pixiv artists are weird, boss.
Editor-in-chief: Yeah, and she'll be weird on the back cover as punishment. Next!
Editor: Horikoshi chose Rock Lee.
Editor-in-chief: No.
Editor: What?
Editor-in-chief: He's going to draw Naruto.
Editor: But h-
Editor-in-chief: No 'but'. It's an anniversary cover, we need iconic main characters, so it's going to be the damn Naruto.
Editor: I'll ask him to sleep an hour instead of two and redo the drawing.
Editor-in-chief: Do it. What about Oda?
Editor: Goku.
Editor-in-chief: See? That's good sense. Oooooook, now let's talk about the new series. I think JUMP MILLION MASTERS X is a good name to promote them, what do you think?

You can like BC but relax, dude.

And what, if I allowed myself to know?

All of them(in this discussion at least) lol, even in the last post you make.

I can overthrow you, if BC were debuted ten years ago, maybe he would have sold as much as Reborn and by the standard of the era would have been considered in the middle band ....

You can't "overthrow me" . You were the one who are making up those excuses to dimiss reborn sales, I'm only saying that can't say that because it's a hypotesis without proof.
You're only talking about "if" and we are saying to you that the "if" means nothing but you still don't let it go...
I don't care if you "overthrow me" but before that, read what's is the topic we are talking and what you said before...

Because it is not a personal opinion, but a fact that the genre of Reborn is due to external pressures.

Dragon ball also have a genre shift, and he also return to fights in the middle of buu saga because external pressures.

God, I don't care if you see that you're full of shit in this one, but don't act allmighty with reborn and then go to post that "all people hate BC and are saying it isn't sucess", it's hypocrite (or a very bad bait)

 

[Doughboy]

I'm not sure if he actually attends the concerts but I know this is like his 3rd known time sending flowers to them lol. We're all fanboys over something.

idk too much about idol groups or even ever dated an asian for that matter but majority of them are pretty from what I've seen:

I wonder what an old married dude like Togashi finds in young girls singing lol

 

[OfficialHxH]

idk too much about idol groups or even ever dated an asian for that matter but majority of them are pretty from what I've seen:

I wonder what an old married dude like Togashi finds in young girls singing lol

Lol to each its own I guess. All the Keyakizaka46 references he puts in Hunter x Hunter though is crazy lol

 

[Xzone]

idk too much about idol groups or even ever dated an asian for that matter but majority of them are pretty from what I've seen:

I wonder what an old married dude like Togashi finds in young girls singing lol

Next HxH characters to appear in this arc, lol.

 

[WyldViolet]

Those who don't know don't know they don't know.
Also, as baffling as his posts always are, I feel it's a little unfair to just all gang up on Ice King. He's clearly in his early teens so his logic and behavior is rather understandable.

 

[Franz]

Also, as baffling as his posts always are, I feel it's a little unfair to just all gang up on Ice King. He's clearly in his early teens so his logic and behavior is rather understandable.

Hahhahha, what a nice guy, really ...

I'm 25.

Do you know what would be really mature?

To dialogue instead of insulting and provoking, but evidently it is easier this way.

 

[Doughboy]

Those who don't know don't know they don't know.
Also, as baffling as his posts always are, I feel it's a little unfair to just all gang up on Ice King. He's clearly in his early teens so his logic and behavior is rather understandable.

what? he's older than me lol. that's besides the point, the crazy thing is nobody is bashing BC or even saying its a failure during this whole argument. Ice King has his views, if they're wrong they're wrong but he's not budging on listening to what others say which is where the problem is. Too many hypotheticals can misplace the truth, that's what I dislike

 

[Franz]

laughed at this joke(other user too) but you take it seriously and you become salty because people say to you "calm down, it was a joke".

Again, jokes are funny usually...

You can like BC but relax, dude.

Aaaaaaaannnnnddddddd ......

What the hell has to do with it?

All of them(in this discussion at least) lol, even in the last post you make.

Explain.

You were the one who are making up those excuses to dimiss reborn sales

And when?

But if I do nothing but say that in 2008 it was in fourth place in the most sold manga ....

 

[Doughboy]

Idk anything about reborn so I can't speak on there but you're using "eras" to say BC will be better. Wouldn't every manga be better back then? How much would Neverland and MHA sell 5-10 years ago? You're being unfair on your part with this argument, you're not taking everything into consideration with all the redeeming facts people are providing you and instead are trying to conform misplaced facts and hypotheticals to suit your goal. You didn't even say anything to Sharkbait's 60% digital number is exactly what I mean but when people mentioned that once the anime stops running things can fall off and decline you replied. How can you possibly argue with someone like that.

 

[WyldViolet]

Hahhahha, what a nice guy, really ...

I'm 25.

Do you know what would be really mature?

To dialogue instead of insulting and provoking, but evidently it is easier this way.

You're my age?
Oh.
I wasn't trying to be insulting or provoke. I was giving you the benefit of the doubt.

 

[Xzone]

Aaaaaaaannnnnddddddd ......

What the hell has to do with it?

Explain.

And when?

You're talking for like, 3/4 pages about this because someone talk about BC sales.And you have a historial of claiming other to share a proof to his argument (and you did it again) but when you are doing the same,(don't posting proof to hold the BC/reborn hipotesys), it's good for you.
You need to calm down, dude.

Reborn is just a manga in the average. Only having debuted at other times has sell more than other manga in today's average.

Is Black clover a manga in the average who debuted in the perfect time to not be axed like Iron knight? Is the same and you are not undertanding it.

And, if you're serious about all this, It can't be helped.But if you are pretending to be retarded to bait people, you're bad at it, learn from sharkbait, he's better baiting people and he's funny.

 

[WyldViolet]

Again, jokes are funny usually...

...everybody else seemed to grasp that they were jokes and thought they were funny.

Anyways. This shit is so off topic and all these posts are going to get deleted. Can we end this before bans start getting dropped? I quite like it here and don't want any of us to go anywhere.

 

[Doughboy]

Yeah I agree, better to leave it there. The topic was interesting but it's going nowhere. BC is a success but things halted its growth when comparing to others.

Nobody posted any color pages other from food wars?

 

[Xzone]

Yeah, better change the topic.
What rookie author did you thinks that should return to do a battle shonen? Or a spokon? Or a rom-com?

 

[WyldViolet]

Yeah, better change the topic.
What rookie author did you thinks that should return to do a battle shonen? Or a spokon? Or a rom-com?

Yeah, better change the topic.
What rookie author did you thinks that should return to do a battle shonen? Or a spokon? Or a rom-com?

I want Gen Osuka, Moue, Takayama, and Utsumi back for battle shonen.

 

[Franz]

You're talking for like, 3/4 pages about this because someone talk about BC sales.

I still do not understand where I would try to minimize or diminish the sales of Reborn, but oh well .....

s Black clover a manga in the average

Er, yes ....

everybody else seemed to grasp that they were jokes and thought they were funny.

Fun is subjective ....

I personally did not find them funny, but not even a little ....

But if you are pretending to be retarded to bait people,

Still with the insults and provocations free, very mature .....

I do not understand where you see I'm pretending to be retarded, but everyone sees what he wants to see I guess ...

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 26, 2018, Original Post Date: Jul 26, 2018 ---

Wouldn't every manga be better back then? How much would Neverland and MHA sell 5-10 years ago?

Sure, and who is denying it?

 

[WyldViolet]

*sigh* not to draw this out further, just to offer some advice.
If you don't like a joke or a post can't you just ignore it rather than hijack the direction of the thread every day?

 

[Xzone]

I want Gen Osuka, Moue, Takayama, and Utsumi back for battle shonen.

Utsumi and Moue were pretty cool, I think the later can have a hit with any genre , he only need a set-up who attract people and a good editor.
I think Osuka needs a writter , maybe tsukuda?(I know is not very liked , but maybe writing knowning what you write will help him unlike with football or cooking).