Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Neala897]

Obviously ne0lation and Higuma are ending, with Souma and flopping gags untouched.

If David really coming out alive its nothing short but a miracle. Which made me wonder if the reason might be popularity among western readers

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

 

[CuriousReborn]

Think OP is getting the lead CP for the double issue

 

[revo68]

Think OP is getting the lead CP for the double issue

Correct

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

This is going to be a strange year:
-Kishimoto is back
-Shibashi is back
-Shokugeki is ending
-Neverland and Kimetsu are warping up for ending
-Dr.Stone, WNL, Yuuna-san, Hinomaru, and even Black Clover have given symptoms that if not now, they could also end soon.
-There are big chances for Shimabukuro, Amano, Shuichi Aso, and Kenta Shinohara to be also back
-There is also the possible serialization of Count Over or whatever, but Masaoki Shindou is getting something serialized.
-Kimetsu managed to do what Fate or SAO weren't able: LiSA and Yuki Kajiura together in a song
-One Piece could be in the third-to-last arc for ending (still, each arc lasts 100-120 chapters, so 3 arcs can last 5 years).

Yep, feels like new era is coming. Meanwhile, is surprising how Haikyuu isn't affected by the wave (well, let's wait until this current tournament is over to see). Hero Academia is also going to be longer, but that's not as surprising, since it has already became the main face of Shonen Jump (when we don't count One Piece).

 

[savethecat]

Wonder is the 2nd new series is from a veteran or just from a rookie they’re confident in

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Personal bet: a rookie. I don't see Shindou coming until Summer at least.

 

[Kave]

"Kimetsu warping up for ending"

Ah yes, my favorite meme

 

[Jovan]

This is going to be a strange year:
-Kishimoto is back
-Shibashi is back
-Shokugeki is ending
-Neverland and Kimetsu are warping up for ending
-Dr.Stone, WNL, Yuuna-san, Hinomaru, and even Black Clover have given symptoms that if not now, they could also end soon.
-There are big chances for Shimabukuro, Amano, Shuichi Aso, and Kenta Shinohara to be also back
-There is also the possible serialization of Count Over or whatever, but Masaoki Shindou is getting something serialized.
-Kimetsu managed to do what Fate or SAO weren't able: LiSA and Yuki Kajiura together in a song
-One Piece could be in the third-to-last arc for ending (still, each arc lasts 100-120 chapters, so 3 arcs can last 5 years).

Yep, feels like new era is coming. Meanwhile, is surprising how Haikyuu isn't affected by the wave (well, let's wait until this current tournament is over to see). Hero Academia is also going to be longer, but that's not as surprising, since it has already became the main face of Shonen Jump (when we don't count One Piece).

Seeing how poor the reception to Kamio Yui is, Shibashi will be quickly out of the magazine again, so I find his return completely buzzless and unworthy to mention.
Black Clover has not given a single symptom of ending so far. This one will go on and on, and they can always pull the Naruto Shippuden like timeskip for it.
Wait, Shokugeki was announced to end?

 

[CuriousReborn]

poor the reception to Kamio Yui

Do we even know how the two new series are being received in Japan?

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 17, 2019, Original Post Date: Apr 17, 2019 ---

Also, weekly sales are up and will post them in a minute or two



129218 *443078 Haikyuu
*60178 *177447 Black Clover
*56910 *188027 DBS
*55207 *158370 Soma
*52676 *159717 KnY
*29301 **74646 Boys Over Flowers
*28748 **91845 WNL
*24867 1839324 OP
*24037 **73893 Dr. Stone
*21572 **70437 Yuuna
-
*12521 *486499 Neverland
**9884 *276195 KnY1
**8903 *199701 KnY14
**8779 *260566 KnY2

 

[Jovan]

Do we even know how the two new series are being received in Japan?

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 17, 2019, Original Post Date: Apr 17, 2019 ---

Also, weekly sales are up and will post them in a minute or two



129218 *443078 Haikyuu
*60178 *177447 Black Clover
*56910 *188027 DBS
*55207 *158370 Soma
*52676 *159717 KnY
*28748 **91845 WNL
*24867 1839324 OP
*24037 **73893 Dr. Stone
*21572 **70437 Yuuna
-
*12521 *486499 Neverland
**9884 *276195 KnY1
**8903 *199701 KnY14
**8779 *260566 KnY2

Saw some people were saying it had no buzz and was not liked much. What I do guess is that Kamio Yui will get a Color Page for Chapter 8-9 (like Gakkyuu Hotei and Hungry Marie), will poll well at the beginning (just like Shibashi previous work, because of the author) and then be cancelled around 28+ chapters.

Seems like Kimetsu got that 30k+ anime boost for sales. Last volume did 126k in 10 days (this volume was 159k in 11 days)

 

[DyanSon]

You know, for how popular MHA(school battle shonen) is no one sure try to copy it. I mean there's like 3 demon slaying battle shonen(KnY,CM,Jujutsu Kaisen) in Jump right now and all three of those is nowhere near close with pre-anime MHA.

 

[MangAniMY]

I hate the forum doesn't allow directly pasting image over here anymore...

anyway, chart thread on twitter with comment, but I'll still just post the images here

Spoiler: twitter

HQ

BC

Souma

KNY

WNL

Stone

Yuuna

 

[Jovan]

You know, for how popular MHA(school battle shonen) is no one sure try to copy it. I mean there's like 3 demon slaying battle shonen(KnY,CM,Jujutsu Kaisen) in Jump right now and all three of those is nowhere near close with pre-anime MHA.

No school battle shonen? How dare you disrespect a proclaimed by Jump as supernatural battle manga Kamio Yui?? (/s obviously)

 

[SharkBait]

You know, for how popular MHA(school battle shonen) is no one sure try to copy it. I mean there's like 3 demon slaying battle shonen(KnY,CM,Jujutsu Kaisen) in Jump right now and all three of those is nowhere near close with pre-anime MHA.

Dont really know what youre asking, as why would you want a HeroAca clone?

KnY, CM, and Jujutsu are so different from each other

 

[DyanSon]

Dont really know what youre asking, as why would you want a HeroAca clone?

KnY, CM, and Jujutsu are so different from each other

But they all demon slaying battle shonen right? Just like i said SCHOOL battle shonen which MHA is.

 

[SharkBait]

But they all demon slaying battle shonen right? Just like i said SCHOOL battle shonen which MHA is.

but theyre all different, one is a time period piece, another is a psuedo-school/academy thing, and the final is an adultish out in the world private business thing.

 

[DyanSon]

but theyre all different, one is a time period piece, another is a psuedo-school/academy thing, and the final is an adultish out in the world private business thing.

But they slaying demon right?

 

[tirakai]

Jujutsu's a school battle shounen.

 

[DyanSon]

Jujutsu's a school battle shounen.

It's more of a demon slaying than a school battle shonen.