Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[CuriousReborn]

Its not disturbing though, this just doesn't appeal to me nor do I find it funny. Maybe if I was 10 years younger.

 

[Jovan]

I have seen worse things than what just happened in Chainsaw Man, meh. Guess I read too much crazy shit for the relatively tame puke kiss to make an impression.

 

[Thundercat27]

Its not disturbing though, this just doesn't appeal to me nor do I find it funny. Maybe if I was 10 years younger.

Did you misread "shounen" in this magazine name?
Maybe you are indeed to old to comprehend that.

 

[101nemesis]

Why are people complaining about a chapter from a series they don't read?
Yeah, its disgusting but who the fuck cares? If it appeals to the fanbase who dig that sort of humor and that's doing well for the series then why does it matter to you, a person who isn't reading the series?

Half the people whining about this CM chapter didn't complain about this Gintama chapter which should fall under their description of "disgusting".

Spoiler: Poop

 

[CuriousReborn]

Did you misread "shounen" in this magazine name?
Maybe you are indeed to old to comprehend that.

Maybe you are indeed to old to comprehend that based on current data most of jump readers are 18+ and above. No need to get butthurt because I dont like a manga, its not like I told you dont read it or it is bad.

 

[Tarot]

Its not disturbing though, this just doesn't appeal to me nor do I find it funny. Maybe if I was 10 years younger.

Good thing this is serialized in a shounen magazine then.

Maybe you are indeed to old to comprehend that based on current data most of jump readers are teenagers and above. No need to get butthurt because I dont like a manga, its not like I told you dont read it or it is bad.

Good thing Denji is a teenager and the rest of the characters are adults. Someone will likely find them relatable.

 

[savethecat]

Comedy is subjective but how is puking in someone's mouth considered as comedy? The way it's presented it looked like some disgusting fetish than for comedy. I've seen gross humor before but this aint it. Y'all better stop reaching lmfao

It’s not my thing, but I don’t see how it isn’t comedy.
There are people who watch Jackass, which is an entire series that involves people hurting themselves and doing gross stuff.
Pretty much anything can be comedy

Also, as people said, the joke isn’t the puke itself. You have to read the series weekly.

Denji is a character who’s only goal is to get with woman. He wants to make out with girls. He wants to get laid.
Everytime he gets lucky and gets something he wants, he gets fucked over in the worst possible way.
In the latest arc Denji’s motivation in defeating the devil was that he would get to kiss this girl after beating it.
In this chapter he’s rewarded with his kiss, but gets puked in the mouth instead

 

[CuriousReborn]

Good thing this is serialized in a shounen magazine then.

Good thing Denji is a teenager and the rest of the characters are adults. Someone will likely find them relatable.

I literally said I'm not the audience for this Manga and I'm well aware that this is a shonen magazine. I said I don't like it and that I didn't find it funny, that's it. I didn't say it doesn't belong to the magazine or that should be canceled. I have no idea what point you are even trying to make here. This is the first time I even talked about Chainsaw Man and probably the last time to.

 

[Thundercat27]

Maybe you are indeed to old to comprehend that based on current data most of jump readers are 18+ and above. No need to get butthurt because I dont like a manga, its not like I told you dont read it or it is bad.

I am perfectly fine with you not reading that manga. It is just hilarious when you used ''too immature'' argument while talking about a manga in a magazine targeting young people.

About your statistic. Yes, ton of people over 18 reading this magazine (myself included). But I read it because jump is a magazine specifically designed for young people. If I want something mature, or tailor toward the "too old for this" demographic, I would choose a seinen magazine instead.

 

[CuriousReborn]

I am perfectly fine with you not reading that manga. It is just hilarious when you used ''too immature'' argument while talking about a manga in a magazine targeting young people.

Well yeah boob jokes are not for me anymore, nor is ecchi or most of jump "romance" from recent years and I dont expect seinen because I know what kind of magazine this is. I read shonen manga because I love adventure, action, stories of hardwork, flashy weird names for special moves or sometimes even some edgy stuff if im feeling it, Its why I read shonen jump, me liking it doesn't mean its mature. As for the ecchi or "humor" they are not for me since more often than not I just roll my eyes whenever I see anything similar and that is perfectly fine, glad that I gave you a laugh though.

 

[Tarot]

Lol Chainsawman has less boob joke or ecchi than most of the stories in the magazine that are about adventure or stories of hardwork like BC, BnHA, Naruto, Bleach, One Piece.

 

[henry9960]

Lol Chainsawman has less boob joke or ecchi than most of the stories in the magazine that are about adventure or stories of hardwork like BC, BnHA, Naruto, Bleach, One Piece.

I enjoy CSM and that's definitely not true lol, his whole motivation for the first 20 chapters was to grab boobs or get a kiss

 

[MangAniMY]

Gintama 702 now available in the app (32 pages)

next chapter on May 27th

 

[Tarot]

I enjoy CSM and that's definitely not true lol, his whole motivation for the first 20 chapters was to grab boobs or get a kiss

Uh hello? Vanessa is a walking fanservice in Black Clover. Early Naruto was pulling pranks with Sexy Jutsu and had Jiraiya being a complete pervert. The entire reason Mineta even exists in MHA is to make sexual harassment jokes. My mind's blanking out on Bleach at the moment but I recall some boob joke involving Orihime.

 

[xAsum0x]

Lol Chainsawman has less boob joke or ecchi than most of the stories in the magazine that are about adventure or stories of hardwork like BC, BnHA, Naruto, Bleach, One Piece.

The MC's entire goal for the first portion of the series is to grope some chicks chest lol. You can like this weird shit but dont protray it to be stuff it isnt

 

[Tarot]

The MC's entire goal for the first portion of the series is to grope some chicks chest lol. You can like this weird shit but dont protray it to be stuff it isnt

Thanks fam. I've read Chainsawman too. My point is the padded boob joke involving Power didn't last for a few chapters whereas the examples I listed in my previous post have existed throughout the series despite supposedly being about hardwork or adventure. It's weird seeing so much contempt for CSM as if it's the only series in the magazine guilty of it.

 

[xAsum0x]

Thanks fam. I've read Chainsawman too. My point is the padded boob joke involving Power didn't last for a few chapters whereas the examples I listed in my previous post existed throughout the series despite being about hardwork or adventure. It's weird seeing so much contempt for CSM as if it's the only series in the magazine guilty of it.

No other series has a MC with such a immature boring goal and a chapter where a chick pukes in the MCs mouth and he swallows it. Can you really not see the difference? If you think its funny thats fine but its funny you guys are acting like this is just normal and ppl are overreacting

 

[Halloween]

No other series has a MC with such a immature boring goal

So yeah, you don't actually understand the series at all. Most detractors don't, I've noticed.

Denji lived in complete poverty, where he literally had to sell his eyeball, testicle, and other non-essential organs just to barely make end's meat.

He nearly lost his mind initially eating toast with jelly on it, because he had never had anything that delicious before. Denji's goals only seem boring if you don't understand the message the author is portraying.

He wants people to enjoy being human, to enjoy the small things in life that most take for granted.

 

[xAsum0x]

So yeah, you don't actually understand the series at all. Most detractors don't, I've noticed.

"You dont agree with me and like something I like so you dont understand the series

 

[Tarot]

No other series has a MC with such a immature boring goal and a chapter where a chick pukes in the MCs mouth and he swallows it. Can you really not see the difference? If you think its funny thats fine but its funny you guys are acting like this is just normal and ppl are overreacting

Do you expect an illiterate 17 year old teenager that has been treated like an animal their entire life and betrayed in the end to have some kind of generic goal like every other MC in the magazine? You're also missing my point in the previous post but I'll stop right here. Thread's already a mess and there's no point in continuing this discussion with someone consistently missing the point.