Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[SharkBait]

I'm talking about the comedy manga on the jump.
and I do not remember another gag that debuted along with saike kusuo, sorry.
Also not the reason to keep hinomaru zumou, but the manga continues to this day. There are manga that remain in the magazine even not selling well, which does not hurt since most sell.

--- Double Post Merged, May 13, 2019, Original Post Date: May 13, 2019 ---

Beautiful character designs. All look like winners. Stoked.

 

[savethecat]

That's what the companies want, not necessarily what Kishimoto wants.

My point is, if this was the case, and companies wanted him to come back with a weekly series, getting another artist was likely his compromise

 

[Xzone]

I only see Samurai 8 as monthly if they send Boruto to V-Jump/Jump SQ or ended it.

 

[cody]

I only see Samurai 8 as monthly if they send Boruto to V-Jump/Jump SQ or ended it.

They can both be in WSJ, they would both have their monthly chapters but in different weeks.

It would be nice if we knew already if it's weekly or not.

 

[101nemesis]

Or you know, maybe Kishimoto himself wanted a weekly schedule. It's not far fetched to think that he missed working like how he did during serialization. He might just be a workaholic who loves doing what he does.

 

[tirakai]

The Samurai 8 going monthly thing will just be another dumb youtube rumour, they happen a lot when popular series/writers are concerned. Like how every half a year they all convince themselves the Bleach anime is coming back.

 

[cody]

The Samurai 8 going monthly thing will just be another dumb youtube rumour, they happen a lot when popular series/writers are concerned. Like how every half a year they all convince themselves the Bleach anime is coming back.

One of the main reasons why I considered it to be an option is because Kishimoto said he wanted it to be monthly back when the manga was initially being teased in 2015, at least that's how I remember things. It's been a while since then and it's most likely weekly since they haven't really teased it to be monthly or anything like that.

 

[Xzone]

The Samurai 8 going monthly thing will just be another dumb youtube rumour, they happen a lot when popular series/writers are concerned. Like how every half a year they all convince themselves the Bleach anime is coming back.

It's speculation because releasing the first volume in october makes no sense, not because youtuber talking.

Samurai 8 1st volume will be out finaly october 4 (and not august 2). Perhaps serie will became monthly after 2nd chapter.

Until october 4 :
-if serie is weekly, will be have 20 chapters (so around 465 pages so 2/3 volumes).
-if monthly, will have 6 chapters for around 225 pages (logicaly 4 first chapter will be in 1st volume).

If serie continue in weekly, make no sens to out 1st volume so late.

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

I read again the first chapter of Samurai 8, it is very good.
Samurai 8, Kamio Yui and Chainsaw are the best series released this year so far.

Btw, Beast Children has a good art.
Is seems more promising than several manga that were released this year.

 

[Stivie]

I read again the first chapter of Samurai 8, it is very good.
Samurai 8, Kamio Yui and Chainsaw are the best series released this year so far.

Btw, Beast Children has a good art.
Is seems more promising than several manga that were released this year.

Did he stop complaining about the nakano for nothing?
In addition, it is not possible to know if beast children survive only by art.

 

[SharkBait]

Not really liking Sam8.

Will assume the 7 others will be more likeable.

Would have been better if like BLack Clover the kid stayed handicapped.

 

[OtterBrigade]

Not sure how you can make that judgement when we haven't seen him fight in his current state

 

[SharkBait]

Not sure how you can make that judgement when we haven't seen him fight in his current state

Hes unattached from the life support machine...

 

[Stivie]

Not really liking Sam8.

Will assume the 7 others will be more likeable.

Would have been better if like BLack Clover the kid stayed handicapped.

More then it would be complicated because it is a battle shonen, in manga of sport it is easier the protagonist to continue with the deficiencies and it surpasses them little by little.

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

Nakano made a good decision (finally) to serialize new sport manga.
He had already completed a year without releasing a new one.

Btw, Jimoto and David-kun flopped.
I'm think its time for Jump search for new gag manga too.

 

[Stivie]

Nakano made a good decision (finally) to serialize new sport manga.
He had already completed a year without releasing a new one.

Btw, Jimoto and David-kun flopped.
I'm think its time for Jump search for new gag manga too.

a question who sells most hinomaru zumou or promised neverland?
Which anime was successful for a second season? hinomaru zumou or promised?
sorry but my view the term neverland will have more impact than hinomaru, so it is worth worrying about wanting another dark manga than a sport, in addition haikyuu will not end yet and will still have the fourth season of the anime.

 

[tirakai]

I wonder if they'll give a lot of let to any new sports series for the sake of having something else running besides HQ during the Tokyo Olympics. Even if its not too big of a hit it'd mean they'd have something to promote (as long as it wasn't a total flop of course but even then they'd maybe just pretend it was ranking well as long as sales are at least passable).

 

[Stivie]

I think it was hasty to launch 3 series along with samurai 8, because we know that the work of kishimoto will stand out more than the others, and will rob more readers.
2 series (Samurai 8 and one more) already was of good size.

 

[tirakai]

Nak's been a little odd with his choice of new series and batches in general really.

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

a question who sells most hinomaru zumou or promised neverland?
Which anime was successful for a second season? hinomaru zumou or promised?

Haikyuu is the best answer for this questions.
That's all folks.
Lol