Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[James Rye]

Glad SxF got such a good sale on its debut, nearly 40k in 4 days is really nice. Let's see how long it stays in the rankings before it drops out and with what kinda sales it gonna leave the ranking.

 

[TyVip]

Glad SxF got such a good sale on its debut, nearly 40k in 4 days is really nice. Let's see how long it stays in the rankings before it drops out and with what kinda sales it gonna leave the ranking.

not higher than 50,000. Reprint doesn't come till the 18th.

 

[Lehran]

I checked the top average rating ranking of manga series on MyAnimeList today and... SpyxFamily is currently in 30th place, on par with Death Note. That's amazing for a series that started so recently.

 

[westabyss]

There are no gag series, and in a few weeks once Zumou ends there'll be only one non-new sport series in the magazine. There's definitely room for a couple new hits.

WSJ isn't a manga of only battle shounen, there are other genre mainstays too.

Battle manga was only an example, read the post properly. Jump usually only has 1-2 sport manga running. Even if Zumou leaves, there is sill Haikyuu. The romcom spot, ecchi spot, the unorthodox battle manga spot are also already taken.
Also i think the concept of the gag manga as it was used to be in the 80s,90s etc, is dead. Gintama's success imo relies on that it is modernizes the gag manga and is more of an action-comedy-drama series.

 

[RafGL]

I checked the top average rating ranking of manga series on MyAnimeList today and... SpyxFamily is currently in 30th place, on par with Death Note. That's amazing for a series that started so recently.

Not like I want to give that kind of rankings the importance they don't have, but yeah, for people to rate it high means it's having a good reception and that helps the series to grow a lot.

 

[Caiops]

Happy to see such a big boost for KnY this week.

Zenitsu and Inosuke helping the series.

 

[Blink22]

Cmon Nak you fraud get SxF to move into the main mag. This series was made to be weekly.

 

[Nemesis]

Cmon Nak you fraud get SxF to move into the main mag. This series was made to be weekly.

No. That won't happen either way.. because as far as I remember, no manga ever transferred from other magazines to WSJ, just the contrary.

 

[BaNChiGay]

Kimetsu no Yaiba Volume 16(4 days)-225,102
My Hero Academia Volume 16(4 Days)- 274,338
Wow. Kudos to KnY Only 50k shorter than MHA vol 16 and that's with only first season back up while MHA already have 2 seasons back up.
I say it's safe to say that only a matter on time before KnY to surpass MHA.

 

[Franz]

I say it's safe to say that only a matter on time before KnY to surpass MHA.

 

[Rain Spectre]

Battle manga was only an example, read the post properly. Jump usually only has 1-2 sport manga running. Even if Zumou leaves, there is sill Haikyuu. The romcom spot, ecchi spot, the unorthodox battle manga spot are also already taken.
Also i think the concept of the gag manga as it was used to be in the 80s,90s etc, is dead. Gintama's success imo relies on that it is modernizes the gag manga and is more of an action-comedy-drama series.

I'd argue that, at this point, "room" doesn't really matter. As long as it's good, readers will pay attention to it.

 

[TxxT]

Kimetsu no Yaiba Volume 16(4 days)-225,102
My Hero Academia Volume 16(4 Days)- 274,338
Wow. Kudos to KnY Only 50k shorter than MHA vol 16 and that's with only first season back up while MHA already have 2 seasons back up.
I say it's safe to say that only a matter on time before KnY to surpass MHA.

How is it safe to say that lol? You're comparing a MHA volume that released without an anime and saw a dip in sales vs a Kimetsu volume that released with an anime, also for all we know Kimetsu might not even have long legs like MHA volumes + there isnt a guarantee that the next Kimetsu volume grows like it did with this one

 

[Aeneas]

How many more chapters do you guys think Kimetsu will go for?

100? 150?

I'm anime-only, so was curious.

 

[Nakura]

How many more chapters do you guys think Kimetsu will go for?

100? 150?

I'm anime-only, so was curious.

If the current arc is indeed the final arc, which it definitely feels like, I'd predict another 50 chapters maybe.

 

[James Rye]

not higher than 50,000. Reprint doesn't come till the 18th.

Which means it might sell out before the 18th? Would be quite funny if it leaves the ranking with a perfect 50k sale before it gets its reprint. XD

 

[4Eyes]

It seems like OP Sales Are experiencing a big drop since the beginning of Wano, but now the things are picking momentum and most confuse moments are done we may see this drop being reverted in the next volume (I hope)

 

[Tomioka_96]

How many more chapters do you guys think Kimetsu will go for?

100? 150?

I'm anime-only, so was curious.

It will end at 200 chapters I bet.

 

[CrimsonEpitaph]

If the current arc is indeed the final arc, which it definitely feels like, I'd predict another 50 chapters maybe.

There's no way that it's the final act though.

Spoiler: Spoiler

There's no way that Tanjiro doesn't participate in the fight during UM1 and against Muzan, and right now he's down for the count. There's probably going to be one more "rest" arc after this one, and then the final battle

 

[Nemesis]

I'll guess that Kimetsu will end with at least more 100 chapters. If Zumou is ending now, the next from the established to end is probably Yunna as Neverland still isn't going to end with how the story is going and WNL probably will only end in 2020.

 

[Drarkknight]

[QUOTE = "Nakurawari, post: 5068216, miembro: 194289"]
Si el arco actual es de hecho el arco final, que definitivamente se siente, predeciré otros 50 capítulos tal vez.
[/ CITAR]
Al aire libre

Spoiler

[/ SPOILER]
Bueno ... en un comentario del autor en el volumen 16 es más que claro que este rumor del arco final es falso.