Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Heiji]

Yes. Issue #36•37 releases on Aug 19th

its 38th issue out 19/08 36/37 will be 05/08.

 

[PluemBNK48]

Congratulations to both
The last saiyuki and Yui kamio
Both of you survived U19 club
LoL

 

[TxxT]

They're calling it "major information" so Im guessing they'll finally be announcing the air date and the title name, it will probably be the same "major" anime info they'll release at the HQ day festival on 8/18

 

[Blue16]

There is an event on August 18th (with anime new info) and August 19th is the official Haikyuu!! day in Japan.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

 

[fuzzb]

People still believe the "cp for good reception" thing?

It can be popular , but saying "is popular because it got CP for good reception" ...

Do you have proof for that?
And where exactly I said that? Where I used the word "popular"? Good reception is not popularity, it may have a direct connection sometimes, but it's not the same. A movie can have good reception from both critics and audience, but to do poorly in the box office -> not popular. And also why aren't other newbies getting CPs? Why are only the popular series getting CPs?
Rain is talking about how bad the series is received, Then I comment its getting CPs for good reception. I have no idea how popular it is at the moment, but since it's getting more than 1 CP, it means it getting well received. And you jump in and start talking about popularity...

 

[Rain Spectre]

Do you have proof for that?
And where exactly I said that? Where I used the word "popular"? Good reception is not popularity, it may have a direct connection sometimes, but it's not the same. A movie can have good reception from both critics and audience, but to do poorly in the box office -> not popular. And also why aren't other newbies getting CPs? Why are only the popular series getting CPs?
Rain is talking about how bad the series is received, Then I comment its getting CPs for good reception. I have no idea how popular it is at the moment, but since it's getting more than 1 CP, it means it getting well received. And you jump in and start talking about popularity...

Uh...you realize that "good reception" is most likely a buzzword, right? Of course Jump is going to give Samurai 8 early CP's, it's a series they were/are very invested in pushing because of Kishimoto's name value. The real reason why they're doing it though is simply just promotion.

 

[fuzzb]

Uh...you realize that "good reception" is most likely a buzzword, right? Of course Jump is going to give Samurai 8 early CP's, it's a series they were/are very invested in pushing because of Kishimoto's name value. The real reason why they're doing it though is simply just promotion.

Sure, you work at Jump and know there was no good reception for S8. Every series that get early CP is just pushing, and nothing to do with good reception, right? I also bet when Jump says the total number of sales, it's just a buzzword too and real number is 3 times less.
I can agree it got more CP than normal early well received new series, but to completely diss it and label it as only push is delusional.

 

[Rain Spectre]

Sure, you work at Jump and know there was no good reception for S8. Every series that get early CP is just pushing, and nothing to do with good reception, right? I also bet when Jump says the total number of sales, it's just a buzzword too and real number is 3 times less.
I can agree it got more CP than normal early well received new series, but to completely diss it and label it as only push is delusional.

Act-Age first CP: Chapter 20. First LCP Chapter 52.
Jujutsu Kaisen first CP: Chapter 16. First LCP Chapter 29
Chainsaw Man first CP: Chapter 13. Still has yet to get an LCP.

Samurai 8 got two CP's before even hitting Chapter 10, and got a LCP at Chapter 12.

This isn't me trying again rag on Samurai 8, I know everyone's sick of that, but this is something I still feel needs to be pointed out; saying Samurai 8 has received beneficial treatment from Jump due to Kishi's name value and in spite of the mixed reception isn't just me spitballing, it's a simple fact.

 

[fuzzb]

Act-Age first CP: Chapter 20. First LCP Chapter 52.
Jujutsu Kaisen first CP: Chapter 16. First LCP Chapter 29
Chainsaw Man first CP: Chapter 13. Still has yet to get an LCP.

Samurai 8 got two CP's before even hitting Chapter 10, and got a LCP at Chapter 12.

This isn't me trying again rag on Samurai 8, I know everyone's sick of that, but this is something I still feel needs to be pointed out; saying Samurai 8 has received beneficial treatment from Jump due to Kishi's name value and in spite of the mixed reception isn't just me spitballing, it's a simple fact.

Act-age was bottom dweller and was about to be cancelled. It managed to survive and pick up in reception and popularity later.
Jujutsu wasn't that well received too until 10th or so chapter and started to pick up after that, and thus it got for ch16 CP
Chainsaw was the best received from those 3 and due to that it got it in ch13.

Like I said, I agree it's more pushed that other newbies that are well received, but it's not only pushing. You are trying to completely say its not having good reception and it's only being pushed. That obviously ain't truth. Not everyone who likes the series will write on twitter... Also even if it's mixed, there is a huge difference from: 10k people love it and 1k hate it (very good reception) vs 30k loved and 30k hate it (mixed reception). Example numbers, don't take them seriously. But if you don't know those exact numbers, even if it's mixed it can still be more popular than other series.

We had other series in the past that had CP before chapter 10. And it wasn't just push...

 

[RafGL]

F-Ken will be published in MANGA Plus.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Prince of Tennis 20th anniversary. Source: revo

 

[Lizard_Boots]

Sorachi celebrating the release of the final volume of Gintama with all his past editors by being thrown into the air, in all his full mosaic glory.

 

[Jovan]

Spy x Family is still going extremely strong on Shoseki:
July 29 #18
July 30 #15
July 31 #20
August 1 #15

 

[MangAniMY]

Spy x Family is still going extremely strong on Shoseki:
July 29 #18
July 30 #15
July 31 #20
August 1 #15

pointing out that kny fanbook is doing extremely well after the Reprint as well

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Source : Nav

 

[savethecat]

Uh...you realize that "good reception" is most likely a buzzword, right? Of course Jump is going to give Samurai 8 early CP's, it's a series they were/are very invested in pushing because of Kishimoto's name value. The real reason why they're doing it though is simply just promotion.

I’m sure if Samurai 8 bombed right out of the gate and was doing awful, Jump would likely invest more time in the other new series that may have better reception, even if they were still will to bet their chip on S8

 

[OtterBrigade]

It would be funny if all these new flops survive an extra round because Food Wars, Sumo and TPN all happened to end.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

If I recall some convo this morning, Neverland is 6 chapters left to end current volume.

I don't see Neverland ending in this volume however, but in next one. That would mean like 15 chapters left. I totally see it being the remaning length for the manga completion.

 

[vinceled]

If I recall some convo this morning, Neverland is 6 chapters left to end current volume.

I don't see Neverland ending in this volume however, but in next one. That would mean like 15 chapters left. I totally see it being the remaning length for the manga completion.

I jus't can't see the series ending that soon. Latest volume that came out went up to chapter 133 which was the beginning of the mini arc that ended with Emma's return in 144. One volume is 9 chapters so volume 16 will be chapters 134-142 so at the very least volume 17 will be until chapter 151, which is 6 chapters when counting from the chapter coming Monday.
The series ending in volume 18 would mean resolving all lose ends in like 10 chapters which I just can't see happening considering the current pace of the manga.